Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Jacobs was substituting for Councillor Willcocks and Councillor Connolly was substituting for Councillor Williams.
Every time East Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Jacobs, as the council published it.
It was noted that Councillor Jacobs was substituting for Councillor Willcocks and Councillor Connolly was substituting for Councillor Williams.
It was noted that Councillor Connolly was substituting for Councillor Nicholls and Councillor Jacobs was substituting for Councillor Willcocks.
Councillor Connolly proposed and Councillor Jacobs seconded, a motion that the2025/26 quarter four corporate risk register and actions being taken to control and mitigate risk have been considered and noted.
Councillor Jacobs, Chair of Overview and Scrutiny, proposed that the recommendations in the report be supported.
It was moved by Councillor Jacobs and seconded by Councillor Horner that Councillor Adams be appointed Chair of the Joint Meeting of Scrutiny Committees. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was noted that Councillor Jacobs abstained from the vote. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Jacobs said that Members should consider whether a workshop should be held March, as per the approach taken for the last two years, to shape the Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme in more detail beyond June.
Councillor Jacobs asked if the 20 January 2026 was a realistic timetable for the final report.
Councillor Jacobs said that the committee had yet to agree when the matter of local government reform would come before Members for a discussion. He said that a date would be put into the diary on this matter.
Councillor Jacobs said that a list of assets had been produced by the Director for Communities, and he would share this with members of the committee.
Councillor Jacobs proposed the following amendment:
The Parking Services Manager responded to questions from Councillor Jacobs regarding the Citisense report and the recommendations.
Councillor Jacobs requested that officers come back to the committee at some point regarding the Citisense recommendations contained within an appendix to the report.
Councillor Jacobs said that LGR scrutiny proposal forms were submitted from Councillor E Buckmaster, and Councillor McAndrew, and that these forms had been circulated to the committee for comments.
Councillor Jacobs said that the next step was to share these forms and comments with the administration, and for Members of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee to agree a reporting timescale. He said that he did not envisage that this subject would be included at the 4 November meeting and instead be more likely for the 20 January 2026 agenda.
Councillor Jacobs presented the ‘Save Havers shops from closure’ petition on behalf of the petition organiser.
Councillor Jacobs asked if the tariff was index linked or if it would be increased over time.
Councillor Jacobs thanked Councillor Crystall for bringing this matter before Overview and Scrutiny Committee. He referred to the actions set out in section f regarding making East Herts a more inclusive environment ... view the full minutes text for item 132.
Councillor Connolly proposed, and Councillor Jacobs seconded a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 26 June 2025, be approved as a correct record, and be signed by the Chair. On being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Jacobs asked for clarification that if the group recommended that a community council was established for Hazel Park, then it would not be in place until 2031.
It was proposed by Councillor Connolly and seconded by Councillor Jacobs, that Councillor Thomas be appointed Chair of the Community Governance Review working group for the 2025/26 civic year.
Councillor Jacobs asked BSTC if:
Councillor Jacobs asked the councillors if they were concerned about the viability of the parish council if the proposed changes do go ahead.
Councillor Jacobs asked if Thorley were concerned about the increase of residents from the development impacting their community.
Councillor Jacobs asked if Thorley PC would step back from their involvement in the planning process if the boundary was moved.
Councillor Jacobs said that Sawbridgeworth was one of the largest towns that was not warded. He asked if Sawbridgeworth could see a time where it could be beneficial to ward the town, especially if the town was ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Jacobs said that he would talk to the Committee Support Officer about this outside of the meeting.
The Council then voted on the original proposal that Councillor Jacobs should be Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
RESOLVED – That Councillor David Jacobs be Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for 2025/26.
Councillor Jacobs felt that the work of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee was welcomed and recognised as important and a valuable part of the governance process. He said that the committee had a forward plan of work moving into 2026 and reminded all Members of the Council that they could submit a topic for consideration via the scrutiny proposal form.
Councillor Jacobs proposed that the recommendation in the report be supported.
It was moved by Councillor Jacobs and seconded by Councillor Thomas that Councillor Adams be appointed Chair of the Joint Meeting of Scrutiny Committees. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Jacobs asked for clarification around the recommendation for making the appointment for 18 months.
Councillor Jacobs felt the recommendation was unclear and wanted clarity as to how far the delegated authority went.
Councillor Jacobs said that the Green/Liberal Democrat administration should ... view the full minutes text for item 184.
Councillor Jacobs said he had attended a meeting of the Bishop’s Stortford Town Council Finance and Policy Committee and the Committee had discussed an aspiration to acquire the Thorley Community Centre from East Hertfordshire District Council.
She said that further discussions were very welcome, and she and Councillor Jacobs were not against the sale in principle. She said the way the sale was handled was very important in terms in respect to the tenants and the boundary of the land.
Councillor Jacobs asked at which point did Charringtons House move from council ownership into developer ownership.
Councillor Jacobs referred to page 13 of the supplementary agenda and questioned why the £170,000 forecast on the United Reform Church Hall had not been spent.
Councillor Jacobs asked if vaping could be included in the exemption list.
Councillor Jacobs said he welcomed the review and the approach.
Councillor Jacobs referred to page 60 of the report and the proposed list of asset disposals. He asked for an update on the progress of this following the discussions held at the Member Asset Reference Group.
Councillor Jacobs said the administration had said that the previous scheme was unacceptable because a bespoke solution for Bishop’s Stortford was not fair and a holistic solution was required across the whole district.
It was noted that Councillor Jacobs was substituting for Councillor Redfern and Councillor Watson was substituting for Councillor Woollcombe.
Councillor Jacobs asked if it was unusual to only have one provision to provide affordable housing included in a Section 106 agreement in a year (2022/23).
Councillor Jacobs referred to Risk 4 – Key Contractor, and asked why this was scored relatively low despite the current risk of industrial action by the waste contractor.
Councillor Jacobs said that the administration were talking about a holistic approach to parking to improve the service for everyone. He asked what that scheme would look like and said the suggested scheme had been brought forward by the BID, not the previous administration. He said that he would be supporting the motion.
Councillor Jacobs presented his motion on notice and said he was removing item 3c from the motion.
Councillor Jacobs said that he knew there were huge funding pressures on local government which could not be met alone through making savings or raising council tax. He said that the motion called for adequate funding for councils in line with inflation and there needed to be a long-term plan for local government funding from the government as inflation would not come down overnight, reserves could only be spent once and services could not be cut twice. He hoped that by joining the Local Government Association’s campaign, the collective voice of councils would be greater, and he wanted to raise the issue on behalf of residents.
Councillor Brittain thanked Councillor Jacobs for his motion and said he agreed wholeheartedly. He said his only concern was that he was not convinced the government would listen.
It was moved by Councillor Nicholls and seconded by Councillor Jacobs, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Audit and Governance Committee meeting held on 31 May 2023 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Jacobs asked for clarification on how the council was at risk of tenancy fraud as it did not hold any housing stock.
Councillor Jacobs referred to paragraph 43 of the 2022/23 report asked for an update on the National Fraud Initiative (NFI).
Councillor Jacobs asked if the Local Authority could be the owner of a property on the register.
Councillor Jacobs said that the external auditor had given a target for their report to be on the agenda at tonight’s meeting.
Councillor Jacobs referred to page 100 of the report and asked for an update on the council’s reserves.
The Head of Strategic Finance and Property said that he would find this information for Councillor Jacobs. The Chairman thanked the Head of Strategic Finance and Property for his report. RESOLVED – that A) it be noted that the General Fund revenue outturn of £195k overspend will be funded from the General Reserve; and B) that the Capital Programme was underspent by £14.797m due to slippage caused by various factors, including archaeological finds.
Councillor Jacobs said that he shared the concerns of Councillors Williamson and Nicholls and asked that the Chairman and Officers considered the priorities for the next meeting.
Councillor Jacobs referred to recommendation (D) and Town and Parish Councils being consulted on the proposals. He asked if the reviews would continue if councils were consulted and were happy with their current arrangements.
Councillor Jacobs said he thought it was important to respect the councils wishes and asked the Head of Legal and Democratic Services to confirm this.
Councillor Jacobs presented his motion on notice. He said that the project had come to symbolise everything that was wrong with its own relationship with the council. He said that the project was being done to Bishop’s Stortford, not with and had been championed by people who did not live there or were interested in the residents’ concerns.
Councillor Jacobs said that residents had reasonably assumed that after the election, a change in administration would result in a change of direction for the project and that the administration would take the time to understand the finances and business case to build a better vision for the site. He said that a better vision was still possible as per the steps outlined in the motion. He said this required a change in direction from the new administration and a good start would be a commitment to reassess all capital projects in light of the current finances which was a commitment signed by both parties in the administration in their shared objectives document.
Councillor Jacobs said that development on the site had been promised since 2010 and a few more months of scrutiny was time worth spending. He urged the joint administration to honour its election commitments and do the right thing.
Councillor Jacobs said that the presentation contained lots of figures but none in relation to service-level agreements (SLA’s), and he asked if there were any SLA’s in place.
Councillor Jacobs referred to paragraph 2.13 of the report and asked how the variety of terms upon which productions are made available to the theatre aligned with the fixed price regime outlined.
Councillor Jacobs referred to page 166 of the report and asked for clarification that the 2021/22 audit would be completed by June 2023.
Councillor Jacobs said that it may be helpful to Members if a clearer statement of the risk itself was included within the format of the register.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Jacobs attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Jacobs's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Jacobs was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 6 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Jacobs declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Jacobs in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Jacobs sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Sep 2026 | 4 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 2 | 9 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.