Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Redfern was substituting for Councillor Estop.
Every time East Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Estop, as the council published it.
It was noted that Councillor Redfern was substituting for Councillor Estop.
Councillor Estop said that she had reservations regarding the proposal, and that she would abstain from the vote. She said that the report and the context was entirely the information about Hatfield Forest and the National Trust’s own mitigation report, with the important schedule of mitigation which the planning service use in terms of development missing.
Councillor Estop said that the recommendation should include that the Director of Place maintains discretion in relation to other aspects of planning applications. She said that in relation to Gilston being exempt, this was a huge area of people who could go to the forest, and that the tariff was a flat rate, regardless of dwelling size.
Councillor Estop said that she was recorded under apologies for absence, and did not take part in the meeting to avoid any ambiguity about predetermination. She said that she had watched the meeting at home via the webcast and would like this to be recorded in the minutes.
Councillor Estop asked what was meant in the report that this would improve the level of council tax collection.
Councillor Estop made a statement in opposition to the sale of the shops and flats. She raised issues such as the council only offering short lets on the shop units, the boundary for the sale containing the whole site, protection of existing businesses using the units, the failure to install roof insulation in the flats and the expenditure of green space. She also raised the concerns of the three business owners in the units and said that local residents had started a petition which currently had 400 signatures.
Councillor Estop asked if there would be some provision for translating the big strategic studies into formats and ways the public could understand.
Councillor Estop said she welcomed the panel and said that it was great to have a body that was open to contributions from all Members.
Councillor Estop said she welcomed the report. She referred to section 3 and the characteristics of the district where the council shares borders with Stevenage, Welwyn and Harlow. She asked if the council had consulted and had dialogue with these neighbouring authorities as part of the visioning work.
Councillor Devonshire proposed and Councillor Estop seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 22 January 2025 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
Councillor Estop said that there was a conservation issue in respect of the relationship to the listed building. She referred in particular to the materials of the listed building. The Planning Officer summarised the materials in place at Highfield Lodge, which were very similar to the existing care home.
Councillor Estop said that it was important to have a sound District Plan and the planning department would now move to produce Strategic Land Availability Assessment to look at the sites and determine the best sites to allocate for development. She said this was the best process for a spatial strategy and not speculative submission of planning applications for larger sites. She did not think that Full Council was the right place for oversight of the process and needed to be a Member led Committee.
Councillor Estop proposed and Councillor Carter seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 4 December 2024 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair, subject to the following amendment:
The Head of Planning and Building Control responded to a question from Councillor Estop in respect of updates regarding sites where development had not progressed.
Councillor Estop mentioned the possibility of a proposal to defer the application to secure more information in respect of the proposed operation so that was a better understanding of the planned activities on the site. The Legal Services Manager said that Members needed to be mindful of the statutory timescales for the council determining the application, and the risk of an appeal for non-determination of the application.
Councillor Estop said that she felt decisions relating to the Old River Lane project should be the responsibility of the Executive or the Delivery Board. She said that the delegated authority was not clear on the scope of powers and prompted concerns that the decision-making lacked transparency and accountability.
Councillor Estop said the report did not set out the level of responsibility and said there had been a history of questionable decisions.
Councillor Estop asked about the £50k regarding the reduced grounds maintenance specification. She said ... view the full minutes text for item 167.
Councillor Estop said that she welcomed the amendment to take Elizabeth Road (Havers Parade) out of the proposed sale of assets for capital receipts.
Councillor Estop proposed, and Councillor Adams seconded, a motion that application 3/23/1642/FUL be granted planning permission, subject to a section 106 legal agreement and the conditions set out at the end of the report, and also subject to the changes to conditions and the Section 106 agreement that had been raised during the meeting.
Councillor Estop asked if the developer disposed of it once it had ownership would it reduce the income to the council.
Councillor Estop said that she welcomed the Charter in principle but felt it was quite weak and that the Growth Board could have been more challenging to developers across the county. She said that the Charter did not acknowledge the role of Development Management Committees in councils and felt that the Charter did not add anything to what already existed in the District Plan.
Councillor Hart said she agreed with the comments from Councillor Estop. She said that if the bar was set too low to get developers to sign up to it, it meant there won’t be any meaningful impact. She said it was good to hear that East Herts were ahead of the game in balancing the need for housing and protecting the natural world but felt the council should stay ahead and not sign up to a watered-down charter.
The Chairman thanked Councillor Estop for her time as a very knowledgeable, dedicated, hardworking and supportive Chair of the Development Management Committee during the 2023/24 civic year.
Councillor Estop proposed and Councillor Connolly Hill seconded, a motion that in accordance with paragraph 6.4.5 of the constitution, the committee agree to depart from the speaking arrangements of the Development Management Committee, to allow [name removed] and [name removed] to jointly address the committee for 6 minutes regarding outline application 3/19/0790/OUT .
Councillor Estop said that she opposed the amendment. She said the hall had not been looked after but it was structurally sound and was used regularly by the community. She said it had been designated an Asset of Community Value so was protected by planning policy.
Councillor Estop referred to paragraph 2.4 about the pausing of the arts centre at Old River Lane. She asked the Executive to consider keeping their options open and talk about the site as development land instead of specifically an arts centre.
Councillor Estop asked if key worker housing would be provided as this went hand in hand with the stated objectives.
Councillor Estop referred to the proposed actions and acknowledged the LCWIP which would make physical changes to the environment to make walking a more pleasant and safe environment.
Councillor Estop said that the area between the bridges had the potential to be unsightly. She asked if this issue could be addressed via the landscaping condition.
Councillor Estop proposed and Councillor Hill seconded, a motion that in accordance with paragraph 6.4.5 in Section 6 – Regulatory Committees of the constitution, the committee agree to depart from the speaking arrangements of the Development Management Committee, to allow Hertfordshire County Councillor Jeff Jones (Buntingford division) to address the committee for 3 minutes in respect of application 3/21/2509/FUL.
Following a question from Councillor Estop, the Principal Planning Officer set out in detail the operation of the Herts Lynx Bus Service.
Councillor Estop said she welcomed the masterplan and said they were helpful and proactive. She said that she had one concern that the plan was described as a collaborative masterplan between the Parish Council and the steering group but the document is headed as Fairview Homes. She felt that masterplans should have a section to say who was involved in the preparation of the document.
Councillor Estop said that she had referred to footpath E2 that had not been included in footway improvements in condition 19.
Councillor Estop said that masterplans were an excellent policy and was pleased to hear that a steering group had helped officers work through the process. She said she felt that the masterplan process and document needed to be easier to understand so that the public felt they had joint ownership. She also said that the document started with aspirations for sustainable, high quality design which she said was an easy cliché and highly specific about high quality.
Councillor Estop seconded the motion and said that progress with the development had been tightly constrained by the tender submission which had not been transparent or been scrutinised. The motion pressed for urgent scrutiny of the relationship between the council as landowner and Cityheart as the preferred developer.
Councillor Estop said that councillors had now had the benefit of helpful officer briefings with background information which had largely been hidden previously.
Councillor Estop proposed and Councillor Stowe seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 5 April 2023 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Estop attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Estop's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Estop was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 11 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Estop declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Estop in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Estop sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Development Management Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 6 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Development Management Forum | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 3 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 2 | 9 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.