Political Balance and Committee Membership of the Council 2026/27
Councillor Deering proposed that Councillor Wyllie should be Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for 2026/27.
Every time East Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Wyllie, as the council published it.
Councillor Deering proposed that Councillor Wyllie should be Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for 2026/27.
Councillor Nicholls proposed, and Councillor Wyllie seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 20 January 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
He also welcomed back Councillor Wyllie.
Councillor Wyllie asked what the council would be doing differently to achieve excellent customer service.
Councillor Wyllie asked about the position of the Scrutiny Officer that had supported Members when he was previously on the committee. The Committee Support Officer explained that there was no Scrutiny Officer and he and a colleague shared the workload of supporting the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
He therefore proposed that Councillor Wyllie should be Chair of this committee.
Councillor Wyllie referred to paragraph 2.1 and the national backlog of opinions. He said their backlog meant the council had not published their accounts which, to residents, might look suspicious. He asked if the council would be asking the auditors for compensation for their failure and the additional officer time involved.
Councillor Wyllie suggested that the proposer and seconder of the motion might wish to include writing to the new MPs representing East Herts to lobby the Minister.
Councillor Wyllie proposed the following amendment:
Councillor Wyllie asked why documents were showing as outstanding on Companies House.
Question 4, Councillor Wyllie supplementary question.
Councillor Wyllie said he thanked the Executive Member for Environmental Sustainability for his initial proposal and asked if the Executive Member regretted that the decision was paused.
Councillor Hoskin said that he felt he had come up with a fairer proposal and hoped Councillor Wyllie would be able to contribute to the debate later in the meeting.
Councillor Wyllie said he had read the report but felt there were good parts and bad parts. He said that he supported the previous scheme proposed but said he could not support the new proposed scheme. He said the pricing for Northgate End was sensible but this had impacted pricing in other car parks increasing them by up to 54% and he said he could not support these increases.
Councillor Wyllie presented his motion on notice about reduced parking charges for town centre workers in Bishop’s Stortford.
Councillor Crystall responded to the motion and said he understood why Councillor Wyllie had submitted the motion. However, he felt it was ill judged. He said that town centre workers were vitally important but the administration thought that it could be done better.
It was moved by Councillor Wyllie and seconded by Councillor Townsend, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 15 March 2023 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken the motion was declared CARRIED.
The previous Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Wyllie, presented the Annual Scrutiny 2022/23 report.
Councillor Wyllie proposed that the recommendations in the report be supported.
Councillor Wilson seconded the proposal and thanked Councillor Wyllie for his excellent service as Chairman for the last four years.
The Chairman also thanked Councillor Andrews for his service on the Licensing Committee Councillor Crystall also thanked Councillor Andrews, Councillor Deering and Councillor Wyllie for their time as Chairmen of Development Management Committee and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. He said it was hard to appreciate how difficult these roles were unless Members sat on the committee.
Councillor Wyllie seconded the amendment.
Councillor Wyllie presented the Bishop’s Stortford Town Council Cemetery Bill as the local Ward Member. He said that the Council resolved to promote a Private Bill to enable the reuse of burial space in two cemeteries in Bishop’s Stortford on 16 November 2022 and there was a statutory requirement for the Council to now confirm that resolution and this report seeks that confirmation. He said that in order to promote the Bill a resolution needs to be passed by a majority of the whole number of the members of the authority.
Councillor Wyllie proposed that the recommendation in the report be supported.
Councillor Wyllie seconded the proposal and reserved his right to speak.
Councillor Wyllie said he supported the report but did have some concerns about over development. He said that he was concerned about any future developers trying to get out of any agreement and wanted to make sure that this agreement was watertight to ensure that Bishop’s Stortford got what it needed and not what future developers wanted.
Councillor Wyllie said he supported the report as the Leader of Bishop’s Stortford Town Council but questioned why the consultation was reported in the Herts Mercury and not in a Bishop’s Stortford newspaper.
Councillor Wyllie asked if there were any improvements that Officers could request of Hertfordshire Highways to improve the East Herts planning process. The Service Manager (Development Management) said that there were regular meetings with Hertfordshire Highways. She said that early advice and intervention from Highways assisted officers in ... view the full minutes text for item 204.
Councillor Wyllie commented on whether Hertfordshire County Councillors could attend the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Wyllie emphasised that come May 2023 it would be the new Councillors on the Committee to shape the work programme.
Councillor Wyllie said that the Scrutiny Officer would forward the response from the Executive Member for Corporate Services to all Members of Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Wyllie addressed the Committee as the local ward Member.
Councillor Wyllie read out the pre submitted question from Councillor Drake in terms of whether more could be done regarding refuse collection and improving communication between the Council and residents, for example by letting residents know (via text), that their refuse might be collected on a different date if, for example, some works were being undertaken in a road which would impact on the ability of the Council to collect on a normal basis.
Councillor Wyllie, on behalf of Councillors Crystall and Devonshire, asked if the Executive Member for Environmental Sustainability could confirm if any approaches had been considered regarding introducing ultra-fast chargers and what might the associated costs be.
Councillor Wyllie seconded the proposal.
Councillor Fernando proposed, and Councillor Wyllie seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 29 April 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. The motion to approve the Minutes having been proposed and seconded, was put to the meeting, and upon a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Wyllie presented the report to Council. He said that the reports provided an overview of the work of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in the years 2019-20 and 2020-21 and the reports were presented annually to Council as required in the Constitution.
Councillor Wyllie proposed and Councillor Pope seconded, a motion that the proposals be supported. A motion to support the recommendation having been proposed and seconded, was put to the meeting and a vote taken. The motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Wyllie seconded the recommendations.
It was moved by Councillor Goldspink and seconded by Councillor Hollebon, that Councillor Wyllie be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
RESOLVED – that Councillor Wyllie be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Councillor Wyllie encouraged the Committee to email him or the Vice-Chairman, Councillor Goldspink, or the Scrutiny Officer with suggestions for topics for scrutiny. He pointed that Members could only really explore two items per meeting. The Scrutiny Officer said that she had shared the link to the Forward Plan in her report to the Committee.
Councillor Wyllie declared an interest in agenda item 7 (Note of a decision of the Chief Executive to approve a scheme for Local Authority Discretionary Grant fund under Urgency Provisions) by virtue of the fact that he was a small business owner.
Councillor Wyllie referred to the information contained in paragraph 2.3 of the report which appeared to conflict with the information on the online form (the date for applications had closed); this asked applicants to state their last date of trading. He felt that this wording may have deterred applicants from applying for a grant that they may have been entitled to and should have asked applicants if they were still trading as a Yes/No answer. If the answer was “yes” they should have been asked the date of their last trading date.
Councillor Wyllie suggested that the date for applications should therefore be extended and that the wording on the online form be rephrased to make it clear that if there were still trading; they could still apply for a grant.
Councillor Wyllie, the Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Committee explained that O&S had had a brief meeting on 8 December 2020 but had nothing to report to the Executive.
Councillor Wyllie, the Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee referred Members to the report which he had submitted which highlighted only one recommendation for Members’ considerations. He said that he would be happy to answer any questions.
There being no questions, the Leader thanked the Councillor Wyllie for his report and thanked him for the courtesy shown to both her and the Chief Executive at the last meeting when they gave a presentation on Covid-19.
Councillor Wyllie, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave a verbal report on the recent meeting of the Committee.
Councillor Wyllie asked that a minor change be made, to ensure all references to sky lanterns were shown correctly, rather than using the phrase “Chinese lanterns”.
Councillor Wyllie, the Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, referred Members to the report he had submitted, setting out the items the Committee had considered at its meeting on 16 June 2020.
Councillor Wyllie invited Executive Members to ask questions.
There being no questions, the Leader thanked Councillor Wyllie for his report.
Councillor Wyllie said, in relation to sky lanterns, that their attractive appearance was outweighed by their disadvantages in terms of fire risk and danger caused by metal parts to wildlife. He thanked the Executive for taking account of the Committee’s comments. The Service Manager (Environmental Health) confirmed the additional recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee could be implemented.
Councillor Wyllie said he welcomed the legislation and this report, which would help smaller businesses. He thanked officers for acting quickly and for working closely with the Police on how the new rules would be implemented, particularly in view of the important of keeping people safe from the Covid virus.
Councillor Wyllie said the Overview and Scrutiny Committee had not met since before the last Executive meeting, as due to the Covid-19 crisis, the Committee’s March meeting had been cancelled. However, it would be meeting on 16 June, and areas of the Committee’s work would shortly, therefore, be back on track.
Councillor Wyllie declared a disclosable pecuniary interest (DPI), in that he was the owner of a small business in the district. He said he had not appreciated at the start of the meeting that he would need to have declared this interest before the item was considered. Advice was sought from the Democratic Services Manager as to the procedure to be followed where a declaration of interest had not been made at the start of the meeting.
Accordingly, Councillor Wyllie left the virtual meeting for the duration of consideration of the item.
Councillor Wyllie thanked Councillor Drake for the work she and the Task and Finish Group had done. The Committee had looked at the findings in detail and considered there could be further scope to explore options, for example, in relation to Airport related parking and on street parking.
Councillor Wyllie asked that the amendment to the proposal should include provision for Councillor Drake to be consulted.
Councillor Pope proposed, and Councillor Wyllie seconded, a motion supporting the recommendation in the report. The motion being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Wyllie said there had been a 50% increase in the number of houses, and that he had concerns at aspects of the highways issues. He would oppose the motion.
Councillor Haysey said Councillor Wyllie had attended meetings of the Steering Group to consider this Masterplanning Framework, at which representatives of Highways had been questioned. This report was the Framework, which had to be progressed before the planning application was considered.
Councillor J Wyllie asked the Executive Member for Neighbourhoods what steps the Council was taking to minimise the disruption and distress caused by fireworks, particularly towards animals in the District, ... view the full minutes text for item 267.
Councillor G Williamson proposed and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion that the recommendations as detailed below be supported. The motion being put to the meeting and a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Wyllie commented on whether the power to a lamppost was sufficient to charge up an electric car.
Councillor J Wyllie, as Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, gave a verbal report. He said the Committee had at its meeting on 5 November 2019, considered a number of items. The subjects which had been considered included Council Tax on long term empty properties, as it was desirable to ensure such properties were returned to use as soon as possible.
Councillor Wyllie said in conclusion that the work programme of the Committee included a Task and Finish Group review of aspects of social housing, to take place in the New Year.
Councillor J Wyllie proposed and Councillor J Frecknall seconded, a motion that the Task and Finish Group would be formed of the Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and Councillors M Goldspink, M Brady and N Symonds. The Group would explore how the Authority and Councillors could support tenants and improve service standards.
It was moved by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor H Drake that the draft Work Programme, as amended be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Wyllie, as Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, confirmed that this work was progressing and would be reported to the Committee in due course.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the purpose of the SPD, which included the objective of retaining access to open spaces. He asked how this aim might be affected for example in Thorley, where developers, rather than the Council, owned land, and where small parcels of land were sold. The Leader said she was not aware of the particular circumstances in Thorley, but if it was not appropriate for such land to be sold if they were in the Green Belt, then Article 4 provisions could be used.
She asked that Councillor J Wyllie send her details of the pieces of land to enable Officers to provide further advice.
Councillor J Wyllie submitted a verbal report on the work of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. The Committee was running a task and finish group on the parking within the District. The group had taken evidence from the Bishop’s Stortford Business Improvement District, and with Hertford retailers and Hertford Town Council.
It was moved by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor I Devonshire that the scoping document, as amended, be approved and that the membership of the Task and Finish Group include those Members who wished to participate, as detailed. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor D Snowdon that the proposal to seek to introduce public speaking at meetings of Overview and Scrutiny Committee, be supported. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Kaye moved, and Councillor M Goldspink seconded, a motion that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
RESOLVED – that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the civic year 2019/20.
Councillor T Beckett proposed, and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion that Councillor M Goldspink be appointed Vice Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the civic year 2019/20. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Wyllie declared a non-pecuniary interest as Member of The Rhodes Trust and of the Old River Lane Delivery Steering Group.
It was moved by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor A Alder that the recommendations as detailed be approved.
Councillor J Wyllie submitted the annual report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committees for 2018/19 The Annual Report set out the work of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and the Performance, Audit and Governance Scrutiny Committee during the civic year 2018/19, and summarised the findings of an internal review and its key recommendations.
Councillor J Wyllie said it was not the case, as Councillor M Goldspink had suggested, that the project would jeopardise The Rhodes Centre or Museum. The Rhodes Centre was not under threat of closing, as had been made clear by Bishop’s Stortford Town Council. The Centre was too small and that its access was too limited to be appealing to theatre companies.
Councillor G Williamson moved, and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Council considered an annual report reviewing the activities of outside bodies to which the Council appointed representatives Councillor J Wyllie moved, and Councillor Mrs D Hollebon seconded, a motion that the recommendation now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the residency status mentioned within paragraph 8 (The Current Disqualification Criteria) as submitted, and queried the absence of European nationals within the list.
Councillor Wyllie suggested that it was for the political party to suspend a Member. In response to a query regarding lack of attendance at meetings, the Head of Legal and Democratic Services explained that non-attendance (over a period of time) did not mean an automatic disqualification as it depended on the Member’s circumstances.
Councillor J Wyllie commented on the overspend (now of £143 k) stating that the Council appeared to go over budget quite frequently. He commented that scrutiny was not about “rubber stamping” overspends and that the Executive should be called to account for the overspend. This view was supported.
Councillor J Wyllie agreed that buying the site was a valuable opportunity to improve and benefit residents and the town centre and that the long term benefits would be fantastic.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to his comments made at the Executive meeting on 16 October 2017 and believed charging would be a backward step for recycling.
Councillor J Wyllie, as the Chairman of the Task and Finish Group, thanked everyone who had contributed to the work which had culminated in the recommendations before the Executive. He highlighted the importance of improved bus services and extending rail services to Buntingford. He also spoke of reducing congestion in Bishop’s Stortford by extending rail links to Stansted Airport from Great Dunmow and Braintree.
It was moved by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor M Freeman that Councillor K Warnell be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office for the civic year 2017/18.
Councillor J Wyllie commented that, whatever the outcome of the community governance review in Bishop’s Stortford, only one Town Council would be involved and so the NHB payment need not be delayed.
The Chief Executive acknowledged this and suggested that in the absence of a form of words to agree now, the protocol could be amended to allow for the scenario detailed by Councillor J Wyllie.
RESOLVED – that any New Homes Bonus payments be held in abeyance for an area which is the subject of a Community Governance review until the outcome of the Community Governance review is complete, at which point, payments will be backdated and paid in line with the outcome of the review, subject to the proviso that the protocol could be amended to allow for the scenario detailed by Councillor J Wyllie.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie, the Acting Head of Legal and Democratic Services explained the legal position in relation to Directors of the proposed company who would also be employees of the Council. The Chief Executive cited, by example, the CCTV partnership and Building Control which worked in partnership with seven other authorities in Hertfordshire.
Councillor I Devonshire proposed and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion that the Executive be advised that the joint meeting of Scrutiny Committees recommends a 2% increase in Council Tax. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Wyllie supported Councillor H Drake’s comments. He believed that the Draft Plan was an excellent document apart from the element relating to Bishop’s Stortford and in particular, the inclusion of the Bishop’s Stortford South site on the basis of unsustainable traffic impact.
Councillor J Wyllie asked that his dissent from the decision in so far as Bishop’s Stortford South was concerned be recorded.
Her concerns were echoed by Councillor J Wyllie.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the “critical” need for primary and secondary education provision as part of the proposed Bishop’s Stortford South development, and his concerns that current flight paths and the expansion of Stansted Airport could have health, noise and air pollution implications to children. He reiterated his concerns about development in this location.
It was proposed by Councillor Mrs D Hollebon and seconded by Councillor J Wyllie that Councillor P Phillips be appointed Chairman for the joint meeting.
The Head of Business Development confirmed to Councillor J Wyllie that the Council did everything possible to avoid the aspirations of residents being hampered by red tape. He also advised that the Authority had to be more conscious of all the surrounding areas in terms of the populations coming into East Herts.
It was proposed by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor Mrs D Hollebon that Councillor P Phillips be appointed Chairman for the joint meeting.
Councillor J Wyllie suggested an amendment at the end of the first paragraph by inserting “East Herts” before “Harlow”. This was accepted by the Leader.
· A Burlton · M Carver · J Ranger · J Wing · M Wood After a few brief words by Councillor J Wyllie, [name removed] received a framed certificate and a civic badge of office from the Chairman.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie, the Director detailed the difference between earmarked and general reserves.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to broken links on the Council’s website. The Head of Information, Customer and Parking Services advised that Officers routinely checked the website for broken links.
He confirmed to Councillor Wyllie that social media was not the best channel for service delivery when compared to direct customer contact as the level of contact via social media was very low.
It was proposed by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor S Bull that Councillor M Pope be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee for the 2015/16 civic year.
Councillor J Wyllie stressed that the Authority must cater for customers who had no access to a computer and e-mail. He referred to the stage 2 complaint regarding the false statement made by an East Herts Council Press Officer. He stressed that such statements should never be allowed to be issued.
In response to comments from Councillor J Wyllie regarding EHPI 64, the Director of Finance and Support Services referred to the potential positive impact on the New Homes Bonus of returning vacant dwellings to occupation. She undertook to reissue an article on that topic that had been circulated via the MIB towards the end of 2014/15 civic year.
Councillor J Wyllie expressed concern that there had not been an item on the agenda in relation to the outcome of the Market Tendering process. The Executive Member for Economic Development explained that as the contract had not yet been signed there was no work to scrutinise. He suggested that this might be added to the Committee’s work programme.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the need to review markets as a whole. The Scrutiny Officer stated that markets had been looked internally and externally, as part of a Task and Finish Group. She undertook to review the outcomes agreed by the Task and Finish Group to see if all the work had been undertaken.
Question 2 Councillor J Wyllie referred to the current pay and display machines in the Council’s car parks having been in operation for a number of years and asked the Executive Member for Economic Development if there were any plans to replace these and improve the convenience of parking in East Herts.
Councillor J Wyllie expressed concern that the number of invoices being paid on time was declining in the short term. He was particularly concerned that small businesses needed cash flow to survive.
Councillor J Wyllie asked whether those in the Armed Forces, suffering from combat stress were provided with help. He also raised the issue of same sex marriages and whether there should be specific mention of the new legal status in the scheme. The Director of Finance and Support Services undertook to clarify the position of the Armed Covenant and provide and a written response on both issues.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the absence of an IT Strategy (14-BTS05) and a Customer Services Strategy (14-IPCS07) and sought assurances that these were progressing. The Chairman stated that the Head of Information, Customer and Parking Services had written to all Members giving an explanation as to why the Customer Services Strategy had been removed from the agenda recently. He stated that it was essential that the strategy challenged all services in meeting the needs of residents and customers.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to on-going services in IT and Microsoft Licenses. He also referred to Parking Services and residents’ and businesses’ wish to “pay on foot”. The Director of Finance and Support Services explained the need to ensure information was secure and that Officers continued to consider any alternatives to Microsoft Licenses if they were appropriate.
Councillor J Wyllie requested that Councillor P Phillips, Executive Member for Economic Development be invited to the next meeting of Community Scrutiny Committee to provide an update on the outcome of the Market Tendering process. This was supported.
Councillor J Wyllie raised the issue of the 30 minutes free car parking in some of the Council’s car parks and stated that more should be done to publicise this new scheme. This was supported.
Councillor J Wyllie asked that officers give consideration to local “seed-bed” units. The Director of Finance and Support Services explained that the Council was constrained by lack of land and that local investment was about finding the right place in which to invest.
It was moved by Councillor M Pope and seconded by Councillor J Wyllie that Councillor W Mortimer be appointed Vice-Chairman for the civic year 2014/15.
It was noted that Councillor J Wyllie was substituting for Councillor N Wilson.
The Accountancy Manager provided a response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie concerning the Council’s assets held for sale. The Director of Finance and Support Services explained that before any decisions on disposal were taken, the best use of the asset would have been considered and matters such as yields, levels of sustainable income and any liability issue would have been taken into account. The Director of Finance and Support Services explained that the report on the Treasury Management Strategy (see Minute 104) explained the approach to direct property investment in more detail.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie, the Shared Internal Audit Service Manager explained that the service had completed 32 out of 34 projects by March 2014.
Councillor J Wyllie queried where the Council stood in relation to the market tender process, adding that this was taking a “long time”. He asked when the process would be finished and what was happening in the meantime. The Executive Member for Economic Development stated that the tendering process was being handled by the Procurement Officer and it was anticipated that the tender would go out next month.
Councillor Wyllie expressed concern that Bishop’s Stortford was losing its market and that “Ad hoc” markets were being turned away. The Executive Member for Economic Development and the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services said that they had no knowledge of “ad hoc” markets being turned away and that anyone could apply for a licence to run a market.
The Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services reassured Councillor Wyllie that no “ad hoc” approaches had been made or turned away and explained the difficulties in terms of resources available for the complex process of procurement.
Councillor Wyllie referred to a lady who had applied for an “exotic market” and who had been turned away and agreed to provide the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services with the details.
Councillor Wyllie suggested that the outcome of the market procurement process and plans for the future be provisionally booked in for consideration at the November meeting of Community Scrutiny Committee. This was supported.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the 65% customer satisfaction figure (EHPI 1a Percentage of customers satisfied with the service - all) in relation to SLM and leisure services provision. The Scrutiny Officer explained that SLM’s annual report had been given at the last meeting of Community Scrutiny Committee when the background to the Net Promoter Score (NPS); a new way of measuring customer satisfaction (loyalty) had been explained. Officers agreed to provide the Member with the supporting papers.
Councillor J Wyllie thanked the Officers for the full and detailed report which had been submitted at his request. He raised the issues associated with Bishop’s Stortford Carnival last year, the problems associated with poor communication and queried whether the process could be simplified. The Head of Community Safety and Health Services explained how the process worked in terms of the Council acting as a facilitator and its liaison with Hertfordshire Highways.
Councillor J Wyllie suggested that all Town Clerks be forwarded new forms. This was supported.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie, Members were advised that Officers had done all they could to ensure that Section 106 money was spent on appropriate schemes in accordance with the terms of Section 106 agreements.
Councillor J Wyllie expressed his disappointment that the report was not on the agenda, stating that he had been trying to get the item on the agenda since last year and that its absence was “suspicious” and “disrespectful”.
Councillor J Wyllie praised Officers for the “good start”. In response to his query about communicating the messages further, the Waste Services Manager provided a summary of how further changes would be disseminated to residents.
Councillor Wyllie was not in favour of “hangers” on the bins preferring instead, some form of sticker. The Head of Environmental Services commented that the stickers had a tendency to become dirty and explained that the hangers were the most effective way of getting the message across to residents and these would provide further links to information, including websites and a waste services campaign. Stickers were also used to let residents know if they were not putting their waste in the correct bin.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to the revised management plan for Waytemore Castle as well as the nearby open space linked to proposed housing development. The Head of Environmental Services advised that Officers were already in consultation with Bishop’s Stortford Town Council and would continue to work closely with them in respect of a Management Plan for the Waytemore Castle and the nearby Red, White and Blue open space.
In response to comments regarding IT from Councillor J Wyllie, the Director stated that the new shared service for IT should ensure improved business continuity in respect of IT, as prior to the new shared service there had been consistent underinvestment in IT.
Councillor C Woodward moved and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion as follows:
Councillor J Wyllie suggested that in the light of the performance indicator review recently undertaken, Members might wish to include temporary road closures and their impact on service users as a subject for scrutiny. This was supported.
Councillor J Wyllie suggested that the display of so much information might confuse the public. Concerns were expressed concerning the display of the “best and worst performing indicators” in terms of how the data might be misinterpreted. The Corporate Planning and Performance Manager explained that if there were red and amber indictors shown, then this might help to show the information more clearly.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to Essential Reference Paper Ci (“Dashboard Analysis”) stating that with less information, this was more clearly understood. The Chairman, on behalf of Members thanked the Corporate Planning and Performance Manager and her team for all their efforts.
It was noted that Councillor D Andrews was substituting for Councillor J Wyllie.
It was noted that Councillor R Beeching was substituting for Councillor J Wyllie.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie regarding bank statements being provided to the Portfolio Holder for Finance, the Head of Finance and Performance explained that this would not normally be the case. He explained that the “cash and cash equivalents” in the balance sheet, included short term investments that met this definition of cash. The Chairman added that he was a Member of the Investment Panel which met regularly to be updated on the Council’s investments.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie, the SIAS explained that there had not been any limitations placed on them.
It was moved by Councillor W Ashley and seconded by Councillor K Warnell , that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Vice Chairman of Environment Scrutiny Committee, for the Civic Year 2013/14.
RESOLVED – that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Vice Chairman of Environment Scrutiny Committee, for the Civic Year 2013/14.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie regarding commercial businesses and recycling, the Head of Environmental Services explained the issues associated with this and particularly the need to ensure that any commercial collection service “brakes even” from an accounting viewpoint. He advised that opportunities to provide commercial recycling would be kept under review and may become financially viable in the future.
Councillor J Wyllie referred to EHPI 157a (Process of planning applications: major applications) and queried the relevance of this as an indicator (and the “red” face shown), given that Planning Officers were trying to resolve legal agreement issues. The Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services suggested that Members might wish to reconsider some of Environment’s Performance Indicators and descriptors, within the context of the review suggested earlier in the meeting as part of the committee’s work programme.
In response to a query from Councillor J Wyllie regarding the possibility of reviewing the PI for Fuel Poverty, the Head of Environment Services said that the Environmental and Strategy Development Manager was keen to move forward on this issue. Members supported the suggestion that Officers report back to their meeting in September 2013, setting out the potential scope for a Task and Finish review of how the Council might work with partners on the issue of and approach to, tackling Fuel Poverty.
Members agreed that Councillor J Wyllie would work with officers on the Performance Indicator working group and, in the absence of any other volunteers, the Chairman would join him.
Councillor J Wyllie commented that recycling rubbish bins in Bishop’s Stortford were not effective as they were not obvious enough in appearance to attract attention and he also suggested improvements to the road-side signage in regard to littering from vehicles.
Councillor J Wyllie commented on whether every town should be treated the same. He suggested that the evening charge should be 50p rather than £1.
Councillor J Wyllie commented on whether the ANPR vehicle could differentiate between a parked vehicle and one which was stationary in a queue of traffic. The Parking Manager stressed that there was no reason to believe this would become a problem in East Herts.
In response to a concern from Councillor J Wyllie in respect of EHPI 2.1e – Planning Enforcement: Service of Formal Notices, the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services undertook to provide a written response after the meeting.
It was moved by Councillor P Gray and seconded by Councillor C Rowley that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Environment Scrutiny Committee for the 2012/13 civic year.
After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, Councillor J Wyllie was appointed Vice–Chairman of the Environment Scrutiny Committee for the 2012/13 civic year.
RESOLVED – that Councillor J Wyllie be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Environment Scrutiny Committee for the 2012/13 civic year.
Councillor J Wyllie expressed concern that on a number of occasions the grounds maintenance staff had cut some grass on a verge on his garden adjacent to his house in Bishop’s Stortford and in so doing had damaged some plants.
Councillor J Wyllie supported the use of the bin hangers to promote recycling and felt that, while the environmental benefits had its place, communicating the costs of not recycling was important. Residents needed to know that landfill was expensive.
Councillor C Woodward proposed and Councillor J Wyllie seconded, a motion that parking charges at Grange Paddocks be deferred until September so that consideration could be given to the results of the parking strategy.
Councillor J Wyllie – Trustee of Rhodes Birthplace Trust, St Michael’s Mead Community Hall and Havers Community Trust.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Wyllie attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Sep 2016 | Council | East Herts Draft District Plan – Bishop’s Stortford – Settlement Appraisal and New Draft Chapter 5 | Against | Carried | 26 for, 11 against, 2 abstained |
| 4 Mar 2015 | Council | Council Tax 2015/16 | For | Carried | 37 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
| 5 Mar 2014 | Council | Council Tax 2014/15 - Formal Resolution | For | Carried | 36 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
| 19 Feb 2014 | Council | Consolidated Budget report 2014/15 and Medium Term Financial Plan | For | Carried | 36 for, 2 against, 0 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Wyllie was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 6 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Wyllie declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Jan 2021 | Executive, item 314 | Councillor Wyllie declared an interest in agenda item 7 (Note of a decision of the Chief Executive to approve a scheme for Local Authority Discretionary Grant fund under Urgency Provisions) by virtue of the fact that he was a small business owner. | |
| 2 Jun 2020 | Executive, item 37 | Councillor Wyllie declared a disclosable pecuniary interest (DPI), in that he was the owner of a small business in the district. He said he had not appreciated at the start of the meeting that he would need to have declared this interest before the item was considered. Advice was sought from the Democratic Services Manager as to the procedure to be followed where a declaration of interest had not been made at the start of the meeting. | |
| 15 May 2019 | Council, item 7 | Councillor J Wyllie declared a non-pecuniary interest as Member of The Rhodes Trust and of the Old River Lane Delivery Steering Group. |
Where Councillor Wyllie sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 4 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 3 | 9 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.