Said6 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Freedom Leisure
· Councillor Hay stated that she understands as a money saving exercise that has stopped paying for music licenses across the board and would like to understand if this decision has contributed to the downturn in participation figures in 3 out of the 4 centres, especially concerning the exercise classes, where users are used to dancing to modern well-known music and now it is, as she understands, music that nobody has ever heard of? Paul Doyle responded that the figures on participation are not as a result of this as this was before the change in music licence. He continued that any issues they have with that system are usually because they need to engage the class instructors better and for every playlist that existed before they do have an equivalent but it is recognised that they are not amazing and the more the instructors engage with the organisation the more that this can be personalised because for every popular song there is usually 2-3 very similar ones.
Said13 Mar 2026Council
Local Government Reorganisation - Response to Statutory Consultation
· Councillor Hay stated that like Councillor Tierney she does not agree with LGR, but members cannot bury their heads in the sand, it is going to happen whether members agree with it or not. She feels that it is very much damage limitation, picking the option that is going to have the least damage for the people of Fenland, and she believes Option D is that option.
Asked2 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Annual Review of Anglia Revenues Partnership
· Councillor Hay asked with the collection of Council Tax, particularly fraud, a large proportion of that collection goes to County Council, are County Council now giving Fenland District Council sufficient money to help with this collection?
Asked2 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Road Safety Partnership Update
Councillor Hay asked why this subject has come to the Fenland District Council (FDC) O&S committee as everything on the report relates to CCC and she is concerned that members of the public reading the report will be confused as to who is responsible for the roads and road safety in the area.
Said2 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Public Health
· Councillor Hay stated that in the presentation diabetes was mentioned but pre-diabetes was not mentioned and, she is aware there is additional support for people and asked if this is something that is being used regularly? John Rooke responded that, to identify prediabetes and undiagnosed cardiovascular risk (high blood pressure and high cholesterol), GP data is used to offer earlier prevention and support.
Named7 Sep 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Update on previous actions.
Councillor Mason advised members that the Overview and Scrutiny Panel had agreed earlier in the year to set up a sub committee to review the Anglia Revenue Partnership, this was under the Chairmanship of Councillor Anne Hay and she will be presenting the findings to the Committee in December.
Named13 Jul 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Chairman for the Municipal Year
He also thanked Cllr Hay for all her efforts as Vice Chairman during that period.
Named13 Jul 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Draft Overview & Scrutiny Annual Report
Councillor Mason thanked Councillor Miscandlon as the previous Chairman, plus Councillor Hay and all who contributed during the past year towards the content of the report. Members made comments, asked questions and received responses as follows:
Named13 Jul 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
Councillor Miscandlon said that he had previously discussed with Anna Goodall and Councillor Hay the possibility of having an extra meeting for sensitive items as we lost two meetings early on in lockdown. 5.
Named8 Jul 2020Fenland Development Forum
Introduction and Apologies
Present: Kris Baxter, Cllr Ian Benney, Lee Bevens, Dino Biaggioni, Cllr Chris Boden, Ted Brand, Stephen Buddle, Marcel Cooper, Emma George, Tanya Gravenor, Emma Grima, Nick Harding, Cllr Anne Hay, Dan Horn, Ben Hornigold, Shanna Jackson, Simon Jackson, Cllr Mrs Dee Laws, John Maxey (Chairman), Carol Pilson, David Rowen, Nick Seaton, Cllr Sutton, Chris Walford, David Wyatt, Justin Wingfield,
Named24 Jun 2020Planning Committee
Appointment of Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year 2020 - 2021
It was proposed by Councillor Meekins, seconded by Councillor Murphy and resolved that Councillor Hay be elected as Vice-Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year.
Seconded24 Jun 2020Planning Committee
Adoption of Planning Validation Requirements
Proposed by Councillor Lynn, seconded by Councillor Hay and members AGREED to adopt the new Local Validation List.
Named17 Jun 2020Council
Committee Structure, Political Balance and Allocation of Seats
Councillor Count and Councillor Connor will form part of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in place of Councillor Hay and Councillor Mrs Mayor.
Named17 Jun 2020Council
Cambridgeshire & Peterborough Combined Authority Appointments
Combined Authority Board: Councillor Boden, Substitute: Councillor Mrs French Audit Committee: Councillor Benney , Substitute : Councillor Miss Hoy Overview & Scrutiny Committee: Councillor Hay and Councillor Mason, Substitutes: Councillor Miscandlon and Councillor Tierney.
Said8 Jun 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
Councillor Topgood thought it counter-productive if they are also coming in November and Councillor Hay said that it had to be borne in mind that we currently do not know when Freedom Leisure can get back up and running; if not until August or September then they will need time to recover.
Seconded3 Jun 2020Planning Committee
Adoption of Planning Validation Requirements
Proposed by Councillor Sutton, seconded by Councillor Hay and agreed that the item be DEFERRED to the next meeting.
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay expressed the view that she agrees with Councillor Murphy and stated that although there will be a new Local Plan in time, it is the current Local Plan which members should be considering when determining applications.
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Hay stated that the proposal does go against LP3 and LP16 and added that on the site opposite where permission had been granted for 3 dwellings this was infill development.
Named13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
He stated that when consideration has been given to the proposed new Local Plan, Councillor Hay had put forward that the building line should be taken further down Ferry Hill. He expressed the view that although the proposal may not be fully compliant with the current Local Plan, it will be when the new Local Plan is introduced.
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay stated that Councillor Benney is correct and she did think it would be sensible to move the boundary going forward; however, members still need to abide with the current Local Plan.
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0167/O Land north of The Barn, High Road, Bunkers Hill, Cambridgeshire, Erect up to 5x dwellings involving the formation of a new access (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay stated that the visibility splay is drawn through the fence line to the host property and is ... view the full minutes text for item P85/19
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0182/O Land South Of Norbrown, Hospital Road, Doddington, Cambridgeshire,Erect up to 2 x dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay stated that Hospital Road it is a very narrow road and has very few passing places and added that she is concerned about the increase of another two dwellings. She also noted that on the edge of the site there are also electricity cables which she also has concerns over.
Asked7 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0083/F The Hollies, Middle Broad Drove, Tydd St Giles, Cambridgeshire Erect a 3-storey 4/5-bed dwelling with detached garage and study above involving demolition of existing dwelling and change of use of land from paddock to garden
· Councillor Hay asked for clarification with regards to ridge heights for 2 storey dwellings? David Rowen confirmed that a normal 2 storey ridge height would be 7.5 metres.
Asked6 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/0958/O Lavender Mill, Fallow Corner Drove, Manea. Erect up to 29 dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay asked for clarification with regard to one of the objections raised by Manea Parish Council, who have stated that the proposal does not include public open space.
Said6 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/0958/O Lavender Mill, Fallow Corner Drove, Manea. Erect up to 29 dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Hay stated that at 3.2 in the officer’s report it states that the proposal includes an area of children’s play area and asked for confirmation as to whether this would be classed as public open space. David Rowen confirmed that the indicative layout plan shows an area of open play space and that would be secured under condition 13 on page 42 of the agenda.
Said26 Feb 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/1070/F Erect a dwelling (2-storey 4-bed), detached garage, and front boundary treatments (fence, gates and piers) at a max height of 2.1m high (approx), Land South Of 72 Fieldside Accessed From, Lake Drove, Coates, Cambridgeshire
· Councillor Hay stated she was going to reiterate the comments made by Councillor Sutton and the site already has outline planning permission, albeit that it was granted on appeal there are no reasons for refusal. The building is acceptable and therefore she will support the officer’s recommendation.
Named20 Feb 2020Council
General Fund Budget Estimates 2020/21 and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2020/21 to 2024/25; Capital Programme 2020 - 2023.
In Favour: Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
Named20 Feb 2020Council
Council Tax Resolution.
In favour of the proposal - Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
Named10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Fenland Community Safety Partnership
Councillor Hay referenced minute OSC40/18 and asked if the analysis of women offender’s in Fenland had taken place yet.
Asked10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Hay asked if the Council are still on target to maximise the National Lottery Heritage Funding for the 11-12 High Street, Wisbech project.
Asked10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Hay asked for an update on the environmental enforcement service in light of the Council’s contract with Kingdom ending.
Asked10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Hay asked for a timescale of the replacement service.
Named10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Call in of Cabinet Decision - Creation of Investment Board and Delegation of Functions
Councillor Hay reminded members that the Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny Panel will be invited to attend meetings of the Investment Board and will therefore have an oversight of the process.
Said29 Jan 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/0931/O - Erect up to 9no dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved) - Land South Of 137, Upwell Road, March, Cambridgeshire.
Councillor Hay agreed and highlighted the appeal which was dismissed by the Planning Inspector on another similar site in Upwell Road and added that granting planning permission will set a precedent for others.
Asked29 Jan 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/1031/O - Erect up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access) - Land North West of 24 Willey Terrace, Doddington Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay asked why the applicant has only applied for planning permission on a small portion of the site.
Named13 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Anglian Revenues Partnership (ARP) Update.
Councillor Hay referenced 2.13 of the report and asked what discussions have taken place between the Council and Cambridgeshire County Council (CCC) in relation to their withdrawal of funding for the fraud initiative.
Said13 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Anglian Revenues Partnership (ARP) Update.
Councillor Hay stated that the figures provided in relation to ‘Single Person Discount Fraud’ shown in 3.7 of the report, are confusing and asked for further clarification on this. Paul Corney explained that if ARP apply a Single Person Discount and then, through fraud work, identify that this needs removing, the charges are automatically charged from that point and they are billed for that period. He explained that ARP do not seek any future savings and only claim for that financial year.
Said13 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Review of Fees and Charges 2020/21.
Councillor Hay stated that the report infers that cemetery and burial costs have risen purely because other Local Authorities have increased their charges.
Said13 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Review of Fees and Charges 2020/21.
Councillor Hay stated that the report could be amended to reflect this.
Named13 Jan 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
· Councillor Cornwell · Councillor Hay · Councillor Mason · Councillor Skoulding (substitute) · Councillor Wicks (substitute) Izzi Hurst agreed to arrange this.
Seconded9 Jan 2020Council
Commercial and Investment Strategy
Proposed by Councillor Boden, seconded by Councillor Hay, Councillor Mrs Mayor opened the item for discussion.
Said9 Jan 2020Council
Commercial and Investment Strategy
· Councillor Hay stated that she welcomes the proposal. She added that she has a query contained within appendix 1, with regard to the core principles of the assets, where it states ’to minimise management and risk, preference is for single occupancy investments’. She stated that in her opinion, it could increase the risk.
Said4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/yr19/0736/voc
· Councillor Hay stated that she sees no reason why three houses need to have a path, when there is a perfectly adequate path across the road.
Moved4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/yr19/0736/voc
Proposed by Councillor Hay, seconded by Councillor Sutton and decided that the application be APPROVED, as per the officers recommendation.
Said4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/841/VOC Variation on conditions 8 and 9 to enable amendment to approved plans relating to Planning permission F/YR18/0386/O (Erection of up to 3 x dwellings (Outline with matters committed in respect of access);Land West Of Sunset Rooms, Station Road, Wisbech St Mary, Cambridgeshire)
· Councillor Hay commented that it is her understanding that the original reason for the whole driveway to be tarmacked was in order for the local authority to be able to carry out refuse and recycling collections at the properties, but now they have indicated it will be a private company that will be servicing those properties. David Rowen confirmed that the condition was one that the committee had imposed previously in order to secure better bin collection arrangements and better amenity in terms of noise being generated from vehicular movements over the gravel.
Said4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0859/FDC Erect up to 3 x dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved);Former Garage Site, Crescent Road, Whittlesey, Cambridgeshire
· Councillor Hay expressed the view that the committee need to be mindful that had the application been submitted by a developer and not by Fenland District Council, would members be considering going against the officer’s recommendation. She added that if members look at the plans, the area that the two latest bungalows encompass, equates to about two thirds of the area of the land where the proposal is planned for. She added that in her opinion to consider three properties on that ... view the full minutes text for item P56/19
Asked4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0860/FDC Erect a dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved);Land North Of, 7 Glebe Close, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
· Councillor Hay asked for clarification as to what the response was from Chatteris Town Council. David Rowen advised that the response was to recommend refusal, due to the loss of a long established car parking area.
Said4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0860/FDC Erect a dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved);Land North Of, 7 Glebe Close, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
· Councillor Hay expressed the view, that currently the area is an eyesore and in her opinion the area can support one dwelling and she will be supporting the officer’s recommendation.
Named4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0860/FDC Erect a dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved);Land North Of, 7 Glebe Close, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
· The Chairman stated he agrees with Councillor Hay and he will be supporting the officer’s recommendation.
Moved4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0860/FDC Erect a dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved);Land North Of, 7 Glebe Close, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
Proposed by Councillor Hay, seconded by Councillor Connor and decided that the application be APPROVED, as per the officer’s recommendation.
Said4 Dec 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0889/O Erect up to 5no 2-storey dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access and scale),Land North Of 3A-15, High Road, Gorefield, Cambridgeshire
· Councillor Hay commented that [name removed] had stated that the proposal would fill a gap between the house on one side and the drain on the other. She ... view the full minutes text for item P58/19
Named6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1108/FDL - Erection of a part 2-storey, part 3 storey and part 4-storey building comprising of: 1 x retail unit (A1) and up to 26 x flats involving demolition of existing building (outline application with matters committed in respec
Councillor Hay supported the application and said she was pleased to see the amendments to the scheme following the previous refusal of planning permission.
Said6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1108/FDL - Erection of a part 2-storey, part 3 storey and part 4-storey building comprising of: 1 x retail unit (A1) and up to 26 x flats involving demolition of existing building (outline application with matters committed in respec
Councillor Hay agreed but stated that all applications should be considered on their own merits and disagreed that this application is similar to the previous application F/YR18/0345/FDL. She highlighted that this proposed development is in keeping with the neighbouring block of flats and is located in a town centre location surrounded by retail units.
Seconded6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0726/O - Erect 1no dwelling with attached garage (outline application with matters committed in respect of access and layout) - Land North Of 20, St Francis Drive, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
Proposed by Councillor Benney, seconded by Councillor Hay and decided that the application be GRANTED; as per officer’s recommendation.
Declared6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0726/O - Erect 1no dwelling with attached garage (outline application with matters committed in respect of access and layout) - Land North Of 20, St Francis Drive, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Hay declared an interest by virtue of the fact that she is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Benney declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) The meeting was adjourned at 2.24pm.
Said4 Nov 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Hay addressed Councillor Murphy, saying that she understood there is a waste duty of care for waste disposal but asked why the fixed penalty notice is £400 for householders but only £300 for a business trade waste offence.
Said4 Nov 2019Council
Commercial and Investment Strategy
· Councillor Hay said she felt the policy to be long overdue but better late than never.
Declared9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0152/O - Erection of up to 50no dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved); Land South Of, 8 - 59 Fairbairn Way, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Hay declared a Pecuniary Interest by virtue of the fact that her property is adjacent to this site.
Named9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0510/LB - Demolition of a Listed Building (existing derelict structures); 11 - 12 High Street, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Hay and Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that they were members of Cabinet and had been involved in a decision in relation to this proposal.
Named9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0509/F - Erect 5-storey mixed use development (1 x retail unit to ground floor and 11 x 1-bed and 4 x 2-bed flats to remaining floors) involving demolition of existing derelict structures in a Conservation Area; 11 - 12 High Street, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Hay and Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that they were members of Cabinet and had been involved in a decision in relation to this proposal. They took no part in the discussion or vote for this item) ... view the full minutes text for item P37/19
Said9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0684/O - Erect up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access); Land East Of 4A, Primrose Hill, Doddington, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay agreed with Councillor Murphy and highlighted the open countryside adjacent to the site.
Said9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0612/F - Erect 2 dwellings (1 x 3-storey 3-bed and 1 x 2-storey 2-bed) involving partial demolition of existing dwelling and garage; 31 Bowthorpe Road, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire, PE13 2DX
Councillor Hay agreed and stated that she felt the proposal was overdevelopment of the site. Whilst she supports the application for the dwelling to the rear of the existing property, she cannot support the proposal for the dwelling adjacent to the existing property due to the lack of space.
Named9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0612/F - Erect 2 dwellings (1 x 3-storey 3-bed and 1 x 2-storey 2-bed) involving partial demolition of existing dwelling and garage; 31 Bowthorpe Road, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire, PE13 2DX
Councillor Hay disagreed that the parking issue will be improved as a result of the development and added that an additional 2 dwellings will bring even more vehicles to ... view the full minutes text for item P39/19
Asked18 Sep 2019Council
Revised Conduct Procedure Rules, Guidance & Templates.
Councillor Hay asked for clarification on the amendment to 2.5.3 (appendix 2 of the report).
Said11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
Previous Minutes
Councillor Hay stated that minute P25/19, the bottom of page 7 of the agenda pack should read; ‘There are no substantive reasons to go against the planning policies’
Said11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0518/F Erect 4 dwellings (2 x 2-storey 4-bed and 2 x 2-storey 3-bed) with garages;Land East Of Tindall Mill, Kirkgate, Tydd St Giles, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay highlighted that Highways had requested an amended plan for the dropped kerb (5.5 of the report).
Said11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0518/F Erect 4 dwellings (2 x 2-storey 4-bed and 2 x 2-storey 3-bed) with garages;Land East Of Tindall Mill, Kirkgate, Tydd St Giles, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay raised concern that Highways had requested this plan and it has not been submitted. Nick Harding informed members that there are two options available to remedy this, if members decide to grant the application; the application could be approved subject to an amended plan being received before planning consent is issued or attach a condition to the planning permission requiring a revised dropped-kerb design plan being submitted.
Asked11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0501/F Erect 5 dwellings (comprising of 3 x 1-bed and 2 x 2-bed flats) and associated parking,Nelson House, 22 Norwood Road, March, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay asked if the opposite side of the road benefits from a footpath. David Rowen confirmed this.
Said2 Sep 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities.
Councillor Hay highlighted that the cumulative figure provided for LP1 ARP1 (page 15 of the agenda pack) is below target for 19/20.
Asked2 Sep 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress of Corporate Priority - Communities.
Councillor Hay asked how many Council Tax Billing Officers are currently recruited by ARP.
Asked2 Sep 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Council Tax Support - 2020/21 scheme.
Councillor Hay asked if the Council had approached Cambridgeshire County Council (CCC) again as per point 4.5 of the report (page 52 of the agenda pack).
Said2 Sep 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Council Tax Support - 2020/21 scheme.
Councillor Hay raised concern from an equalities perspective about the treatment of a new UC claimant and an existing claimant with a change in circumstances, as different assessments are carried out and could result in different claim amount.
Said18 Jul 2019Council
Membership of Committees, Panels and Outside Bodies.
Councillor Hay pointed out that her name was missing from the list of nominated representatives for Nightlayer IDB.
Said17 Jul 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0352/F Land West of 126-128 Elliott Road, March.Erection of 3xsingle storey 3 bed dwellings with detached garages
· Councillor Hay stated that she felt that it was a good scheme because it tidies up the area. She added that in 2017, March Town Council recommended approval for a proposal of 4 dwellings, however in 2019, they are recommending refusal for over development where it is fewer dwellings. She commented that she will be agreeing with the officer recommendation for approval.
Named17 Jul 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0352/F Land West of 126-128 Elliott Road, March.Erection of 3xsingle storey 3 bed dwellings with detached garages
· Councillor Patrick stated that he was impressed with the layout of the plans and he concurs with Councillor Hay with regard to the reasons for refusal from March Town Council. He added that the proposal does tidy up the area and will make it far more pleasant.
Said17 Jul 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0362/F Land North West of Seafield Farm, Gorefield Road, Leverington, Erection of 3 x 2 storey, 3 bed dwellings with associated double garages
· Councillor Hay stated that members need to be mindful that we are here to determine the application before them today. She added that permission has already been granted for 3 houses irrespective of the Inspectors decision, and irrespective of whether we agree with it. It would prove very difficult to refuse this application, as it is just a change of design and she will be supporting it.
Named15 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Council Tax Support - 2020/21 scheme
Councillor Hay and Councillor Miscandlon apologised to officers on behalf of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel, for deferring this item to a later meeting date.
Seconded15 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Council Tax Support - 2020/21 scheme
Proposed by Councillor Miscandlon, seconded by Councillor Hay and agreed that the item be DEFERRED in the absence of the relevant Portfolio Holders.
Asked15 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
Councillor Hay asked for an update on the Empress Swimming Pool in Chatteris and its status as an Asset of Community Value.
Named15 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
Officers provided Councillor Hay with an update.
Asked15 Jul 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Future Work Programme
Councillor Hay asked that Cabinet reconsider the appeals process and delegation for Assets of Community Value as Portfolio Holders are responsible for making decisions regarding Assets of Community Value and Cabinet are currently responsible for undertaking an appeals process which could be seen as a conflict of interest.
Named10 Jul 2019Fenland Development Forum
Introduction and Apologies
Lee Bevens, Eugene Cooper, Cllr Anne Hay, Keith Hutchinson, Carol Pilson, David Rowen, Martin Williams, Christian Wilson and Justin Wingfield.
Named3 Jun 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year.
It was proposed by Councillor Miscandlon and seconded by Councillor Bristow that Councillor Hay be nominated as Vice-Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel for the Municipal Year.
Named3 Jun 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year.
A vote was taken which resulted in the need for a casting vote by the Chairman for this Item, Councillor Miscandlon, resulting in Councillor Hay being appointed Vice-Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel for the Municipal Year.
Named29 May 2019Planning Committee
Appointment of Vice Chairman for the Municipal Year
It was proposed by Councillor Connor, seconded by Councillor Bristow and resolved that Councillor Hay be elected as Vice-Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year.
Said18 Apr 2019Cabinet
Economic Growth - update from the O&S Review
· Councillor Hay said that although she felt there were more statements than recommendations in the report, she was pleased to see that consideration is being given to business partnering via account manager.
Said18 Apr 2019Cabinet
Economic Growth - update from the O&S Review
· Councillor Hay commented that, sometime in the future, she would expect Cabinet to receive an update on progress made against some of the recommendations.
Said25 Mar 2019Staff Committee
New Alcohol and Drugs at Work Policy
· Councillor Hay noted the statement on Appendix 2 that the Council “would not necessarily have the jurisdiction to test contractors” and asked if this could be built into their contracts. Sam Anthony advised that this could be done with future contracts but in the case of existing contractors, the Council could either seek to test them or have them removed from the premises if suspected of being under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol.
Asked25 Mar 2019Staff Committee
New Alcohol and Drugs at Work Policy
· Councillor Hay asked if there had been a previous policy. Sam Anthony advised there had been a substance misuse policy but this was based on observed behaviour, whereas the testing process responds to a legitimate concern and provides fact.
Asked27 Feb 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1146/F. Land West Of 327, Norwood Road, March, Cambridgeshire Erection of 2 x single-storey 3-bed dwellings with attached single garage
· Councillor Hay asked whether any amended Highway plans had been submitted following a comment received from Cambridgeshire County Council Highways where they state that Prospect Road does not allow 2 way vehicle flow at the access and stated that it could result in vehicles being stationary on Wisbech Road. David Rowen stated that no amended plans were requested in respect of that comment, as it was considered that Prospect Road is of a limited width and the addition of 2 properties, although intensifying the use of the access, would not cause any problematic issue. In addition where Prospect Road meets Wisbech Road, there is quite a wide footway and parking area which was considered to provide a refuge if required.
Named21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Corporate Budget 2019 & Medium Term Financial Strategy
Members considered the Corporate Budget 2019 and Medium Term Financial Strategy report presented by Councillor Hay.
Said21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Corporate Budget 2019 & Medium Term Financial Strategy
Councillor Hay pointed out that should it be decided to set Council Tax at the same level as the current year, this would lead to a shortfall of £708,000 in 2020/21.
Named21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Corporate Budget 2019 & Medium Term Financial Strategy
[Councillor Hay abstained from voting on the proposal to amend Recommendation 3(x)]
Named21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Comprehensive Spending Review - Customer Services Review March and Wisbech
Members considered the Comprehensive Spending Review report into the relocation of the One Stop Shops in March and Wisbech presented by Councillor Hay.
Moved21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Comprehensive Spending Review - Customer Services Review March and Wisbech
Councillor Hay proposed a debate on moving to the Boathouse in Wisbech and to Fenland Hall in March.
Said21 Feb 2019Cabinet
Comprehensive Spending Review - Customer Services Review March and Wisbech
· Councillor Hay commented that moving into Fenland Hall would provide greater resilience as staff could be moved more easily between the contact centre and one stop shop area. There is not enough room at the library to house staff that currently work out of the March One Stop Shop, therefore some of these would have to be relocated to Fenland Hall anyway.
Seconded21 Feb 2019Council
Final Business Plan 2019-20
Proposed by Councillor Connor, seconded by Councillor Hay and AGREED to approve the Final Business Plan 2018-19.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Corporate Budget 2018 & Mid Term Financial Strategy
Members considered the Corporate Budget 2018 and Mid Term Financial Strategy report presented by Councillor Hay. Members were reminded that they were debating and voting on the altered recommendations which gave the option to either set Council Tax with a 1.97% increase [option ix (a)] or alternatively a 0% increase for this financial year [option ix (b)]. Members asked questions and made comments as follows:
Said21 Feb 2019Council
Corporate Budget 2018 & Mid Term Financial Strategy
· Councillor Hay stated her belief is that members would be doing this Council a disservice by supporting a 0% increase, as even with a 1.97% increase there would be a deficit in 2019/20 of £553k which will rise should 0% be supported. She feels there are a number of risks, such as the new homes bonus and fairer funding review and any new administration after May will face the prospect of having to go through a second comprehensive spending review to present a balanced budget for 2020/21.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Corporate Budget 2018 & Mid Term Financial Strategy
· Councillor Tierney respected the way Councillor Hay had made her case but he held a different view. He said Overview & Scrutiny had looked at the budget and under-spend over recent years and it is broadly their view that there is no need at this time to raise Council Tax. He acknowledged that there are potential risks in the future, but members are not here to do the easy thing, but to do the right thing.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Corporate Budget 2018 & Mid Term Financial Strategy
Councillor Hay made reference to failing to raise council tax by 2% this year will require the need to have a second comprehensive spending review next year but regardless of what the Council Tax increase may or may not be, we should be doing that anyway. The Council needs to continue to review what it does and look for additional savings to transform the way it delivers services to its residents. There is a culture of ultra-caution in this Council, proven by the level of surplus generated over the last five years and the problem with underspending by such a vast amount is that when members are making decisions, they are being made on a false premise.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Council Tax Resolution
Members considered the revised Report presented by Councillor Hay.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Senior Manager Pay Policy
Members considered the Senior Manager Pay Policy Statement Report presented by Councillor Hay.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
Senior Manager Pay Policy
He said that Councillor Hay had admirably laid out the legislative background but did she believe the outcomes from the pay structure throughout the Council are good?
Said21 Feb 2019Council
Senior Manager Pay Policy
Councillor Hay advised that it was entirely appropriate.
Said21 Feb 2019Council
Senior Manager Pay Policy
· Councillor Hay pointed out that the Chief Executive’s pay is slightly misleading as it also includes the car allowance. Also, the pay was set by the previous leader and was well below that of his predecessor.
Named5 Feb 2019Corporate Governance Committee
Previous Minutes
· Cllr Sutton stated that at the end of item CGC20/18, it had been agreed that a letter would be sent to Councillor Buckton, Councillor Hay and Anna Goodall recommending that the Council pursue the options available in relation to an electronic claims system for member’s expenses. He asked if this letter had been sent.
Named17 Jan 2019Cabinet
Fees and Charges 2019/20
Members considered the Fees and Charges for 2019/20 report presented by Councillor Hay. Cabinet considered the recommendations of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and AGREED to approve the Fees and Charges for 2019/20.
Said17 Jan 2019Cabinet
Comprehensive Spending Review - CCTV Delivery
Members made the following comments: · Councillor Hay said that both the Clerk and Finance Officer of Chatteris Town Council had stated they were very impressed by the presentation and they felt that partnering with Peterborough could only bring benefits to the service.
Said14 Jan 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Revised General Fund Budget and Capital Programme 2018/19; Draft General Fund Budget Estimates 2019/20 and Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2019/20 to 2023/24; Capital Programme 2019 - 2022.
Councillor Hay said the reason was not intended in this way.
Said14 Jan 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Revised General Fund Budget and Capital Programme 2018/19; Draft General Fund Budget Estimates 2019/20 and Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2019/20 to 2023/24; Capital Programme 2019 - 2022.
Councillor Hay explained that this figure will not be confirmed until February 2019 and will be a one-off payment to the Council therefore it has not been included in the budget. Kamal Mehta confirmed that the sum has been included in the accounts however will not show as it has been earmarked to the Council’s Brexit fund. Therefore, as it comes in and goes out of the accounts it does not show in the budget.
Said9 Jan 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/0899/F Site of former DRP Vehicle Services, Fallow Corner Drove, Manea Erection of 2x2-storey, 3 bed-dwellings and 1x2-storey, 4-bed dwelling
· Councillor Hay stated that the proposal for three properties on the development is too many and is cramped and, with regard to the width of the parking spaces, she feels that they are inadequate and will lead to on street parking. For those reasons she cannot approve the application.
Named13 Dec 2018Cabinet
Local Council Tax Reduction Scheme Review 2019/20
Members considered the Council Tax Reduction Scheme 2019/20 presented by Councillor Hay. Cabinet AGREED to recommend for Council approval the Council Tax Reduction Scheme effective from 1 April 2019 as set out in Section 2 and Appendix A.
Named13 Dec 2018Cabinet
Draft Budget 2019/20 & Medium Term Financial Strategy
Members considered the Draft Budget 2019/20 and Medium Term Financial Strategy presented by Councillor Hay.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
Council Tax Reduction Scheme (CTRS) - 2019/20
Members considered the Council Tax Reduction Scheme (CTRS) 2019/20, presented by Councillor Hay.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
Council Tax Reduction Scheme (CTRS) - 2019/20
· Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Hay for her responsiveness in proposing this item be considered earlier by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee next year.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
Polling Districts and Polling Places Review.
Members considered the Polling Districts and Polling Places Review, presented by Councillor Hay and Councillor Boden.
Said13 Dec 2018Council
Polling Districts and Polling Places Review.
Councillor Hay said Councillor Boden had been heavily involved in the Working Group and has made a great contribution to the formulation of the report and amendments.
Seconded19 Jul 2018Cabinet
Economic Development
Councillor Hay seconded the amended recommendations.
Asked14 Jun 2018Cabinet
Proposed Disposal of Property Assets Report
· Councillor Hay asked for clarification and an explanation on section 1.2, where it states that a previous approach was set aside in favour of a more straightforward disposal strategy.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.