Asked12 Oct 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Update from Clarion
· Councillor Murphy asked what Clarion does to help elderly residents stay in contact as many elderly residents cannot use the digital services on offer? Sally Greethan stated that there are a variety of ways the elderly can stay in contact, the phone system is still in place during the week, there is a live smart scheme in place for elderly residents and there are staff on site ... view the full minutes text for item OSC68/23
Asked6 Jul 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Freedom Leisure
· Councillor Murphy asked if there were any plans to provide a swimming pool in Chatteris as it is a growing town with residents expecting it to have a pool.
Seconded8 Jun 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27
Proposed by Councillor Miscandlon, seconded by Councillor Murphy and agreed that Councillor Woollard be elected as Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel for the municipal year 2026/27
Seconded8 Jun 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Vice-Chairman for the Municipal Year 2026/27
Proposed by Councillor Miscandlon, seconded by Councillor Murphy and agreed that Councillor Foice-Beard be elected as Vice-Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Panel for the municipal year 2026/27
Seconded27 May 2026Planning Committee
Appointment of the Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year 2026/27
Proposed by Councillor Purser, seconded by Councillor Murphy and resolved that Councillor Marks be elected as Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027.
Asked2 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Road Safety Partnership Update
Councillor Murphy asked what the process is with road signs that have been damaged and left on the roadside. Simon Burgin stated that the highways network has an asset register and it is the job of the highways manager to review their part of the network and order news parts for missing signs to be repaired or replaced. ... view the full minutes text for item OSC43/23
Said4 Feb 2026Planning Committee
F/YR25/0808/RM Land North of 2-8 Gibside Avenue, Chatteris Reserved Matters application relating to detailed matters of appearance, landscaping, layout and scale pursuant to outline permission F/YR22/1186/FDC to erect up to 4x dwellings and associated works
· Councillor Murphy expressed the view that the proposal fills a gap, it is built up around the site, and it was a piece of land that was always going to be built on so he fully supports it.
Moved4 Feb 2026Planning Committee
F/YR25/0808/RM Land North of 2-8 Gibside Avenue, Chatteris Reserved Matters application relating to detailed matters of appearance, landscaping, layout and scale pursuant to outline permission F/YR22/1186/FDC to erect up to 4x dwellings and associated works
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Purser and agreed that the application be GRANTED as per officer’s recommendation.
Named4 Feb 2026Planning Committee
F/YR25/0808/RM Land North of 2-8 Gibside Avenue, Chatteris Reserved Matters application relating to detailed matters of appearance, landscaping, layout and scale pursuant to outline permission F/YR22/1186/FDC to erect up to 4x dwellings and associated works
(Councillor Benney declared that he was portfolio holder at the time this land was sold and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon.) (Councillor Mrs French registered, in accordance with Paragraph 2 of the Code of Conduct on Planning Matters, that she had been lobbied on this application.) (Councillor Murphy registered, in accordance with Paragraph 14 of the Code of Conduct on Planning Matters, that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning.
Seconded19 Jan 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Chairman for the Remainder of the Municipal Year 2025/26
It was proposed by Councillor Miscandlon, seconded by Councillor Murphy and resolved that Councillor Woollard be elected as the Chairman of Overview and Scrutiny for the rest of the municipal year 2025/26.
Seconded19 Jan 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Appointment of Vice-Chairman for the Remainder of the Municipal Year 2025/26
It was proposed by Councillor Miscandlon, seconded by Councillor Murphy and resolved that Councillor Foice-Beard be elected as Vice-Chairman for the rest of the municipal year 2025/26.
Asked19 Jan 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Review of Fees and Charges 2026/27
· Councillor Murphy asked why the charges for the Whittlesey Fair are lower in cost than any of the other main towns?
Said19 Jan 2026Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Revised General Fund Budget and Capital Programme 2025/26, Draft General Fund Budget Estimates 2026/27 and Draft Medium Term Financial Strategy 2026/27 to 2030/31 and Capital Programme 2026/27 to 2028/29
· Councillor Murphy pointed out a typo error on pages 49 and 50 Councillor Boden assured this would be amended before it is submitted to Council.
Named8 Sep 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Sutton asked Councillor Murphy whether he could provide an update with regard to Waste Vertical Integration (WVI) and also with regard to the abolition of the charge for brown bin collections as was indicated during the election period?
Said8 Sep 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy stated ... view the full minutes text for item C21/20
Asked8 Sep 2020Cabinet
Previous Minutes
Councillor Murphy asked for it to be noted that under CAB/11/20, Capital Programme Update the £19,000 that Councillor Mrs French had referred to was actually being used towards lighting at West End Skate Park.
Said8 Sep 2020Cabinet
Coates Conservation Area Appraisal
Councillor Murphy said that he is glad to see the green areas are being kept for perpetuity as they are an asset to the village of Coates and added that the old photographs within the report were wonderful to see.
Said2 Sep 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0537/F 16 North Street, Wisbech,Change of use of ground floor from offices to 5 x1-bed and 1 x 2-bed flats including erection of a 2 metre high close boarded timber fence/gate, addition of cladding and painting of brickwork and refurbishment of windows to flats 1-10
· Councillor Murphy expressed the view that he is pleased to see where the refuse and recycling has been accommodated and asked for clarification with regard to one of the conditions where it states that the boundary treatments and access control measures shown, shall be fully implemented and maintained in perpetuity thereafter and he asked who will be maintaining this and where is this documented?. Gavin Taylor stated that whoever is controlling this building will be responsible for ensuring that they are maintained in perpetuity and if the property is sold then the planning condition will remain with the land Members asked questions, made comments and received responses as follows:
Named2 Sep 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0603/F Land West Of 44 Robingoodfellows Lane Fronting, Norwalde Street, March, Erect 1 dwelling (2 storey 3-bed)
· Councillor Murphy made comments regarding the impact on the street scene.
Said6 Aug 2020Cabinet
Capital Programme Update
Councillor Murphy said that this figure was originally set aside to pay for replacement of the skate ramps. However, when it came to it there had been enough money received from a variety of sources to be able to update the entire skate park. He agreed that all the work had been done and said he would look into this further as to why the figure had not been removed.
Named6 Aug 2020Cabinet
Capital Programme Update
Councillor Boden thanked Mark Saunders and asked Councillor Murphy if he could circulate the information to Cabinet members once it had been identified. Cabinet AGREED to approve the updated capital programme and funding schedule at Appendix A of the report.
Asked29 Jul 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0224O Land West Of 36, Peterborough Road, Whittlesey.Erection of 9no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access and layout) including demolition of existing greenhouses (retrospective)
· Councillor Murphy asked for clarification with regard to refuse collection and stated that at 5.3 in the officer’s report, it makes reference to a private road having to be constructed to a suitable standard to accommodate a 26 tonne vehicle, and questioned what is deemed as suitable. David Rowen stated that a suitable road would need to be constructed to accommodate physically a vehicle of that size. A condition is included with regard to the agreement of a refuse collection strategy to be in place prior to the first occupation and as part of that if it is the intention of the applicant to build a road, which would be to an adoptable standard, which would allow the Council’s refuse vehicles to collect.
Seconded24 Jun 2020Planning Committee
Appointment of Vice Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year 2020 - 2021
It was proposed by Councillor Meekins, seconded by Councillor Murphy and resolved that Councillor Hay be elected as Vice-Chairman of the Planning Committee for the Municipal Year.
Named24 Jun 2020Planning Committee
Adoption of Planning Validation Requirements
(Councillor Murphy had left the meeting prior to consideration of this item)
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Murphy expressed the opinion that the proposal is in an elsewhere location and is a distance from the built up area of Chatteris. He expressed the view that it cannot be classed as infill development and there is no footpath or lighting on that particular stretch of the road.
Said13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Murphy added that the proposal is against the aims and objectives of the National Planning Policy Framework and also against Policies LP3 and LP16 of the current Local Plan.
Named13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Hay expressed the view that she agrees with Councillor Murphy and stated that although there will be a new Local Plan in time, it is the current Local Plan which members should be considering when determining applications.
Moved13 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0120/O Land West Of Gaultree Lodge, London Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, Erect a dwelling (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Mrs Mayor that the application be REFUSED as per the officer’s recommendation. T his was not supported on a vote by members, which included the use of the Chairman’s casting vote.
Asked7 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR20/0083/F The Hollies, Middle Broad Drove, Tydd St Giles, Cambridgeshire Erect a 3-storey 4/5-bed dwelling with detached garage and study above involving demolition of existing dwelling and change of use of land from paddock to garden
· Councillor Murphy asked for clarification with regard to the replacement increase of the new dwelling which is shown in the officer’s report as 257% and asked what the normal percentage that would be expected. David Rowen stated that the policy in the Local Plan talks about it being similar. The percentage increase in the proposal is significant and the scale is considered as inappropriate in this particular case.
Said6 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR14/0977/O Pike Textile Display Limited, 16 North End, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire. Erection of 21 dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved)
· Councillor Murphy stated that in his opinion, as long as officers are in discussions with the Lead Local Flood Authority to ensure any issues and concerns are resolved, as well as officers finalising the details with regard to the section 106 agreement, he can see no reason why this application should be refused, it will bring much needed housing into Wisbech.
Named6 May 2020Planning Committee
F/YR14/0977/O Pike Textile Display Limited, 16 North End, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire. Erection of 21 dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved)
· Councillor Sutton stated that he concurs with Councillor Murphy and added that whilst he appreciates it is an indicative plan, there needs some consideration given at the reserved matters stage with regard to the parking layout.
Named20 Feb 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Wicks addressed Councillor Murphy and congratulated the ‘Get it Sorted’ team on the amount of information being passed to members and residents concerning recycling.
Said20 Feb 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy stated that the collection dates are already on the council’s website.
Named20 Feb 2020Council
General Fund Budget Estimates 2020/21 and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2020/21 to 2024/25; Capital Programme 2020 - 2023.
In Favour: Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
Named20 Feb 2020Council
Council Tax Resolution.
In favour of the proposal - Councillor Benney, Councillor Mrs Bligh, Councillor Boden, Councillor Booth, Councillor Connor, Councillor Cornwell, Councillor Count, Councillor Mrs Davis, Councillor Divine, Councillor Mrs French, Councillor Miss French, Councillor Hay, Councillor Hoy, Councillor Humphrey, Councillor Mrs Laws, Councillor Lynn, Councillor Marks, Councillor Mason, Councillor Maul, Councillor Meekins, Councillor Murphy, Councillor Patrick, Councillor Purser, Councillor Rackley, Councillor Seaton, Councillor Sutton, Councillor Tierney, Councillor Wallwork and Councillor Wicks and Councillor Yeulett.
Asked20 Feb 2020Cabinet
South Fens Enterprise Park Development Proposals
Councillor Murphy asked that when further units are built could they be built larger than the existing incubator units. They are ideal for new businesses as a start but as they grow the units become too small for their needs so they then move out of Chatteris.
Said10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Murphy explained that the Council are currently considering the options available to them and members will be kept updated.
Said10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that the Council hope to have a new service in place within the next 3-4 months.
Said10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that this information is contained within the survey and literature available on the website too. He added that the disposal of food waste is a priority of central government who are developing a waste and resources strategy. He confirmed that in Fenland, food waste must be placed in the residual bin.
Said10 Feb 2020Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2019-2020.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that there had been issues with graffiti in March recently however these had been reported ... view the full minutes text for item OSC40/19
Said29 Jan 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/0931/O - Erect up to 9no dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved) - Land South Of 137, Upwell Road, March, Cambridgeshire.
Councillor Murphy agreed with officer’s recommendation to refuse planning permission.
Seconded29 Jan 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/0931/O - Erect up to 9no dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved) - Land South Of 137, Upwell Road, March, Cambridgeshire.
Proposed by Councillor Meekins, seconded by Councillor Murphy that the application be refused as per officer’s recommendation.
Said29 Jan 2020Planning Committee
F/YR19/1031/O - Erect up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access) - Land North West of 24 Willey Terrace, Doddington Road, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Murphy stated that the road currently has a ‘stop line’ of development and this should be adhered to. He stated that if planning permission is granted for three dwellings, this will no doubt spread over time. He agreed with officer’s recommendation to refuse planning permission.
Named9 Jan 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Patrick addressed Councillor Murphy and asked for an update with regard to the possibility of the re-introduction of the free collection of brown bins.
Said9 Jan 2020Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy replied that there are no plans to reinstate the free collections. He added that Central Government will make the decision over the next few years as to whether they will fund a free collection and if they do, this free service will be passed onto residents.
Named9 Jan 2020Cabinet
Environmental & Waste Statement of Intent (3Rs)
Members considered the Environmental & Waste Statement of Intent report presented by Councillor Murphy.
Said9 Jan 2020Cabinet
Environmental & Waste Statement of Intent (3Rs)
Councillor Murphy agreed this was an error and accepted the amendment. Cabinet AGREED:
Named11 Nov 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Environmental Enforcement Contract- progress update
Carol Pilson informed members that unfortunately Councillor Murphy was unable to attend today’s meeting due to personal circumstances.
Named11 Nov 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Environmental Enforcement Contract- progress update
Officers are also working alongside Portfolio Holders, Councillor Murphy and Councillor Tierney.
Said6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1108/FDL - Erection of a part 2-storey, part 3 storey and part 4-storey building comprising of: 1 x retail unit (A1) and up to 26 x flats involving demolition of existing building (outline application with matters committed in respec
Councillor Murphy agreed and stated that development of the site is long overdue.
Declared6 Nov 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0726/O - Erect 1no dwelling with attached garage (outline application with matters committed in respect of access and layout) - Land North Of 20, St Francis Drive, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Hay declared an interest by virtue of the fact that she is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Benney declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) The meeting was adjourned at 2.24pm.
Named4 Nov 2019Cabinet
Play Areas
Members considered the report on Fenland’s play areas detailing the planned refurbishment programme and the potential capital investment necessary for a 5-year plan presented by Councillor Murphy.
Said4 Nov 2019Cabinet
Play Areas
Councillor Murphy pointed out that there was a discrepancy on the report between the table and the narrative. Namely the table at paragraph 4.4 of the report should state Burcroft Road and not Jasmine Close. The play equipment at Jasmine Close does not require planned maintenance.
Asked4 Nov 2019Cabinet
Play Areas
Further to the recommendation within the report, Councillor Murphy asked if Members would agree to a second recommendation, that being to delegate to the Portfolio Holder for Environment any changes to the planned replacement programme outlined at 4.4 of the report.
Said4 Nov 2019Cabinet
Play Areas
Councillor Murphy replied that this is happening now, and at the last Cabinet meeting in September Councillor Hoy suggested it would also be useful to have information in relation to non-council owned play equipment across the district, as this would give a true reflection of all play areas. This would help us to make informed future investment decisions based on need and ensure as far as possible there is equity of equipment across the area.
Named4 Nov 2019Cabinet
Play Areas
Councillor Boden thanked Councillor Murphy and said he is looking forward to seeing the comprehensive list of play equipment across the whole of Fenland, whoever owns them. The report in front of us today concerns replacement equipment on existing sites and if external sources of funding become available at short notice, knowing the totality of provision across Fenland will be extremely helpful in helping us to focus our attention where it is most needed. Cabinet AGREED to approve the planned approach to capital spending identified in the report, and ask that the S151 officer make appropriate funding available within the Council’s capital programme where identified should additional Section 106 funding or external funding not be available by the time the replacement work is due.
Named4 Nov 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
He asked Councillor Murphy what is the level of recycling of the materials collected by Street Pride and what is the level of recycling undertaken by Street Scene officers as part of their collection of waste around the area?
Said4 Nov 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy thanked Councillor Wicks for the question, stating he would get back to him with the answer.
Named4 Nov 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Hay addressed Councillor Murphy, saying that she understood there is a waste duty of care for waste disposal but asked why the fixed penalty notice is £400 for householders but only £300 for a business trade waste offence.
Said4 Nov 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy responded that he would ... view the full minutes text for item C44/19
Said9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR17/0349/VOC Variation of conditions 2 and 3 of appeal reference APP/D0515/C/15/3008989 relating to planning permission F/YR14/0854/F to increase the number of static caravans from 5 to 8 and touring caravans from 1 to 5 (to be used by t
Councillor Murphy highlighted that when members had visited the site, it had been well maintained and tidy. He hoped that if members approve the application today, that this continues.
Declared9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0152/O - Erection of up to 50no dwellings (outline application with all matters reserved); Land South Of, 8 - 59 Fairbairn Way, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire
She left the Chamber for the duration of this agenda item) (Councillor Benney declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters)
Declared9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0510/LB - Demolition of a Listed Building (existing derelict structures); 11 - 12 High Street, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Hay and Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that they were members of Cabinet and had been involved in a decision in relation to this proposal.
Declared9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0509/F - Erect 5-storey mixed use development (1 x retail unit to ground floor and 11 x 1-bed and 4 x 2-bed flats to remaining floors) involving demolition of existing derelict structures in a Conservation Area; 11 - 12 High Street, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Hay and Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that they were members of Cabinet and had been involved in a decision in relation to this proposal. They took no part in the discussion or vote for this item) ... view the full minutes text for item P37/19
Named9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0684/O - Erect up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access); Land East Of 4A, Primrose Hill, Doddington, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Murphy disagreed and stated that the site is located outside of the village. He highlighted that by approving the application, a precedent will be set for other sites located in open countryside. He supported officer’s recommendations to refuse the application as it does not comply with policy.
Named9 Oct 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0684/O - Erect up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access); Land East Of 4A, Primrose Hill, Doddington, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Hay agreed with Councillor Murphy and highlighted the open countryside adjacent to the site.
Named18 Sep 2019Council
To receive any announcements from the Chairman of the Council and/or the Head of Paid Service.
Councillor Murphy made the following statement in relation to this year’s In Bloom awards;
Named18 Sep 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Mrs Bligh stated that following her suggestion at the last meeting of Council regarding the dog fouling prevention stencils, she had engaged with Councillor Murphy and thanked him for his support on this project. She explained that hopefully with the support of the Highways Authority the project can move forward.
Named18 Sep 2019Council
Motion submitted by Councillor Chris Boden regarding Sky/Chinese Lanterns.
Councillor Boden confirmed this was agreed as part of an executive decision made by Councillor Murphy 10 months ago.
Named18 Sep 2019Cabinet
Open Spaces - Play Areas.
Cabinet considered the Open Spaces – Play Areas report presented by Councillor Murphy.
Named18 Sep 2019Cabinet
Open Spaces - Play Areas.
Councillor Boden proposed that Councillor Murphy and officers give consideration to formulating an appropriate plan for future year’s works on existing play areas and equipment. He asked that budgetary requirements are considered as part of this research including the potential use of existing and future Section 106 monies.
Said18 Sep 2019Cabinet
Open Spaces - Play Areas.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that the Council do have a future works programme for existing play equipment with work scheduled for the next 5-10 years. He explained that whilst Section 106 funding can be considered there are alternative funding streams available to the Council too. He agreed to share this information with members at a future meeting of Cabinet.
Named18 Sep 2019Cabinet
Open Spaces - Play Areas.
Councillors [name removed] asked if she could discuss with Councillor Murphy the potential of a new state-of-the-art BMX track in March and the possible funding available for this.
Said18 Sep 2019Cabinet
Open Spaces - Play Areas.
Councillor Murphy agreed.
Moved11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0518/F Erect 4 dwellings (2 x 2-storey 4-bed and 2 x 2-storey 3-bed) with garages;Land East Of Tindall Mill, Kirkgate, Tydd St Giles, Cambridgeshire
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Sutton and decided that the application be GRANTED subject to an additional condition being attached to the planning permission regarding access details; as per officer’s recommendation.
Named11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0636/FDC Erect 1 dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved); Land South Of 18, Rowan Close, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
Councillor Benney, Councillor Sam Clark and Councillor Murphy left the Chamber.
Declared11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0636/FDC Erect 1 dwelling (outline application with all matters reserved); Land South Of 18, Rowan Close, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire
(Councillor Benney, Councillor Sam Clark and Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that at they are members of Cabinet and had been involved in a decision in relation to this proposal.
Named11 Sep 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0179/VOC Variation of condition 4 of planning permission F/YR17/0685/VOC (Erection of 6 x 3-storey, 3-bed dwellings with balcony to front and integral garage and 4 x 3-storey, 2-bed dwellings) in relation to access;Land South West Of, Queen Street Close, March,Cambridgeshire
Councillor Benney, Councillor Sam Clark and Councillor Murphy returned to the Chamber.
Moved14 Aug 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0186/O Erection of up to 19 no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access) involving demolition of existing dwelling and outbuildings; 158 Stonald Road, Whittlesey.
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Sam Clark and decided that the application be APPROVED, subject to the conditions stated, as per the officer’s recommendation.
Named18 Jul 2019Cabinet
Play Equipment - Response to motion
Members considered the Open Spaces – Play Area Equipment report in response to a motion at Council on 23 May 2019, presented by Councillor Tierney on behalf of Councillor Murphy.
Said19 Jun 2019Planning Committee
Previous Minutes
· With regard to minute number P5/19 concerning application F/YR18/0458/F, Councillor Murphy clarified that the point he raised should read ‘Councillor Murphy highlighted that the proposed application complies with the National Planning Policy Framework.
Named19 Jun 2019Planning Committee
Previous Minutes
He added that if the planning permission complies with Policy LP15 of the Fenland Local Plan, which ensures suitable vehicular and pedestrian access there is no reason that the application should not be approved.’ · Coucillor Hay highlighted that also in minute P5/19, there is an error and it should read that Councillor Patrick agreed with Councillor Murphy that the proposal complies with planning policy and there is no reason for the application not to be approved.
Asked29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR12/0569/O Residential development of up to 149 dwellings; retail development ;open space; landscaping and pedestrian, cycle and vehicular access off 46 Lynn Road
Councillor Murphy asked for confirmation that this application is for outline planning permission and not full planning permission. David Rowen confirmed that the application is for outline planning permission.
Said29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR12/0569/O Residential development of up to 149 dwellings; retail development ;open space; landscaping and pedestrian, cycle and vehicular access off 46 Lynn Road
Councillor Murphy agreed but stated that a timescale for completion of the legal agreement needs to be stipulated to avoid further delays.
Said29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/0458/F Site of Former Kingswood Park Residential Home, Kingswood Road, March; Erection of 24x 2 storey dwellings comprising of 12 x 2 bed and 12 x 3 bed, together with an extension to Kingswood Road to provide new vehicular and pedestrian access
Councillor Murphy highlighted that the proposed application complies with National Planning Policy Framework. He added that if the planning permission complies with Policy LP15 of the Fenland Local Plan, which ensures suitable vehicular and pedestrian access, there is no reason for the application to be approved.
Named29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/0458/F Site of Former Kingswood Park Residential Home, Kingswood Road, March; Erection of 24x 2 storey dwellings comprising of 12 x 2 bed and 12 x 3 bed, together with an extension to Kingswood Road to provide new vehicular and pedestrian access
Councillor Patrick agreed with Councillor Murphy that the proposal complies with planning policy and there is no reason for the application to be approved.
Moved29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/0458/F Site of Former Kingswood Park Residential Home, Kingswood Road, March; Erection of 24x 2 storey dwellings comprising of 12 x 2 bed and 12 x 3 bed, together with an extension to Kingswood Road to provide new vehicular and pedestrian access
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Patrick and decided that the application be APPROVED as per officer’s recommendation.
Declared29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1103/VOC Anaerobic Digester Plant, Iretons Way, Chatteris; Variation of Conditions of Planning Permission F/YR14/0163/F
(Councillor Benney declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he attends Chatteris Town Council planning meetings but takes no part in discussions) (Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters) (Councillor Connor declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he has been lobbied on this agenda item)
Said29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0139/F Rear of 50 Wood Street, Chatteris.Erection of 2no single-storey 2 bed dwellings and erection of a single-storey double garage for No 50, including removal of existing garage and alternations to access
Councillor Murphy said it was refreshing to see a site proposing the development of 2 sought after bungalows. He said the proposed dwellings will have ample space and have been designed well. He stated that he fully supports the application.
Moved29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0139/F Rear of 50 Wood Street, Chatteris.Erection of 2no single-storey 2 bed dwellings and erection of a single-storey double garage for No 50, including removal of existing garage and alternations to access
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Connor and decided that the application be APPROVED as per the officer’s recommendation.
Declared29 May 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0139/F Rear of 50 Wood Street, Chatteris.Erection of 2no single-storey 2 bed dwellings and erection of a single-storey double garage for No 50, including removal of existing garage and alternations to access
(Councillor Benney declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he lives in close proximity of the proposed development and left the Council Chamber for the entirety of this agenda item) (Councillor Murphy declared an interest by virtue of the fact that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning matters)
Said24 Apr 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1104/F Land east of 13 Norfolk Street, facing Orange Grove, Wisbech Erection of a 3 storey block of flats comprising 2x2 bed and 1x1 bed
Councillor Murphy commented that the proposal tidies up the area and enhances it and Councillor Benney concurred.
Moved24 Apr 2019Planning Committee
F/YR18/1104/F Land east of 13 Norfolk Street, facing Orange Grove, Wisbech Erection of a 3 storey block of flats comprising 2x2 bed and 1x1 bed
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Benney and decided that the application be APPROVED; as per the officer’s recommendation.
Asked24 Apr 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0146/O Land South and West of 4-5 Mill Hill Lane, March Erection of up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Murphy asked for clarification as to where the 18 responses from the public which had been received had originated from. Sheila Black stated that they had been received from within the ward and any received from outside the ward had been discounted.
Asked24 Apr 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0146/O Land South and West of 4-5 Mill Hill Lane, March Erection of up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Murphy asked for further clarification with regard to specific addresses of support and objection to the proposal which [name removed] ascertained and provided to members.
Asked24 Apr 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0146/O Land South and West of 4-5 Mill Hill Lane, March Erection of up to 3no dwellings (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
Councillor Murphy asked for confirmation as to how far the residents would have to move their refuse and recycling bins to the designated collection point. Sheila Black confirmed that plot 3 would have to move their bins 110 metres and plot 1 would be 75 metres. ... view the full minutes text for item P76/18
Asked18 Apr 2019Cabinet
Economic Growth - update from the O&S Review
· Councillor Murphy asked if there was a timescale to deliver the recommendations. The Chief Executive advised that there is no specific timescale but officers are working behind the scenes on proposals. Thought is already being given to what the economic growth delivery team may look like and work is being undertaken on a commercial investment strategy.
Seconded27 Mar 2019Planning Committee
F/YR19/0042/F Land North of 101 and 101A Elm Low Road, Wisbech Erection of 3x2-storey dwellings, comprising of 2x3 bed and 1x2 bed
Proposed by Councillor Mrs Bligh, seconded by Councillor Murphy and decided that the application be APPROVED; as per the officer’s recommendation.
Said19 Mar 2019Corporate Governance Committee
Risk based Internal Audit Plan 2019/20.
Councillor Murphy explained that the Contracts Manager is responsible for the monitoring of both the Freedom Leisure contract and the Tivoli Contract.
Said19 Mar 2019Corporate Governance Committee
Risk based Internal Audit Plan 2019/20.
Councillor Murphy explained that due to the size of Freedom Leisure, there should be little concern regarding the management of their contract with the Council.
Said27 Feb 2019Planning Committee
F/YR17/1127/O. North of The Green and North of 145-159 Wisbech Road, March, Cambridgeshire 118no dwellings involving demolition of 147a Wisbech Road (outline application with matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Murphy stated that 12 statutory consultees have raised no objections to this application and, therefore, he cannot see any reason for it to be refused.
Named21 Feb 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor French asked Councillor Murphy what is happening with the river in March whereby a number of boats continue to overstay their mooring times, frustrating local residents, and how the situation will be resolved, acknowledging that one side is the responsibility of Middle Level and the other side the responsibility of the Council.
Said21 Feb 2019Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy responded that the Council now has a scheme in place to issue penalties to those who stay longer than 48 hours at our moorings and with more boaters mooring in the better weather, formal monitoring will now take place, with those in contravention of the limit being issued with a fixed penalty notice. Unfortunately, some boaters then move to the opposite bank which is not subject to our scheme. He added that the Council is liaising with Middle Level regarding this practice to prevent it occurring and the Council will also investigate Council Tax evasion with these boat owners.
Said18 Feb 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Progress in Delivering the Environment Corporate Objectives 2018-2019.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that as Kingdom’s patrols become more effective, there is less need for them to patrol certain areas. 5.
Said14 Jan 2019Overview and Scrutiny Panel
Review of Fees and Charges 2019/20.
Councillor Murphy explained that this is a very competitive market and the private companies offering this service do not release their prices. Following a review, the Council are now achieving a larger amount of income in this area.
Named13 Dec 2018Cabinet
Clinical Waste Solutions
Members considered the Clinical Waste Solutions Report presented by Councillor Murphy.
Said13 Dec 2018Cabinet
Clinical Waste Solutions
Councillor Murphy said that there have been several date changes, but 1 April 2019 is the current confirmed date. Unfortunately the NHS has not been forthcoming with information regarding collection numbers.
Said13 Dec 2018Cabinet
Clinical Waste Solutions
Councillor Murphy advised that this is what we are trying to do, but we are dependent on the NHS.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Mrs French explained that there is a persistent issue with fly-tipping in Lambs Drove and asked Councillor Murphy if the Council had approached Cambridgeshire County Council and Landowners to explore the option of installing a barrier to prevent this from happening. She asked how many times the Council have removed fly-tipping from this location and what the associated cost has been.
Said13 Dec 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy explained that a barrier cannot be installed across the road, as residents have a right of way and access. He confirmed that it is an ongoing issue both on Fenland District Council and Cambridgeshire County Council land. He was unaware of the costs associated with the removal of this fly-tipping.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
Clinical Waste Solution.
Members considered the Clinical Waste Solution report, presented by Councillor Murphy.
Named13 Dec 2018Council
Clinical Waste Solution.
Councillor Murphy clarified that as negotiations with the NHS are ongoing, the Council must have this approval in case it is implemented prior to the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting takes place.
Seconded5 Dec 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0557/F Westhaven Nursery, Peterborough Road, Whittlesey Erection of 18 x 2 storey dwellings (Phase 2) comprising of 5 x 2 bed and 13 x 3 bed
Proposed by Councillor Mrs Laws, seconded by Councillor Murphy and decided that the application be APPROVED as per the officer’s recommendation.
Said20 Nov 2018Corporate Governance Committee
Treasury Management Strategy Statement and Annual Investment Strategy Mid-Year Review 2018/19
Councillor Murphy agreed and said consideration is given to each case as to whether it is best for the Council to purchase a piece of equipment or lease it.
Said20 Nov 2018Corporate Governance Committee
Items of Topical Interest
Councillor Murphy agreed, as waiting for the next CSR may take too long.
Named15 Nov 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
· Councillor Mrs Bligh asked Councillor Murphy if more enforcement patrols could be committed to the villages?
Said15 Nov 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy replied that there are fewer patrols because less is happening in the villages than the towns, but he will arrange a further patrol of the villages in this instance. · Councillor Mrs Bligh stated that there is still an issue with dog fouling and asked if Councillor Murphy would consider anti dog fouling stencils to be spray painted on pavements?
Said15 Nov 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy responded that this method was used about five or six years ago and did not work. · Councillor Bligh noted that the Council has committed investment to markets in the Fenland towns and requested a breakdown of the investment amount per town.
Said15 Nov 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy agreed to provide this. · Councillor Tibbs asked Councillor Oliver for updates on Wisbech Vehicle Exchange and the abandoned building at the top of Petts Close?
Asked12 Nov 2018Staff Committee
Overview of Sickness Absence
Members made comments, asked questions and received responses as follows: · Councillor Murphy asked how stress is measured as this is different to each individual? Sam Anthony agreed it is difficult to measure but there is a stress awareness policy and a stress risk assessment can be undertaken by trained staff or HR on individuals who state they are experiencing stress. There are six factors determined by the Health and Safety Executive to help identify what those stressors are.
Said7 Nov 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0526/F Land West of 114-116 Elm Road, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire Erection of up to 10 x 2 storey dwellings, comprising of 8x4 bed with garages and 2x3 bed, detached binstore.
Councillor Murphy said he could not see any reason to refuse this application.
Moved7 Nov 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0526/F Land West of 114-116 Elm Road, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire Erection of up to 10 x 2 storey dwellings, comprising of 8x4 bed with garages and 2x3 bed, detached binstore.
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Mrs Laws and decided that the application be APPROVED as per officer’s recommendation.
Said7 Nov 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0606/O Crowson Motors, 13-16a Roman Bank, Leverington, Cambridgeshire Erection of up to 4xdwellings
Councillor Murphy said he believed the development would improve the look of the existing site and could see no reason to refuse the application.
Moved7 Nov 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0606/O Crowson Motors, 13-16a Roman Bank, Leverington, Cambridgeshire Erection of up to 4xdwellings
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Mrs Hay and decided that the application be APPROVED as per officer’s recommendation.
Said10 Oct 2018Planning Committee
F/YR16/1170/O CFC Disposals Limited, Upwell Road, Christchurch,Wisbech Erection of up to 16 no dwellings (Outline matters committed in respect of access)
· Councillor Murphy commented that, in his opinion, it is development in the open countryside and, as Officer’s have pointed out, it is all linear development on that side of the road.
Said10 Oct 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0626/F 29A Maple Grove, March, Cambridgeshire,PE15 8HT Erection of a part 2-storey/single-storey side/rear extension and porch to front of existing dwelling
· Councillor Murphy stated that, on the site visit, it was felt that the proposal was not set far enough back, which would mean that if a vehicle was parked it would overhang the pavement.
Said13 Sep 2018Council
PETITION - Clinical Waste Collection Charges
Councillor Murphy addressed the petition with the following statement:
Said13 Sep 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy stated that he would see that this matter was addressed.
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee
F/YR17/0507/O, Land South East of 208 Coates Road, Coates .Erection of up to 60 x Dwellings (Outline with Matters committed in respect of access only)
· Councillor Murphy commented that the proposal if approved will mean it will go over the threshold for the village and asked whether this will set a precedent going forward with planning applications. David Rowen explained that thresholds are a complicated matter and the issue of thresholds in the Local Plan was never to put an absolute cap on development and the intention was to give a small element of control to local residents over what development could take place in their villages. As time has moved on, in particular with the appeal decision in Manea which identified that unless there is substantial planning harm which can be identified, the threshold issue itself is not one on which planning permission can be refused.
Said15 Aug 2018Planning Committee
F/YR17/0507/O, Land South East of 208 Coates Road, Coates .Erection of up to 60 x Dwellings (Outline with Matters committed in respect of access only)
· Councillor Murphy commented that with regard to the open space and play area he would like it noted that Fenland District Council will not be responsible for the upkeep and maintenance of these ... view the full minutes text for item P17/18
Moved15 Aug 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0381/F. Wisbech Grammar School, 46- 48 North Brink, Wisbech. Construction of a staff car park with access via Harecroft Road and link footpath to existing school and raising of existing Astro Turf Fence to 6.0 metres (max) on eastern side
Proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Clark and decided that the application be APPROVED as per the Officer’s recommendation.
Seconded15 Aug 2018Planning Committee
F/YR18/0568/F Land East of the Haven, Seadyke Bank, Murrow. Erection of 5no industrial buildings (B1) and offices and 1.8 metre high fencing
Proposed by Councillor Mrs Laws, seconded by Councillor Murphy and decided that the application be REFUSED as per the Officer’s recommendation.
Said19 Jul 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy responded that matched funding has not yet been secured. WREN who the Council used to obtain funding from no longer recognises Wisbech and March as it is outside its area. It is hoped that there will still be consultation in the late Summer with works to start in 2019;
Seconded19 Jul 2018Council
Appointment of Acting Monitoring Officer and Notification of Acting Deputy Monitoring Officer
It was proposed by Councillor Sutton, seconded by Councillor Murphy and AGREED to:
Said18 Jul 2018Planning Committee
F/YR17/0548/F - Land West of 338 and Land South East of 344 Main Road, Church End, Parson Drove - Change of Use of Barn to tea room and agricultural land to Ti-pee camping site and Erection of 2x2 storey 5 bed dwellings with integral garage (plot 1) and detached double garage (plot 2).
Councillor Murphy said Parson Drove and Church End are distinctly separate settlements and have developed in a predominantly linear form along the main road. He said the southern side of the road has remained undeveloped, as it is considered outside of the settlement boundary. He highlighted that the site is located in Flood Zone 3 and said public representation had discussed that the development would be built outside of the built-up area and would exceed the permitted limit for residential developments in the village.
Said20 Jun 2018Planning Committee
F/YR17/1147/F March Cold Stores Limited, 20 -24 Marwick Road, March Erection of a cold storage building including plant rooms, 6no loading docks, 14no vehicle charging points, 2no condensers and new hardstanding area
· Councillor Murphy stated he was also concerned with the ... view the full minutes text for item P4/18
Said17 May 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy explained that amendments had been made to the policy in relation to the overstay period and charges associated with this.
Said17 May 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy confirmed that this is the responsibility of Middle Level.
Said17 May 2018Council
To receive reports from and ask questions of Cabinet members with portfolio holder responsibilities, in accordance with Procedure Rules 8.1 and 8.2.
Councillor Murphy said he would provide Councillor Mrs French with a response after the meeting.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.