Council Committees
Cllr Vernon Smith had nominated Cllr Piers Camp for the position. There being no further nominations, the appointment was agreed.
Every time Gloucestershire's minutes name Councillor Smith, as the council published it.
Cllr Vernon Smith had nominated Cllr Piers Camp for the position. There being no further nominations, the appointment was agreed.
Question 3 - Cllr Vernon Smith questioned why road signs on Westgate Bridge, Gloucester, warning the public of roadworks in February, remained, despite the commitment for obsolete signage to be removed.
Question 4 – Cllr Vernon Smith referred to the estimated cost of the two bat mitigation structures of £166k and whilst recognising the importance of environmental protection issues questioned whether the Council could have implemented a more cost-effective solution.
Question 5 – Cllr Vernon Smith asked whether the Cabinet Member was of the view that the public should have been consulted and made aware of plans for asylum accommodation.
4.3 Cllr Vernon Smith (Chair of Council) “First of all, Mark, I would like to say thank you. I remember as a new councillor, and a bouncing puppy running around in 2009 “what can I do, how can I assist” I was very honoured to be appointed Cabinet Champion for Flooding in 2010. I would like to add that on the back of that I would say that Gloucestershire County Council has delivered nearly £50m in flood alleviation schemes with partners around the county and also protecting over 2000 properties from flooding.
GCC members Cons 3 Lib Dem 2 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 0 7 Cllr Rob Vines Cllr Paul Baker Cllr John Bloxsom Cllr Chris McFarling Cllr Matt Babbage Cllr Bernie Fisher Cllr Vernon Smith
2.2 Cllr Vernon Smith was proposed by Cllr Mark Hawthorne, Leader of the Council, and seconded by Cllr Lynden Stowe, Deputy Leader of the Council.
2.5 On being put to a recorded vote, it was RESOLVED that Cllr Vernon Smith be elected as Chair of Council for the 2024/25 Civic Year.
Voted for Cllr Vernon Smith (27) – Cllrs Carole Allaway Martin, Matt Babbage, Alastair Chambers, Stephen Davies, Stephen Fifield, Andrew Gravells, David Gray, Terry Hale, Tim Harman, Mark Hawthorne, Stephen Hirst, Nicholas Housden , Mark Mackenzie-Charrington , Paul McLain, Andrew Miller, Dominic Morris, Emma Nelson, Dave Norman, Sajid Patel, Alan Preest , Philip Robinson, Vernon Smith, Lynden Stowe, Brian Tipper, Pam Tracey, Robert Vines, Kathy Williams.
2.6 Cllr Vernon Smith made the Declaration of Acceptance of Office.
2.7 Cllr Smith asserted that he was humbled and honoured to have been elected as Chair of Council for a second year, and that he would continue to carry out his duties to the best of his ability.
A1 Scrutiny committees Ø Corporate Overview and Scrutiny GCC members Cons 6 Lib Dem 4 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 1 13 Cllr Matt Babbage Cllr Colin Hay Cllr Wendy Thomas Cllr Chloe Turner Cllr Alastair Chambers Cllr Andrew Gravells Cllr Roger Whyborn Cllr Paul McLain Cllr Lisa Spivey Cllr Kathy Williams Cllr Jeremy Hilton Cllr Andrew Miller Cllr Alan Preest Ø Health GCC members Cons 4 Lib Dem 3 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 9 Cllr Andrew Gravells Cllr David Brown Cllr David Drew Cllr Sue Williams Cllr Terry Hale Cllr Paul Hodgkinson Cllr Alan Preest Cllr Linda Cohen Cllr Pam Tracey Ø Adult Social Care and Communities GCC members Cons 5 Lib Dem 2 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 9 Cllr Terry Hale Cllr Lisa Spivey Cllr Steve Robinson Cllr Cate Cody Cllr Tim Harman Cllr Suzanne Williams Cllr Mark Mackenzie-Charrington Cllr Pam Tracey Cllr Vernon Smith Ø Children and Families GCC members Cons 5 Lib Dem 2 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 9 Cllr Nick Housden Cllr Linda Cohen Cllr David Drew Cllr Beki Hoyland Cllr Paul McLain Cllr Ben Evans Cllr Andrew Miller Cllr Emma Nelson Cllr Pam Tracey Ø Environment GCC members Cons 6 Lib Dem 3 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 11 Cllr Rob Vines Cllr Roger Whyborn Cllr Wendy Thomas Cllr Chloe Turner Cllr Alan Preest Cllr David Willingham Cllr Saj Patel Cllr Gill Moseley Cllr Vernon Smith Cllr Emma Nelson Cllr Brian Tipper Ø Joint Economic Growth GCC members Cons 4 Lib Dem 2 Lab 1 Green 1 Ind 0 7 Cllr Rob Vines Cllr Paul Baker Cllr John Bloxsom Cllr Chris McFarling Cllr Matt Babbage Cllr Bernie Fi
2.6 Cllr Vernon Smith was proposed and seconded.
In their nomination, the Leader and Deputy Leader highlighted that Cllr Smith was a dedicated, passionate, and enthusiastic councillor who was a true advocate for his communities and ambassador for the Council.
RESOLVED that Cllr Vernon Smith be elected as Chair of Council for the 2023/24 civic year.
Cllr Vernon Smith made the Declaration of Acceptance of Office.
2.8 Cllr Smith shared that he was very honoured and humbled to become the next Chair of Council and would endeavour to show the same level of commitment and fairness as his predecessor. He thanked members for their support.
3.5 Members congratulated both Cllr Smith and Cllr Williams on their election and wished them luck for their time in the roles.
Cllr John Bloxsom substituted at the meeting for Cllr Thomas, and Cllr Alan Preest substituted at the meeting for Cllr Smith.
Cllr Mark Hawthorne proposed and Cllr Andrew Miller seconded that Cllr Vernon Smith be nominated as Chair of the Environment Scrutiny Committee.
On being put the vote, it was RESOLVED that Cllr Vernon Smith be appointed as Chair of the Environment Scrutiny Committee.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the team were concentrating on the first part of the process - bringing orders to the committee.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied regarding the 1983 Act, a County definitive map was published which would include the city areas. He was happy to speak to the individual in more detail.
Cllrs Joe Harris and Rebecca Halifax presented a petition relating to the resurfacing of Victoria Road in Cirencester to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Vernon Smith suggested that a spokesperson from the Cotswold District Team communicate outcomes to stakeholders.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the Tour of Britain in Gloucestershire was welcome news. He noted the previous schemes carried out on the road network and the work that was continuing with highways managers and the programmes already in place.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that crossings were only one of the measures that could be put in place to help road safety. Some pedestrian crossings were part of schemes so it was difficult to have a complete picture.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that in an ideal world you would replace a paving slab with the same material. It was important, though, to make the location safe in an emergency, and that materials were not always readily available.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he had looked at the location for a crossing and he advised the member to talk to his local highways manager.
Cllr Smith was represented by Cllr Keja Berliner on behalf of Tewkesbury Borough Council.
Cllr Ben Evans presented a petition relating to a road junction in Churchdown to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Chloe Turner presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition for the Council to implement road safety measures and reduce the speed limit on a section of the A419 in Thrupp .
Cllr Roger Whyborn presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition calling on the Council to install an electronic pedestrian crossing on Warden Hill Road to help pupils attending Bournside , Belmont and Bettridge Schools to cross safely.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied he would be making further requests for a response on these points.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that this was an important question as the contract was short term and the industry was looking at a number of ways to research and reduce green solutions and lower temperature materials for the longer term.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood sought Cabinet approval to procure and award a contract for the delivery of structural maintenance works for up to 4 years from April 2022 to 2026, following the successful conclusion of the current contract.
Cllr Vernon Smith – Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood Cllr Kathy Williams – Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Delivery
Cllr Mark Hawthorne on behalf of Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood asked Cabinet to delegate authority to the Head of Highway Authority (in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood) for the purpose of procuring highway services and construction phase works, through competitive tender, in relation to Blakeney West Geotechnical Stabilisation Scheme and awarding contracts for the provision of such services and works.
Cllr Mark Hawthorne on behalf of Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood sought Cabinet approval for the Executive Director of Economy, Environment & Infrastructure to be authorised to procure a highways framework agreement for a term of four years with an estimated value of £60 million over its term. The proposed framework agreement would be set up under two lots; one for Highways Schemes and the other for Structures and Geotechnical Schemes.
Cllr Vernon Smith responded by providing assurances that the County Council took road safety seriously and was always looking to improve. 20mph speed limits were just one item in the tool kit to reduce speeds and make roads safer.
Cllr Paul Hodgkinson presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition calling for a weight limit to be installed in Bourton-on-the-Water due to the increasing disruption due to heavy goods vehicles.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that there was a meeting on 8 October with public rights of way officers to go through this in more detail. He put on record his thanks to the Commons and Rights of Way Team.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that there were £58m worth of flood alleviation schemes and he would happily show the member the work being carried out on gullying emptying and flood alleviation.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he would be happy to meet on site with the local highways manager and would look at what the Council could do to get the section completed.
Cllr Vernon Smith outlined as well as improving the road network, there was also cycling, walking and supporting the environment to reduce carbon emissions. He praised the scheme which was moving forward. The report outlined the work to reduce congestion and pollution on the A40 and ease people’s transition to incorporate sustainable transport into their everyday habits.
Cllr Vernon Smith outlined the investment in highways.
Cllr Vernon Smith agreed to arrange a visit when possible.
Cllr Vernon Smith advised in general that there were lots of positive walking and cycling schemes that were linked within major road schemes. They requested that [name removed] made contact directly if there were particular schemes causing concern so a more detailed response could be provided.
Cllr Vernon Smith advised they would speak with officers to share the data with the councillor and reiterated they would be happy to meet outside the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith expressed to hear jobs were not progressing as they should in the maintenance system. If the councillor would provide details, these jobs could be followed up on the system to see what the delay was.
Cllr Lynden Stowe – Deputy Leader & Cabinet Member for Finance and Change Cllr Stephen Davies – Cabinet Member for Childrens Safeguarding and Early Years Cllr Carole Allaway Martin – Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Commissioning Cllr Kathy Williams – Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care Delivery Cllr David Gray – Cabinet Member for Environment and Planning Cllr Dave Norman – Cabinet Member for Public Protection, Parking and Libraries Cllr Phil Robinson – Cabinet Member for Economy, Education and Skills Cllr Vernon Smith – Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood Cllr Tim Harman – Cabinet Member for Public Health and Communities
Cllr Vernon Smith responded that he would personally ensure that the team were considering that part of the legislation.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the team worked to the Transport Asset Management Plan looking at how we move forward and get the best value for money in the work carried out. He also detailed the Highways Maintenance Efficiency Plan, noting that the documents were available online.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that they were keen ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that so much significant highways work had been undertaken.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he understood the frustration and urged the individual to contact Tewkesbury Borough Council as they would be able to take action if Bovis Homes exceeded the threshold.
Cllr Stephen Davies presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition relating to the roundabout road improvements at the A38 Perry Way junction, near Frampton-on-Severn.
Cllr Smith thanked officers for their work on this project.
Cllr Phil Awford presented Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, with a petition relating to the concerns of the local community regarding the frequent closure of the A417 at Maisemore due to flooding.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he would.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he would update the member following the meeting.
Question 10: Cllr Rachel Smith Agenda Item 13: Contracts relating to the sale and purchase of Electricity and Gas Cllr Smith conveyed her disappointment that some of the answers to her questions had not been addressed.
Cllr Smith expressed concern that the error in Table 2 of the cabinet report, (energy consumption forecasts provided by West Mercia Energy had been published in the public domain.
Cllr Smith asked if the cabinet member was satisfied the cabinet report was accurate and enquired if the misreported information would affect the recommendations?
Question 16: Cllr Rachel Smith Agenda Item 13: Contracts relating to the sale and purchase of Electricity and Gas Cllr Smith relayed her understanding of the council’s commitment to reducing carbon emissions as a commitment to reducing emissions across the whole of the county, and not just to the council estate.
Cllr Smith referred to the assessment that the recommendation would have a ‘positive’ impact on tackling climate change referenced in the cabinet report and suggested that the ‘offset’ estimate included in the answer to her question should in fact refer to the council estate?
Cllr Smith asked if the cabinet member accepted that, in terms of climate change, the impact of the estimated reduction in net CO2 emissions after today’s decision, would, at best, be carbon neutral?
Question 18: Cllr Rachel Smith Agenda Item 13: Contracts relating to the sale and purchase of Electricity and Gas Cllr Smith questioned whether the council had engaged with other councils across the UK who had operated similar models for the purchasing and selling of electricity?
Cllr Smith asked why ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Vernon Smith advised that the question would be better addressed to officers at Cheltenham Borough Council.
Cllr Vernon Smith agreed to liaise with the officer who provided the information and the planning authority regarding this matter.
Cllr Vernon Smith suggested that [name removed] have a conversation with him outside of the meeting on the issue.
Cllr Vernon Smith agreed to ask the relevant officer to check where Great Western Terrace was in the programme for road resurfacing.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he would be happy to discuss the issue with Cllr Smith outside of the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought cabinet approval to authorise the Executive Director of Economy, Environment & Infrastructure to enter into a European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) agreement with the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government to undertake development works on the Gloucester & Sharpness Canal Towpath b etween Rea and Sellars Bridge, Gloucester.
Cllr Smith referred to the fantastic opportunities this phase of the development would bring to the local community. He emphasised how that the scheme would support the increased development between Gloucester and Hardwicke and the thriving outer city developments at Quedgeley and Kingsway. Significant additional growth was also anticipated at the new Hunts Grove Development, where it was hoped new residents would be encouraged to travel into Gloucester using the towpath.
Cllr Smith confirmed that this particular phase of the works included biodiversity enhancements to support habitat creation and that many residents were delighted by the scheme.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member: Highways and Flood, commended officers for staying on target with budget targets in spite of the challenges created by the recent storms that had affected the county. It was noted that the council’s £150 million highway investment programme was still on target. Having considered all of the information, including known proposals, alternative options and reasons for recommendations, Cabinet noted the report and, RESOLVED to: - 1.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that sometimes repairs had to be carried out in less than ideal weather, but were subject to regular inspections. He said that the way to reduce potholes was major resurfacing.
If Cllr Smith would like to put forward suggestions on how to address the climate change emergency and what services would need to be cut to allocate the additional funding, I would be interested to consider the proposals at the next council (budget) meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval to enter into a funding agreement with the Forest of Dean District Council in respect of the Lydney Coastal Community Fund Highway Improvement Scheme.
Cllr Smith informed members that the Forest of Dean District Council had been awarded funding from the Coastal Community Fund ( CCF ) for the “Destination Lydney Harbour Project”. The £1.9m Destination Lydney Harbour project aimed to attract increased visitor numbers to Lydney Docks and Harbour through a range of physical improvements to the canal and wider public realm, cycling and walking routes, and from the introduction of visitor information space and public toilet facilities at the docks.
Cllr Smith stated that the proposed agreement was an ‘enabling project’, aimed at creating an environment for the future economic growth and investment in this unique location.
Cllr Smith informed cabinet that the Forest of Dean District Council wished to enter into a joint funding agreement with Gloucestershire County Council (GCC) to provide £1.5 million of funding to the county council (as the local highways authority), to undertake the highway elements of the project. It was noted that the funding did not form part of the council’s £150 million investment in highways.
Question 3 : Cllr Paul Hodgkinson Agenda Item 6: Financial Monitoring Report Cllr Hodgkinson expressed concern about the negative feedback he had received in response to the new highway maintenance contract and asked what issues Cllr Smith was referring to when referring to ‘cost pressures’ experienced during the mobilisation stage and bedding in period of the contract?
Cllr Vernon Smith (Cabinet Member: Highways and Flood) Disappointed to hear ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval for the procurement and award of the council’s contract for the delivery of structural maintenance works in April 2020. In September 2017, a new delivery model was developed in consultation with Cabinet and a cross-party Cabinet Panel to take forward the way in which the council procured and delivered its highway contracts post April 2019.
Building on the success of the previous year, Cllr Smith explained that the contract for delivery of the council’s structural maintenance works with effect from 1 April 2020 would help in delivering the council’s £150 million investment in the county’s highways.
Outlining a variety of projects (both completed and underway), Cllr Smith stressed the importance of considering the county’s carbon footprint as part of the council’s commitment to reducing its carbon emissions. He also stressed the value of the proposed contract in enabling the council to bid for the best evaluations.
Commending the smooth delivery of the council’s resurfacing works during the past two years, Cllr Smith thanked the Highways Team for their hard work.
Cllr Vernon Smith, (Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood), sought authorisation for the Lead Commissioner, Highway Authority to receive funding from Highways England (via the Cotswold Canal Trust) for the proposes of procuring a contract for works in respect of the proposed A38/A419 Whitminster Roundabout Bridges and Canal Improvements Scheme.
Cllr Smith confirmed that the Cotswold Canal Trust had received two grants to support work on the Cotswold Canal Restoration Project. The grants comprised Heritage Lottery Funding and Highways England Funding. Total funding for the scheme was estimated at £4.5 million.
Outlining the options outlined in the cabinet decision report, Cllr Smith sought to authorise the Lead Commissioner: Highways Authority to progress the works, as described above.
Cllr Ward agreed to feedback to Cllr Smith of the Committees verdict.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he would be happy to do this.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that best practice was being followed but that he would be happy to discuss this when they met and go into more detail.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval to conduct a tender process and award a contract in respect of the A4173 Safer Roads Fund, ( Pitchcombe Junction Improvement Scheme), This Report is presented to Cabinet with the request to authorise the contract procurement and the making of any necessary ancillary orders for the A4173 Safer Roads Fund; Pitchcombe Junction Improvement Scheme.
Cllr Smith recalled that in 2018, the County Council had been successful in bidding for a funding package of just over £2m for safety improvements along the A4173 from the Department for Transport’s ( DfT ) Road Safety Foundation. This would be used to support the Council’s ongoing £150m investment in Gloucestershire Highways.
2.2 In addition, Cllr Smith suggested additional wording of: ‘The Chief Executive acknowledged that the council was in a poor negotiating position in relation to UBB’. The Committee as a whole did not agree to the change, but suggested that Rachel’s proposed amendment be included in the current meeting’s minutes to reflect her view.
2.4 Cllr Smith noted the action from the meeting for her to write up a one page strategy on the residual waste project. She had prepared a one page strategy and was seeking advice as to how to proceed. This was again picked up at the end of the meeting and officers would take this forward and provide advice.
5.4 Cllr Smith summarised the recommendations, highlighting in particular the ‘cut and collect’ business case and engagement with local council’s going forward. It was explained that a lot of the recommendations hinged on the need to reduce the fertility of soil which has become too nutrient rich.
5.5 An agreement was made between Cllr Moor, as the Cabinet Member responsible, Cllr Smith and the Committee that Cabinet would feedback on the recommendations in September.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that all schools would be made aware of the opportunities and he provided some detail of the strategy for cycling moving forward over a five year period. He thanked the Highways Advisory Board for their input and urged members to use their Highways Local money to improve cycling areas across the county.
Cllr Vernon Smith suggested that dialogue was the answer and that the member could meet with the Council’s Legal Team and restaurant owner to discuss the matter further.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the previous contractor Amey had only been paid for work completed.
Cllr Smith referred to the motion at full Council in June 2018, where it had been agreed unanimously to set up a task group to protect and encourage biodiversity in Gloucestershire. The cross-party membership of the task group had arranged several meetings, including a public workshop event in January 2019. The event had been well attended and had attracted a significant level of local and national interest.
Outlining the ambitions of the task group, Cllr Smith confirmed that the main focus had been the management of road verges (grass cutting). Another key factor had been the impact of litter on hedgerows and road verges. It was suggested the issue be communicated to Parish Councils.
6.8 Cllr Smith requested figures on how the third party recycling credits are paid to organisations.
Cllr Vernon Smith thanked [name removed] for bringing up the topic of cycling explaining that the £150 million investment in highways would help cyclists and other road users.He provided examples of how councillors could use their Highways Local money to help improve cycling safety.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that the Council took road safety very seriously and that highways managers continued to make sure inspection processes operated following national best practice.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated he would be happy to meet with the member and senior highways managers if the member had specific issues that he wished to raise.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he understood the frustration but that if there was an emergency involving utility companies then the Council was obliged by law to assist them where they took action. He would be happy to meet with the member to discuss further.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that he shared the frustration and that there was no consensus with the community. He was happy for him to work with the County Council and Local Highways Manager to see if safety measures could be put in place that everyone agreed with.
Cllr Nigel Moor presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith on behalf of Moreton Park residents relating to street lighting on a footpath.
Cllr Eva Ward substituted at the meeting for Cllr Smith.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval for the Council to act as the accountable body to funding streams for proposed works on the Gloucester Canal Towpath.
Cllr Smith gave a detailed account of the key points relating to the decision to undertake a major upgrade of the existing Gloucester Canal towpath between Gloucester City Centre and the South of the City.
Cllr Smith referred to the benefits of the scheme, including the ambition to extend and promote the local economy.
Outlining the political and officer support for the scheme, Cllr Smith confirmed that the proposed works were due to commence in August and September 2018, with an anticipated completion date of early 2019. The initial phase of works was to extend the Monks Meadow section of the towpath to Elmore Lane West.
Continuing to lobby on the second phase of the scheme, Cllr Smith informed members that officer advice was to proceed with the delivery of the first stage of the scheme utilising Section 106 contributions and funding secured from the Gloucestershire Environmental Trust.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval to adopt the new Code of Practice for Well Managed Highway Infrastructure and to bring the Highways Maintenance Policies and Processes in line with the new code.
Cllr Smith explained that the ‘Code of Practice for Well Managed Highway Infrastructure’ introduced in October 2016 was due for adoption in October 2018. Each highway authority would be required to determine codes of practice standards based on experiences and historical data to reflect local needs, priorities and affordability. The changes in policies to be aligned to the new Council strategy.
Cllr Smith elaborated on the importance of distinguishing what constituted a pothole when reporting road defects, which, as explained in his response to a member question earlier in the meeting, could be viewed differently by different road users.
Cllr Smith agreed with Cllr Ray Theodoulou, Cabinet Member for Finance and Change, that the financial incentive from the government to adopt the new code could be viewed as a ‘carrot and stick’ approach, but nevertheless, upheld the position that the code would be beneficial to the council when dealing with highway maintenance repairs in the future.
Cllr Smith referred to the backlog of highway repairs inherited from previous administrations and suggested that the improvements made since 2005 could be further improved following adoption of the code.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, gave a detailed summary of the decisions taken to fulfil the Council’s statutory duties in relation to highway maintenance and safety, including an outline of the investment proposals within the Highways Capital Programme.
Cllr Smith said how pleased he was to update members on the £150 million investment in Gloucestershire’s highways. Other cabinet members shared his enthusiasm, making particular reference to the £23 million plus investment in carriageway resurfacing works and the £2 million plus invested in supporting the programme of major schemes funded by the Gloucestershire (GFirst) Local Enterprise Partnership and Department of Transport. It was noted that a significant amount of national funding had been invested in Gloucestershire in this the first year of a 5 year rolling programme.
Cllr Theodoulou presented the report in conjunction with fellow cabinet colleagues, Cllr Nigel Moor, Cabinet Member for Fire, Planning and Infrastructure and Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, commended the merits of the scheme and expressed his full support for the proposals, clarifying that the scheme would be of major strategic importance to the road improvement works at Over and the Metz Way, due to commence later in the year.
Cllr Smith said the scheme would help in moving the county’s transport network into the 21 st Century. He also said that, if the council ‘didn’t invest in major projects, traffic in Gloucestershire would grind to a halt’.
Cllr Smith explained that the use of gender-neutral language was important to avoid bias towards a particular sex or social gender.
Cllr Smith explained that gender-neutral language was used for the most part within the Constitution, however the use was not consistent. It was therefore proposed that the language within the Constitution be tidied up so that it is gender-neutral throughout.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, presented a report on measures to improve the inspection and fixing of pavements to the Committee.
Question 13 - Max Wilkinson referred to a ‘pot hole summit’ in 2015 attended by Cllr Vernon Smith and County Council officers.
He asked that Cllr Vernon Smith confirm that he is politically responsible for fixing potholes in Cheltenham.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that there was additional investment for re-surfacing highways within the budget proposals. He encouraged members to report any defects on Highways.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that the total cost would be around £700,000 with the Council offering to put forward half the amount for the whole scheme to be delivered.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, expressed his appreciation and thanks to the Highway Team and to Gloucestershire Fire and Rescue Service for their commendable efforts during the recent period of bad weather.
Cllr Smith thanked officers for their support in providing information relating to the motion. She said that that the main drivers for electric vehicles were climate change, air quality and cost savings. She believed that it was incumbent on the Council to set an example.
Cllr Smith and Cllr Dobie accepted the following changes to the motion (see the highlighted text):
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he understood the frustration with landslips and that action with regards to this was prioritised, with the best way forward considered. This particular landslip was a complex one and he would be happy to meet with the member and officers at the site to discuss further.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, welcomed the scheme which he believed would complement the wider investment in the local road network. He expected work to start on site in Autumn 2018.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, gave a detailed update on the Council’s proposed Highways Services Procurement Strategy before seeking cabinet approval to carry out three legally compliant tender processes for the procurement and delivery of highway services. On conclusion of the tender processes, (and in consultation with the Cabinet Member), the Council to enter into a contract with the three preferred providers, evaluated as offering ‘best value for money’ for delivery of the required services.
Cllr Smith informed the meeting that, in consultation with cabinet members and following discussions with a cross-party Cabinet Panel, he and officers had developed a robust procurement strategy for delivery of the council’s highway services, post April 2019, (following expiry of the current Amey contract).
Cllr Smith informed members that the proposal was to move away from a single provider model to a multiple provider model, with some day to day operating decision-making and design of works being delivered by an-house team, resulting in approximately 45 staff transferring into the Council. The aim of the proposed model would allow the authority more control over the delivery of works, without significantly increasing its exposure to risk.
Outlining some of the principles on which the strategy would attempt to ensure the contract was the ‘right contract’, Cllr Smith confirmed that the intention was to carefully evaluate the quality of bidders, (soft market testing has already indicated a number of bidders have demonstrated an interest in bidding for the contract); continue to engage with the cross party Cabinet Panel; develop a long term, positive relationship with the Term Maintenance Contractor, and develop a reliable performance management system to ensure the successful delivery of the contract.
Cllr Smith said that the approach to be taken would be one of ‘evolution’ and not ‘revolution’.
Cllr Smith referred to the positive comments that had been received from the cross-party Cabinet Panel, (reported at Appendix B of the report). He reported that the panel met regularly and that he had been pleased with how the work of the group had progressed.
Outlining the proposed governance structure for delivering the new contracts, Cllr Smith explained how the council intended to manage performance, including the potential for poor performance. He informed members that use of the Highways Maintenance Efficiency Programme ‘standard’ contract documents, including new engineering contract, would ensure robust mechanisms were included in the contract, and enable any contractual and commercial issues to be resolved.
In addition, an update from Highways Development Management would be arranged for Cllr Smith on infrastructure in relation to the Brimscombe Port development.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the Council worked closely with the bio-diversity plan and that he would ask officers to provide her with a written response.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he agreed that there was a need to follow the guidance and action plans and thanked the member of the public for raising the issues. He asked that she provide him with details of where she felt there were failings and he would ask officers to look into it.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he was really interested in how Dorset was working and was keen to see the details. He would ask officers to speak to Dorset.
He requested that the petition be forwarded to Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, following the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he understood the frustration of the member and residents. He explained that all landslips were classed as a priority and needed to be evaluated. New photographs of the site suggested that there was still movement of the soil, once that movement had stopped work would begin to resolve the issue.
Cabinet Members Cllr Vernon Smith and Nigel Moor welcomed the increased investment proposed for their respective portfolio area, including the benefits anticipated from such investments.
Cllr Smith conveyed particular appreciation for the proposed increase of £4.325 million in the Highway Capital Budget and the added investment in the council’s road investment scheme. In noting the report, Cabinet RESOLVED to:
Cllr Nigel Moor presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith on behalf of Great Rissington residents regarding a highway matter.
In seconding the motion, Cllr Smith said that residents in her division were outraged that the Council had entered into a contract to build an incinerator. She believed that it was right and proper to pause the process to critically review the project and its associated costs. She stated that taxpayers money was being wasted if construction continued while there remained concerns around the legality of the contract.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, apologised for the lack of engagement with local members and he offered to meet Cllr Hay on site.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, referred to the forthcoming review of the current highways service strategy and outlined proposals to engage with members in the development of a revised strategy for the procurement of highway services from April 2019.
Cllr Smith reaffirmed the cabinet manifesto commitment to invest at least £150m in Gloucestershire’s highway network over the next five years, more than double the amount invested in the annual resurfacing works programme.
Reporting that the current highways contract was due to end on 31 March 2019, Cllr Smith stated this was an exciting opportunity for the council to consider different delivery models and that he remained very open-minded to the options this presented.
The proposed timeline for officers to work with Cllr Smith in researching and developing delivery model options and developing a procurement strategy was outlined as follows:
Cllr Smith confirmed this was just the start of the procurement process, for which he intended to set up a cross party cabinet panel for members and officers to work together on this huge project.
Cllr Vernon Smith thanked [name removed] for coming to the meeting. He replied that once the consultation was completed and the responses worked through, this work would be progressed appropriately.
Cllr Vernon Smith ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Nigel Moor relating to a highway matter at Upper Rissington (Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood).
Cllr Lesley Williams relating to road works to lay cables in the High Street, Stonehouse (Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood).
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that following the Conservative amendments during the budget discussion there was now £9m more for highways. He would ask officers to provide the member with the specific details.
Cllr Vernon Smith responded that for some services such as parking it was easy to collate the information but with regards to highways, asset management was used with spend allocated where there was the greatest need.
Cllr Vernon Smith confirmed he would provide the member with a written response.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, presented the report.
Answering a question from Cllr Dr John Cordwell, Cllr Smith said that he would check when the parish and town council survey was being undertaken and inform Cllr Cordwell outside the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member: Highways and Flood sought approval of a legal strategy to enable the implementation of the , Cheltenham. Members noted a correction to recommendation iii (b) and deletion of the reference to paragraph iv).
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he thought some interesting points had been raised and stated that officers would liaise with him to get some more detail and look at ways that this might be moved forward.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that each county councillor had a highways local budget.
The following petitions were presented to Cllr Mark Hawthorne, Leader of the Council, as Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, had stepped out of the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, presented the report. He said that he was pleased that performance targets were being met and in some instances exceeded. Responding to questions, he reminded members to report potholes and any other road defects on the Council’s dedicated website – www.gloucestershire.gov.uk/reportit .
Cllr Vernon Smith thanked the project manager, Scott Macaulay-Lowe, and the Communications Team for their efforts.
Response by: Cllr Vernon Smith I remind you, as a minority administration, this budget was set by the council in February 2016; a budget supported by yourself as former Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group. Again, I believe to compartmentalise is the wrong way to look at budgets. Each year, the council considers each area of spending, with each district alternating in priority.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval to conduct a competitive tender process for the appointment of a single contractor for the construction of works for the Metz Way/ Abbeymead Avenue Improvement Scheme in Gloucester.
Outlining the merits of the proposed scheme, Cllr Smith informed members that one of the key objectives was to improve the transport links between Cooper’s Edge and Gloucester. The overarching goal, however, would be to improve travel conditions for all road users travelling along congested sections of the Metz Way. The proposed scheme would be joint funded by GFirst LEP, and from Section 106 Developer Contributions.
Local member, Cllr Andrew Gravells, (to whom Cllr Smith thanked for the extensive lobbying undertaken in his ward), particularly welcomed the scheme.
Responding to the suggestion, Cllr Smith assured Cllr Williams, any evidence of poor driver behaviour would be detected from traffic flow cameras and addressed by local police working in partnership with the Gloucestershire Road Safety Partnership.
Cllr Smith advised that the proposed works included several schemes and were due to commence in March 2017 Having considered all of the information, including known proposals and the reasons for the recommendations, Cabinet RESOLVED to – Authorise the Commissioning Director, Communities and Infrastructure to:
Welcoming the proposal, Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member: Highways and Flood, informed members that the additional funding would be used to address some of the seasonal highway maintenance work across Gloucestershire.
15.2 Cllr Vernon Smith substituted at the meeting for Cllr Wilson.
The Cabinet Member’s response, (from Cllr Vernon Smith), to be reported at the Environment and Communities Scrutiny Committee meeting on 22 November 2016, with an update to Full Council on 7 December 2016.
Response by : Cllr Vernon Smith – Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood I believe it is very important for local councillors to have an input to the new programme, via discussions with the appropriate Local Highways Manager. The Highways Team takes the allocation of funding very seriously and is currently working extensively to address this issue. There is also a Shadows Meeting on 21 July 2016, to which you are welcome to attend.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, gave an update on the results of key performance indicators, taken from Parish and Member Customer Highway Satisfaction Surveys during 2014/ 2015.
Acknowledging the negativity of some of the methodology used during the surveys and the poor performance of the highways contract during the initial years of the contract, Cllr Smith confirmed that improvements had been made since this time.
Responding to member’s concerns, Cllr Smith agreed it would be useful to gain a better understanding of why the outcomes of the ‘parish’ and ‘member’ customer satisfaction levels in 2014/15 had been so low and proposed that the council commission an independent review of the situation. Outlining the proposals for the review, the Cabinet Member explained that, with a significant amount of the initial research work undertaken by the council’s Communications Team, it was likely the costs in investing in external consultants would be lower than anticipated.
The Cabinet member is no doubt aware of Burnside, and other subsequent case law, which indicates that systematic deficiencies in addressing standing water constitutes a failure to maintain, so could he explain why, in many cases, the Council is neglecting its duties pursuant to Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 Cllr Vernon Smith thanked Cllr Willingham for making him aware of his concerns. He advised that Highways followed guidance linked to the Highways Efficiency Maintenance programme and this followed best practice.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained the difficulties involved due to a high pressure gas main running through the network. This is a very complicated issue. The Council was having to work with Severn Trent, the gas board and utility services to resolve the issues.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that enforcement on private roads was a matter for the owner. The Council could advise residents on the options that were available. They should do this through their local county councillor.
Cllr Nigel Moor presented two petitions relating to highway issues at Moreton Park to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Brian Oosthuysen presented a petition relating to highway issues on Butterow Hill in Rodborough to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, advised that a document had just been published providing an analysis of complaints and the steps that were being to address problem areas. He noted that the highways contractor had engaged the services of a retired Council officer to work with members to understand their particular concerns. He said that the performance indicators for the condition of roads had improved significantly.
A member called for Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, to consult all members about the extension of the parking enforcement contract.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, suggested that the member speak to the senior highways officers who were in the chamber ready to provide detailed information on local issues after the meeting. He confirmed that he had seen the new patching machine in operation and had been impressed by the quality and speed of the work.
Cllr Smith advised that members could use their Highways Local funding for weed control although he was mindful that some communities had concerns around the use of pesticides. He suggested that the member work with others including the district council and the local parish council.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought Cabinet approval to exercise the contractual right to extend the current Parking Management Services Enforcement contract for a further 2 years, commencing on 1 April 2018, with an estimated gross value of £2.4m.
Cllr Smith proposed members consider option 2 of the options outlined on pages 139 of the agenda pack as the preferred option.
Cllr Smith believed this would be the best option for the council at this time. Having considered all of the information, including known proposals and the reasons for the recommendations, Cabinet noted the report and, RESOLVED to: Authorise the Commissioning Director: Communities and Infrastructure to:
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that some of these signs were likely to be historic and that no review had been undertaken in the area for some time. He stated that he had today asked senior officers to review the signs and remove as required.
Cllr Steve Lydon presented a petition relating to the car park at Castle Street in Dursley to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that Gloucestershire had done a fantastic job with regards to cycling. He stated that if you took London out of the figures the average spend in the UK per head was 67p, with Gloucestershire higher at £1.02 per head. He detailed a number of schemes where there had been spending to support cycling and urged members not to forget to use their Highways Local funding.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, stated that percentages could give a misleading picture of the overall performance when the number of cases involved was small. He said that the priority was emergency defects where performance was above target. In overall terms, the principal road condition in the county was improving.
Cllr Brian Oosthuysen presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, regarding the condition of highways within his division, Rodborough .
Cllr Vernon Smith responded by stating that as alternative technologies developed he would be keen to listen to proposals, but that he did not feel that there were suitable alternatives currently available for heavy duty vehicles.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that his answer had come from past highways information.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, responded to the issues raised. He invited members to accompany him for a day so that he could show them the steps that were being taken to maintain and improve the network. He said that new technology and equipment would improve the way in which potholes were filled and provide a mechanism for larger areas to be resurfaced where there were a number of potholes in close proximity.
At the end of the debate, there was an exchange between Cllr Smith and Cllr Chris Coleman over attendance at the Cheltenham area highways meetings.
Cllr Coleman asked Cllr Smith to withdraw a comment he had made about Cllr Coleman’s non-attendance at the meetings.
Cllr Smith refused to withdraw the comment. The Vice-chairman noted that the Cheltenham area highways meetings were held at Shire Hall and he called on officers to arrange them in Cheltenham to make it easier for local members to attend. He believed that this principle should be extended for other service areas at the Council too.
In response, Cllr Vernon Smith thanked [name removed] for bringing this to his attention, but stated that the Council was implementing its car parking policy lawfully and followed national best practice. He asked that if [name removed] had any additional information then would he share it with senior officers.
Cllr Vernon Smith responded by explaining that best practice was being followed and emphasised the professionalism of officers and the support and training available to them.
Cllr Vernon Smith reiterated his previous answer. He was happy for officers to look at any new information, but stated that officers were complying with the law.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he disagreed with the statement and that officers had the training and support they needed to carry out their roles.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that this was not factual and that officers carried out a professional, open and transparent job.
Question 6 – Nigel Wise asked Will the Council now arrange for a face-to-face meeting with me and the Cabinet Member responsible Cllr Vernon Smith including council officers so that these matters can ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Chris Coleman presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, calling for the Council to proceed with the consultation on the railway area parking review in Cheltenham.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that the Council was always open to listen to proposals.
Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, explained that this was complex and there would need to be discussions with officers about how such an indicator could be put in place.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he would be happy to discuss the member’s particular concerns outside of the meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought to approve the award of an 18 month interim contract for the provision of traffic signal maintenance services, and to enter into a tender process for the award of a 9 year contract commencing October 2017.
Cllr Smith informed members that the current Traffic Signal Maintenance Contract was due to expire at the end of March 2016. Planned arrangements had been to join the existing framework contract with other South West authorities. Due to delivery issues, however, this framework had not been available, thus rendering insufficient time for the council to undertake and complete the necessary procurement before 1 April 2016.
In presenting the report, Cllr Smith sought both an interim and a long term solution for the council’s maintenance service. The proposed long term solution proposed a full and open procurement for a maintenance, supply and installation service with a single contractor for a 9 year contract, (initial term of 5 years and 2 options to extend for 2 further years).
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood to be invited to give a verbal update on the work being undertaken to control flooding in the Cotswold District at a future meeting.
Cllr Vernon Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 (Cheltenham Transport Plan Traffic Regulation Orders) of the agenda.
Cllr Smith declared his interest as a member of the Cheltenham Task Force.
Response by: Cllr Vernon Smith; Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood I agree that the Bath Road Trial highlighted a number of problems – this is why we are looking at implementing a phased approach from which any issues can be tweaked. A real trial will enable us to consider the advantages and disadvantages when implemented.
Response by : Cllr Vernon Smith; Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood The strong voices are reflected in the votes taken by Cheltenham Borough Council. There are also strong voices from the public.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member: Highways and Flood, acknowledged the level of public interest relating to this decision, clearly reflected by the number of public and member questions that had been submitted for consideration at the meeting.
Referring to the revised recommendation that had been circulated earlier in the meeting, Cllr Smith acknowledged that the Cheltenham Transport Plan, and the Traffic Regulation Orders required to implement the highways elements of the plan, continued to be controversial. He confirmed that three extensive public consultations had been held, in addition to a public Traffic Regulation Order Committee meeting, each of which had contributed to highlighting the extent of support and objection to the scheme. Noting how divisive the issue had been, the Cabinet Member clarified that this was one of the reasons why the County Council was looking to implement a phased approach to the scheme in order to address the concerns that had been raised, and to deliver a balanced solution.
Cllr Smith confirmed that one of the objectives of the Cheltenham Transport Plan was to improve access to the town, with the key priority aimed at reducing the severance of the High Street environment and enhancing the town centre, particularly for pedestrians. Whilst not ruling out the Boots Corner section of the town, it was proposed that this would only be considered once the other elements of the scheme had been successfully implemented.
Noting the amendments to the recommendations, Cllr Smith stated that, if the proposals for the Inner Ring Road were successful, and subject to sufficient funding being available, it would be the council’s intention to proceed with improvements to Boots Corner.
Cllr Smith outlined the revised recommendations circulated earlier in the meeting. Having considered the information in the published report, the revised recommendations, the published due regard statement, and the responses to the questions and supplementary questions submitted by members of the public and elected members, CABINET RESOLVED to: - 1. Accept the recommendations from the Traffic Regulation Committee made on 15 January 2015 relating to the inner-ring road changes, with the exception of the Boots Corner proposed trial;
Hosted by the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, Cllr Vernon Smith, the seminar to include an update on the performance of the council’s Amey contract and the current highways strategy. The seminar to also include an update from the Highways Development Management Team on the council’s role as a statutory consultee in the local planning process.
In response Cllr Vernon Smith explained that he would provide [name removed] with a written response to the questions outlined above. In addition he offered to meet with him to ‘walk the area’ and understand his specific concerns.
Cllr Vernon Smith replied that he was happy to talk to officers and emphasised the importance of a close relationship between highways managers and the local member.
Cllr Vernon Smith informed the member that the figure reflected the time period of the contract from 1 April 2014. He explained that there was a regular rota for the cleaning of gullies and that the same contractor from the previous 5 years had been used. He felt progress had been made after a slow start.
In response, Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he believed that the employment on a temporary basis of an ex Network Manager and previous Divisional Surveyor to assist in managing the backlog of work showed a willingness to take action.
Cllr Vernon Smith provided details of the need for ‘slippage’ to be built into the contract of around 10% for the first quarter to take into account the impact of outside factors such as the weather. This would be a matter for the Advisory Board to consider.
Cllr Vernon Smith, as Chairman of the Flood Action Group, gave an in-depth overview of the work that had been carried out during the past year, and on the steps taken to prevent further flooding in the Cotswold District.
Cllr Smith informed members that there had been a number of significant successes following establishment of the flood action group and that real progress was being made.
Cllr Smith welcomed the financial commitment that had been offered by Thames Water in December 2014, and the undertaking from the Environment Agency to carry out dredging and de-silting works in parts of the district.
Noting concerns about drainage issues in the Moreton -in-Marsh area, Cllr Smith requested that a letter from Cotswold MP, Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, be sent to the Environment Agency for a response. The cabinet member thanked the local MP for his invaluable support during the past year.
Thanking officers from Gloucestershire County Council and Cotswold District Council, Cllr Smith believed the Cotswold Flood Action Group review was a good example of effective scrutiny.
Outlining some of the work already undertaken by the county council’s communications team, Cllr Smith proposed that a newsletter be send to relevant town and parish councils after each flood action group meeting. It was noted that the next action group meeting would be held on 29 June 2015.
b) Member petitions Cllr Richard Leppington presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flooding, calling for a 20mph speed limit at Church Walk, Viney Hill.
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, sought approval for the council to undertake a competitive tendering process for the award of a contract for the maintenance of the Council’s street lighting and investment in Light Emitting Diode (LED) lighting.
In presenting the report, Cllr Smith made a correction to recommendation a) and references to the estimated life value of the contract to read £32 million and not £35 million. Investment in LED lighting had been approved as part of the council’s LED budget for 2014/15 to 2016/17. The Cabinet Member was now seeking approval to procure LED lighting as part of a contract to include the maintenance of street lighting and illuminated signs and bollards.
Cllr Smith informed members that LED lighting was now mainstream technology in which many councils were investing. He was particularly pleased to announce that Gloucestershire was taking a lead in providing efficient street lighting services from which to deliver financial and carbon savings in line with the council’s Medium Term Financial Strategy, Carbon Management Plan and Transport Asset Management Plan.
Cllr Smith alerted members that without investing in LED street lighting, the service would be financially unsustainable.
Cllr Smith added that, energy efficient street lighting offered an affordable street lighting service, allowing the council to keep its street lights on and provide better quality lighting. Furthermore, the investment would help reduce the impact on the environment, with at least 50 per cent less carbon emissions, less light pollution and reduced impact on wildlife. It also assisted in creating several road and community safety benefits.
Cllr Smith drew attention to the Due Regard Statement confirming that any negative impacts would be addressed in draft statements by service standards. Highlighting the need for effective communication with the public throughout the transition period, and having considered all of the information, Cabinet welcomed the proposal and: - RESOLVED to: - Authorise the Commissioning Director: Communities and Infrastructure to:
Cllr Vernon Smith, Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, summarised the background to the Elmbridge Transport Scheme, a scheme intended to tackle congestion at one of the busiest roundabouts in Gloucestershire and improve public transport routes between Cheltenham, Churchdown and Gloucester. In seeking authorisation for the Commissioning Director: Communities and Infrastructure to undertake the necessary steps from which to progress the scheme, the Cabinet Member summarised the works from which the improvements would be made.
Outlining the projected timeline for the works, Cllr Smith, alerted members that there was still a considerable way to go before construction works commenced in the Autumn of 2016. Leader of the Council, Mark Hawthorne, described this stage in the proceedings as a vital artery to take talking the scheme forward and making a huge investment in the county’s infrastructure. Having considered all of the information, including proposed options and the reasons for the recommendations, Cabinet RESOLVED to : - 1) Make and submit to the Secretary of State a Compulsory Purchase Order to compulsorily acquire all landand rights shown (coloured pink and blue respectively in Appendix C) required for the Elmbridge Transport Scheme;
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he would provide the member with the information.
Cllr Vernon Smith explained that this was an aspiration and that MPs should be supported. He used the example of the A417 loop as an indication of what could be achieved if members worked together.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that he would provide the member with a detailed response.
Cllr Vernon Smith apologised for Old London Road not being included in the answer and confirmed that it was on the list. The County Council’s position was that public safety was paramount and some roads had to be closed to undertake the appropriate survey before reopening the road. Officers were working hard in order to progress this work as soon as possible.
Cllr Vernon Smith stated that work was underway to reduce the backlog on Commons and Public Rights of Way (CROW).
Cllr Colin Guyton presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, requesting a reduction in the speed limit on Morse Lane, Drybrook .
Cllr Vernon Smith responded that cycling was an important issue, that he welcomed any ideas, and that he believed in working in partnership with districts. He referred to the work within his own division around the ‘healthy towns’ initiative.
Cllr Vernon Smith reiterated that he would be happy to talk to members about any ideas around partnership working and would be keen to work with partners on suggestions they had in relation to bidding for funding in this area.
Cllr Klara Sudbury presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, relating to traffic flows on streets east of Bath Rd in Cheltenham.
Cllr Steve McHale presented a petition to Cllr Vernon Smith, the Cabinet Member for Highways and Flood, relating to a bus service on Matson Lane, Gloucester.
Question 6 – Cllr Vernon Smith asked whether the Cabinet Member agreed that the changes to the Alderman Knight School had left the school in a better position to develop in the future.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Smith attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Nov 2022 | Environment Scrutiny Committee | Bus Improvements Task Group | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Smith was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Smith declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Jul 2015 | Cabinet, item 3 | Cllr Vernon Smith declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 (Cheltenham Transport Plan Traffic Regulation Orders) of the agenda. | |
| 22 Jul 2015 | Cabinet, item 3 | Cllr Smith declared his interest as a member of the Cheltenham Task Force. |
Where Councillor Smith sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Constitution Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Environment Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Jul 2022 | 2 | |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Oct 2020 | 1 | |
| Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.