CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Monmouthshire/Councillor County Councillor Phil Murphy
CM

Councillor County Councillor Phil Murphy

Monmouthshire CouncilCaerwent wardConservativeCouncillor since 2004
Chair, Planning Committee
Follow Councillor Murphy's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
60%meetings attended492 of 815 since 2004, apologies 34
44times in the minutesAsked 0, said 21, moved 3, seconded 3
40recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
0declarations at meetingsInterests declared on agenda items
8committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time Monmouthshire's minutes name Councillor Murphy, as the council published it.

Moved22 May 2025Place Scrutiny Committee

Election of Chair

Councillor Lucas was proposed by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Brown.
From the council's minutes: Place Scrutiny Committee, 22 May 2025, item 1Open the meeting
Named22 May 2025Place Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor Dymock, Councillor Murphy as substitute.
From the council's minutes: Place Scrutiny Committee, 22 May 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded15 May 2025County Council

Appointments to Committees

In order to provide clarity around the appointment of the chair of Democratic Services Committee, the Chief Executive provided the following amendment which was moved by Councillor John and seconded by Councillor Murphy:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 15 May 2025, item 7Open the meeting
Named19 Sep 2024People Scrutiny Committee

Call-In of the decision by Cabinet of 11th September 2024 regarding the Home to School Transport Policy 2025-26

ACTION – to be shared with members Councillor Murphy:
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 19 Sep 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Said19 Sep 2024People Scrutiny Committee

Call-In of the decision by Cabinet of 11th September 2024 regarding the Home to School Transport Policy 2025-26

Councillor Murphy highlighted safe walking routes as an example of the importance of proper consultation. He appreciated that the current numbers need consideration each year but fundamental routes, e.g. Caerwent-Caldicot, should have been identified.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 19 Sep 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Named19 Sep 2024People Scrutiny Committee

Call-In of the decision by Cabinet of 11th September 2024 regarding the Home to School Transport Policy 2025-26

A resident whose children would be affected by the proposals informed Councillor Murphy that there is no safe walking route from Caerwent to Caldicot, with blind corners and a lack of pavement in some places – had the consultation been longer and at a more appropriate time, examples such as these, in which walking routes for children would be irresponsible, might have been put forward.
From the council's minutes: People Scrutiny Committee, 19 Sep 2024, item 2Open the meeting
Said19 Mar 2024Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee

Covid learning and pandemic preparedness

A great deal of info rmation was exchanged , and although officers naturally took the lead in the specific operations Councillor Murphy felt he always knew what was going on, and his opinion was sought on things .
From the council's minutes: Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee, 19 Mar 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named19 Mar 2024Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee

Covid learning and pandemic preparedness

He was very impressed by how the various agencies linked together.   ·         Councillor Murphy observed that w here the system broke down was that in i tially all of the public followed the rules, then frustration kicked in and an unwillingness to follow the rules began to set in. Departments were affected, in that internal audit and Monlife disappeared, and an important part of the strategy was to furlough as few people as possible and move them into other operations. One of the best things that was done was the introduction of the Cwtch, for staff to come together online to share their frustrations and be kept  ...  view the full minutes text for item 3.
From the council's minutes: Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee, 19 Mar 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named21 Jun 2023Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee

Election of Chair

Councillor Neill was nominated by Councillor Murphy, seconded by Councillor Buckler.
From the council's minutes: Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee, 21 Jun 2023, item 1Open the meeting
Seconded21 Jun 2023Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee

Appointment of Vice Chair

Councillor Buckler was nominated by Councillor Pavia, seconded by Councillor Murphy.
From the council's minutes: Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee, 21 Jun 2023, item 2Open the meeting
Named25 Jan 2023Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee

Apologies for Absence

Councillor Murphy was elected as vice-chair for the meeting, nominated by Councillor Chandler and seconded by Councillor Bond.
From the council's minutes: Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee, 25 Jan 2023, item 1Open the meeting
Named31 Jan 2022Children and Young People Select Committee

Budget Scrutiny: Scrutiny of the budget proposals for 2022/23.

Councillor Murphy, Will McLean, Tyrone Stokes and Jane Rodgers answered the members’ questions.
From the council's minutes: Children and Young People Select Committee, 31 Jan 2022, item 2Open the meeting
Said22 Oct 2020County Council

From County Councillor A. Watts to County Councillor P. Murphy, Cabinet Member for Resources

Councillor Murphy explained that the Gwent Local Resilience Forum (LRF) has received £150,000 Covid19 specific funding to support the partners in the Strategic Coordinating Group (SCG) and the work of any tactical groups. MCC has received around £11,000.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 22 Oct 2020, item 12Open the meeting
Said22 Oct 2020County Council

From County Councillor A. Watts to County Councillor P. Murphy, Cabinet Member for Resources

Councillor Murphy responded that Council has been paying the living wage, and the last budget saw an increase in payments to care homes to ensure staff were paid the living wage.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 22 Oct 2020, item 12Open the meeting
Moved16 Jul 2020County Council

Section 151 Officer Covid 19 Update

The recommendations were proposed by Councillor Murphy and seconded by Councillor Fox.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 16 Jul 2020, item 5aOpen the meeting
Named16 Jul 2020County Council

Submitted by County Councillor V. Smith

Councillor Murphy left the meeting at 16:30pm
From the council's minutes: County Council, 16 Jul 2020, item 7bOpen the meeting
Named22 Jul 2019Monmouthshire Farm School Endowment Trust

To confirm and sign the minutes of the previous meeting of the Monmouthshire Farm School Endowment Trust

The minutes of the meeting of MFSET held on 21 st January 2019 were confirmed and signed by Councillor Murphy.
From the council's minutes: Monmouthshire Farm School Endowment Trust, 22 Jul 2019, item 4Open the meeting
Said17 Jan 2019County Council

From County Councillor D. Batrouni to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy responded that corporately there were 11 cases in 2018. School based there were 3 cases. The average suspension time corporately was 4.7 months, and 3 months in respect of schools.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 17 Jan 2019, item 6aOpen the meeting
Said8 Nov 2018Governance and Audit Committee

To note the action list from 13th September 2018.

Councillor Murphy confirmed that the information was already available in-house in the education section and the schools that are in deficit have an actively managed recovery plan.
From the council's minutes: Governance and Audit Committee, 8 Nov 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Said8 Nov 2018Governance and Audit Committee

Progress Report: Wales Audit Office Proposals for Improvement.

Councillor Murphy responded that the attendance of a cabinet member is normally requested by the chair. Officers will check the wording matches the appropriate code.
From the council's minutes: Governance and Audit Committee, 8 Nov 2018, item 9Open the meeting
Said25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor A. Davies

Councillor Murphy welcomed the motion and was pleased to see the level of constructive input, particularly from the Economy and Development Select Committee around our procurement approach.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 6cOpen the meeting
Seconded25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor M. Feakins

In the absence of Councillor Feakins, Councillor Greenland presented the motion, which was seconded by Councillor Murphy.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 6dOpen the meeting
Named25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor J. Pratt to County Councillor P. Murphy

Does Councillor Murphy agree that for the Labour Administration to keep blaming Westminster is not a true reflection of the situation and what representation are we making to the Welsh Government in Cardiff?
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 7cOpen the meeting
Said25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor J. Pratt to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy responded that he was pleased that the Labour Group were able to support the point for challenging our settlement. He added that the Leader is on the distribution sub-group and speaks of the inequality on our behalf. The WLGA is constantly lobbying.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 7cOpen the meeting
Named25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor J. Pratt to County Councillor P. Murphy

As a supplementary Councillor Pratt asks if Councillor Murphy agrees with the Labour Council Leader from Swansea that the Local Government Secretary Alan Davies is characterising himself as Mr.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 7cOpen the meeting
Said25 Oct 2018County Council

From County Councillor J. Pratt to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy agreed.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 25 Oct 2018, item 7cOpen the meeting
Named7 Aug 2018Planning Committee

APPLICATION DC/2018/00007 - Demolition of magistrates court and police station building and erection of a building comprising 47 retirement living apartments with associated residents lounge, refuse, electric, rechargeable buggy store, gues

It was moved by County Councillor Powell, and seconded County Councillor Murphy that application DC/2018/00007 be approved subject to conditions and section 106 agreement outlined in the report.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Aug 2018, item 4Open the meeting
Named7 Aug 2018Planning Committee

APPLICATION DM/2018/00528 - Proposed replacement dwelling. Argoed Cottage New Mill Road Tregagle Trellech Monmouth.

It was moved by County Councillor Murphy and seconded by County Councillor that application DM/2018/00528 be approved subject to conditions, as outlined in the report.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Aug 2018, item 6Open the meeting
Named7 Aug 2018Planning Committee

APPLICATION DM/2018/00707 - Application to retain amendments to approved application DC/2017/00728 (Site 4). Residential Quarters Redchillies Thai And Indian Restaurant Five Lanes North Fives Lanes Caerwent.

It was moved by County Councillor Murphy, and seconded by County Councillor Powell that application DM/2018/00707 be refused on the basis that the scale and mass of the garage was excessive, its layout was out of character in relation to the remainder of the development, and it had an unacceptable overbearing effect on the amenity of the neighbouring dwelling to the east, conflicting with policies S17, DES1 b), c) and d) and EP1 of the adopted LDP.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Aug 2018, item 8Open the meeting
Named7 Aug 2018Planning Committee

APPLICATION DM/2018/00910 - Community hub facility and associated landscaping. Three Fields Site Main Road Magor Monmouthshire.

Councillor Murphy read a statement from Councillor L. Dymock, with similar sentiments echoed by Councillor F. Taylor, in full support of the application.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Aug 2018, item 10Open the meeting
Moved7 Aug 2018Planning Committee

APPLICATION DM/2018/00910 - Community hub facility and associated landscaping. Three Fields Site Main Road Magor Monmouthshire.

It was moved by Councillor Murphy, and seconded by Councillor Higginson that application DM/2018/00910 be approved subject to conditions, as outlined in the report.
From the council's minutes: Planning Committee, 7 Aug 2018, item 10Open the meeting
Named21 Jun 2018County Council

From County Councillor T. Thomas

Councillor Murphy looked forward to a report of clarification around the policy.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 13aOpen the meeting
Named21 Jun 2018County Council

From County Councillor A. Easson to County Councillor P. Murphy

How does Cllr Murphy intend to address the financial pressures on Monmouthshire’s budgets to realise the difficulties expected and aspirations of the Communities of Severnside in this time of growth, and what will be your priorities, and how will you deal with them?
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 14hOpen the meeting
Said21 Jun 2018County Council

From County Councillor A. Easson to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy responded and in doing so he cautioned against getting ahead of ourselves. New house building significantly to our financial sustainability. Growth in population and households would see likely upward adjustments of the WG funding settlement, which is population based.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 14hOpen the meeting
Said21 Jun 2018County Council

From County Councillor A. Easson to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy responded that any prudential borrowing has to be supported by a water tight business case, and everything would be looked at on its own merits.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jun 2018, item 14hOpen the meeting
Said6 Mar 2018County Council

Motion from County Councillor Groucutt

Councillor Murphy advised that a response had been received from administrators of Torfaen Pension Fund which would be circulated to Members. The statement advised that the fund welcomed the interest and did not, at the time of the survey, invest £245m, the figure was £197m. The over-statement was due to assumptions made in the compilation of the survey.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 6 Mar 2018, item 11aOpen the meeting
Said29 Jun 2017County Council

Motion From County Councillor A. Easson

Councillor Murphy said that as the amendment include the term ‘ vired ’ he was unable to support.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 29 Jun 2017, item 8aOpen the meeting
Said29 Jun 2017County Council

Audit Committee Annual Report 2016-2017

Councillor Murphy responded that regular meetings had been held with representatives of Chepstow School, and was happy to report that the recovery plan has been successful to the point where looking forward to the end of this current year they forecast to be in slight surplus.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 29 Jun 2017, item 9aOpen the meeting
Said19 Jan 2017County Council

Audit Committee 15th December 2016

In response, Councillor Murphy added that a full an extensive response had been supplied, which would also be supplied to Audit Committee.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 19 Jan 2017, item 7bOpen the meeting
Said30 Jun 2016Governance and Audit Committee

Action List from the previous meeting

County Councillor Murphy informed the Committee that he and County Councillor Hacket -Pain, as cabinet Members, had called in the new Business Manager, the Chair of Governors, the Temporary Business Manager and some other representatives from Chepstow School and would be meeting them shortly with a view to obtaining further information in respect of a number of issues relating to the school and how the school’s budget is likely to be brought under control.
From the council's minutes: Governance and Audit Committee, 30 Jun 2016, item 4Open the meeting
Said30 Jun 2016Governance and Audit Committee

Action List from the previous meeting

County Councillor Murphy stated that he would  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.
From the council's minutes: Governance and Audit Committee, 30 Jun 2016, item 4Open the meeting
Said10 Mar 2016County Council

from County Councillor D. Batrouni to County Councillor P. Murphy

Councillor Murphy responded that he would get back to Councillor Batrouni with the information.
From the council's minutes: County Council, 10 Mar 2016, item 13aOpen the meeting
Said10 Mar 2016County Council

from County Councillor D. Batrouni to County Councillor P. Murphy

‘What are the Council administration’s plans for the extra £109,000 received from the Welsh Government?’ County Councillor Murphy responded:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 10 Mar 2016, item 13bOpen the meeting
Said21 Jan 2016County Council

Question from H. Cullen-Jones to County Councillor P. Murphy

In light of this, would Councillor Murphy allow Bridges to present their case to the Strong Communities Select Committee so it can be reviewed by the democratically elected members?’ Councillor Murphy responded:
From the council's minutes: County Council, 21 Jan 2016, item 2aOpen the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Murphy attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
5 Mar 2026County CouncilCouncil Tax Resolution and Revenue and Capital Budgets for 2026/2722 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
5 Mar 2026County CouncilCapital Strategy and 2026/27 Treasury Management StrategyCarried25 for, 20 against
23 Oct 2025County CouncilDeposit Local Development Plan SubmissionLost20 for, 25 against
23 Oct 2025County CouncilDeposit Local Development Plan Submission22 for, 22 against
6 Mar 2025County CouncilCouncil Tax ResolutionCarried22 for, 21 against, 1 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilDeposit Replacement Local Development PlanCarried21 for, 20 against, 1 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Meirion HowellsCarried24 for, 0 against, 0 abstained
24 Oct 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor HowellsCarried22 for, 1 against, 0 abstained
18 Jul 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Lisa DymockLost18 for, 23 against, 0 abstained
18 Jul 2024County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Richard JohnLost16 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
7 Dec 2023County CouncilRelocation of pupil referral service south monmouthshireCarried23 for, 21 against, 0 abstained
26 Oct 2023County CouncilReplacement local development plan (rldp) preferred strategyCarried23 for, 22 against, 1 abstained
26 Oct 2023County CouncilFrom County Councillor Frances Taylor to County Councillor Catrin Maby, Cabinet Member for Climate Change and EnvironmentCarriedUnanimous
21 Sep 2023County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Alistair NeillLost21 for, 22 against, 0 abstained
22 Jun 2023County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor Richard JohnLost15 for, 23 against, 2 abstained
1 Oct 2021County CouncilAppointment of Chief Officer Social Care, Safeguarding & HealthCarriedUnanimous
3 Dec 2020County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor F. TaylorCarriedUnanimous
22 Oct 2020County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor D. BatrouniLost10 for, 20 against, 1 abstained
10 Sep 2020County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2020/21CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilTreasury policy and strategy 2020-21CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilSafeguarding evaluation report april 2018 - march 2019CarriedUnanimous
5 Mar 2020County CouncilBudget decision - flood recovery responseCarriedUnanimous
19 Sep 2019County CouncilCorporate Plan Annual Report 2018/19Carried21 for, 8 against, 4 abstained
19 Sep 2019County CouncilCapital Programme - 21st Century Schools ProgrammeCarried13 for, 21 against, 1 abstained
19 Sep 2019County CouncilSubmitted by County Councillor D BatrouniLost8 for, 13 against
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor P. FoxCarriedUnanimous
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor F. TaylorCarriedUnanimous
20 Jun 2019County CouncilFrom County Councillor D. BatrouniLost9 for, 22 against, 2 abstained
14 May 2019County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2019/20CarriedUnanimous
2 Oct 2018Planning CommitteeApplication DM/2018/01092 - Four shepherd huts for holiday let use. Land At Bentra Farmhouse, Pentre Road, Llangovan, Monmouth.CarriedUnanimous
2 Oct 2018Planning CommitteeApplication DC/2017/00994 - Construction of essential rural enterprise worker's dwelling and retention of two kennel blocks, small pets building, use of part of barn for dog and cat kennelling, two permanent isolation kennels, dog groomingCarriedUnanimous
2 Oct 2018Planning CommitteeApplication DM/2018/00408 - Provision of a new cycle and pedestrian bridge spanning approximately 60m across the River Usk between Llanfoist and Abergavenny, provision of earthwork ramps to cater for disabled access, provision of a new footCarriedUnanimous
2 Oct 2018Planning CommitteeApplication DM/2018/01279 - Agricultural building housing farm animals. Kemeys House Farm, Church Lane, Kemeys Commander, Usk.CarriedUnanimous
26 Jul 2018County CouncilGovernance arrangements for proposed alternative delivery model for tourism, culture, leisure and youthCarried28 for, 9 against
26 Jul 2018County CouncilFrom County Councillor D. BatrouniLost15 for, 22 against
8 May 2018County CouncilTo elect a Chairman of the County Council for the Civic Year 2018/19CarriedUnanimous
20 Mar 2017County CouncilAppointment of chief officer, children and young peopleCarriedUnanimous
8 Jun 2016County CouncilAppointment of the Chief Officer, Resources.CarriedUnanimous
12 May 2016County CouncilAppointment of Democratic Services Committee and appointment of Chairman of the CommitteeCarriedUnanimous
4 May 2016County CouncilAppointment to the role of Monitoring Officer/Head of LegalCarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Murphy was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Planning Committee
112 of 129
County Council
102 of 111
Governance and Audit Committee
76 of 96
Members' Seminars
13 of 71
Monmouthshire Farm School Endowment Trust
22 of 36
Severnside Area Forum
2 of 11
Performance and Overview Scrutiny Committee
7 of 7
Appointments Committee
1 of 2
Individual Cabinet Member Decisions
0 of 166
Cabinet
83 of 92
Lower Wye Area Committee
9 of 18
Investment Committee
14 of 18
Economy and Development Select Committee
14 of 16
Strong Communities Select Committee
7 of 8
Children and Young People Select Committee
6 of 6
Joint Select Committee
5 of 6
Adults Select Committee
4 of 6
Public Services Scrutiny Committee
4 of 4
Place Scrutiny Committee
4 of 4
Central Mon Area Committee
1 of 2
North Monmouthshire Area Committee
2 of 2
Appointments Committee - expired
2 of 2
Severnside Area Committee (2020)
1 of 1
People Scrutiny Committee
1 of 1
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
+1
Mar
Apr
May
+1
+2
Aug
+4
Oct
Nov

Present at 25 of 53 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Murphy declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

No declarations of interest by Councillor Murphy in the minutes read so far.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Murphy sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Planning CommitteeChairSep 20151291 Dec 2026
County CouncilCommittee MemberSep 201511110 Dec 2026
Governance and Audit CommitteeCommittee MemberSep 20159614 Jan 2027
Members' SeminarsCommittee MemberJun 201671
Monmouthshire Farm School Endowment TrustCommittee MemberJan 201836
Severnside Area ForumCommittee MemberMar 2024117 Jan 2027
Performance and Overview Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 2023724 Nov 2026
Appointments CommitteeCommittee MemberJun 20262
Individual Cabinet Member DecisionsCommittee MemberJan 2016166
CabinetCommittee MemberSep 201592
Lower Wye Area CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 201318
Investment CommitteeGuestJun 201818
Economy and Development Select CommitteeCommittee MemberNov 201516
Strong Communities Select CommitteeCommittee MemberNov 20158
Children and Young People Select CommitteeCommittee MemberOct 20156
Joint Select CommitteeCommittee MemberDec 20156
Adults Select CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 20176
Public Services Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberNov 20204
Place Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberJul 20244
Central Mon Area CommitteeGuestJun 20162
North Monmouthshire Area CommitteeCommittee MemberJan 20192
Appointments Committee - expiredCommittee MemberAug 20252
Severnside Area Committee (2020)GuestJan 20191
People Scrutiny CommitteeCommittee MemberSep 20241
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies