Application for major development - tadgedale quarry. wain homes north west. 24/00589/ful
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear
Every time Newcastle-under-Lyme's minutes name Councillor Fear, as the council published it.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear
Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Turnock The next three applications were discussed en-bloc as each affected the other.
Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Bailey.
Amended Recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Evans
Councillor Fear presented the amendment submitted by the Conservative group. He referred to the standard calculation which was used to calculate the amount of housing required in the Borough and therefore, any sites removed from the Local Plan would require another site being put in. If the previous administration had not got a Plan in place, the additional 2000 houses that the Government had imposed in the new figures would have had to have been included in the Plan being discussed this evening.
Councillor Fear pointed out a typing error at point D where it should read AB2 instead of B2.
Councillor Fear stated that the Plan had been developed to try and ensure that impositions of national government were imposed upon the Borough as lightly as possible. Reference was made to paragraph 3.17 which stated that, although the Borough was under the national average for unemployment, the figures were slightly over the national average in Staffordshire. It was hoped that the Local Plan would help to provide the jobs required to bring the local unemployment figures down.
Councillor Casey-Hulme spoke on this application Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by the Chair.
Cllr Fear wished to hear more about the meeting with Capital & Centric at the Bournemouth LGR Conference as well as if things would be in synch with the Ryepark McCarthy and Stone developments.
Cllr Fear suggested that the portfolios falling under the Committee’s remit be added to the document and that portfolio holders be invited to attend the meetings. A standing item on Planning Enforcement and Performance was also recommended in light of the government perceived intentions to take away the matter from local authorities.
Councillor Fear thanked [name removed] for his good and steady leadership of the Planning Department.
Chair – Cllr Paul Northcott Ton behalf of Planning Committee members, the Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning, Councillor Fear thanked Councillor Northcott for his Chairmanship of this committee over the last few years and wished him well for the future.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Hutchison.
Councillor Fear stated that Peter was a hard worker who cared about his council work and also worked hard to keep the Wye Road Community Centre running for many years. Peter’s interest in the community had continued when he had left the Council. Condolences were sent to the family.
Councillor Fear said that this administration had kept its promise in respect of keeping Council Tax increases below inflation. £800,000 had been wasted on the Local Government Reorganisation – which could have been used ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Following a lengthy debate, The Chair proposed the recommendations and Councillor Fear seconded. A vote was taken:
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Northcott.
Councillor Fear stated that this was heartening and looking to the future it was hoped that it would remain like this.
Councillor Fear also hoped that the Government would provide national funding for the recovery and restoration of the site and also that a public inquiry would be held.
Councillor Sweeney agreed with Councillor Fear, the crucial question being who would pay for the recovery and restoration.
Councillor Fear endorsed the Leader’s approach, noting that democracy mattered and this was just another coordinated attack on basic freedoms in this country.
Councillor Fear agreed with all that had been said and stated that it had all worked well but improvements could always be made, such as ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Amended recommendation (additional condition) proposed by Councillor Burnett-Faulkner and seconded by Councillor Fear.
A Motion, concerning inappropriate accommodation for Asylum Seekers in Newcastle-under-Lyme was submitted by the Conservative Group, proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear seconded the Motion and reserved the right to speak in the debate.
On paragraph 4 – Devolution and Forced Local Government Reorganisation Update Councillor Fear recalled that, at the last meeting, it was noted that Staffordshire Moorlands District Council did not seem to be cognizant on this Council’s position on the compulsory reorganisation and a letter was sent to them in that respect. The Leader was asked if any reply had been received back and if he agreed that Staffordshire Moorlands had surrendered to ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Amended recommendation proposed by Cllr Fear and seconded by Cllr Holland.
Councillor Fear stated that it was a retrograde proposal which should be refused on poor design. In addition, it went against paragraph 139 of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF).
Cllr Fear was disappointed that half of the households would have to take their bins to a collection point. He also enquired about paragraph 14B of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) on neighbourhood plans containing policies and allocations to meet identified housing requirements along with latest figures in terms of housing supplies.
Councillor Jill Whitmore spoke on this application Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor John Williams
Cllr Fear also noticed the odours had dropped but would need to be reported to the Environment Agency and the Council if they were to be noticed again.
Cllr Fear and the Deputy Leader were also enthusiastic about the project.
Cllr Fear proposed that the application be refused on the grounding of the development not allowing for sufficient car parking provisions.
Cllr Fear expressed his despondency at the rise of complaints along with his hope that things were indeed heading in the right direction.
Priority 2 – A Successful and Sustainable Growing Borough Cllr Fear thanked the planning section for the hard work put in and reported that in relation to the percentage of complainants informed within the required timescales of actions to be taken about alleged breaches of planning control things were going in the right direction despite having been impacted by work absences and capacity.
Councillor Fear requested that a future report be brought back to Committee showing due discharge of the conditions.
Cllr Fear emphasized the importance of optimizing the data and evidence collected by officers along with working closely with the Environment Agency.
Cllr Fear shared his enthusiasm about the budget and the fact the Council had managed to deliver on keeping the Council tax low and maintaining services.
Councillor Fear stated that this was not the end but hopefully the beginning of the end of the process and the pressure needed to be kept up.
Councillor Fear, referring in particular to the low increase in Council Tax, stated that the MTFS showed that this Council kept its promises. The Council had not cut services but had improved them.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear stated that the notion that the EA was ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
The application was deferred to enable officers to provide further details of a management plan for the facility to limit anti-social behaviour and information/statistics on the operation of existing facilities, the submission of a Health Impact Assessment and for Cllr Northcott and Cllr Fear to write to the Police to urge them to attend the next meeting of the Planning Committee.
The Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning - Councillor Fear introduced a report seeking approval for the Final Draft Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Local Plan 2040 and to carry out consultation.
Councillor Fear advised that without a Local Plan in place the Borough would be vulnerable to predatory development and also would run the risk of having a plan written by the Government.
Councillor Fear stated that if the Council did not have a plan in place by June, 2025 the process would have to start all over again.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader if he agreed that yesterday’s Inquiry was very informative but also very concerning and if it would be possible for a link to the recording to be sent to the relevant secretary of state so that he may be brought up to date with what had been happening.
Councillor Fear stated that the complaint figures indicated that the problem was getting worse thus showing that Walleys Quarry was not operating as it should and therefore the EA needed to show improvement. It was hoped that the new Government would allow a public inquiry, which had previously been turned down.
Councillor Fear suggested that the spikes in complaints at weekends could be down to more people being at home, depriving them of relaxation time.
- Cllr Heesom, portfolio holder for Community Safety and Wellbeing - Cllr Hutchison, portfolio holder for Sustainable Environment - Cllr Fear, portfolio holder for Strategic Planning - Cllr Skelding, portfolio holder for Leisure, Culture and Heritage - Cllr Sweeney, portfolio holder for Finance Town Centres and Growth - Cllr S Tagg, portfolio holder for One Council, People and Partnerships Watch the proceedings here
Councillor Fear requested that the hoarding around the site be respectful in the vicinity of the war memorial to preserve the serious ambience of Remembrance Sunday, should works still be ongoing in November.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Jones and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear expressed his disappointment at the increase in complaints during February and asked, if that were to happen again, was that evidence that Best Practical Means were not being used.
Councillor Fear stated that an adverse event would be presumptive evidence that Best Practical Means was not happening.
Councillor Fear commented on the notion that if the operator claimed that it was too expensive to put it right then they did not have to and asked if there was any documentation that would give a sense of proportionality, giving the limit of expenditure that was deemed to be excessive.
The Leader’s recommendation for a closure of the site was supported by the Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning Cllr Fear.
Councillor Fear stated that action needed to be seen coming from the EA.
Cabinet had previously discussed closure notices and Councillor Fear felt that the EA should be asked for reasons why they were not going to issue a closure notice.
- Cllr Fear commented that a lot of the stats had doubled over time and the situation was not acceptable anymore.
The new leadership at the Environment Agency was welcome and Cllr Fear wished to know what would be in place to manage the situation if the operator went out of business. – This question was not to be discussed in a public forum at this moment in time.
Cllr Fear welcomed the agreement which would come as a huge relief for local residents.
The Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning, Councillor Fear stated that the figures were disappointing.
Referring to the table at paragraph 3.4, MMF9, Councillor Fear stated that, for one minute in every seven the Hydrogen Sulphide level had been in excess. The Leader stated that the Council’s role through the Abatement Notice was to meet and discuss the issues with the operator and was pleased that officers would be doing that. At Full Council in October, Members had asked the Leader to write to the new Secretary of State regarding issues with the EA.
The Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning, Councillor Fear introduced a report seeking approval and adoption of an updated Planning Enforcement Plan. A copy of the Plan was appended to the report. The report had previously been considered by the Planning Committee.
Councillor Fear stated that the prioritisation referred to dealing with immediate damage that could be done by breaches in Planning legislation and the rapidity in which the Council needed to respond.
Cllr Fear welcomed the overall good figures and expressed his confidence that small spikes should go down as well with additional expert input. The Leader reminded that the site had been caped which should bring even more positive results by the autumn. The issue should in all cases remain a key priority with regular updates to members.
- Cllr Fear wished to echo the Leader and said the report’s conclusions should be taken seriously; overall good relationships within the Council were to be praised with employees feeling they could voice their opinion and members able to engage with the process; the Leader commented that staff were signed up for the regeneration agenda and going the extra mile as required.
- Cllr Fear welcomed the contract and more generally the support to group sports, which taught a lot of social skills.
Cllr Fear echoed the Leader’s enthusiasm and underlined the importance of getting in the contract while the market was vibrant to get the best value.
The Deputy Leader supported Cllr Fear and the Leader’s statements.
This was seconded by Councillor Fear.
This was echoed by Cllr Fear.
Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Northcott and seconded by Councillor Fear
Councillor Gary White spoke on this application Amended recommendation (Removal of Permitted Development Rights) proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor John Williams.
Councillor Gary White spoke on this application Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Dave Jones.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Panter.
Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear, the Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning felt it would be worthwhile to include Members representations. Officers had had a lot of time wasted by this and there had been 5 postponements of this and the proposed new date was insulting.
The Portfolio Holder for Planning and Growth, Councillor Fear introduced the item, drawing Members’ attention to paragraphs 1.6, 1.9 and section 2 of the report.
Amended recommendation moved by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Northcott
Councillor Gary White spoke on this application Amended recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Northcott.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader the following:
Councillor Fear asked the Leader to outline the jobs involved. The Leader stated that the jobs included lifeguards at J2, refuse collectors, drivers, mechanics and operators of machinery.
Amended recommendation moved by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Northcott.
Councillor Fear stated that, as this involved the demolition of old buildings and erection of new on key sites, the Cabinet and relevant officers should be urged to maximise the amount of consultation with Members with regard to the form of the buildings.
Councillor Fear gave a verbal update for the Planning Committee which had met on its regular cycle and had undertaken a site visit since the last Council meeting. There had been a rising problem with open enforcement cases. A meeting with senior members of the Section, the Portfolio Holder and the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee had led to an agreement that those working within the Section would devote a bit more of their time to enforcement matters which was welcomed by members of the Planning Committee.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader if he agreed that a much more streamlined and obvious website was needed. The Leader agreed that the website, with the multi-click feature needed to be streamlined which it would be under the new website and would have a more professional look. In addition the ‘One Front Door’ would be launched in September.
Councillor Fear asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Town Centres and Growth, what was in the pipeline because as High Street’s began to change, the Market would play an important part of generating prosperity in the Borough Councillor Sweeney stated that other events in the pipeline were: Artisan Markets on the third Sunday of the month and there was a waiting list for stalls there; on 29 ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Fear gave a verbal update for the Planning Committee which had met on its regular cycle. These had now moved to hybrid style meetings and had been well attended. At the last meeting there had been an excellent set of performance reports from the Committee and officers were thanked for their hard work in very difficult times.
Proposed by the Chair, Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor John Williams.
Councillor Fear was also a member of the sub-group.
Councillor Fear agreed that something should be done in case a pandemic was to happen again.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader for an outline of the threats posed by a Clean Air Zone (CAZ) for residents and businesses in the Borough.
Councillor Fear stated that this was very concerning and asked the Leader for assurance that he would continue to campaign and lobby against the imposition of a CAZ in the Borough.
Councillor Fear gave a verbal update for the Planning Committee stating that the Committee had continued to meet on its regular cycle via hybrid and had maintained good attendance.
At the last meeting the performance figures for the Planning department were excellent and Councillor Fear thanked officers for their efficiency.
Councillor Fear asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Efficiency for an update on the external Auditors professional opinion on the Council’s 2019/2020 Statement of Accounts.
Councillor Fear congratulated everyone involved for their hard work and stated that it had gone really well.
Councillor Fear felt that wind farms were not attractive and very ineffective. Reference was made to the wind farm situated off the coast of North Wales.
Councillor Fear stated that, on a recent visit none had been turning and added that there were many small things that could be done which would be more effective.
In respect of solar panels, Councillor Fear asked what there was on top of Castle House as an example. Such panels would look ugly in the countryside ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor Fear advised Members that the former Home Farm site at Keele had water free urinals and they were odour free. He wondered if Keele would have any information as to how much water the Council could save by using this method.
The Chair, Councillor Fear seconded the proposal.
Councillor Fear declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/308/FUL as a member of the Moseley Railway Trust.
Conditions (ix) and (x) proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Moffat
Councillor Fear declared a non-prejudicial interest in application 20/00003/FUL as a member of the Moseley Railway Trust.
Conditions in relation to the roof colour and the residential accommodation being linked to the business proposed by Councillor Reddish and seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear did not vote on this application.
Councillor Fear asked how much money had been received by the Council already in relation to this. The Leader advised that almost half a million pounds had already been received. There was a mechanism in place to get more funding in and this, in turn would be used to bring in even more funding.
Councillor Fear advised that the Committee had met on its regular cycle and they had been well attended. Simeon Manley was thanked for his work as the Interim Head of Planning and welcomed the new Head, Shawn Fleet.
A Motion was received on Brexit, proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Holland.
Councillor Fear spoke on the Motion stating that he was delighted to be bringing it to Council. He had campaigned for Brexit all along and added that this country had been a beacon to the rest of Europe.
The amendment was debated and was not accepted by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear stated that he would accept inserting the word Borough but would not accept replacing ‘request’ with ‘demand’.
Condition (xvi) was proposed by Councillor Simon Tagg and seconded by the Chair - Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear questioned whether at paragraph 6 it should read meeting and not meetings. This would be amended.
Councillor Fear agreed with this stating that slang was not appropriate in documents such as this.
A verbal update was given for the Economy, Environment and Place Scrutiny Committee by the Vice-Chair, Councillor Fear as he had chaired the previous meeting.
Councillor Fear stated that the Committee had looked at the Car Parking Strategy where valuable contributions had been made.
Councillor Fear advised that the Committee had met on its regular cycle and there had been a site visit that had taken place on 2 November where varied planning control issues had been dealt with.
Councillor Fear asked for an update into the investigation into foul odours believed to be coming from Walley’s Quarry.
Councillor A Fear was appointed as Chair for the meeting
The minutes of the meeting held on 20 June 2019 were agreed as a correct record subject to a note being made within the final paragraph of item 5 – Allocation and Homeless Policy that Councillor Fear was not supportive of activities to help and support rough sleepers.
Councillor Fear welcomed the receipt at this meeting of the Public Speaking at Planning Protocol. Members were advised that an outstanding appeal case had been reported at the last Planning Committee meeting, where a decision was awaited from the Inspector. A letter had been sent to the Planning Inspectorate on behalf of the Planning Committee for an update.
Councillor Fear asked The Portfolio Holder for Finance and Efficiency how the Council was spending the money provided by the Government to prepare for Brexit on 31 October.
Councillor Fear asked Councillor Sweeney to write to the government asking them to declare Brexit Day a Bank Holiday.
Councillor Fear referred to a breakdown in relations between the Council and the unions prior to December 2017 and the recently improved relations.
The Chair of the Planning Committee, Councillor Fear gave a verbal update:
Councillor Fear asked the Leader for an update on the introduction of PSPOs, particularly in relation to aggressive begging in the town centre.
Councillor Fear stated that a recent Scrutiny Committee had found that zero tolerance yielded good results and asked if this Council would take that approach.
In relation to items 6 and 12 - The Lyme Lottery, Councillor Burnett declared an interest as a Trustee of Kidsgrove Sports Centre Community Group, Councillor Fear declared an interest in Moseley Railway Trust and Councillor Waring declared an interest in Go Kidsgrove .
In general members were supportive of the activities being carried out to help and support rough sleepers although Councillor Fear contrasted the picture with the absence of beggars in Nantwich Town Centre where there was no offer of support services and questioned whether there was a link between homelessness and the provision of services.
Moved by Councillor John Williams and seconded by Councillor Fear.
The Chair Councillor Fear, advised that the Committee had continued to meet on a regular basis. There had been some very large applications put through the Committee recently. Members were reminded that there was provision for members to speak at Committee on applications within their ward.
Councillor Fear then asked what impact this would have on the Council’s borrowing requirement.
Councillor Fear asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Efficiency what mechanism was in place for monitoring the implementation of the Council’s Capital Programme.
Councillor Fear asked what the Member involvement was in the Group.
The Chair Councillor Fear , advised that many applications had been put before the Committee as had appeals, one of which had challenged the Council’s Five Year Housing Land Supply where the Planning Inspectorate had agreed with the Council’s decision.
Councillor Fear asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Efficiency for an update on the asbestos situation at the former Civic Offices.
Councillor Fear, Chair of the Planning Committee advised that the rules public speaking at committees had varied slightly in that speakers could now speak with plans of proposed developments up on the screens. These plans would, however, be restricted to the official ones that had been submitted with the application.
Councillor Fear asked The Leader of the Council for an update on his work with the Business Improvement District (BID).
Councillor Fear said that the petition was ‘heartfelt’ and should be considered in the broader process.
Councillor Fear, Chair of the Planning Committee advised Members that the Committee had met on its regular cycle and thanked officers for the 3D system that had been used for marking out at a recent site visit.
Councillor Fear stated that th3D effect should be used for all future site visits.
Revised recommendation proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Tagg.
Traveller Incursions Councillor Fear welcomed this report and thanked the Police for their work in this matter.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader if the Local MP had been approached. The Leader stated that he had had a response and that legislation was coming forward.
Councillor Fear asked the Leader if the funding for a new Sport and Leisure Centre in Kidsgrove referred to by the previous administration had been located?
It was moved by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Sweeney that Councillor Simon Tagg be appointed as Leader of the Council.
The paragraph referred to ‘firm’ action being taken and a request was made by Councillor Fear to use the word ‘firm’ within the report where it referred to action being taken.
Councillor Fear asked the Portfolio Holder for Finance and Resources for an update on the overspend of £102,000 at 30 November, 2017.
Councillor Simon Tagg, nominated by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Sweeney.
An amendment to condition ( iv ) – to remove the word ‘broadly’ was proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Tagg.
Revised wording of the recommendation was proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Tagg.
Councillor Fear asked whether all Members had seen the presentation on the Joint Local Plan and why it had not come to this evening’s meeting? The Leader stated that this was a Special meeting – set up for a specific purpose. A presentation on the Local Plan would be arranged for all Members, possibly prior to the meeting in September.
Proposed by Councillor Northcott and Seconded by Councillor Fear.
Councillor Fear asked who would decide which was the preferred option from the six given and was advised that the Council would decide. The Planning committee would have the opportunity to agree which of the six options went forward for a final decision.
Councillor Fear asked what the remit of the consultation was and also, what would happen if the two authorities – Newcastle and Stoke had different opinions? This concern was shared by a number of Members.
Proposed by Councillor Fear and seconded by Councillor Reddish
Proposed by Councillor Holland and seconded by Councillor Fear
A motion was received, proposed by Councillor Holland, seconded by Councillor Fear regarding the EU Referendum.
The Committee considered the reports and a proposal to refuse the application was put forward by Cllr Northcott and seconded by Cllr Fear on the following grounds:
The Committee considered the report and Cllr Fear proposed approval subject to the following additional conditions along with those recommended in the report, this was seconded by Cllr Mrs Heesom .
Cllr Fear, seconded by Cllr Reddish moved approval subject to the conditions indicated in the report and the following additional condition:
Cllr Fear proposed a site visit which was seconded by Cllr Mrs Braithwaite, all Members voted in agreement.
Cllr Fear proposed the following recommendation which was seconded by Cllr Turner and voted on with all members in agreement:
Cllr Northcott moved that the application be refused and this was seconded by Cllr Fear for the following reasons:
Cllr Sweeney moved the first amendment which was seconded by Cllr Fear.
The following amendment was moved by Cllr Fear and seconded by Cllr Miss Reddish:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Fear attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Application for minor development - land rear of 57 high street, alsagers bank. mr mohammed saleem. 25/00851/pip | 3 for, 3 against, 6 abstained | ||
| 3 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Application for minor development - land off wereton road, audley. mr stephen adams. 25/00883/pip | Carried | 5 for, 3 against, 4 abstained | |
| 14 Jan 2026 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - baldwin's gate farm, newcastle road, baldwin's gate. mr chris o'hanlon, bellway homes limited. 25/00661/ful | Carried | 5 for, 6 against | |
| 25 Feb 2025 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - former jubilee baths, nelson place, newcastle. integritas property group (ipg) number 8 ltd. 25/00008/ful | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Feb 2024 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | 23 for, 16 against | |
| 11 Oct 2022 | Planning Committee | Application for major development - park hill farm, park lane. mrs pat pimlott. 22/00214/ful | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Sep 2022 | Council | Motions of members | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Nov 2021 | Council | Recommendations of the independent remuneration panel | Lost | 16 for, 24 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Nov 2019 | Council | Review and update of the borough council of newcastle-under-lyme's council and committee procedure rules | Lost | 20 for, 21 against | |
| 13 Aug 2019 | Planning Committee | 5 boggs cottage, keele. 14/00036/207c3 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jun 2019 | Economy, Environment & Place Scrutiny Committee | Recycling service update | Carried | 5 for, 2 against | |
| 5 Jan 2016 | Planning Committee | Application for Major Development - Tadgedale Quarry, Eccleshall Road, Loggerheads. Renew Land Developments Ltd. 15/00015/OUT | Carried | 5 for, 3 against | |
| 25 Nov 2015 | Council | Motions of Members | Carried | 31 for, 19 against, 5 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Capital Strategy 2015 | Lost | 26 for, 28 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Scheme of Delegation in Relation to Planning Functions | Carried | 28 for, 25 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2015 | Council | Scheme of Delegation in Relation to Planning Functions | Carried | 27 for, 2 against, 24 abstained | |
| 16 Dec 2014 | Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Asset Management Strategy | Carried | 9 for, 7 against | |
| 16 Dec 2014 | Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Asset Management Strategy | 9 for, 9 against | ||
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Treasury Management Annual Report 2011/12 | Carried | 30 for, 9 against, 8 abstained | |
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Motions of Members | Lost | 12 for, 39 against | |
| 12 Sep 2012 | Council | Motions of Members | Carried | 38 for, 0 against |
Meetings Councillor Fear was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 17 of 26 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Fear declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Jun 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Fear declared a non-pecuniary interest in application 20/308/FUL as a member of the Moseley Railway Trust. | |
| 14 Apr 2020 | Planning Committee, item 3 | Councillor Fear declared a non-prejudicial interest in application 20/00003/FUL as a member of the Moseley Railway Trust. | |
| 27 Jun 2019 | Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | In relation to items 6 and 12 - The Lyme Lottery, Councillor Burnett declared an interest as a Trustee of Kidsgrove Sports Centre Community Group, Councillor Fear declared an interest in Moseley Railway Trust and Councillor Waring declared an interest in Go Kidsgrove . |
Where Councillor Fear sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 217 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 120 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Mar 2020 | 41 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Economy and Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2022 | 11 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Local Government Reorganisation Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| Finance, Resources and Partnerships Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 46 | |
| Finance, Assets & Performance Scrutiny Committee | Guest | Jan 2018 | 21 | |
| Recycling and Waste Strategy Cabinet Panel | Committee Member | Jan 2013 | 17 | |
| Economy, Environment & Place Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2019 | 14 | |
| Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2012 | 7 | |
| Grants Assessment Panel | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 3 | |
| Scrutiny Review Working Party - Walley's Quarry | Chair | Aug 2020 | 3 | |
| Joint Finance, Resources & Partnerships and Economic Development and Enterprise Scrutiny Committees | Committee Member | Dec 2014 | 2 | |
| Newcastle-under-Lyme Sports Council Annual General Meeting | Non-elected, non-voting | Oct 2011 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Task and Finish Group - Climate Change/Sustainability | Committee Member | Sep 2020 | 1 | |
| Health,Wellbeing & Partnerships Scrutiny Committee | Substitute | Nov 2021 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.