Constitution and Governance Review
moved by Councillor Charles and seconded by Councillor Cartman:
Every time North Somerset's minutes name Councillor Cartman, as the council published it.
moved by Councillor Charles and seconded by Councillor Cartman:
Councillor Cartman spoke in support of the project, advising that there was not an additional capital or revenue commitment for the council.
The report was presented by Councillor Ashley Cartman, nominated shareholder representative. He explained the remit of the company and that it was successfully operating and moving towards profitability.
Councillor Cartman introduced the report. He informed members that it was an update report following the council’s decision to bring waste services within a council controlled company. The report was from the shareholder perspective as the council owned the company.
Councillor Cartman presented the report. He reminded members that the report before them was not the final budget for 2023/24 and that this report was an update following the recent publication of the Local Government Finance Settlement which had also updated the council’s financial assumptions.
Councillor Cartman brought recommendation 2 to members’ attention in respect of the Safety Valve funding settlement discussions that were ongoing with the government in relation to the cumulative deficit on the Dedicated Schools Grant and the delegation to the council’s s151 officer to continue those discussions.
Councillor Cartman responded that transformation work was needed in the area of Home to School transport and conversations had already started to determine best practice. He acknowledged the use of the financial risk reserve to support the funding gap in the current year budget due to the higher than expected pay award and rising energy costs. He added that he shared members’ concerns over the level of funding for Children’s Services in not anticipating further growth.
Councillor Cartman presented the report and explained that it was a follow on from the Council decision in May 2022 to transition out of Castlewood, remove it from the council’s office requirement and release it for development. The report outlined options for redevelopment of the site that had been considered including use for residential, office, industrial, hotels and a mixed use. He added that environmental and social aspects had been considered as well as financial.
Councillor Cartman advised that he was aware of the importance of the development to residents, councillors and the town of Clevedon and the desire to make the site a landmark development. In light of these concerns and to allow for better and more detailed member involvement and democratic oversight, he proposed an amendment to the recommendations to include the following:
In responding to the points made, Councillor Cartman confirmed that the redevelopment would be residential led but with commercial space which would give the council an option to retain office space in the north.
Councillor Cartman presented the report noting that it was coming to Council because costs had increased and an additional £10m capital funding commitment was being sought. He added that the cost of not proceeding with the project would be £15m with the total cost to North Somerset taxpayers of £20m if it went ahead.
Councillor Cartman informed members that it was expected the government would underwrite any additional cost increases that resulted from inflation. The additional funding required for the project was being met by the council, the West of England Combined Authority (WECA), and the Department for Transport (DfT) but that the council’s decision to inject more funds was contingent on decisions of other bodies to also increase their funding and that the council would not bear future overrun costs.
moved by Councillor Cartman and seconded by Councillor James it was
Moved by Councillor Charles and seconded by Councillor Cartman “This council notes 1. That Government has very recently published its response to the Committee for Standards in Public Life 2019 report into strengthening the local government standards regime after a three year wait. The response falls short of making changes to the standards regime but suggests that councils can adopt changes themselves to strengthen conduct issues.
Councillor Cartman presented his reported and noted that whilst he feared it would be difficult to find an affordable green contract, he was pleased to announce that a net zero green energy contract had been obtained for a premium of 3%. He added that although the council was procuring from a large supplier this time, it did not preclude purchasing from local sources in the future. He informed members that because of pricing and volatility in the energy market, the report proposed giving delegated authority to the S151 Officer in consultation with himself and other officers to achieve the best spot price possible through the council’s energy consultants.
In discussing the report, members were reassured by Councillor Cartman that as much as possible a robust approach to Russian gas supplies would form part of the contract. Members further noted that an “Invest to Save” approach to installing solar panels on the roofs of council buildings would support the drive to lower costs.
Moved by Councillor Cartman, seconded by Councillor Canniford and
Councillor Cartman presented the report noting that the key theme was an ongoing transition to a digital offering to customers as it was how the majority of residents wished to engage with the council and that it was more cost-effective. He added that members’ concerns with the digital approach had been considered and changes to the strategy as a result were noted in the appendix. Face to face appointments would be extended particularly in the north of the district through the use of the library facilities.
Councillor Cartman presented the report drawing members’ attention to an additional £4m from the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) including £1.2m for social care projects and £2.4m for the Healthier Together Matched Funding S256 agreement including support for the voluntary sector with a focus on debt and financial advice.
With the agreement of the Chairman, Councillor Cartman presented the Executive finance references and the council tax setting report en bloc, that is:
In presenting the Executive references and the report, Councillor Cartman outlined the council’s financial strategy for the year ahead which sought to protect vital services whilst also investing an extra £40m in long-term local projects to improve services for children, green initiatives and local facilities. He highlighted some of the initiatives as set out in the report which focussed on the key priorities of supporting children and young people, delivering better basic services, investing in communities, and tackling the climate emergency. He stated most of the council’s money went on providing key basic services such as social care, children’s services, recycling & waste and road maintenance, and confirmed residents would continue to receive good council services.
Councillor Cartman presented the reference from the Executive.
Moved by Councillor Cartman, seconded by Councillor Solomon it was
Councillor Cartman presented the reference from the Executive and the report on the Revenue Budget Update and Council Tax Setting 2022/23. All the finance items were discussed together en bloc (see minute no. COU 102 above).
Moved by Councillor Canniford and seconded by Councillor Crockford-Hawley “That the first set of recommendations as set out in the exempt report be approved and adopted.” Councillor Cartman proposed an amendment to the recommendations, with the addition of a further recommendation requiring any increase in expenditure over and above that set out in the report to be brought back to Council, as follows:
Councillor Cartman introduced the report, and the Director of Corporate Services summarised the council’s financial position after the first five months of 2021/22, drawing attention to key issues, known pressures and potential risks at this stage of the financial year.
Councillor Cartman thanked officers for a comprehensive and detailed report and recognised the dedication of officers across the council in addressing the Covid pressures and ensuring the council was not left financially exposed. He referred to ongoing work to address financial pressures and challenges in the usual key areas and reassured members that a prudent approach was being taken in working towards a balanced budget. In discussing the report members raised the possibility of exploring whether the additional costs of the Weston Town Centre Enhancement Scheme as a result of unmapped utilities could be recovered from the utility companies, and to options for mitigating the shortfall in income from fees and charges as a direct result of the Covid pandemic.
Councillor Cartman presented the report, drawing attention to the update on resources and on service pressures and priorities as set out in paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2 of the report. He referred to the significant work required to bridge the budget gap and the limited room for manoeuvre but gave assurances that at all stages priority would be given to protecting frontline services. He referred to ongoing uncertainties and the approach being used to close the budget gap, and confirmed the council’s commitment to consult and engage on the budget process.
At the invitation of Councillor Cartman, the Director of Corporate Services presented the report which provided a summary of the council’s financial position after the first four months of the 2021/22 financial year and included details relating to key issues, known pressures as well as the potential risks that had been identified at this point in time. Members were informed that this was the first report of the new financial year and so efforts had focused upon material areas of the council’s budget or those which continued to be impacted by Covid-19.
Councillor Cartman thanked the finance team for their work on the report and noted that it was good news with less than 1% variant on the four year outcome which was testament to the good work and culture and controls of the council. However, he stressed the fact that there were still a number of risks.
Councillor Cartman presented the report which provided an update with regards to assumptions which underpinned the council’s medium-term financial plan, covering the 3-year period to 2024/25, which was last considered by the Executive in February 2021. The council recognised the importance of aligning limited resources and allocating them to the priorities identified within the Corporate Plan, which meant that it continually reviewed all aspects of financial planning and considered new risks, issues and challenges as they emerged. This was essential given the uncertainties, pressures and impacts which had arisen as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic.
In presenting the report, Councillor Cartman stressed the need to improve the consultation process and to consult with citizens and residents more frequently. This included parish and town councils and partners in the community to see what more could be done and this included members. He referred to proposals in the report to undertake this over the autumn period and he welcomed the involvement of Executive colleagues in this process.
At the invitation of Councillor Cartman, the Director of Corporate Services provided an update for members. She explained that the position was uncertain and was a programme in development. It was slightly more promising for 2022/23 than had been thought in February 2021 but it would still be a challenge to find the efficiencies and transformations given the pressures faced.
Councillor Cartman thanked the Director of Corporate Services and her team for their hard work on the report.
Moved by Councillor Canniford, seconded by Councillor Cartman and
Councillor Cartman thanked officers for a comprehensive and technical report and welcomed Amy Webb, Director of Corporate Services, to her first meeting. The Director of Corporate Services gave a brief summary of the council’s financial performance for the 2020/21 financial year, with the council delivering within its overall resource envelope and achieving a balanced budget. She referred to the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and the significant levels of additional resources from central government to address these challenges.
Councillor Cartman referred to the challenges of the past year and to the council’s achievement in presenting a balanced budget position. He referred to continuing uncertainties facing the council over the coming year with rising adult social care costs, general inflation and limited opportunities for raising revenue via Council Tax increases. He drew members’ attention to the changes to the capital programme, and referred to the huge investment in local communities, including additional funding for road maintenance and repairs.
Councillor Cartman presented the report. He thanked the finance team for their work on the budget and confirmed that end of year figures reflected those within this report. However he referred to the ongoing uncertainties and risks around the Covid emergency and funding from central government and warned against complacency.
With the agreement of the Chairman, Councillor Cartman presented the Executive finance references and the council tax setting update report en bloc, that is: Treasury Management Strategy 2021/22; Capital Strategy 2021-2025 and Capital Budget 2021/22;
In presenting the Executive references and the report, Councillor Cartman thanked Richard Penska and the Finance team for their work in bringing forward the reports and expressed special thanks to Richard for his invaluable contribution. He also paid tribute to his Executive colleagues for their collaboration and team work in presenting a robust and balanced budget. He referred to the three core themes within the corporate plan of ‘open’, ‘fair’ and ‘green’ as reflected within the council’s finance reports and he outlined the key elements within the reports.
On the Motion of Councillor Cartman, duly seconded it was
Councillor Cartman presented the reference from the Executive.
Councillor Cartman presented the reference from the Executive and the update report on the Revenue Budget Update and Council Tax Setting 2021/22 (agenda item 16a).
Councillor Cartman presented the report. He summarised the report and the recommendations, stressing that these three corporate strategies were independent yet inextricably linked, and were fundamental to the council’s transformation programme and to the delivery of excellent services. He referred to the proposals outlined in section 3 of the report and the conclusion that the Town Hall should be retained as the primary office and cultural heart of the council but stressed that decisions on the future of sites listed within Group 2A as set out in paragraph 3.17 of the report would be subject to feasibility and business cases.
Councillor Cartman assured members that any future decisions on sites would be evidence based and subject to a rigorous feasibility process as detailed in the report, and he encouraged members to attend and get involved in any consultation and scrutiny sessions.
Councillor Cartman – Executive Member with responsibility for procurement Councillor Canniford – Executive Member with responsibility for business Councillor Davies – Executive Member with responsibility for human resources Councillor Bridger – Chairman of the Community and Corporate Organisation Policy and Scrutiny Panel
Councillor Cartman presented the report. He outlined the proposals as set out in the report and the funding available to support the new vision. He was pleased to bring forward timely plans to repurpose the centre, diversifying away from pure retail use and broadening the experience on offer to residents and visitors.
This proposal was taken on board by Councillor Cartman.
With the agreement of the Chairman, Councillor Cartman presented the following four finance reports en bloc, that is: ; Treasury Management Strategy 2021/22; Capital Strategy 2021-2025 and Capital Budget 2021/22; Medium Term Financial Plan (MTFP) and Revenue Budget 2021/22.
In presenting the reports Councillor Cartman referred to the core themes within the council’s finances and outlined the key elements within each of the reports. He paid tribute to staff and volunteers within North Somerset Together for their hard work throughout the year and their kindness in supporting local communities. He made reference to the persistent budget pressures faced by the council over many years, the ongoing impacts resulting from the pandemic and future uncertainties around local government funding.
In discussing the proposals members thanked Councillor Cartman and officers for the detailed and comprehensive budget reports. Reference was made to the range of exciting new schemes included within the capital strategy with significant investment planned across the district. Members welcomed the additional investment in a range of services that reflected the key themes and values of the administration.
Councillor Cartman presented the Council’s treasury management strategy for the 2021/22 financial year which incorporates the financial planning assumptions used in the financing of the capital programme, as referenced later on the agenda. All the finance reports were discussed together en bloc (see minute no. EXE 76 above).
Councillor Cartman presented the Capital Strategy and budget, outlining the council’s approach to capital investment over the short, medium and longer term and providing a high-level overview of how capital expenditure activity contributes to the provision of local public services within the area. All the finance reports were discussed together en bloc (see minute no. EXE 76 above).
Councillor Cartman presented the report, providing an overview of proposed investments in priority areas of focus for the Executive which aimed to deliver tangible benefits to residents through improving local amenities and access to them, and also to businesses and the wider community through providing targeted support and facilitating recovery plans. The report finalises the MTFP planning assumptions and recommends a final revenue budget to Council for 2021/22 in readiness for setting the council tax charges for the year ahead.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Cartman attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Cartman's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Cartman was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
North Somerset has not published attendance for Councillor Cartman's meetings yet.
What Councillor Cartman declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Cartman in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Cartman sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Cartman yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.