Actions arising
Action 2 Councillor K Payne requested clarification regarding the different directorate expenditure budget figures stated in the Scrutiny Committee and Cabinet reports.
Every time Rutland's minutes name Councillor Payne, as the council published it.
Action 2 Councillor K Payne requested clarification regarding the different directorate expenditure budget figures stated in the Scrutiny Committee and Cabinet reports.
The Clerk reported that Kirsty Nutton, Strategic Director – Resources had met with Councillor K Payne and that the matter had been clarified.
---o0o--- Councillor K Payne asked her question to Councillor G Waller, Leader of the Council.
---o0o--- Councillor Karen Payne, with the permission of the Chair, joined the meeting at 8.20 p.m.
---o0o--- · Councillor K Payne requested clarification regarding the different directorate expenditure budget figures stated in the Scrutiny Committee and Cabinet reports.
· Councillor Powell and Councillor K Payne had met with Andrew Gordon, Interim Head of Property on the 21 st November 2024 to discuss the current stage of the review and possible future involvement of the Task and Finish Group.
It was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded that the minutes of the 26 th September and 31 st October 2023 meetings be approved.
Councillor K Payne asked her question to Councillor C Wise, Portfolio Holder for Highways, Transport and the Environment, as set out in the agenda supplement.
It was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded that the minutes of the 27 June meeting be approved.
A report from Councillor K Payne regarding a meeting of the Hanson Cement Ketton Liaison Committee attended by herself and Councillor M Farina.
Councillor R Powell nominated Councillor T Carr as the substitute representative and this was seconded by Councillor K Payne.
Councillor K Payne queried how the Council would evidence that it was delivering against the Financial Sustainability Strategy. The Strategic Director of Resources informed members that the report detailed the impact on the medium term financial strategy (Section 3.11).
Councillor K Payne nominated Councillor R Powell as the Chair of the Asset Review Task and Finish Group and this was seconded by Councillor S Lambert.
Councillor D Wilby nominated Councillor K Payne as the Vice Chair of the Asset Review Task and Finish Group and this was seconded by Councillor T Carr .
b) APPROVED Councillor K Payne as the Vice Chair of the Asset Review Task and Finish Group.
A motion to appoint Councillor K Payne was moved by Councillor R Powell and seconded. Upon being put to the vote, with 27 votes in favour the motion was unanimously carried.
RESOLVED a) That Councillor K Payne be APPOINTED as Chair of the Audit and Risk Committee for the 2023-24 municipal year.
Report No. 27/2023 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. It was explained that the Government’s May 2022 Levelling Up and Regeneration Bill proposed further discretionary Council Tax premium options on empty properties and second homes. With billing authorities encouraged to adopt Council Tax premiums on empty properties and second homes with a view to incentivising property owners to bring those properties back into use.
A motion to approve the recommendations of Report No. 27/2023 was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded.
Report No. 57/2023 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The report set out the finings of the review of into the effectiveness of the Strategic Overview and Scrutiny. The review had been requested by Council when it agreed to establish a single Committee in April 2022 and had included a survey open to all Members and the matter had been discussed by the Constitution Commission prior to Council.
A motion to approve the recommendations of Report No. 57/2023 was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded.
Report No. 28/2023 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The report set out recommendations of the Cabinet to Council regarding the Council’s budget for 2023/24.
Treasury Management Strategy and Capital Investment Strategy It was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded that the Treasury Management Strategy and Capital Investment Strategy be approved. Upon being put to the vote, with 22 votes in favour, the motion was unanimously carried.
2) APPROVED the Capital Investment Strategy in Appendix 2 Fees and Charges The proposals were introduced by Councillor K Payne, it was requested that consideration be given to how the Council communicated any increases and fees and charges to residents and communicated the rationale for the rises, particularly where the fee was set nationally rather than by the Council. Assurance was also given that the outstanding matter of taxi licenses would be addressed and concluded.
Report No. 36/2023 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The report sought Council approval for the appointments of Kirsty Nutton as Strategic Director for Resources (S151 Officer) and Kim Sorsky as Strategic Director for Adults and Health following a recruitment process including interview by a Chief Officer Appointments Committee.
A motion to approve the recommendations of Report No. 36/2023 was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded.
Report No.04/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 04/2023 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.26/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 26/2023 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.37/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 37/2023 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.10/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Report No.01/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 01/2023 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.02/2023 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 02/2023 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Councillor K Payne declared a non-pecuniary interest in Report No.165/2022 as being Ward Member, and had therefore been involved in putting the neighbourhood plan together.
Report No.168/2022 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 168/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.156/2022 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 156/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.157/2022 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 157/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.158/2022 was introduced by Councillor Karen Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 158/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.125/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 125/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Report No.111/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 111/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed RESOLVED That Cabinet:
The recommendation was moved by Councillor K Payne and seconded.
---o0o--- Councillor K Payne introduced the recommendations of Report No. 104/2022, requesting a number of changes to the budget for 2022/23, it was highlighted that any budget increases would be held centrally and only be released following analysis of need and comparison to grants and other funding available.
Councillor K Payne reminded Members of a recently circulated report on a meeting of the Rural Services Network.
Report No. 106/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 106/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed RESOLVED That Cabinet:
Report No. 105/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 105/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed RESOLVED That Cabinet:
Report No. 104/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Councillor Payne highlighted the difficulty with recruitment which had a material impact on performance against the budget. This position was replicated across the sector where all Councils had struggled to recruit to core roles and to bring in additional resource even on a short term basis when funding had been available.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 104/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed.
Councillor K Payne felt it was heavily weighted towards the public sector rather than the private sector. Penny Sharp, Strategic Director for Places responded saying that those in the list are given first preference in terms of marketing for the first 3 months. The guidance does not exclude anybody else who is a first-time buyer from participating in the scheme, it just gives preference to that eligible group.
Report No. 103/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Councillor Payne highlighted that to continue to move quickly to distribute funding, the report in front of the Cabinet sought to extend delegated powers to the Strategic Director of Resources and Portfolio Holder for Finance. This covered the Household Support Fund and Council Tax Energy Rebate Scheme which were already in progress when previous delegated powers were removed.
It was proposed by Councillor K Payne that the recommendations of report No. 103/2022 be agreed, this was seconded and upon being put to the vote the motion was unanimously agreed RESOLVED That Cabinet DELEGATED authority to the Strategic Director for Resources in consultation with the Portfolio Holder with responsibility for finance to finalise the Council’s policy in relation to the discretionary element of the Council Tax energy rebate scheme and Household Support Fund and to make any further changes should funding still be available.
Councillor K Payne declared a personal interest in item 4, Planning applications, application 2021/1423/MAO due to knowing the applicant.
Councillor Payne confirmed she came to the meeting with an open mind.
RESOLVED In consultation with Cabinet Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation:
Report No. 72/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Report No. 69/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
In response to a query regarding the six-monthly review of the Strategic Risk Register by the Committee, it was confirmed by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder that this was in line with guidance from the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy. It was also confirmed by the Strategic Director for Resources that although the Policy would be expected to be next reviewed in four years’ time, there would always be the option to commence a review at an earlier point if circumstances required.
Report No. 01/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Councillor Payne highlighted various key points:
Members thanked Councillor Payne and the finance team for the report and its contents.
RESOLVED In consultation with the Cabinet, Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation:
Report No. 02/2022 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation.
Cllr Payne explained that the Council would look to develop a longer term (10 year) capital plan over the next year. Members welcomed the intention to produce a longer term plan and thanked officers for their hard work in producing the Strategies.
Report No. 146/2021 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The purpose of the report was to provide all Members with an update on the revenue budget position for 21/22 and the future outlook and in particular progress on closing the financial gap which stood at £2.7m for 22/23 (at the time the Council set its original budget in February 2021).
Councillor Payne drew the Cabinets attention to the £400,000 underspend in Adult Social Care and £410,000 in Childrens Services through changes in working practice, a windfall of £551,000 won against a Social Care residency case in Cambridgeshire and £130,000 underspend on resourcing.
Councillor Walters thanked Councillor Payne and Officers for the report.
In response to concerns raised by Members in relation to how quickly the Council was moving in reducing the deficit, Councillor Payne advised that the Senior Management Team were meeting on Wednesday 17 November to identify further projects to potentially reduce budgets.
Report No. 147/2021 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The purpose of the report was to provide Cabinet and all Members with an update on the delivery of the capital programme as at the end of September 2021.
Councillor Payne asked Cabinet to note that the Security Commission had requested a report on how CIL and S106 monies were going to be spent and this was being presented at the Growth, Infrastructure and Resources Committee on Thursday 18 November 2021.
Report No. 143/2021 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The purpose of the report was to updated Members on the progress against the Treasury Management Strategy, prudential indicators and highlighted whether any policies required revision. The underlying purpose of the report supported the objective in the CIPFA Code of Practice on Treasury Management (revised 2017) and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) Investment Guidance which required that Members received reports on and adequately scrutinised the treasury management service.
Councillor Payne asked if the allocation of the number of dwellings for larger villages was for larger villages with Neighbourhood Plans and whether this would apply if there was not a Neighbourhood Plan in place. Penny Sharp, Strategic Director for Places confirmed that the two communities in question were currently reviewing their Neighbourhood Plans and were seeking to make allocations. Further clarification would be provided outside of the meeting.
During discussion Councillor Payne highlighted to Cabinet that this was an additional pressure on budgets and there was no certainty that the Council would be able to fund the increase through grants.
Councillor A MacCartney delivered her question to Councillor K Payne as the Portfolio Holder for Finance, which had been circulated to Members in the agenda supplement.
The Chairman invited Councillor Payne to respond.
Queries about fossil fuel investment | Leicestershire County Council In response to Councillor Macartney’s supplementary, Councillor Payne stated that the Treasury Management Strategy would be updated around 3 months’ time due to the CIPFA guidelines currently being consulted on.
Report No. 150/2021 was introduced by Councillor K Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The purpose of the report was t o ask Council to opt into the national sector-led arrangements for the appointment of the external auditor.
It was moved by Councillor Payne that Council endorse the contents of the report. This was seconded and upon being put to the vote, the motion was unanimously carried.
Councillor K Payne and Councillor G Brown declared non-pecuniary interests in item 4 – Planning Applications, applications 2020/1263/MAF and 2020/1264/MAF due to knowing one of the speakers for the applications and as the Ward Members for Ketton.
No apologies for absence were received from Members of the Committee, but it was noted that the Strategic Director of Resources and Councillor K Payne, the Portfolio Holder, had been unable to attend.
Report No.66/2021 was introduced by Cllr Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation. The purpose of the report was to inform Cabinet and all Members of the provisional revenue and capital outturn for 20/21 including the impact of COVID 19 on the Council’s finances, the latest position on the 21/22 budget and the latest Medium Term Financial Plan position including the financial gap. In advising Members of the latest position the report also sought approval for various transfers and budget adjustments.
In consultation with Cabinet, Cllr Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation:
· Cllr Payne informed attendees that the grants received during the pandemic, although small, had been used wisely.
Cllr Payne, the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation, approved the intention to revoke the Risk Based Verification Policy with immediate effect.
Cllr Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation introduced the report, stating that surviving the past 18 months of the pandemic had posed great personal and commercial challenge making it a time like no other experienced in the past. Covid had generated ever changing demands on the Council through rapid and frequently changing regulation and direction, the creation of vaccination and testing centres, administering and delivering over £14m worth and thousands of grants, and the changing demands of social care for residents to name but a few aspects. On top of all of this the Council had continued to deliver business as usual.
It was against this backdrop that Cllr Payne wished to recommend to Council the principles outlined in the report in respect of future work and budget savings.
In respect of the delegated authority to the Portfolio Holder to spend up to £500k to allow savings projects to be accelerated, Cllr Payne emphasised the point that no money drawn down from reserves would be spent unless there was proven significant gain.
Cllr Payne felt that the large underspend identified was good news as it would help to cushion the blow of the financial pressures that RCC was expected to experience this year such as unforeseen and unknown pandemic demands, a higher than anticipated pay award, the environment bill that would change the way waste was handled, a social care uplift, potential rework of the Local Plan, subsiding the Leisure Contract, and Climate Change demands that were currently in definition. A similar challenge had been identified for 2022/23.
Cllr Payne, Portfolio Holder for Finance, Governance and Performance, Change and Transformation, in consultation with Cabinet, recommended ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
· Councillor Payne made a plea for officers to engage with parish councils over the strategy particularly those with neighbourhood planning groups who had already done much of the work on parking requirements and issues within the village.
· Councillor Payne felt that the biggest issue with ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
· Councillor Payne wholeheartedly supported the concept and felt that being able to see and use the metrics would be very valuable especially being able to see the different demands on officers.
Councillor Payne was proposed by Councillor Woodley and this was seconded by Councillor Harvey.
Councillor Payne declared an interest as her husband was an employer of 120 people in Rutland.
The Monitoring Officer had advised Councillor Payne that this was not a pecuniary interest but that it would be wise to declare it for the purposes of transparency.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Payne attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Payne's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Payne was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Rutland has not published attendance for Councillor Payne's meetings yet.
What Councillor Payne declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Oct 2022 | Cabinet, item 3 | Councillor K Payne declared a non-pecuniary interest in Report No.165/2022 as being Ward Member, and had therefore been involved in putting the neighbourhood plan together. | |
| 28 Apr 2022 | Planning and Licensing Committee, item 2 | Councillor K Payne declared a personal interest in item 4, Planning applications, application 2021/1423/MAO due to knowing the applicant. | |
| 16 Jan 2020 | Growth, Infrastructure and Resources Scrutiny Committee, item 443 | Councillor Payne declared an interest as her husband was an employer of 120 people in Rutland. |
Where Councillor Payne sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Payne yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.