New Library Byelaws
On the motion of Councillor Hill, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson, when put to the vote, the motion received the support of the Council and, of those present and voting, it was unanimously :
Every time Stoke-on-Trent's minutes name Councillor Watson, as the council published it.
On the motion of Councillor Hill, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson, when put to the vote, the motion received the support of the Council and, of those present and voting, it was unanimously :
The following motion was moved by Councillor Hill and, in the absence of Councillor Gordon-McCusker, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson:
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Knapper, it was:-
The Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Services, Councillor Alastair Watson, in conclusion of his speech, confirmed that Cabinet had approved and accepted the government offer of £16.8 million Exceptional Financial Support ... view the full minutes text for item 67.
Question 2: From Councillor Faisal Hussain addressed to the Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Services (Councillor Alastair Watson) Could the relevant cabinet member tell me the total time and total funding to date including government grants/funds have been spent in putting the Meir Station proposals together.
In response, Councillor Alastair Watson stated that the previous Conservative national Government, working with the local government, had sold many dreams dressed up as a plan which had misled the public into thinking ... view the full minutes text for item 57.
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Colclough, when put to the vote, it was:
On the motion of Councillor Robinson, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson, when put to the vote, it was:
Introduced by Councillor Alastair Watson (Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Services), the Committee was advised that the budget proposals as submitted represented the next steps of the previous year’s stabilisation and recovery plan to minimise cuts to services and maximise savings. This would be achieved by continuing to focus on partnership working and resolving issues at their roots, with results showing zero unmet hours in domiciliary and a reduction in numbers of children in care.
Councillor A Watson, Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Services, formally introduced the budget which was presented to Overview and Scrutiny members with an overview of the General Fund revenue budget with specific reference to the proposals under the remit of this committee for discussion and comment as part of the budget consultation.
Introduced by Councillor Alastair Watson (Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Services), the Committee were informed that the budget proposals were the next steps of the previous year’s stabilisation and recovery plan, to maximise efficiency and minimise cuts to services. It was noted that since 2010, City Council spending power had reduced by 25%. The Committee was advised of £1.1 million of public consultation savings and £6.4 million of none public consultation savings and proposals for a council tax rise of 4.99%.
In the absence of Councillor Alastair Watson, Councillor Robinson presented the City Council’s Management of Risk Policy and sought approval of it, following consideration of comments received from the Audit and Standards Committee.
On behalf of Councillor Alastair Watson, the Leader presented this report. She referred to a new operating model for Procurement and Commercial Services and sought approval of the Procurement Code, which replaced the Contract Procedure Rules.
In presenting this report on behalf of Councillor Alastair Watson, the Leader sought approval of the Responsible Procurement Code. She suggested that the Code would ensure that officers worked with suppliers to deliver a resource efficient and resilient Council with high environmental quality outcomes including for example, encouraging suppliers to adopt processes and procedures to reduce their environmental impact, and also required all suppliers to support the council’s ethics policies, uphold cultural commitments and share ethical values.
In presenting this report, Councillor Alastair Watson proposed that a Joint Committee be established on behalf of Staffordshire County Council and Stoke-on-Trent City Council, to take all decisions within the budget and policy framework for both councils arising from the winding down and cessation of the Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Local Enterprise Partnership (SSLEP). He suggested that the imminent closure of the SSLEP and integration of responsibilities into the upper tier authorities had created a need to consider how such functions were managed and decision made across the Stoke-on-Trent and Staffordshire geography.
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Robinson, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Finlay Gordon-McCusker, it was:-
Councillor Alastair Watson seconded the motion.
In presenting this report, Councillor Alastair Watson sought approval in respect of a change to Council Tax charges in the City, following the new Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 issued in October 2023, which allowed a premium to be charged on homes that remain empty after one year (rather than the current minimum two-year period).
Councillor Alastair Watson reported that the Local Government Finance Act 1992 required the Council to set a robust and legal budget before 11 March 2024. He further reported that the City Council had sought Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) from the government due to a projected budget shortfall of £10m for 2023/24 and £11.5m for 2024/25. The total request being for £42.2m as set out at paragraph 3.7 of the report submitted.
Councillor Alastair Watson (Cabinet Member, Financial Sustainability and Corporate Resources) invited the committee to review a recent Cabinet decision supporting a new government office building in the Smithfield district to provide a home for an expected 500 jobs. Jon Rouse (City Director) and Nick Edmonds (Director of Strategy and Resources, Section 151 Officer), further outlined the reasons for the decision and committee members asked questions, which included reviewing the effectiveness of the commercial decision making in this instance .
The following motion was moved by Councillor Alastair Watson and seconded by Councillor Glen Watson:
On the motion of Councillor Gordon-McCusker, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson, when put to the vote, it was unanimously:
The Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Resources, Councillor Alastair Watson, reiterated the significance of the early conversations that had taken place with central government. The Committee was also advised that as part of the proactive work undertaken, a number of independent financial reviews had been invited to support the Council in reviewing and addressing the challenges faced.
The Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Resources, Councillor Alastair Watson, reiterated the significance of the early conversations that had taken place with central government. The Committee was also advised that as part of the proactive work undertaken, a number of independent financial reviews had been invited to support the Council in reviewing and addressing the challenges faced.
The Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability and Corporate Resources, Councillor Alastair Watson, reiterated the significance of the early conversations that had taken place with central government. The Committee was also advised that as part of the proactive work undertaken, a number of independent financial reviews had been invited to support the Council in reviewing and addressing the challenges faced.
Councillor Alastair Watson, Cabinet Member for Finance and Corporate Services introduced the report setting out the financial position of services under the remit of the committee which demonstrated a £2.2 million underspend. He noted however that, in order to achieve a balanced budget across all services at the end of the 2022/23 financial year, a number of one-off savings had been made and this did not represent a sustainable position for future years.
This was seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson.
Long Service Awards The Lord Mayor presented Councillor Gurmeet Singh-Kallar, Councillor Shaun Pender and Councillor Alastair Watson with Long Service Awards in recognition of their twelve years of service as an Elected Member. The City Council joined the Lord Mayor in congratulating them.
Councillor Watson agreed with Councillor Elliott, noting the strategy had originally been requested approximately 1 and a half years prior, and also noting the strategy was due to go to Cabinet later the same month.
Councillor Watson did not feel the Committee had been provided with sufficient documentation to carry out meaningful scrutiny.
Councillor Watson questioned the consultation, and asked if it was felt we needed to save pitches or if we had a surplus.
Councillor Watson proposed that Councillor Sheila Pitt be elected Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Chair of the Council for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor Watson proposed that Councillor Stephen Funnell is hereby elected Deputy Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Vice Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor Watson sought clarification on whether the Civic was connected to the network. Andrew Briggs confirmed that they had adopted the principles of the District Heat Network and would be installing pipes and connecting to the Stoke Town network.
In response to questions raised by Councillor Watson in respect of the review that had taken place, Andrew Briggs confirmed that the Review had been undertaken between March and December 2021 and that it had always been the plan to connect residents but the domestic market would not be viable for approximately 10 years. The review had changed the pace of delivery and a cluster base had been adopted so that there were some benefits early on before connecting more of the network at a later date. David Harris, Assistant Director Investment, Planning and Regeneration added that the review had slightly delayed the wider roll-out of the network but had expediated delivery of the clusters.
Councillor Watson commented on the accuracy of the record of the discussion on the treasury management item and the lack of reference to an important question that he had raised about the appropriateness of adopting the same approach as others on the assumption that it was always the right approach.
Councillor Watson commented on the proposal to acquire a dedicated Enterprise Risk Management system and queried the benefits that this would provide above and beyond the current applications used. In response the increased functionality that the system would provide was set out along with the efficiencies to be gained from an automated approach to document management. It was also explained how the system would provide a more integrated approach to the separate risks.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Woolner “that Councillor Stephen Funnell be appointed Chair of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2021/22 Municipal Year” was carried.
A Motion, moved by Councillor Stephen Funnell, seconded by Councillor Alastair Watson that “Councillor Joanne Powell-Beckett be appointed as Chair of the Audit Committee for the 2021/2022 Municipal Year” was carried.
Councillor Watson proposed that Councillor Sheila Pitt be elected Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Chair of the Council for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor Watson proposed that Councillor Stephen Funnell be elected Deputy Lord Mayor of the City of Stoke-on-Trent and Vice Chairman of the Council for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor Watson raised a number of points and questions regarding the proposed schemes including clarification on whether there was to be a covered walkway along Station Road, what changes were to be made to the Leek Road/City Road Junction and the cost of the various improvements. He also queried what due diligence was undertaken in respect of the appointment of contractors to ensure value for money in terms of quality and who was responsible for quality control, snagging and ensuring that the schemes were adequately resourced. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Infrastructure and Heritage confirmed that there was to be a covered walkway along Station Road either side of Winton Square, and that whatever the final design, they would need to make sure that it was sympathetic to its surroundings and maintainable.
Councillor Watson referred to the previous points made by the Committee on the Joint Local Plan and the underlying principals of what was and was not included within it and questioned how that feedback had informed the principals and aims of this Plan. The Strategic Manager Planning Services confirmed that the messages regarding social infrastructure had been heard and that that work would come through in the later versions of the Plan and at this stage it was about the key issues which were raised in ... view the full minutes text for item 38.
In response to a question from Councillor Watson regarding issues that could be resolved, Councillor Adams explained that in respect of self-managed sites, the vast majority were not paying any rent. The new lease had been prepared which would be going out for people to sign up and they would be asked to pay a ground rent. Furthermore, they had inserted a clause within the lease that allotment holders could refer to the City Council if there was any dispute with the Committee of the self-managed site.
The Strategic Manager – Audit and Fraud highlighted the recent amendments made to the register and in response to a question from Councillor Watson it was explained that the risk assessment was likely to be similar for other Local Authorities and that a benchmarking exercise with other Local Authorities and private corporations had been undertaken approximately twelve months ago.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Ashworth and seconded by Councillor Watson:
BS02-2122 – Restructure of Regeneration and Economic Growth Councillor Watson queried how the net reduction of one occupied post would help in making the service more responsive and Councillor Smith also questioned whether now was the right time to be altering the regeneration arm of the organisation when there were so many on-going projects. The Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Infrastructure and Heritage gave assurances that the proposals would not impact on projects but would provide an enhanced focus.
Councillor Adams declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had received phone calls and a visit from residents but had advised them on the process only Councillor Ali declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Dodd declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had been contacted by residents asking her not to support the call-in Councillor Hussain declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Watson declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he was a Cabinet Member in 2014 when this issue had previously been raised.
Councillor Watson queried where facilities such as schools and surgeries were referred to and believed that these aspects should be front and centre and highlighted that other areas and principles such as the railway were mentioned. The Team Manager Planning Policy explained that these elements were included at this stage within the infrastructure section and would also be included in part 2 within the detail on sites. They were currently working with education and health colleagues to gather evidence but from a planning perspective, until the site selections had taken place, the demand was unknown.
Objective 4.5.3: Councillor Watson asked for details of the “Commercialisation Toolkit” and the Assistant Director – Finance explained that this was about producing an “in-house” guide for Officers in order to assist with improving efficiency and to assist in thinking about opportunities in individual areas of the business.
Councillor Watson further asked what the difference was from current practice to what was contained within the Guide and also asked for an example of this to be provided. The Cabinet Member for Finance and Partnerships referred to the Tier 4 Management Programme which had been introduced within the Authority, confirming that one of the modules covered commercialisation and social value and that the Toolkit referred to was a continuation of what already happened within the Council. Asked if the Toolkit included information on localism and using local suppliers, the Assistant Director – Finance confirmed that the Procurement Strategy did include a section on social value.
Councillor Watson asked what these costs related to and the Assistant Director – Finance explained that the High Needs budget covered a range of different areas including special schools, some staffing costs, provision for Education and Health Care (EHC) Plans and placement costs.
Councillor Watson asked why Legal Services (Ref CS3) on page 32 was showing as red and the Assistant Director – Finance explained that this related to a budget proposal in the previous year which sought to generate additional income by selling legal services externally but because of in-house pressures this had not been possible and would be addressed in year.
With regard to CS21C – Software savings from the introduction of the new Social Care case management system, Councillor Watson asked the reason for this showing as amber and the Assistant Director – ICT, Libraries and Customer Services reported that this was due to a delay in delivery of the system.
Councillor Watson also queried SEN Transport referred to on page 43 and the Assistant Director – Finance confirmed that there had been a slight improvement from Quarter 2 but that it remained a pressure overall and plans had been put into place with the City Director to address this issue.
Councillor Watson asked about Special Educational Needs (SEN) Transport indicating that he understood that this was an area for a reduction in the budget, not an increase. The Assistant Director – Finance explained that the associated Policy was currently being reviewed and had been the subject of a Cabinet report in December 2017.
Committee Members Comments and Questions Councillor Watson enquired whether it was anticipated that there would be an increase in the number of calls received by the Contact Centre as a result of the reduction in the Budget for pro-active work and the Strategic Manager – Customer Services explained that the Co-operative Working element was being absorbed and that she was not aware of any additional calls or enquiries that would be generated as a result.
Councillor Watson suggested that it would be useful to see where any impact may be experienced and the Assistant Director – ICT, Customer Services and Libraries agreed to monitor this situation.
Councillor Watson referred to the number of students who registered to vote and the Assistant Director – Governance confirmed that there had been an increase in the number of additional students on the electoral register of 125. The Chair also asked if there was any available information regarding the number of eligible voters in the City other than census date. The Assistant Director – ... view the full minutes text for item 78.
Councillor Shotton asked a question on behalf of Councillor Watson, who had now left the meeting, in relation to paragraph 5.9 contained within the report relating to borrowing of £28.5m and asked if this amount related to three separate loans. The Director confirmed that this sum was comprised of two loans; one for £4.5m and the other for £24m.
Following a debate, which included reference to the Housing and Planning Bill and the capping of new tenancies at up to five years, Councillor Watson moved, and Councillor Funnell seconded, an amendment to the recommendations set out in the report submitted which had the effect of adding the following words:- “(iii) That the City Council asks the Prime Minister, David Cameron MP, to think again and review capping the term of lifetime tenancies to five years.” Councillor Chetwynd moved and Councillor Banks seconded, that a recorded vote be taken on the amendment and this was supported by more than18 members present and voting at the meeting.
Councillor Watson suggested that the main problem was the length of time that callers were left on hold and felt that the best approach would be to receive detailed information at this Committee, introduce ways of mitigating the problem and then to continue to monitor the situation.
Councillor Watson welcomed this report which he thoroughly supported, adding that the proposals were moving in the right direction.
Councillor Watson also welcomed this item, particularly in respect of the proposed road improvement schemes which should help to ease congestion.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Watson expressed his support for this proposal adding that it would provide proper legal and contractual arrangements to support the delivery of social care in conjunction with the Clinical Commissioning Group.
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Watson expressed his support for this item and highlighted the fact that the budget for this proposal had already been approved as part of the budget proposals and therefore the item was being considered today solely to agree to commence the procurement process.
Councillor Watson, Cabinet Member for Finance Governance and HR presented this item which summarised the financial position of the General Fund, Housing Revenue Account and Capital Investment Programme as at the end of December 2014 and provided a forecast outturn for 2014/15.
Councillor Watson, Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented this report which outlined the Council’s performance for the period October 2014 to December 2014 and provided highlights and key messages shown by the data.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Watson expressed the view that going to one supplier for this was a step in the right direction and should result in economies of scale being realised. The Chair explained that, in addition, it should help to generate income for corporately operated venues.
Councillor Watson also expressed support and pointed out that the young people would be paid the Living Wage.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Watson.
The Leader of the Council, Councillor Mohammed Pervez moved a motion to approve the Capital Investment Programme for 2015/16 to 2019/20, which was seconded by Councillor Watson.
Councillor Watson moved a motion to approve the recommendations as set out in the report now submitted, which was seconded by Councillor J. Garner.
The Lord Mayor called for a recorded vote to be taken in relation to the motion that had been moved by Councillor Watson and on being put to the vote the outcome was as follows:
For clarity therefore, Councillor Watson (Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR), confirmed that the proposals considered by the Cabinet (Ref. 12.2.15) and those contained in the report now submitted were accurate and final.
Garner, seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
Councillor Watson, Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented this report, the purpose of which was to give feedback on Cabinet’s Budget Proposals for 2015/16 to 2018/19 from meetings of Overview and Scrutiny Committees in December 2014 and January 2015.
Continuing, Councillor Watson referred to the detailed breakdown of the proposals considered by Overview and Scrutiny within the report confirming that in the first round of meetings, Overview and Scrutiny had asked for further information in respect of 11 of the 61 proposals put forward and that 49 of the 61 proposals (80.3%) were supported.
Councillor Watson also reported with regard to six petitions that had been received by the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny all of which related to budget saving PEP23 – School Crossing Patrols.
Councillor Watson, as Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR, presented the Medium Term Financial Strategy 2015/16 – 2018/19 and the Revenue Budget and Council Tax Setting report for 2015/16 explaining that in recommending this report to City Council, the Cabinet were supporting the Council Tax requirement for 2015/16.
In presenting this report, Councillor Watson gave details to the background of current financial situation commenting upon the fact that Stoke-on-Trent City Council was one of the unitary authorities worse affected by cuts to Government funding which had resulted in having to realise savings of £97m in the last four years.
Councillor Watson referred to the phased approach which the Council would take to some budget proposals such as school crossing patrols, CAMHS, Meals on Wheels, etc and also confirmed that there would be no increase in Council Tax in the forthcoming financial year. The Budget met the City Council’s statutory and legal responsibilities.
Councillor Watson explained that the Programme was linked to the Revenue Budget and Council Tax Setting 2015/16 report included earlier on the agenda. He further commented that the Programme had been prioritised to ensure that everything in it made a real difference to the City and designed to allow adjustment to schemes in the event of projections/estimates changing. The Programme also demonstrated the Council’s commitment to investment.
Councillor Watson, Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented the Treasury Management and Annual Investment and Borrowing Strategy 2015/16 and Prudential Indicators 2015/16 to 2019/20, required in accordance with the Local Authorities (Capital Finance and Accounting)(Amendment)(England) regulations 2014 and the Code of practice on Local Authority Accounting UK.
It was noted that Councillor Crowe and Councillor Walker had replaced Councillor Watson and Councillor Platt on the Committee.
On the motion of Councillor J.Garner , seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Hassall, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Crowe, it was:-
The Executive Director of People and Councillor Watson (Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR) left the meeting at this point (11:05am).
Garner moved, and Councillor Watson seconded, that the petitions be noted.
In seeking the Council’s support to the Medium Term Financial Strategy, Councillor Watson moved that a minor amendment be made to the document by way of a reference to the essential link between housing growth and job creation being noted in a paragraph within. He explained that the reason for the minor amendment was to make it clear that economic growth did not come from housing growth alone and the City wanted jobs and growth.
Councillor Watson then moved that, subject to the minor amendment as outlined, the Medium Term Financial Strategy be approved to support the planning process and underpin the budget and policy framework of the City.
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor J. Garner, it was:-
Towns Against Tax Dodging (Avoidance & Evasion) It was moved by Councillor Watson and seconded by Councillor Platt, that:- “While many ordinary people face falling household income and rising costs of living, some multinational companies are avoiding billions of pounds of tax from a tax system that fails to make them pay their fair share. Local governments in developing countries and the UK alike would benefit from a fairer tax system, enabling them to provide quality public services.
The UK government must listen to the strength of public feeling and act to end the injustice of tax dodging by large multinational companies, in developing countries and the UK.” Councillor Watson advised that, should the motion receive the support of the Council, the feedback to the UK government would be undertaken by Towns Against Tax Dodging.
In moving that the minutes of the Cabinet meetings held on 25/9/14 and 30/10/15 be noted, Councillor Watson asked the City Council to note an administrative correction required to the minutes of 30/10/15 to include Catherine A Parkinson in the list of other attendees present at the meeting. He further commented on the Cabinet’s consideration of the Local Council Tax Support scheme at the meeting of 30/10/14, as referred to in paragraph 559 of the minutes submitted. He advised that the Scheme needed to be considered by full City Council and in order to provide further clarity to that effect, he asked the City Council to note that the Council Tax Support Scheme 2015/16 would be submitted to the next ordinary meeting on 29/1/15.
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented this report which summarised the financial position of the General Fund, Housing Revenue Account and Capital Investment Programme as at the end of September 2014 and provided a forecast outturn for 2014/15.
Councillor Watson introduced this report which outlined the Council’s performance for the period July – September 2014 and provide key highlights and key messages shown by the data. He commented specifically in relation to a number of statistics referred to within the report including details on an increase in Council Tax and Business Rates collection rates and visitor numbers to the Potteries Museum and Art Gallery.
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet member for Finance, Governance and Human Resources introduced this report and the Strategic Manager, Programmes and Transformation updated the Committee on the progress against savings, targets, performance and budgets across the Corporate Services Directorate for the period April 2014 to June 2014.
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet member for Finance, Governance and HR introduced the report.
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented this report which sought approval to correct an error in the wording of a previous report and decision taken by Cabinet (31/7/14 – Clause 525 refers) for .
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR explained that the purpose of this report was to recommend the (MTFS) to the City Council as part of the authorities Budgetary and Policy Framework.
In presenting the report Councillor Watson referred to a correction in respect of the Governance Arrangements Structure of the Renaissance Council Transformation Programme as referred to within the report.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR, Councillor Watson presented this report which outlined the options for the Authority’s Local Council Tax Support Scheme (LCTS) for 2015/16. The report also established the impact of the current scheme, assessed the need for consultation on any proposed amendments and highlighted amendments required to the Council’s Section 13A relief (Council Tax Hardship Relief) through the revision of the local Policy.
AARP Best Employers International Award Councillor Watson explained that Stoke-on-Trent City Council was the only UK recipient of the Best Employers International Award 2014, which was recognition of the authority’s commitment to supporting older people in the workplace through innovative human resource and workforce practices that benefited workers aged 50 and over. It was noted that the application submitted had made reference to the City Council’s commitment to making Stoke-on-Trent a great place to grow old, especially following its recognition as an Age Friendly City by the World Health Organisation, and also its membership of Workage , the 3 year EU-funded project involving Nottingham Trent University.
Garner moved, and Councillor Watson seconded, that the petitions be noted.
Councillor Watson moved the following motion, which incorporated a further proposal in addition to the recommendations as set out in the report submitted, to replace Cllr Crowe with Councillor Platt on the Human Resources Committee:- (i) “The City Council notes that Councillor Bridges is no longer a Member of the Labour Group and is referred to as a non-aligned Member in this report.
Having been seconded by Councillor Watson, the motion was put to the vote and it was:-
This report was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR, Councillor Watson, who outlined the purpose of the report, which was to recommend that PWC LLP be procured to help deliver the service transformation and resultant savings and efficiencies arising from outline business cases that they had developed on behalf of the City Council.
Cabinet Members Comments/Questions Councillor Watson referred to the work of the Night Time Economy Task and Finish Review Group, of which he had been a member and commented on the fact that this Policy would be a great tool to support the work and recommendations from that Group. The Cabinet Member concurred with these comments and indicated that this Policy would put the onus on the applicant to prove that there was a need for what they were proposing and that it could be used to vary the offer in the City Centre.
The Committee noted that Councillor Alan Dutton had replaced Councillor Alastair Watson as a Labour Group nomination on the Licensing and General Purposes Committee with effect from 8 July 2014.
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Hamer, it was:-
Councillor Watson the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and Human Resources presented the Quarterly Business Review Quarter 1 2014/15 which outlined the Council’s performance for the period April to June 2014.
Councillor Watson referred to the continued increase in demand for Council services and the fact that despite these additional pressures, the Council’s performance remained strong, a fact which was of credit to the Council’s staff and partners. Continuing, he also commented on the fact that, in many cases services were improving. He also outlined some of the challenges that faced the Council in the future.
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR presented the Financial Performance Report as at the end of June 2014 which summarised the position of the General Fund, Housing Revenue Account and Capital Investment Programme as at the end of June 2014 and provided a forecast outturn for 2014/15.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR, Councillor Watson, introduced this report which considered the write off of irrecoverable debts over £25,000 against the relevant bad debt provision and also gave details of the irrecoverable debt under £25,000 that had been written off under delegated authority.
Councillor Watson the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and HR outlined the purpose of this report which was to seek approval to utilise the Health Trust Europe (HTE) Management Consultancy Framework for further engagement of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC) LLP to help deliver savings and efficiencies from the business cases under development.
Councillor Watson continued by explaining that the Council’s staff were employed to run services but that there was also a need to re-design services in response to the Government’s budget cuts and that PWC had been engaged to assist with this process.
Councillor Watson, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Procurement and Commissioning presented this report which sought permission to tender and award a contract for 3 companies to undertake provision of debt recovery services for a period of 4 years from Enforcement Agents and Collection and Tracing Services for the collection of:
Cabinet Members Questions/Comments Councillor Watson expressed support for this item commenting on the fact that we needed more and better roads in the City.
Councillor Watson thanked the lead petitioners and moved that the petitions be noted.
and · write to all local MPs outlining the Council’s position.” Councillor Platt moved and Councillor Watson seconded, that a recorded vote be taken and this was supported by more than18 members present and voting at the meeting.
A motion moved by Councillor Abi Brown and seconded by Councillor Joy Garner, that Councillor Alastair Watson be appointed Chair of the Licensing and General Purposes Committee for the municipal year, was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Alastair Watson, seconded by Councillor Abi Brown, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Shotton, it was:-
A pologies were received from Councillor Randolph Conteh, Councillor Gwen Hassall and Councillor Alastair Watson.
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Brereton, it was:-
Councillor Watson welcomed the report and ... view the full minutes text for item 45.
In the absence of the Chair, Councillor Watson agreed to attend the Workshop if the Chair was unable to attend.
On the motion of Councillor Pender, seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
Councillor Watson questioned whether now the process has been simplified it is felt that more robust information is missing. Responding the Strategic Manager – Corporate Procurement felt that all the information was included and the system gave consistency.
Councillor Watson advised that his understanding was that Local Centres already provided this service. Responding the Assistant Director HR & Transformation advised that not all Local Centres have kiosk, some just have telephones where people can call the Council offices.
A motion moved by the Vice Chair, Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Wedgwood, “that the committee notes the information provided by Councillor Conteh on behalf of petitioners and recognises that this problem needed to be dealt with on a school by school basis”, was carried.
Garner, seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
Present - Councillor Martin Garner (Chair), Councillor Randolph Conteh, Councillor Gwen Hassall, and Councillor Alastair Watson (Reserve).
It was noted that the Reserve Member (Councillor Hassall) had taken the place of Councillor James on the Sub-Committee and Councillor Watson was in attendance as the new Reserve Member.
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor J. Garner, it was:-
Councillor Watson commented that it was more important to measure the time taken to answer a call than to record the number of abandoned calls and he stated his view that anything over two minutes would be an unacceptable amount of time to wait for a call to be answered.
Councillor Watson volunteered to be the committee’s representative on the Children and Young Peoples Strategic Partnership Board.
A Motion moved by Councillor Neil Day, seconded by Councillor Ann James that “Councillor Alastair Watson be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Children and Young People’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the Municipal Year” was carried.
On the motion of Councillor Reynolds, seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Rosenau, it was:-
On the motion of Councillor Dutton, seconded by Councillor Watson, it was:-
A Motion moved by Councillor Watson, seconded by Councillor Wanger “that Councillor Alison Wedgwood be appointed as Chair of the Business Services and Chief Executive’s Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the remainder of the Municipal Year” was carried.
Councillor Watson requested more information on the work surrounding telecoms. Responding, the IT Client Manager explained currently 2 networks are used within our existing buildings but work is underway within new buildings to use just one. Also, working closely with the property department, savings are being made on earlier disconnection when buildings close.
It was noted that Councillor Fry had been replaced as a member of the Committee by Councillor Watson.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Watson to the meeting.
Councillor Watson asked if there was an option for older children to help younger underperforming children and if so, ... view the full minutes text for item 25.
Councillor Watson asked if the increased number of referrals to the care service had resulted in an increase in the instances of increased stress levels amongst staff.
It was moved by Councillor Banks and seconded by Councillor Watson, that the report be noted.
The Sub Committee was requested to conduct a hearing into, and determine, a complaint that Councillor Alastair Watson had breached the Members’ Code of Conduct.
It was summarised that a complaint was received that Councillor Alastair Watson had failed to register his interests in accordance with the requirements of the Members’ Code of Conduct. The alleged breaches of the Code of Conduct were detailed as follows:
In accordance with the order of proceedings, the Sub Committee considered the report of the Deputy Monitoring Officer and heard a submission from Councillor Alastair Watson.
The Sub Committee examined the case and considered the submissions made and also considered verbal statements made by the Deputy Monitoring Officer and Councillor Watson.
Having considered the complaint and having made the findings that Councillor Alastair Watson was appointed to several outside bodies at a meeting of City Council on 7 July 2011, namely, Fostering Panel, PATROL (Parking and Traffic Regulations Outside London) Adjudication Joint Committee and Bus Lane Adjudication Service Joint Committee and was required to register his interests in these outside bodies within 28 days, i.e. by no later than 3 August 2011 and did not register his interests until 17 August 2011 i.e. fourteen days outside of the deadline, Councillor Alastair Watson was found to have breached Paragraph 13 of the Members’ Code of Conduct but not Paragraph 5 of the Code. Having then offered the parties the opportunity to address the Sub-Committee on the issue of sanction, the decision of the Sub-Committee was as follows:
Councillor Watson requested that training on petitions be included in the members’ training programme.
Councillor Wilcox moved and Councillor Watson seconded that the minutes of the City Renewal Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 19 March 2012 be noted.
Councillor Watson asked if the mixed use development proposed on the Lord Nelson site would draw trade from the City Centre The Strategic Manager for City Centre and Town Centre Regeneration explained that he did not believe that the facilities to be provided would draw trade from the City Centre but be an alternative, smaller scale canalside offer aimed at City Waterside residents.
Comments from Committee Members In response to a request for clarification of a ‘grey’ exclusion from the Chair and a question about the number of ‘grey’ exclusions from Councillor Watson , the Strategic Manager - School Support explained that this type of exclusion included instances when pupils are sent home from school for a few days and not given any school work to perform during their absence or when the school has suggested that parents move their child to another school. He stated that it was impossible to provide a definitive number of ‘grey’ exclusions from the city’s schools but reassured the committee that schools were reminded that this type of exclusion was illegal and that schools were challenged when making such exclusions and asked to rectify the situation, which they tended to do when challenged.
Councillor Watson expressed his support for the consolidation of City Council sites.
Comments from Committee Members Councillor Watson referred to ‘Recommendation Four’ and asked if the community and voluntary sector were included in the list of contacts and organisations which supported parents, carers and partner agencies and would be maintained by the Family Information Service.
Councillor Watson asked for the cost of the Reach pupil referral unit and why this work could not be carried out in school.
Councillor Dutton provided feedback on the Adoption Panel and Stoke Schools PFI Project Liaison Group and Councillor Watson provided feedback on the Fostering Panel.
Councillor Watson welcomed the report and the opportunity to undertake the visits. He asked if the visits were unannounced or prearranged.
· Councillor Watson requested further information on the tendering process including how scores were applied and how the tender was awarded.
· Councillor Watson queried if the process was costly.
· Councillor Watson felt that the Directorate should be commended for their work given the financial pressures that were being experienced.
Members received representations from Councillor Watson, Ward Member, and from [name removed], applicant, supporting the application.
Julie Brough , Democratic Services Officer reported on the membership changes to the Committee, namely that Councillor Aumir had replaced Councillor Watson, Councillor Crowe had replaced Councillor Dutton and Councillor Wedgwood had replaced Councillor Crowe.
Councillor Watson asked for clarification on the proposed level of support and for a comparison between the proposed reduction in the number of teachers of the deaf and the proposed reduction in other areas of teaching.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Watson attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Watson's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Watson was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 6 of 17 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Watson declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Mar 2020 | (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal, item 41 | Councillor Adams declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had received phone calls and a visit from residents but had advised them on the process only Councillor Ali declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Dodd declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as she had been contacted by residents asking her not to support the call-in Councillor Hussain declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he is a member of the Gillani Noor Masjid Mosque, Chaplin Road, Normacot Councillor Watson declared a Personal Interest in item 3 (Clause 42 refers) as he was a Cabinet Member in 2014 when this issue had previously been raised. |
Where Councillor Watson sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City Council | Committee Member | May 2011 | 21 | 17 Dec 2026 |
| Planning Committee - Development Management | Committee Member | May 2014 | 6 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Adult Social Care, Health Integration and Wellbeing Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 4 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | |
| Staffordshire & Stoke-on-Trent Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Children and Young People | Vice-Chair | May 2011 | 14 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Corporate Services | Cabinet Representative | May 2011 | 8 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Committee | Committee Member | May 2013 | 8 | |
| (archived) Overview and Scrutiny Committee - City Renewal | Committee Member | May 2011 | 6 | |
| Planning Committee - Policy Group | Committee Member | Jun 2014 | 2 | |
| Cabinet | Cabinet Member | Dec 2014 | 2 | |
| (archived) Human Resources Sub-Committee (Employment Appeals) | Committee Member | Sep 2013 | 1 | |
| (archived) Audit Committee | Cabinet Representative | Nov 2014 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.