Member Questions at Meetings
In debate an amendment was proposed by Councillor Hyman to amend the wording within the proposed constitutional changes by replacing references to “responding to the question” with “answering the question”.
Every time Waverley's minutes name Councillor Hyman, as the council published it.
In debate an amendment was proposed by Councillor Hyman to amend the wording within the proposed constitutional changes by replacing references to “responding to the question” with “answering the question”.
The Councillor Hyman argued that members of the public and councillors should receive direct answers to questions rather than responses that may not address the issues raised. It was suggested that such a change would promote transparency, accountability and clarity in council proceedings.
The Chair welcomed Cllr Jerry Hyman to the Committee.
For: Cllr David Beaman, Cllr Dave Busby, Cllr Janet Crowe, Cllr Jerome Davidson, Cllr Adam Duce, Cllr Alan Earwaker, Cllr Tony Fairclough, Cllr Paul Follows, Cllr Maxine Gale, Cllr George Hesse, Cllr Jerry Hyman, Cllr Victoria Kiehl, Cllr ... view the full minutes text for item CNL6/25
David Evans - Objector Sir Andrew Carter - Objector Anthony Frendo – Support Andrew Watson - Support Cllr Nigel Moreland – Tilford Parish Council Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Councillor Cllr David Munro – Ward Councillor Following the debate, the Committee voted in favour of the officers’ recommendation to grant permission 7 in favour, 2 against and no abstentions.
Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Councillor Following the debate, the Committee voted in favour of the officers’ recommendation to grant permission 8 in favour, 2 against and no abstentions.
Councillor Jerry Hyman addressed the Executive, stating ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 26/25
Councillor Jerry Hyman addressed the Executive; he believed that there was a serious issue with 100% of complaints being upheld. He noted that while Officers ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 32/25
Councillor Liz Townsend, Deputy Leader & Portfolio Holder for Planning & Regeneration and Economic Development, introduced the report which gave an update on the New Build Project Councillor Jerry Hyman addressed the Executive, he called the project an interesting story with increasing costs. He raised the question of if ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 36/25
Councillor Jerry Hyman had registered to speak at the Committee, he stated that while he supported the updating of the strategy he wanted to better understand the next steps in relation to ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 12/25
Councillor Hyman, had registered to speak in advance, he stated that there had been a lengthy debate at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in relation to this. He expressed ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 13/25
[name removed] – Objector Cllr Chris Jackman (on behalf of Cllr Catherine Powell) – Objector [name removed] – Supporter Cllr Tony Fairclough (statement read out by clerk) – Representative of Farnham Town Council Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Councillor Cllr George Hesse – Ward Councillor Following the debate Cllr Maxine Gale proposed to defer the item and was seconded by Cllr Andy Macleod. The Committee voted to defer the item, five in favour, four against and two abstentions.
Councillor Hyman was registered to speak on this item and explained that there were questions on the January CIL motion and also on the March Grounds Maintenance that had inconsistencies which were within the 2024/25 year and could become significant governance issues; he asked that those be flagged up so that they were resolved and would not become further risks.
· On page 61 of the documents which is an item that talks about the Local Plan at the first paragraph, Councillor Hyman stated that the statements in there were false and that the Council was in denial in respect of what the National Planning Policy Framework stated.
A further amendment was proposed by Councillor Hyman, seconded by Councillor Clark to include the following wording to recommendation two was as follows:
Cllr Jerry Hyman was invited to speak on this item and set out that he acknowledged that this item was due to be considered at Council later in the month and would spend ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 129/24
Councillor Hyman proposed an amendment, seconded by Councillor Barker-Lomax, as follows:
Note: Councillor Hyman arrived at the meeting at 19.11pm during consideration of this item.
Concern was reiterated by Cllr Hyman.
Ben Baille – In support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Borough Councillor Cllr Graham White – Ward Councillor Cllr David Beaman – Ward Councillor Following the debate, the Committee voted in favour of the officers’ recommendation to grant permission 11 in favour, none against and no abstentions.
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item and asked if the committee were aware of the legal constraints the planning system were required to adhere to with regards to habitats regulations and whether this was being taken into consideration in developing the Local Plan? Officers advised that specialist consultants had been appointed to advise on habitats regulations to ensure that the implications were taken into ... view the full minutes text for item 92.
Cllr Jerry Hyman – Borough Councillor Cllr George Hesse – Ward Councillor Following the debate, the Committee voted in favour of the officers’ recommendation to grant permission 12 in favour, none against and two abstentions.
However, it was to be noted that Councillor Jerry Hyman had requested to speak on various agenda items.
Mike Tooth – Objector Ben Baille – In support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Councillor Cllr David Beaman – Ward Councillor Cllr Graham White – Ward Councillor During the debate Councillor Carole Cockburn put forward a motion to defer the item for the developer to reconsider the design of the eastern boundary with regards to the orientation of the properties and the landscaping of the buffer on this boundary.
Councillor Hyman advised of some inconsistencies that he had observed in the rules, but was broadly supportive.
Councillor Hyman expressed his view that the duty of candour should have been included in the protocol.
In response to Councillor Hyman, the Mayor confirmed that the timing of the proposal was a consequence of the calling of the General Election, that [name removed] was not the Returning Officer for Guildford Borough Council; and that the maximum fee recoverable by the Acting Returning Officer for UK Parliamentary Elections was set out online.
I thank Cllr Hyman for his question.
As Cllr Hyman is aware, Although Waverley is, through the allocation of CIL funding, a supporter of the Farnham Infrastructure Programme and, as such a partner of the programme … … the ultimate authority and the ultimate responsibility for the Farnham Infrastructure Programme, and the resulting air quality, rests with Surrey Highways.
· Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Borough Councillor · Cllr Andy Macleod – Waverley Borough Councillor and Surrey County Councillor Following the debate the Committee voted on the motion and it was carried 12 votes in favour, no votes against and no abstention.
Councillor Hyman declared an interest in item 7 as a Waverley Borough Council tenant.
Councillor Hyman sought clarification of the status of the pay claim for staff. The Leader responded that the budget reflected the pay proposal that had been put to the unions, and the Council was awaiting a response.
Councillor Hyman advised Members that were using paper copies that the Standards and General Purposes Committee had added the words ‘ or conflict of interest’ to section 4 on Personal Responsibility.
That being noted, Councillor Hyman expressed his support for the proposal. There being no further debate, the Mayor called upon Members to vote and it was RESOLVED unanimously:
Councillor Hyman sought clarification of whether the wording of the recommendation should be revised as a consequence of Guildford Borough Council having resolved to approve the same matter the previous evening. The Monitoring Officer explained that as Members were cognisant that Guildford Borough Council had approved the matter, the recommendation before Members remained sound. There being no further speakers, the Mayor called upon Members to vote and it was RESOLVED unanimously that: 1.
Councillor Hyman noted the contextual information provided which showed that some Councils such as Sevenoaks had a much lower threshold whilst Norwich had a significantly higher threshold, it was unclear which direction would be most appropriate for Waverley. Furthermore, not all of the Surrey authorities had been included in the comparison, and it was unclear whether there was any correlation between financial soundness of an authority and its financial threshold for key decisions.
· Councillor Hyman acknowledged the concerns expressed by Councillor Goodridge but would support the recommendation as a necessity to discharge business.
43.7 Accepting that there were still alterations to be made, non-voting member Cllr Hyman noted that the Strategy does not align with the years of the new Local Plan, contended that Waverley may not be able to afford to widely engage in Passivhaus retrofitting and thus advise others, and queried the home build costs of the Property Development Strategies. He also raised what he felt were contradictions in the policies on congestion. The Executive Head of Regeneration and Planning Policy clarified that the Strategy’s 10-year time horizon was planned and that the document will be reviewed as appropriate.
44.3 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman reiterated the importance of consulting with residents and asked if a document could be made available that demonstrates the differences from the 2019 version. Officers stated that they would endeavour to provide this document, and that the Commonplace engagement platform will be employed to consult with residents, while the Executive are enthusiastic for consultation to take place with young people.
45.2 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman emphasised the importance of delivering protections to residents, while Cllr White questioned whether there are plans for Neighbourhood Plans’ number of allowed Strategic Site classifications to be reduced from the current 100. The Interim Planning Policy Manager noted that this was being considered due to the necessity of demonstrating 5-year housing land supply.
Cllr Hyman suggested that the Committee could consider renaming it the ‘Joint Senior Staffing Committee’. The Officers advising the Committee did not feel this would be a point of confusion and noted that any change would be subject to approval from the Guildford Borough Council’s Corporate Governance Committee and Full Council because it is a Joint Committee. The Executive Head of Legal and Democratic Services further advised that this Committee could make a recommendation to Full Council ‘subject to the approval of the Guildford Borough Council Full Council’, however it was advised that this mechanism should only be utilised for serious amendments that have been flagged up by the Committee.
Cllr Hyman had registered to make a statement on the agenda item and was allocated 4 minutes to speak.
Cllr Hyman raised questions about the length of time the threshold had remained unchanged as part 1.4 of the report states that it had been in place for ‘quite some time’. He questioned the relevance of ‘Funding received’ in part 1.4 of the report and questioned the justification for what he perceived as losing financial control of the Council during uncertain times and cited financial challenges faced by local councils.
In response to the comments made by Cllr Hyman, The Executive Head of Legal and Democratic Services clarified that the exact amount of time could not be determined due to lack of records however it is estimated to be approximately 10 - 12 years. It was clarified that the inclusion of ‘funding received’ was explained as part of benchmarking against other authorities. Further, the Executive Head of Legal and Democratic Services explained that the proposed change would not compromise financial control of the Council, rather enhance efficiency in decision making.
Cllr Hyman suggested that Members must be able to ensure the accuracy of legal advice or information being provided and argued that there are no ‘checks and balances’ in the Constitution by which the Monitoring Officer be held to account in the case of incorrect legal advice. He further raised a point about section 4.0, bullet points 1 & 2 of Appendix 1, and stated that this would not be appropriate if the Monitoring Officer is the subject of the investigation or has an interest. Finally, he sought clarification about the reference to ‘special persons’ in section 4.0 of Appendix 1.
Councillor Hyman spoke against the proposal as in his opinion insufficient information had been made available, including the reasoning for the salary uplift.
Councillor Hyman raised a point of order, specifying that Article 12 had not been complied with as there was insufficient information to make a decision including an absence of the proposed start date and whether [name removed] would receive an additional fee as Returning Officer. The Mayor, having sought the advice of the Monitoring Officer, ruled that the point of order was not valid, as no Council Procedure Rule or Law had been alleged to have been breached.
Councillor Merryweather responded, stating, "Councillor Goodridge was speaking about the outturn report at the end of the fiscal year rather than the point where it is at now." 63.8 Councillor Hyman commented that on page 23 of the report, it stated that the good performance had been down to robust management of staff costs.
Councillor Hyman asked if this would be continued because there appeared to be some suggestion that the council might be deviating from that policy in a big way. The Mayor invited the Leader to respond.
Councillor Hyman supported the use of The Hill over Folly Hill School during school terms, considering it a good option.
67.8 Councillor Hyman highlighted issues with limited parking when using only one polling station and potential problems during holidays.
68.6 Councillor Hyman agreed that there was a failure to evaluate the current value of land and surrounding buildings, emphasising the significant value involved, amounting to millions of pounds. He raised concerns about flooding in Springfield and stressed the importance of evaluating finances and consulting residents before proceeding.
Councillor Hyman referred to page 292, pointing out that no value was given for the properties as they are. He also mentioned the gross development value being based on open market valuations, suggesting the council should cover various aspects.
Councillor Hyman clarified that he was not going into that point, and he continued to highlight issues of winter flooding, indicating that the council would undergo public consultation.
71.3 Councillor Hyman requested the motion to be put up on the board. The Mayor clarified that the motion had not been agreed upon; the council had agreed to the amendment.
Councillor Hyman indicated a desire to speak on this. T he Mayor stated that Councillor was out of time.
Susan Sale stated that council procedure rule 11.8 had not been met as notification by Councillor Hyman had not been received until 1:24 pm.
30.5 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman registered to speak on this item. He asked if there would be electric car charging stations at Brightwells Yard, Farnham, and requested an update on the status of the planned foot and cycle bridge there.
Planning Development 30.10 Cllr Hyman noted that it would be useful for members to better understand the Planning Advisory Service (PAS) Development Management (DM) Challenge Toolkit. The Executive Head of Planning Development advised a recent workshop with the Planning Team had captured ... view the full minutes text for item 30.
51.8 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman queried a summary update on the progress of the implications of the collaboration agreement to Legal Services. The Joint Executive Head of Legal and Democratic Services noted that the lack of a formal decision from Council at this stage means that Legal Services cannot progress with a shared service, though limited preliminary sharing arrangements have begun.
51.9 Cllr Hyman asked when he may receive confirmation that the issue of habitat compliance will be included in the Local Plan and when Members will be briefed.
54.2 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman asked if it was necessary to enter exempt session, which no member of the Committee intimated they would like to do.
The Chair noted that any matters that concerned Cllr Hyman could be taken forward outside of this meeting.
54.3 Cllr Hyman and Cllr Atkins voiced concerns around asset valuation and fears this could have potential negative impacts. The Senior Accountant stated that they would work with Cllrs Hyman and Atkins on this and the Gross Domestic Value to clarify procedures.
55.3 Cllr Hyman expressed concern about agreeing a project in principle without assessment of mitigation to potential environmental harm from development. He reiterated that the authority must demonstrate how mitigation will be effective for development to be lawful.
56.3 Non-voting member Cllr Hyman raised concern that planning issues and constraints are duly followed, though was happy to support the recommendations if this is considered. The Housing Services Manager noted that planning permission had already been obtained, subject to meeting the planning conditions.
Cllr Hyman registered to speak;
Cllr Hyman proposed that Cllrs should be given transparency about which elements of the Constitution are being changed, given that the Constitution had recently been re-written the year before. He noted there was not a track changes version at that time and we need to learn lessons from this to highlight what has been changed and how the changes will achieve the Council’s Corporate Plan objectives. He suggested that the Councils should look at aligning with Surrey County Council and other neighbouring councils, and queried if there was any plans for unitary?
The Chair used his discretion to allow Cllr Follows, Leader of the Council, to make any comments on the issues raised by Cllr Hyman.
Cllr Hyman stated that he would like a Duty of Candour to be incorporated into the Memorandum of Understanding to ensure transparency between Councillors and Officers. He also asked clarity on the MoU referencing access to officers. While the DLUHC report stated that call free times have been implemented.
20.2 Cllr Hyman was registered to speak on this issue but withdrew.
Cllr Hyman registered to speak and was allocated 4 minutes to make his statements.
Cllr Hyman sought an update on the exploration of gas at Loxely Well and inquired about whether this information was still considered exempt. He also raised concerns regarding a legal challenge in relation to the Waverley Lane Quantum Fields development and requested information on the progress made.
It is noted that Cllr Hyman was accidentally excluded from the exempt portion of this meeting, as he was attending remotely by Microsoft Zoom.
- Cllr Hyman proposed that a vote should be taken before the exclusion of the press and public.
Councillor Hyman concurred and cautioned that the Council had to be mindful of the risk of increasing development costs overall and should where possible consult with local residents about developments in their area. 39.5 Councillor Spence expressed concern that the original contractor had gone into administration and sought assurance that the Council had mitigation in place, such as a surety bond, with the proposed contractor. At the invitation of the Mayor, Officers clarified that the previous contractor had gone into administration prior to a JCT Contract being in place. The resolution from the Executive on 1 August 2023 authorised a JCT Contract to be entered into with Feltham Construction Ltd.
36.4 Councillor Hyman was concerned that the financial challenges at Guildford Borough Council would absorb significantly more of the postholders’ time and that it was apparent that any saving made by joint arrangements would be absorbed by interim arrangements instead. Councillors Hyman and Reed stressed the financial risk that it was uncertain how long the interim arrangement was intended to last.
26.3 Cllr Hyman noted the long history to this project, and thanked the current and previous administration for their work in achieving this outcome.
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item and asked members to look at the planning performance relating to national indicators and how the improvement action plan was performing. Members were advised, as previously outlined, that this would be addressed at the next meeting with Claire Upton-Brown, Executive Head of Planning Development.
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak and advised he had concerns regarding the timescales for the comprehensive review. He advised the agreement at full council had been for a minimal review not a full one and it would be important to apply Waverley constraints first in order to ascertain how many houses could be justified. He suggested two working groups be established to look at the challenge toolkit and this review.
Lucy Jacob – in objection Jon Boyes – in support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Ward Councillor Following the debate, the Committee voted unanimously in favour of the officers’ recommendation to grant permission.
Cllr Hyman - stated disagreement with the proposals on the grounds that the proposed changes should go through the O&S Services Committee for further scrutiny.
16.8 Cllr Hyman noted that the agenda for the meeting of the Western Planning Committee on 14 June had been published the previous day, and questioned whether that would be valid, and whether the membership could be ... view the full minutes text for item CNL16/23
12.4 The Leader began by thanking Cllr Hyman for his advice prior to the meeting, that the revised proposals should be referred to the Standards & General Purposes Committee for consideration and recommendation to Full Council. He went on to outline the proposed changes:
12.7 Cllr Hyman asked that the reduction in ... view the full minutes text for item CNL12/23
Cllr Jerry Hyman had submitted the following question:
Cllr Anna James and Cllr Jerry Hyman also expressed reservations.
101.5 Cllr Hyman reminded Members that the Council had a statutory duty to prepare an AQAP and that must have specific measures to reduce exceedances. In his view the AQAP was a plan to have a plan in 6 months when the final plans emerging from the Farnham Infrastructure Plan had been agreed by Surrey County Council. Currently, there were no specific proposals and no specific funding identified for the Farnham Infrastructure Plan.
101.6 Cllr Hyman proposed an amendment to the recommendation to ensure that proposals from the Farnham Infrastructure Plan had to be approved by Waverley Borough Council so that the Council retained responsibility for the AQAP.
Cllr Hyman proposed amending the recommendation by adding the words:
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item and advised he felt this was a plan to have an action plan rather than a plan in itself as it had no measures in it. He also raised concern that Farnham had not had a proper plan for over 15 years as Surrey CC had failed to ever implement one. He disagreed with the sentence “ It will also be ensured that the Farnham AQMA will remain in place until the Farnham Infrastructure Programme is implemented” and felt it should be removed.
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item.
Cllr Hyman asked for an answer to the following question:
82.1 Cllr Hyman declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in Agenda Item 7 (HRA Business Plan – Revenue Budget and Capital Programme 2023/24) as a Waverley Tenant.
Cllr Hyman left the Council Chamber for the debate and vote on that item.
86.1 Cllr Jerry Hyman left the Council Chamber having previously declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in relation to this item.
Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke on this ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 86/22
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak and highlighted the responses from other Local Planning Authorities and the risk of Waverley being forced to take on some of their housing need allocation as has already happened with Woking. He also raised the need to ensure we comply with the habitats regulations.
Councillor Hyman recommended that the Resources Committee should also have access to the Executive Forward Plan.
Councillor Hyman queried the appropriation of garages from HRA to general fund.
76.4 Cllr Jerry Hyman referred to the agenda report and queried what would be the legal and contractual risks referred to in paragraph 10.2, in the event that the appointment was not confirmed by Council. The Leader advised that the councils would have to begin the recruitment process again, with consequential costs and risk.
Cllr Hyman raised a Point of Order, and asked the Mayor to clarify the arrangements under the Petition Scheme regarding the number of signatures a petition needed to be accepted by the Council, the Executive or the Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
62.6 At the request of Cllr Hyman, Cllr Cosser, and other Members, the Mayor adjourned the meeting at 7:16pm for five minutes to allow Members time to read the amendment. The meeting resumed at 7.20pm.
66.2 Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke to point out that changes to the Scheme of Delegation were in effect changes to the Constitution and should be approved by Council.
Cllr Hyman also noted his concern that the revised Constitution agreed by Council in October 2022 had changed the way in which the Minutes of the Executive and other Committees were presented to Council, and suggested that Members might want to revisit this.
Cllr Hyman abstained from the vote and asked for this to be recorded in the minutes.
70.3 Cllr Hyman spoke and highlighted the potential reputational damage to Waverley, as the local electoral administration authority, for any chaos developing at polling stations, and also the personal risk to elections staff working on polling stations. He was totally supportive of the motion.
The Mayor invited Cllr Hyman, who had registered to speak, to make his statement.
71.2 In respect of EXE46/22, Cllr Hyman commented on the Portfolio Holder’s response to the from a member of the public.
In respect of EXE50/22, Cllr Hyman noted there were some typographical errors in the policy document, and also that it should have been submitted to Full Council for approval so that all Members were aware of it. At the invitation of the Mayor, the Leader responded that the Policy had been scrutinised by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, so there had been transparency and opportunity for Members to input to the Policy.
Councillor Hyman spoke on this item, expressing concern over the short notice given for the taking of the urgent decision and the online reviews for the proposed contractor. He also sought clarification that the procurement process had been compliant with relevant legislation.
He had asked that, in addition to the noting report that was required to go to the Council meeting, a similar report come to the next meeting of the Executive and encouraged Councillor Hyman to take part in that meeting.
Councillor Hyman spoke on this ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 59/22
Councillor Hyman welcomed the solution proposal although expressed concern over the cost and ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 61/22
· Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item and raised the issue of legal compliance and duty of candour in relation to appropriate assessments and mitigation. He reminded the Committee that in November 2021 the previous Head of Planning had agreed to get the current bird numbers from Natural England and provide information on the Farnham Park SANG strategy and it’s effectiveness. He asked if this information had been forthcoming and was advised it had not.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as substitute for the late Cllr Roger Blishen.
An alternative recommendation to refuse permission was proposed by Cllr Stephen Mulliner and seconded by Cllr Jerry Hyman.
43.4 Councillor Hyman requested that his vote against the recommendation be recorded.
44.1 The Mayor invited Councillor Hyman, who had registered to speak on Part II matters, to make his statement:
44.2 In respect of EXE 25/22 (Urgent Item – Loxley Well), Councillor Hyman made a statement on the costs of pursuing legal action.
44.4 The Mayor invited Councillor Hyman, who had registered to speak on Part II matters, to make his statement.
44.5 In respect of EXE 43/22 (Fairground Development Project Progress Update Report), Councillor Hyman made a statement on the use of public money for legal advice in respect of environmental law and asked a question in respect of appropriate assessments.
44.6 The Mayor cautioned Councillor Hyman on his use of language when making statements and invited the Leader to respond. The Leader referred to previous Counsel advice and numerous statements made at previous meetings on this subject.
44.7 Councillor Hyman made a point of personal explanation and reiterated his question. The Mayor advised that the Leader had already responded.
Councillor Hyman expressed some concern over the deadline for questions proposed.
48.7 Councillor Hyman spoke on the substantive recommendations, as amended. He expressed some concern over the proposal to delegate minor changes to the Monitoring Officer; and the lack of a tracked changed version to consider.
49.2 Councillor Hyman spoke on the report, raising some concern over the versions of the document and the format of some of the numbering. In response, the Leader advised that the Monitoring Officer had delegated authority to make any updates relating to legislation and encouraged councillors to engage with Democratic Services on any corrections required.
An alternative recommendation to refuse permission was proposed by Cllr Jerry Hyman and seconded by Cllr Carol Cockburn.
Cllr Hyman was in remote attendance, having registered to speak in accordance with Procedure Rule 23. He noted that the document contained a ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 41/22
Cllr Hyman was in remote attendance, having registered to speak in accordance with Procedure Rule 23.
Cllr Hyman outlined his objection ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 43/22
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this item:
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this item in accordance with Procedure Rule 23.1. In relation to the delegated authority reference O.1 to the Joint Executive Head of Planning Development, he queried who determined that the SPA reasons referred to had been resolved, and referred to his concerns regarding the council’s approach to the Habitats Regulations.
However, Councillor Jerry Hyman attended the meeting to ask questions relating to item 6 Corporate Performance, item 9 Business Transformation and item 14 Property Investment Advisory Board update.
Councillor Hyman queried the savings to date, highlighting staff travel saving and queried if there were other elements that should be included. The Chair felt that these were questions to be answered by David Allum at the next meeting.
Councillor Hyman raised a query regarding commercial activity and change in the council policy. The Chair confirmed that there was a change in policy, imposed by the regulators, he went on to confirm that if the council did invest in commercial activity, it would lose access to the Public Works Loan Board for three years.
· Cllr Hyman, who had registered to speak on this item, advised he was still not convinced that a correct response had been received and that he was attending a meeting this Wednesday with Head of Planning and Portfolio for Planning to discuss Habitats regulations and appropriate assessments. He also advised we had still not received the updated bird numbers from Natural England.
Cllr Hyman, who had registered to speak on this item, asked how we could be confident that the law and legislation was being followed? He felt that the principles set out in the document was not of use as:
Cllr Hyman, who had registered to speak on this item raised a number of items he felt the Committee should address around:
Councillor Hyman spoke on the report seeking clarification on the recommendations, some of which ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 32/22
Councillor Hyman ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 34/22
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as substitute.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as a substitute.
Cllr Jerry Hyman advised that he wished to raise a point of order in relation to Item 8.1. He raised concern that the appropriate assessment had not been put on the portal until the afternoon of the meeting.
Cllr Hyman was present as a substitute for Cllr Martin.
Cllr Hyman declared a non-registrable interest as he had met the owner of the application site in the past.
Catherine Powell, Surrey CC – Object Douglas Bond, Woolf Bond – Support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Farnham Town Councillor Cllr Andy Macleod – Ward Councillor The Committee considered the application.
At the invitation of the Chairman, Councillor Hyman spoke on the report and expressed concern that it was proposed to spend money before an assessment of the viability had been carried out and the appropriate assessments should be carried out before being considered by the Executive and Council.
Cllr Jerome Davidson proposed adding a discretionary booking fee element of up to £1 (representing an increase to the current booking fee in place within Waverley which amounts to 60 pence) and this was seconded by Cllr Jerry Hyman.
117.1 The Mayor invited Councillor Hyman, who had registered to speak on Part II matters, to make his statement:
117.2 In respect of EXE115/21 (Climate Change and Sustainability SPD), Councillor Hyman made a statement expressing concern over whether an appropriate assessment had been carried out.
117.3 The Mayor responded to Councillor Hyman, reminding him of the independent legal advice provided on this issue previously.
Councillor Hyman spoke on the amendment.
A question was submitted by Cllr Jerry Hyman and a response was supplied by the Chairman. The question and answer are attached to the minutes for information.
Councillor Hyman ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 109/21
Councillor Jerry Hyman seconded the proposal.
Cllr Mulliner proposed to refuse the permission on grounds of the harm to the AONB and this was seconded by Cllr Jerry Hyman.
· Cllr Hyman suggested that under Section 2- D Accountability that Councillors and Residents should be able to drill down and asked for a duty of candour. It was felt this was covered by Councillors being able to raise under ‘emerging governance’ on the Audit Committees Agenda each meeting.
Cllr Jerry Hyman raised the issue of the Legal Departments reliance on applicants and appellants evidence when dealing with appeals and judicial reviews. He felt this meant we were not putting across our strongest case in these matters. Officers advised that in our submissions to court we are using a very experience senior barrister and were confident of his advice.
Peter Banks – Object David Murray-Cox – Support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Ward Councillor The Committee considered the application.
82.1 Councillor Hyman declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in item 9.2 as a Waverley Tenant.
Councillor Hyman had been granted a dispensation by the Monitoring Officer under s33 of the Localism Act 2011 to participate in and vote on this item.
82.6 In response to a question from Councillor Hyman, following advice from officers the Mayor advised that it was not necessary to declare an interest in respect of Members’ Allowances as there was not a decision to be made on Members’ Allowances on the agenda.
90.4 On a point of order, Councillor Hyman sought clarification on the figures quoted in the report.
Councillor Hyman asked that his vote against the recommendations be recorded.
Councillor Hyman asked that his vote against the recommendation be recorded.
94.2 The Mayor opened up the debate, and the following Members spoke: Councillor Hyman.
94.3 The Leader responded to the point raised by Councillor Hyman.
97.8 In respect of EXE 76/21 (Capital Projects), Councillor Hyman welcomed the proposals for the Bourne Pavilion, however sought clarification on how the projects were decided.
97.10 In respect of EXE 91/21 (Service Plans), Councillor Hyman expressed concern that the service plans did not reflect the statutory duty to have an Air Quality Action Plan and that it appeared that the Council had delegated its responsibility to Surrey County Council through the Farnham Board. 97.11 Councillor Williams advised that consultants had been appointed to draft a new Air Quality Action Plan.
Councillor Hyman spoke on the report and asked why there was no reference in the statement to those working from home following the pandemic and whether the ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 88/21
Councillor Hyman spoke on the report and sought clarification on the statutory requirement for the Council to have an air quality action plan and that this could not be delegated to the Farnham ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 91/21
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak and raised concern regarding the lack of a legal appropriate assessment and the update from Natural England on current bird numbers which had still to be submitted. He felt we could not submit without this appropriate assessment. Zac Ellwood, Head of Planning and Economic Development assured members that an adequate appropriate assessment had been carried out.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as substitute.
Cllr Jerry Hyman proposed an alternative recommendation to refuse and was seconded by Cllr Carole Cockburn.
Cllr Jerry Hyman advised that now we were working in partnership with Guildford Borough Council we needed to ensure we were being compliant with the Habitat Regulations.
Cllr Hyman spoke on this item and challenged the conclusion of the HRA screening report which in his opinion was incorrect.
Following concerns raised by Cllr Hyman regarding the accuracy of aspects of the report, the Committee RESOLVED to recommend that the report receive an additional proofread and be checked for factual and legal accuracy.
Cllr Hyman agreed to forward details of his concerns by email.
He wished [name removed] well in the event that the Council approved the recommendation, however would not be voting for the appointment on the basis of his concerns over the collaboration. 58.4 Councillor Hyman sought clarification on the wording of the recommendation regarding finalising of the negotiations, and whether it was possible for the Council to agree to the appointment if the terms and conditions had not yet been agreed.
48.3 Councillor Hyman asked that it be clarified that the recommendations were from an Independent Panel; and that there was no reference to those Members who receive more than one special responsibility allowance as there was concern that some Members were taking on too much responsibility and receiving allowances, while their colleagues were taking on extra work.
Councillor Hyman sought clarification on the process for taking and scrutinising any delegated decision.
An alternative recommendation to refuse was proposed by Cllr Stephen Mulliner and seconded by Cllr Jerry Hyman. The Committee voted 11 in favour, 0 against and 3 abstentions Decision That planning permission be REFUSED on the following grounds:
Cllr Jerry Hyman advised that he was generally supportive of the proposal to introduce some flexibility around the requirement for councillors to stand when speaking at meetings of Council, but was concerned about how a councillor would make a Point or Order or Point of Personal Explanation and ensure that they were heard by the Mayor.
With regard to the overview and scrutiny committees, Cllr Hyman noted that the review of the Corporate Performance Report by each committee took a great deal of time and suggested that this report could be dealt with in a different way to make better use of committee time.
Cllr Hyman emphasised the role of scrutiny to ask questions and contribute to making improvements in council services, but this relied upon being given full and honest answers to questions.
The Red Court site would have been more appropriate for inclusion and it would protect the green belt and Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. 1.4 Councillor Hyman spoke on the item, seeking clarification whether the appropriate assessments had been carried out in respect of protected habitats and expressed concern that the approach was unlawful and one he did not feel able to support. 1.5 In response, the Leader advised that the Council’s Planning and Legal officers had confirmed that if a proposed plan was considered likely to have a significant effect on a protected habitats site then an appropriate assessment of the implications for the site, in view of the site’s conservation objectives, must be undertaken. An appropriate assessment of the draft LPP2 hadbeen carried out. This should be read in conjunction with the appropriate assessment of LPP1, which was found sound by the Planning inspector.
Councillor Jerry Hyman attended as a substitute.
34.3 Councillor Hyman spoke on the amendment. The Mayor called for a vote on the amendment which was agreed by assent.
Councillor Hyman sought clarification on the apportionment of the costs and savings and felt that the IAA should be made available before making a decision and given appropriate scrutiny.
Officers advised the Committee that 4 late representations had been received from the Haslemere South Residents Association, a neighbour, comments on Biodiversity and Cllr Jerry Hyman reference the lack of a Habitat assessment. These had all been circulated to members for information.
Against: Cllrs David Beaman, John Robini, Jerome Davidson, George Hesse, Jerry Hyman, Daniel Hunt and Roger Blishen Abstain: Cllr Kika Mirylees and Michaela Martin An alternative recommendation to refuse was proposed by Cllr David Beaman and seconded by Cllr Jerry Hyman. The Committee voted 7 in favour, 5 against and 2 abstentions.
27.4 In respect of EXE 9/21 (Mental Health report from Community O&S Committee), Councillor Hyman reiterated the comments he made at the Executive meeting on 22 June 2021 and asked that percentages of staff to be trained and costs should be brought back to a future meeting of the Executive.
27.6 In respect of EXE 11/21 (Take the Jump), Councillor Hyman felt that the recommendations in the report were virtue signalling and that the Council should not be taking part in the initiative.
27.8 In respect of EXE 12/21 (Capital Projects), Councillor Hyman felt that the recommendations should be put before the Overview and Scrutiny Committees for consideration before spending money on feasibility studies.
Councillor Hyman spoke on this item, asking that money not be spent on unnecessary feasibility studies and projects without justification and that residents be involved.
Ian Jacob – Object J Boyes – Support Cllr Scotty Fraser – Farnham Town Council Cllr Jerry Hyman – Ward Councillor The Committee were not happy that many of the previous reasons for refusal had been met and therefore voted unanimously against permission for this application.
An alternative recommendation to refuse the item was proposed by Cllr Jerry Hyman, seconded by Cllr Carole Cockburn was carried unanimously.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as a substitute.
If it is decided that the Plan needs to be updated then current policy in the NPPF states that strategic policies should look ahead over a minimum 15 year period from adoption.” 107.2 In accordance with Procedure Rule 10.9, Cllr Hyman proposed that the question be referred to the Executive, and this was duly seconded by Cllr Mary Foryszewski.
Cllr Hyman expressed serious concerns about the proposal which he felt was undemocratic, and unnecessary; he could not support the proposal, and suggested that the number required for a quorum should be reduced, if that was the potential barrier to making a democratic decision.
110.4 Cllr Hyman remained concerned about the proposal, even with the amendment, which he did not feel addressed his fundamental points: that any decision taken under such a delegation would be undemocratic, and the delegation was not necessary. Cllrs Cosser , Adams, Wilson, Dickson, Gale and Blishen all spoke in support of the amended proposal.
112.2 In response to comments from Cllr Hyman, Cllr Palmer confirmed that any outstanding planning applications required before the car park opened would be submitted by Crest Nicholson at the appropriate time.
Cllr Hyman, on EXE 87/20, and EXE 91/20 Cllr Cockburn, on EXE 93/20
99.2 Cllr Hyman spoke in support of the proposal to continue the current arrangements for the planning committees, but was concerned at the lack of detail in the proposals for the ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 99/20
The minutes of the Licensing C Sub Committee held on 8 th February 2021 were agreed subject to some grammatical changes pointed out by Cllr Jerry Hyman.
Cllr Hyman had a number of queries:
Cllr D’Arcy proposed and Cllr Ruth Reed Seconded and this was AGREED by a majority with Cllr Hyman abstaining.
Cllr Hyman advised he had identified a number of spelling and grammatical errors in the policy and would speak to officer’s offline to rectify.
RESOLVED that Waverley Borough Council expresses its support for the Climate and Ecological Emergency Bill and empowers the Leader of the council to write to local MPs and other stakeholders highlighting this council’s support For: 29 Cllrs Christine Baker, David Beaman, Roger Blishen, Peter Clark, Richard Cole, Martin D’Arcy, Jerome Davidson, Sally Dickson, Paul Follows, Maxine Gale, Joan Heagin, George Hesse, Daniel Hunt, Andy MacLeod, Penny Marriott, Michaela Martin, Mark Merryweather, Peter Nicholson, Nick Palmer, Ruth Reed, Paul Rivers, Penny Rivers, John Robini, Anne-Marie Rosoman, Liz Townsend, John Ward, Michaela Wicks, Steve Williams, George Wilson Against: 23 Cllr Brian Adams, Carole Cockburn, Steve Cosser, Kevin Deanus, Brian Edmonds, Patricia Ellis, David Else, Jenny Else, Jan Floyd-Douglass, Mary Foryszewski, Michael Goodridge, John Gray, Val Henry, Peter Isherwood, Anna James, Robert Knowles, Peter Marriott, Peter Martin, Stephen Mulliner, John Neale, Julia Potts, Trevor Sadler, Richard Seaborne Abstentions: 1 Cllr Jerry Hyman 87.2 The following motion was moved by Cllr George Wilson, and seconded by Cllr Paul Follows:
Cllr Hyman expressed his support for the strategy, but stressed the need to deliver against it.
76.2 With regard to EXE53/20, Property Acquisition, Cllr Hyman asked if the price paid for the property could be made public.
78.3 Cllr Jerry Hyman had submitted the following question in relation to the minutes of the Audit Committee meeting held on 14 September 2020:
78.4 The Mayor thanked Cllr Hyman for his comments and question, and advised him that the minutes of committee meetings are approved at subsequent meetings of that committee. During that item of a committee’s agenda, there is the opportunity to query, expand upon or debate the minutes. The purpose of this item at the Full Council meeting was for the Council to receive the minutes, rather than get into a further debate on the published record of a particular committee’s meeting.
79.2 Council RESOLVED to agree the proportional allocation to seats on the Principal Committees and SCC Local Committee in accordance with the political proportionality of the Council, with all in favour except Cllr Hyman who abstained.
Martin Birt (Agent) – In support Cllr Jerry Hyman – Waverley Councillor who had registered to speak on this item.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as a substitute.
Cllr Hyman acknowledge that he had received 2 old reports relating to Brightwells and Memorial Hall and until he had had time to read the content he would not make any comments and he would then decide what he would do.
53.1 From Cllr Jerry Hyman :
Only Cllr Hyman spoke against the LPP2, on the basis that in his view it was not compliant with Regulation 9 of the Habitats Regulations.
61.2 Cllr David Beaman made a statement in his capacity as Chairman of the Western Planning Committee, to correct what he felt were inaccurate and misleading statements made by Cllr Hyman as a member of the Standards Committee at the meeting on 5 October.
During this debate Cllr Jerry Hyman made statements which I consider to be both inaccurate and misleading.
When debating a protocol for the use of break out rooms Cllr Hyman requested that any protocol needed to be brought back to The Standards Committee for agreement stating “I don’t think that the Chairmen will particularly care if it is lawful or proper what is done there going by what they have done so far”.
When Cllr John Robini as Chair of The Standards Committee (and also Vice Chair of the Western Area Planning Committee) responded that he had faith in the two Planning Committee Chairmen (myself and Cllr Richard Cole) Cllr Hyman stated “ History proves otherwise, History proves otherwise We represent the residents”. (Minutes 63 to 65 of the webcast).
Not being a member of The Standards Committee I was unable to correct this misrepresentation at the time but as Chair of the Western Area Planning Committee I am very concerned that Cllr Hyman knowingly made statements that totally misrepresent my views and opinions on the use of break out rooms.
Cllr Hyman was present at this meeting as an observer and did personally intervene (even though being only an observer he had no right to do so).
I believe that Cllr Hyman, who ... view the full minutes text for item CNL61/20
Cllr Jerry Hyman advised he was a member of ‘Friends of Farnham Park’ but this was a non-pecuniary interest.
23.5 Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this matter and asked the auditors the extent to which they independently assessed matters in relation to laws and regulations including following up on recent judgements.
25.5 Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on the AGS. He stated that he would not be happy with the AGS being signed off with the current wording in relation to Air Quality and the Habitats Regulations, which in his opinion did not address outstanding historical and continuing legal omissions and oversights with regard to process in granting planning permission to Crest Nicholson, and in complying with EU and UK legal judgements.
40.4 Cllr Hyman also stated his support for the recommendations, but noted that many businesses in a similar situation were cutting costs to the bare minimum and he was concerned that residents might perceive the council’s approach as putting off difficult decisions.
41.2 Cllr Jerry Hyman also spoke in relation to the same matter, and asked for clarification that the comment at EXE18.7/20 reflected fairly the Leader’s comments regarding the consultation by Cllr Oliver. The Leader confirmed that whilst he understood there were some officer contacts and discussions about the possibility of some sort of unitary bid from Surrey, none of the eleven Borough and District Leaders were informed or consulted before the letter went to the Minister.
43.4 Cllr Hyman thanked Officers for making the typographical corrections to the Policy that he had highlighted at great length during the Licensing Committee. He was fully supportive of the Policy and the recommendations before Council.
44.2 Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke in relation to the Internal Audit Plan, and his request to see a copy of the report relating to lessons learned from the Brightwells and Memorial Hall projects. He had been sent a report but not the one requested, so he had still not been able to carry out scrutiny of these projects and find out about the lessons learned and what investigations were being carried out in respect of the matters that were still outstanding with Brightwells.
Cllr Davidson suggested that Cllr Hyman take this matter up with the Strategic Director.
Councillor Hyman also asked for confirmation that the issues raised by him around the Sweetman / Crondall case in UK law was being complied with. The planning lawyer assured the committee that all relevant legislation was applied.
The Chairman welcomed Cllr Jerry Hyman to the Committee in his place.
Cllr Hyman provided detailed comments on editing and content of the report and policy and asked for clarification within the policy on a number of matters including time periods for determining applications, use of barriers, and distancing. Committee members also noted that there were some inconsistencies in the conditions in relation to use of outdoor heaters, for example. [name removed] thanked Members for their detailed comments The Committee endorsed the principle of the policy and the need to help businesses recover from the lockdown, and RESOLVED to recommend that Council:
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item and advised that he had asked the same question regarding the Review on the Management of Major Projects relating to the lessons learned from Brightwells and Memorial Hall projects and would like to see a copy of this report. He also felt these should also go to scrutiny and be publically available even if areas have to be redacted for the areas stated above.
Councillor Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this item. He noted that ‘the review relating to Ethics and Culture has been deferred to 2020-21 as the Governance review being completed by Members has not been finalised and it was deemed more effective to await the outcomes before any value can be obtained from an Internal Audit review of the governance arrangements around ethics.’ He therefore asked when the Governance review would be completed.
Cllr Hyman had also asked w hat systems and processes existed to enable residents, Members and the independent internal audit function to hold the Council Leadership, Monitoring and Legal functions to account in respect of legal compliance and fraud prevention, without having to resort to High Court action.
In response, [name removed] directed Cllr Hyman to the corporate complaints process, or the option of contacting the Monitoring Officer, Standards Committee or External Auditors directly with evidence to support any allegations being made. Internal Audit would raise any concerns relating to the legal compliance and fraud prevention through the Council’s Management Board, and with the External Audit function if this was necessary.
Melanie Hill - Objector Debra Lee – on behalf of Tilford Parish Council Mike Conoley – Supporter (Agent) Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke in accordance with the Council’s Procedure Rules.
David Wylde - Objector (representing the Farnham Society) Scotty Fraser – on behalf of Farnham Town Council David Gilchrist – Supporter (for the Applicant) Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke in accordance with the Council’s Procedure Rules.
13.3 Cllr Jerry Hyman asked for an update on the work to develop the Climate Emergency Strategy and Action Plan (EXE 71/19), and whether it would be delayed as a result of the Covid-19 emergency.
13.5 Cllr Hyman then referred to the proposals for Leisure Centre improvements (EXE 72/19) and asked whether his suggestions about improvements to the skate park were being progressed, and also if the planned improvements were going to be delayed.
15.5 Cllr Jerry Hyman asked for clarification on what Council was being asked to approve as he was confused by the detail of the report, which appeared to have been overtaken by events.
The concerns raised by Cllr Jenny Else and Cllr Hyman at the Executive meeting on 12 May had been resolved off-line.
18.2 Cllr Jerry Hyman spoke in support of the revisions and in particular the definition of Honesty , which was now a simple requirement that holders of public office should be truthful. The Standards Committee was now looking forward to reviewing the new Model Code of Conduct being prepared by the Local Government Association.
19.4 Cllr Jerry Hyman noted that VMPR1 had now been overtaken by this meeting, and so was no longer needed. He was also concerned about the wording of VMPR 8 with regard to excluding press and public from a meeting, to avoid disclosure of exempt information, and how this could be assured.
Cllr Hyman was unhappy with recommendation (iv) on the change to the Scheme of Delegation, which he felt removed an important part of the check and balances, but other councillors felt that this was a reasonable measure to help manage work loads, provided there was committee oversight of decisions made.
(Cllr Jerry Hyman asked that his vote against this recommendation be recorded.)
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on Part II matters:
21.4 Cllr Hyman encouraged Members to read the report on the Air Quality Investigation (AUD 48/19), and expressed his view that there were significant implications for the planning permissions for the East Street development.
Cllr Hyman also referred to the External Audit Plan 2019/20 (AUD 49/19) and reiterated the comments he made at the Audit Committee regarding the Sweetman ruling.
Cllr Hyman was pleased to see the revisions being brought forward, but noted that the Standards Committee was still waiting for a report on proposals to address the best practice guidance set out in the CSPL’s review of standards arrangements. He also asked what arrangements were in place to ensure that Members followed the Nolan Principles.
Cllr Jerry Hyman attended as a substitute.
Cllr Jerry Hyman had registered to speak on this matter. He advised that he had been part of a group, along with the gentleman who had made the Freedom of Information request.
Cllr Hyman asked what action has been taken to avoid this ever happening again; why the names of the officers interviewed had been redacted when it was all in the public domain; and, why the report did not contain information that Councillors were interviewed also.
Cllr Hyman went on to raise concern that a legal notice had been submitted by Waverley Borough Council to Crest Nicholson on 29/12/2010 by the Air Quality Officer at the time (not the one referred to in the report), advising they could not approve the Brightwells planning application due to an incomplete EIA. However this had not been considered when the application was approved. He felt this was a matter of governance and did not feel it was suitable for this administration to say the issue was closed when it clearly was not.
Cllr Hyman thanked officers for a very open report and acknowledged that the redactions were mainly concerning employment issues.
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this item. He asked why the falsification of figures risk had not been included within the significant risks. He commented that the falsification of the transport assessment for the Brightwells scheme in Farnham which the Air Quality Officer had identified in 2010 had not been considered and, in his view, this posed an enormous risk to Farnham and to Waverley’s reputation.
Cllr Hyman expressed his view that there was an assumption that an assessment for mitigation was in LPP1 but it is not.
Cllr Hyman asked that the committee take this forward as he felt we were selling mitigation to developers.
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this item. He highlighted that section 5.2 Statutory Challenges outlined the two High Court Judgements but had not mentioned the issues around the impact of not implementing the European Court of Justices ruling 2018 ( Sweetman ruling).
Cllr Hyman also raised that at the end of section 10 of the report it stated ’ …no matters of significance have been omitted from this statement.’ Yet there was no mention of the Sweetman judgement and the falsified transport assessment of 2010.
Tom Horwood reminded the committee that this was a draft statement and officers would take on board the comments made by Cllr Hyman and the committee and consider items that needed including. The Air Quality issue had been covered in previous year’s statements and would be added in again reflecting the guidance given.
Cllr Hyman had registered to speak on this item. He thanked Gail for highlighting the review of the Air Quality audit.
Cllr Hyman gave apologies and left the meeting at 9.20pm, during the consideration of the Capital Strategy.
Cllr Jerry Hyman left the meeting before the start of consideration of this item.
Councillor Jerry Hyman questioned the latter and felt that if they had said they would not raise council tax, why were they doing it now. The proposed increase was not a huge percentage but 1.3% was the rate of inflation, of which, this was above. He also questioned where the Council was with the staff pay negotiations and the real costs of appeals and judicial reviews.
Councillor Jerry Hyman raised concerns around balancing the budget and aligning with the corporate strategy. Concerns were also raised by the Committee regarding the Policy and Governance outcome of “ Committee papers are provided and read electronically, ensuring better data protection, lower costs and lower carbon footprint”. It was felt that for larger agendas/documents, using an ipad was difficult and made it less accessible.
Cllr J Hyman attended as a substitute.
It was noted that Councillor Jerry Hyman was one of the Members referred to in the Monitoring Officer’s Report. The details of the Standards hearing were already in the public domain.
50.2 Cllr Hyman referred to the public question ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 50/19
54.2 In response to comments from Cllr Hyman, Cllr Merryweather explained that the ... view the full minutes text for item EXE 54/19
43.1 Cllr Jerry Hyman proposed the following motion, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 12:
43.2 The Mayor invited Cllr Hyman to explain the purpose of his Motion.
Cllr Hyman explained that the purpose was a simple, process matter that would show how the council’s responsibilities to endangered species could be met. It followed on from his questions to the Executive and Council in October, and the Climate Emergency motion passed by the Council in September. The Officer report on the Climate Emergency had referred to the Intergovernmental Science – Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services report highlighting nature’s dangerous decline and unprecedented rates of species extinction.
- Cllr Hyman and Cllr Gray also expressed support.
Cllr Hyman asked that performance be evaluated against the Strategy via Overview and Scrutiny and the Executive.
Simon Paterson – Objector Jesse Chapman – Supporter Councillor Jerry Hyman as Ward Councillor]
Councillor Jerry Hyman also spoke on the application.
Cllr Hyman noted that a new Communications and Engagement was due to be approved in Q3 and asked if the previous version could be circulated to help Members to identify the changes. Robin agreed to circulate this after the meeting.
29.1 The following question was received from Cllr Jerry Hyman in accordance with Procedure Rule 11:
CNL 31.2/19 Statement of Community Involvement (EXE 23/19) 31.2.1 Cllr Hyman opened the discussion by reminding Members that the Statement of Community Involvement (SCI) had been brought back to Council for Members to ensure that is was lawful, and to consider whether the public should be consulted on the changes to the SCI.
The key issue was whether the SCI was lawful, and he referred Members to paragraph 2.18 of the Officer’s report which stated “ The Council does not have a specific policy as such to deal with neighbourhood planning. ” Cllr Hyman then referred to S18 (2B) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004, which he maintained the Council was not complying with in the published SCI.
31.2.2 Cllr Hyman asked for a response to three questions: that the Constitution did require Members to act within the law? That the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004, Section 18 (2B) required that the council have an SCI which sets out the policies for giving advice or assistance on modification of Neighbourhood Plans? And, that the council did not have that policy?
Cllr Hyman concluded that he could not support the recommendation as proposed.
31.2.3 Cllr MacLeod advised Members that officers had spent a lot of time considering the amendments Cllr Hyman had proposed in July, and he and officers had met with Cllr Hyman to explain the approach now recommended. Officers’ advice was that the approach was lawful, and he was content with this.
31.2.5 Cllr Hyman made a point of personal explanation, to confirm that he had attended the meeting with officers, and he had been disappointed that officers had refused to put up on a screen the law and show how the SCI was lawful. He asked again for his questions (in 31.2.2) to be answered.
Cllr Hyman raised a point of order to ask the Mayor if he was going to receive a response to his questions.
The Mayor advised that she was content with the advice given, and if Cllr Hyman still had ... view the full minutes text for item CNL31.
32.3 Cllr Hyman fully supported the reinstatement of informal questions, and asked that these be included in the webcast of the meetings.
33.3 Cllr Hyman argued that the increase came at a time of budget constraints for the Council and recommended that there should be a complete review of Member allowances to ensure value for money for time spent on council work.
21.1 The following question had been received from Cllr Jerry Hyman:
23.1 Cllr Andy MacLeod introduced the report that reviewed the amendments to the Statement of Community Involvement (SCI) that had been proposed by Cllr Hyman at the Full Council meeting on 16 July 2019.
Cllr Jerry Hyman and [name removed] (Tenants’ Panel attended as substitutes.
Cllr Hyman questioned the anticipated total cost for the Ockford Ridge development as the net gain overall was only 38 extra homes. Andrew Smith suggested this was an unfair assumption as the existing properties were no longer fit for purpose and therefore the redevelopment of the entire site was necessary to provide acceptable homes.
Similarly, Cllr Hyman felt that important decisions shouldn’t be taken using data from only one month, as areas such as grass cutting, which was a very popular topic in the summer, had not made the list at all.
Showing the latest 300 of 381.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Hyman attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jul 2026 | Council | Member Questions at Meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Amended Redundancy Policy - Pension Strain Costs | Carried | 38 for, 2 against, 2 abstained | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Councillor Connor Relleen - Approval of Reason for Non-attendance at meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Waverley Householder CIL - Lack of Progress | Carried | 22 for, 20 against | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Waverley Householder CIL - Lack of Progress | Carried | 22 for, 20 against | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Cranleigh Leisure Centre - Lack of Progress | Lost | 18 for, 22 against | |
| 30 Jun 2026 | Council | Cranleigh Leisure Centre - Lack of Progress | Lost | 18 for, 22 against, 2 abstained | |
| 19 May 2026 | Council | Appointment of Committees and Other Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Apr 2026 | Council | Regulatory Services Animal Welfare Charter | Carried | 31 for, 2 against, 6 abstained | |
| 21 Apr 2026 | Council | Leader of the Opposition | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Apr 2026 | Council | Section 151 Officer Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Apr 2026 | Council | Statutory Officer Disciplinary Joint Appeals Panel - Terms of Reference | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Apr 2026 | Council | Constitutional Updates | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Mar 2026 | Council | Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) Exceptional Circumstances Relief | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Mar 2026 | Council | Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL): Issue of the Neighbourhood CIL Cap | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Mar 2026 | Council | Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL): Issue of the Neighbourhood CIL Cap | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Mar 2026 | Council | Cranleigh Leisure Centre | Carried | 33 for, 6 against | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Capital Strategy 2026/27 | Carried | 26 for, 1 against, 15 abstained | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Council Tax Setting 2026-27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Feb 2026 | Council | Proposed Changes to Public Speaking Procedure Rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Feb 2026 | Council | Statutory Officer Disciplinary Policy & Procedure | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2026 | Council | New Affordable Housing Delivery, Chiddingfold – Supplementary Budget Allocation | Carried | 37 for, 4 against | |
| 27 Jan 2026 | Council | Duration of Meeting | Carried | 35 for, 6 against | |
| 10 Dec 2025 | Council | Local Government Reorganisation: The Establishment of a West Surrey Joint Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 10 Dec 2025 | Council | Shared Financial Services between Guilford and Waverley | Carried | 28 for, 2 against, 5 abstained | |
| 2 Dec 2025 | Council | Affordable Housing Strategy | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2025 | Council | Revisions to the Inter Authority Agreement | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 2 Dec 2025 | Council | Appointment of Joint Strategic Director of Finance & Resources (S151 Officer) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Proposed joint Executive Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Proposed Revised Overview & Scrutiny Committee Arrangements | Lost | 18 for, 19 against, 1 abstained | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Proposed joint Standards Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Executive Working Groups Protocol | Carried | 34 for, 1 against, 1 abstained | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Executive Working Groups Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Code of Practice on Good Governance for Statutory officers | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Social media Policy for Councillors | Carried | 27 for, 1 against, 9 abstained | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | S151 Officer review of Members’ Allowances Scheme 2025/26 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | 69 High Street - Business Case update and decision to progress | Carried | 31 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | 69 High Street - Business Case update and decision to progress | Carried | 10 for, 25 against, 2 abstained | |
| 22 Oct 2025 | Council | Willmer House: Timber Structure Repair and Replacement at Façade | Carried | 27 for, 2 against, 5 abstained | |
| 9 Sep 2025 | Council | Shared Regulatory Services | Carried | 32 for, 6 against, 2 abstained | |
| 15 Jul 2025 | Council | Shared People & Organisational Development Service | Carried | 24 for, 9 against, 5 abstained | |
| 15 Jul 2025 | Council | Access to Information Procedure Rules | Carried | 34 for, 1 against, 2 abstained | |
| 15 Jul 2025 | Council | Part 2 - Articles of the Constitution | Carried | 35 for, 0 against, 1 abstained | |
| 6 May 2025 | Council | Local Government Reorganisation in Surrey | Carried | 29 for, 6 against | |
| 6 May 2025 | Council | Local Government Reorganisation in Surrey | Carried | 29 for, 6 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Mar 2025 | Council | Grounds Maintenance | Lost | 15 for, 17 against | |
| 25 Mar 2025 | Council | Grounds Maintenance | Lost | 15 for, 17 against, 6 abstained | |
| 4 Mar 2025 | Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel on Members Allowances | Lost | 14 for, 25 against, 3 abstained | |
| 4 Mar 2025 | Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel on Members Allowances | Lost | 14 for, 22 against, 6 abstained | |
| 4 Mar 2025 | Council | Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel on Members Allowances | Carried | 26 for, 10 against, 6 abstained | |
| 28 Jan 2025 | Council | Motions | Carried | 37 for, 0 against, 6 abstained | |
| 16 Sep 2024 | Council | Museum of Farnham MEND Project: Budget Approval | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Charter Against Modern Slavery | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Officer Scheme of Delegation and Proper Officer Scheme | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Revised Financial Procedure Rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Revised Contract Procedure Rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Revised Joint Councillor / Officer Relationship Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Proposed Changes to the Inter Authority Agreement | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Revised Statement of Community Involvement | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2024 | Council | Exempt - HRA Property Disposal | Carried | 34 for, 1 against, 3 abstained | |
| 21 May 2024 | Council | Establishment of Committees 2024/25 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 May 2024 | Council | Appointments to Committees 2024/25 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Feb 2024 | Council | Motion - Opposition to the expansion of Farnborough Airport | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Revised Terms of Reference for the Joint Governance Committee | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Pre-Election Publicity & Decision Making Policy | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Proposed Monitoring Officer Protocol | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Officer Employment Procedure Rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Review of the Waverley Borough Council Key Decision Financial Threshold | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Council | Revised Council Procedure Rule - Extraordinary Meetings of the Council (Rule 3.2) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 3 Oct 2023 | Executive | Solar PV for Leisure Centres | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Aug 2023 | Council | Appointment of S151 Officer | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jul 2023 | Council | Public Space Protection Orders No 1. and No. 2 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Jul 2023 | Council | Approval of funding to meet the budgetary requirement for the Museum of Farnham MEND Project, which enables building fabric repairs and conservation work to Grade 1 lsited Wilmer House | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Jun 2023 | Council | Proposed changes to the Size, Composition and Terms of Reference of Waverley Borough Council's Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Mar 2023 | Council | Ockford Ridge Refurbishment Phase 4 - Deep Retrofit including Green Technology Pilot | Carried | 35 for, 4 against, 1 abstained | |
| 14 Dec 2022 | Western Planning Committee | WA/2022/00383 - Land at Borrow House Farm, Jumps Road, Churt, Farnham, GU10 2LB | Carried | 8 for, 3 against | |
| 9 Nov 2022 | Western Planning Committee | WA/2022/01752 - Land at Chapman House, Meadway, Haslemere, GU27 1NN | Lost | 5 for, 8 against | |
| 9 Nov 2022 | Western Planning Committee | WA/2022/01752 - Land at Chapman House, Meadway, Haslemere, GU27 1NN | Lost | 7 for, 2 against, 4 abstained | |
| 18 Oct 2022 | Council | STD 05/22 Review of the Waverley Constitution | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Oct 2022 | Council | STD 05/22 Review of the Waverley Constitution | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Oct 2022 | Council | STD 05/22 Review of the Waverley Constitution | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Sep 2022 | Council | APPOINTMENT OF JOINT s151 OFFICER | Carried | 24 for, 4 against | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Western Planning Committee | Wa/2022/00955 - land centred coordinates 482046 143525 fullers road rowledge farnham gu10 4df | Lost | 2 for, 12 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Western Planning Committee | Wa/2022/00955 - land centred coordinates 482046 143525 fullers road rowledge farnham gu10 4df | Carried | 13 for, 2 against | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Western Planning Committee | Wa/2022/00906 - land at springfield 30 frensham vale lower bourne farnham gu10 3ht | Carried | 9 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Western Planning Committee | WA/2022/00131 - Land at 22 POTTERY LANE WRECCLESHAM FARNHAM GU10 4QJ | Carried | 13 for, 1 against, 1 abstained | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Western Planning Committee | WA/2022/00699 - Land at 12 WINGS ROAD, FARNHAM GU9 0HW | Carried | 12 for, 0 against, 3 abstained | |
| 20 Jul 2022 | Western Planning Committee | Confirmation of Tree Preservation Order (No 2/22) - Land to the rear of 12 Hillgarth, Beacon Hill, Hindhead, Surrey GU26 6PP | Carried | 11 for, 0 against, 0 abstained | |
| 20 Jul 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2022/00386 - Land at 12 Upper Hale Road, Farnham, GU9 0NJ | Carried | 8 for, 3 against | |
| 20 Jul 2022 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2022/00293 - land east of bridleway 186 centred coordinates 486985 147072 crooksbury road farnham | Lost | 4 for, 6 against | |
| 20 Jul 2022 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2022/00293 - land east of bridleway 186 centred coordinates 486985 147072 crooksbury road farnham | Lost | 6 for, 0 against | |
| 19 Jul 2022 | Council | EXE 17/22 Godalming Regeneration Project | Carried | 28 for, 10 against | |
| 28 Jun 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2021/02891 - Land at 80 - 84 EAST STREET FARNHAM GU9 7TP | Carried | 6 for, 4 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2021/01663 - land at 2 the reeds | Lost | 0 for, 9 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2021/01663 - land at 2 the reeds | Carried | 10 for, 0 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2020/2062 - land at edgecombe, 10 hill road, haslemere | Lost | 3 for, 4 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2020/2062 - land at edgecombe, 10 hill road, haslemere | Carried | 5 for, 0 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A3 - wa/2022/00419 - land at santis, 42 courts mount road, haslemere | Carried | 10 for, 1 against | |
| 25 May 2022 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2022/00251 - land at orchard view, 4 sturt road, haslemere, gu27 3sb | Carried | 10 for, 1 against | |
| 23 May 2022 | Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Hackney Carriage Fares | Carried | 5 for, 1 against | |
| 26 Apr 2022 | Council | EXE 110/21 Housing Asset Management Strategy | Carried | 25 for, 6 against | |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2022/00307 - Land at Imbhams Farm HOLDFAST LANE HASLEMERE GU27 2EX | Carried | 8 for, 2 against | |
| 20 Apr 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - WA/2022/00019 - Land at 11 Ferns Mead, Farnham | Carried | 6 for, 1 against | |
| 30 Mar 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2021/03034 - Land Coords 486634 143311 The Reeds, Tilford, Farnham | Lost | 2 for, 10 against | |
| 30 Mar 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2021/03034 - Land Coords 486634 143311 The Reeds, Tilford, Farnham | Lost | 4 for, 6 against | |
| 30 Mar 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2021/03034 - Land Coords 486634 143311 The Reeds, Tilford, Farnham | Lost | 7 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Mar 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - WA/2022/00498 - Land at Andrews of Hindhead Ltd, Andrews, Portsmouth Road, Hindhead | Carried | 10 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Mar 2022 | Western Planning Committee | A3 - WA/2021/01238 - Land at Deerwood, Woolmer Hill Road, Haslemere | Carried | 11 for, 1 against | |
| 22 Feb 2022 | Council | Exe 93/21 property matters - property acquisition | Carried | 28 for, 1 against | |
| 22 Feb 2022 | Council | Exe 93/21 property matters - property acquisition | Carried | 28 for, 1 against, 6 abstained | |
| 16 Nov 2021 | Western Planning Committee | Confirmation of tree preservation order (no 08/21) - group of scots pine trees at 75 shortheath road, farnham, gu9 8sf | Carried | 9 for, 1 against | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2020/0804 - land at kilnside farm, moor park lane, farnham, gu10 1ns | Carried | 10 for, 2 against, 1 abstained | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2021/01365 - andrews of hindhead, portsmouth road | Lost | 4 for, 10 against | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2021/01365 - andrews of hindhead, portsmouth road | Lost | 10 for, 2 against, 1 abstained | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A3 - wa/2021/01456 - land at 3 forestdale, gu26 6ta | Lost | 3 for, 11 against, 0 abstained | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A3 - wa/2021/01456 - land at 3 forestdale, gu26 6ta | Lost | 11 for, 0 against, 3 abstained | |
| 12 Oct 2021 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2021/01188 - land at 8 abbots ride, farnham | Lost | 0 for, 11 against, 3 abstained | |
| 20 Jul 2021 | Western Planning Committee | Wa/2020/0558 - agreement of the reasons for refusal at the old mission hall, hookstile lane, farnham gu9 8lg | Carried | 13 for, 0 against | |
| 20 Jul 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2020/1213 - land at red court, scotland lane, haslemere | Lost | 5 for, 7 against, 2 abstained | |
| 20 Jul 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2020/1213 - land at red court, scotland lane, haslemere | Lost | 7 for, 5 against, 2 abstained | |
| 6 Jul 2021 | Council | EXE 8/21 - Property matter | Carried | 24 for, 14 against | |
| 6 Jul 2021 | Council | EXE 8/21 - Property matter | Carried | 24 for, 14 against, 1 abstained | |
| 15 Jun 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2020/0558 - Land at The Old Mission Hall, Hookstile Lane, Farnham GU9 8LG | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Apr 2021 | Council | Review of political proportionality of the Council and appointment of committee memberships | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Apr 2021 | Western Planning Committee | B2 - wa/2020/0345 - land at bourne woods | Carried | 11 for, 3 against, 1 abstained | |
| 23 Mar 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2020/0558 - land at the old mission hall, hookstile lane, farnham gu9 8lg | Carried | 9 for, 3 against | |
| 23 Mar 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2021/0133 - land at garages 1 to 5, turners mead, , chiddingfold | Carried | 9 for, 3 against | |
| 23 Mar 2021 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2019/1850 - land at chasemoor, portsmouth road, hindhead | Carried | 5 for, 5 against, 3 abstained | |
| 23 Feb 2021 | Council | EXE 71/20 Annual Pay Policy Statement 2021/22 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Feb 2021 | Council | EXE 75/20 ICT Strategy 2021-2024 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Feb 2021 | Council | Std 41/20 amendments to the virtual meeting procedure rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jan 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2020/1356 - Land at 1&2 Old Dairy Cottages, Hillside Farm, Churt | Carried | 2 for, 10 against | |
| 19 Jan 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - WA/2020/0772 - Land Rear of 9 Upper South View, Farnham, GU9 7JW | Carried | 2 for, 12 against | |
| 19 Jan 2021 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - WA/2020/0772 - Land Rear of 9 Upper South View, Farnham, GU9 7JW | Carried | 12 for, 2 against | |
| 22 Dec 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2020/0772 - Land at Rear Of 9 Upper South View, Farnham GU9 7JW | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Dec 2020 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - WA/2019/1922 - Land at 19-22 Queens Mead, Chiddingfold, GU8 4UQ | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 Dec 2020 | Council | Exclusion of press and public | Carried | 34 for, 19 against | |
| 24 Nov 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A4 - WA/2020/1307 - Land at 19 The Fairfield, Farnham GU9 8AJ | Carried | 1 for, 13 against | |
| 24 Nov 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A4 - WA/2020/1307 - Land at 19 The Fairfield, Farnham GU9 8AJ | Lost | 13 for, 1 against, 1 abstained | |
| 24 Nov 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A4 - WA/2020/1307 - Land at 19 The Fairfield, Farnham GU9 8AJ | Lost | 12 for, 1 against, 1 abstained | |
| 29 Sep 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A1. WA/2020/1095 - Dackelwood, Old Frensham Road, Lower Bourne GU10 3PU | Carried | 4 for, 11 against | |
| 29 Sep 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A1. WA/2020/1095 - Dackelwood, Old Frensham Road, Lower Bourne GU10 3PU | Lost | 11 for, 1 against, 3 abstained | |
| 29 Sep 2020 | Western Planning Committee | B1. WA/2019/1915 - Land at 9 Wellington Lane, Farnham GU9 9BA | Carried | 8 for, 5 against, 2 abstained | |
| 4 Aug 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - wa/2020/0029 - land at the heights, 5 hill road, haslemere | Lost | 1 for, 12 against | |
| 4 Aug 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2020/0259 - land coordinates 492599 134278 track known as muddy lane, prestwick lane, grayswood | Carried | 3 for, 11 against | |
| 4 Aug 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A3 - wa/2019/1215 - land at 8 kiln lane, lower bourne | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Aug 2020 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - wa/2020/0767 - land at 2 ridgeway cottages, runwick lane | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Aug 2020 | Western Planning Committee | B2 - wa/2020/0242 - 135 kings road, haslemere | Carried | 2 for, 9 against, 1 abstained | |
| 30 Jul 2020 | Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Election of Vice-Chairman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A1 - WA/2020/0056 - Land at Four Seasons, Uplands Road, Farnham GU9 8BP | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jul 2020 | Western Planning Committee | B1 - WA/2019/2097 - Land at Riverside 3 car park. | Carried | 12 for, 2 against | |
| 23 Jun 2020 | Western Planning Committee | A2 - wa/2020/0105 - land at woolmead, farnham | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Sep 2019 | Standards Committee | Council Procedure Rules | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Feb 2019 | Council | Medium Term Financial Plan 2019/20 - 2021/22 and General Fund Budget 2019/20 | Carried | 39 for, 0 against | |
| 12 Feb 2019 | Council | Housing Revenue Account Business Plan, Revenue Budget and Capital Programme 2019/20 | Carried | 42 for, 0 against | |
| 30 Oct 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | Item A1, WA/2018/0275 - Land at Sturt Farm, Sturt Road, Haslemere GU27 3SE | Carried | 15 for, 1 against, 2 abstained | |
| 13 Aug 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | Item A1, WA/2017/0920 - 5 - 21 Wey Hill, Haslemere | Carried | 14 for, 5 against, 1 abstained | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2018/0329 - Little Acres Nursery, St Georges Road Badshot Lea GU9 9NT | Carried | 14 for, 2 against | |
| 25 Jul 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2018/0329 - Little Acres Nursery, St Georges Road Badshot Lea GU9 9NT | Carried | 13 for, 2 against | |
| 13 Jun 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2018/0308 - Land At East Street, Farnham | Carried | 13 for, 4 against | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | MOTIONS | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 15 May 2018 | Council | Brightwells Regeneration: temporary facilitation measures | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Feb 2018 | Council | Minutes of the special executive - 20 february 2018 - local plan | Carried | 41 for, 1 against | |
| 20 Feb 2018 | Council | Financial strategy 2018/2019 - 2020/2021 | Carried | 44 for, 0 against | |
| 8 Jan 2018 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2017/1636 - Land At Backward Point, Cranleigh Road, Ewhurst, GU6 7RJ | Carried | 18 for, 1 against, 2 abstained | |
| 27 Nov 2017 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2017/1396 - Land Between Downs Link And Rear Of 120 To 132 Horsham Road, Cranleigh | Carried | 12 for, 6 against, 2 abstained | |
| 21 Feb 2017 | Council | Budget 2017/2018 | Carried | 40 for, 5 against | |
| 15 Feb 2017 | Joint Planning Committee | APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION - WA/2016/1625 - Land South of High Street between Alfold Road and Knowle Lane, Cranleigh | Carried | 14 for, 7 against | |
| 29 Nov 2016 | Council | Minutes of the executive - local plan item only | Carried | 41 for, 1 against |
Meetings Councillor Hyman was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 14 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Hyman declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Feb 2024 | Council, item CNL93/23 | Councillor Hyman declared an interest in item 7 as a Waverley Borough Council tenant. | |
| 21 Feb 2023 | Council, item CNL82/22 | 82.1 Cllr Hyman declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in Agenda Item 7 (HRA Business Plan – Revenue Budget and Capital Programme 2023/24) as a Waverley Tenant. | |
| 28 Jun 2022 | Western Planning Committee, item 16 | Cllr Hyman declared a non-registrable interest as he had met the owner of the application site in the past. | |
| 22 Feb 2022 | Council, item CNL82/21 | 82.1 Councillor Hyman declared a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in item 9.2 as a Waverley Tenant. |
Where Councillor Hyman sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2016 | 98 | |
| Audit & Risk Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2016 | 17 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Joint Planning Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2016 | 47 | |
| Executive | Observer | Sep 2016 | 35 | |
| Western Planning Committee | Substitute | Jun 2020 | 25 | |
| Area Planning Committee (Western) | Committee Member | Oct 2016 | 23 | |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Value for Money & Customer Service | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 22 | |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Environment | Substitute | May 2017 | 21 | |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Housing | Substitute | Jul 2017 | 16 | |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Community Wellbeing | Substitute | Jun 2017 | 13 | |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2020 | 10 | |
| Standards Committee | Observer | Oct 2016 | 9 | |
| Community Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Sep 2016 | 4 | |
| Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2016 | 4 | |
| Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Housing Maintenance Contracts Procurement Review Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2016 | 4 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Services | Observer | Nov 2021 | 4 | |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Resources | Observer | Sep 2022 | 4 | |
| Community Overview and Scrutiny Leisure Centre Management Contract Review Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2017 | 3 | |
| Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Joint Meetings | Vice Chair | Nov 2016 | 2 | |
| Executive Co-Portfolio Holder for Housing Decisions | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 1 | |
| Landlord Services Advisory Board (Executive Working Group) | Committee Member | Jul 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.