Asked3 Mar 2025Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Integrated Settlement
Councillor Cathy Bayton asked if the Strategy met the needs identified in the State of the Region report. The Head of Policy and Integration responded that while the strategy covered some areas, it required an integrated regional response and collaboration with local authorities, and the private sector.
Asked3 Mar 2025Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Devolved Buildings Retrofit Pilot
Councillor Cathy Bayton asked about lessons learned from previous pilots, and the SMART Hub Lead provided details, and emphasised the importance of engaging with community organisations. With regards to the concerns raised in relation to best practice, the SMART Hub Lead confirmed that best practice examples and lessons learned would be shared with both local authorities and community organisations.
Named3 Mar 2025Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Q3 Performance monitoring against the Annual Business Plan
Councillor Cathy Bayton and Councillor Ellen Fenton raised concerns with regards to the Thrive to work programme and requested that this be added to the work programme for 2025/26. The Performance Manager also confirmed that there are no known triggers for a project review but encouraged the committee to request specific projects to be brought to scrutiny based on the information within the report.
Named20 Jan 2025Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Chair's Remarks
The Chair expressed appreciation for her contributions and noted the challenges Councillor Cathy Bayton faced in balancing her new responsibilities with her current commitments.
Named2 Sep 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
WMCA Brownfield Land Remediation - Final Report of the Task & Finish Group
Councillor Cathy Bayton commended the committee members and officers for their work on the report and thanked them for the inclusion of a biodiversity recommendation and the chair noted the importance of keeping biodiversity as close to the sites as possible.
Asked2 Sep 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
One Public Estate (OPE) Programme: Progress Update
Councillor Cathy Bayton questioned the process and why the projects were not representative of the entire region. The Head of Property and Strategic Assets clarified that all local authority partners were contacted for expressions of interest, and it is a bidding process with robust criteria. However, he confirmed that not all local authorities submitted bids for the pilot and the Senior Implementation Manager for One Public Estates confirmed that the pilot project and funding were not spread across the region.
Asked2 Sep 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
WMCA Place Pilots Programme Update
Councillor Cathy Bayton queried the NHS Integrated Care Boards project pilot, and it was explained that the ICBs come together to develop an infrastructure strategy and collaborate on assets to deliver this strategy. He confirmed that the WMCA acted as a facilitator, aiding in the speed of delivery, and ensuring rollout across other areas of the ICB and the entire region.
Asked2 Sep 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
West Midlands Regional Energy Strategy Refresh
Councillor Cathy Bayton queried retrofitting homes and asked if there were any plans to roll out retrofitting in the region. In response, it was confirmed that work was being conducted with delivery partners to strategically roll out retrofitting as part of the devolution deal.
Said2 Sep 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
West Midlands Regional Energy Strategy Refresh
Councillor Cathy Bayton requested that lessons learned from the Dudley Net Zero Neighbourhood pilot be shared with councillors and in response, the Energy Research Analyst and Partnership Co-Ordinator invited all Councillor to such an event that would be occurring in the near future.
Said1 Jul 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Skills Scrutiny Review: Progress Report on the implementation of the recommendations arising from the review
Councillor Cathy Bayton praised the Job Rotation pilot in Coventry, which supports staff upskilling and the Director for Employment Skills, Health, and Communities stressed the importance of local employer engagement for the success of such programs. It was agreed that an update would be available by March 2025, with a preliminary report on the pilot including the participating employment sectors would be presented to the committee in November 2024.
Asked1 Jul 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Performance monitoring against the Annual Business Plan
Councillor Cathy Bayton asked whether any KPIs need to change in light of the new mayoral manifesto. The Performance Manager explained that the KPIs were identified by Executive Directors and were reviewed continuously, with potential changes occurring if business needs changed.
Said1 Jul 2024Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Performance monitoring against the Annual Business Plan
Councillor Cathy Bayton emphasised the need for tangible KPIs for housing and requested feedback on whether these could be more measurable. The Performance Manager assured members that while the current KPIs were being reviewed, he would feedback members comments with regard to housing for consideration.
Named10 Jul 2023Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Chair
The committee noted that at the WMCA Board meeting held on 9 June 2023, Councillor Cathy Bayton had been appointed as the Chair of this committee for 2023/24.
Said8 Mar 2021Overview & Scrutiny Committee
'Economic Needs of the Black Country' Scrutiny Review - Summary of Findings
Councillor Cathy Bayton also highlighted that the review identified the role of the Association of Black Country Authorities as being unclear, and she supported an overarching strategy to closely align the work of the Black Country authorities, whilst still allowing for local solutions to local problems.
Said8 Mar 2021Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Effectiveness of Transport Delivery Committee in Overseeing the Delivery of WMCA Transport Policies - Update on Recommendations
It was noted that a review of Mayoral and members’ allowances was still outstanding, and Councillor Cathy Bayton stressed the importance of progressing this as a matter of priority. Recommended:
Named23 Nov 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Call In Procedure
(b) Call In - Affordable Housing Collaborative Delivery Vehicle: Progress Update The Chair provided an overview of the stated reason for the call-in, which was initiated by Councillor Naeem Akhtar, Councillor Cathy Bayton, Councillor Ahmed Bostan, Councillor Stephen Simkins and Councillor Lisa Trickett, namely:
Said23 Nov 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Affordable Housing Collaborative Delivery Vehicle: Progress Update
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted the lack of governance oversight evidenced within the report for this vehicle and requested reassurance on how this was going to be taken forward, given that the proposals would result in public money supporting a private asset. She also requested a clear understanding on the plan for delivery, referencing how social housing was being addressed within local development plans, which would help enable the demand seen in the region for social housing to be better targeted. She also felt that local authorities had ... view the full minutes text for item 88.
Said2 Nov 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Transport Scrutiny Sub-Committee Minutes
Councillor Cathy Bayton confirmed this had been the case. It was also noted that a ‘deep dive’ look at the concessionary fares schemes would be undertaken.
Said13 Jul 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Covid-19 Regional Recovery
Councillor Cathy Bayton raised concerned that the schemes being progressed did not adequately address the retail and hospitality industry and questioned as to why to the WMCA was seeking funding for a project such as the Creating Grand Central Diagnostics Hub at Birmingham New Street station that they had no responsibility over.
Said13 Jul 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Covid-19 Regional Recovery
Councillor Cathy Bayton noted that a number of projects within the asks of Government, including the Dudley Interchange and Very Light Rail schemes, were essential projects to support local economic recovery and redevelopment and had previously been supported by the WMCA. The implications of these schemes now losing out on funding to other schemes would be significant.
Named13 Jul 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Transport Scrutiny Sub-Committee Governance Arrangements
(2) Councillor Cathy Bayton be appointed as Chair of the Transport Scrutiny Sub-Committee.
Said6 Jul 2020Housing & Land Delivery Board
Housing and Land: Update on Economic Recovery Strategy
Councillor Cathy Bayton raised the issue of the possible conversion of redundant office buildings to residential accommodation under Permitted Development rights, without the benefit of planning permission or any requirement of developers to make appropriate contributions towards the provision of essential infrastructure such as roads or health facilities. She asked that the WMCA make it clear that this permitted development was not its preferred option to address the current housing shortage in the region. The Chair advised that whilst it was not his preferred option, he understood that this change had now become put forward as part of amendments to planning legislation.
Said15 Jun 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Recovery Planning: Current Position, Approach and Portfolio Updates
Councillor Cathy Bayton stressed the importance of having a clear understanding of the different sectoral challenges, particularly as furlough arrangements ended and the economic impact on individuals became more apparent. She also stressed the importance of understanding differential sub-regional impacts, rather than imposing one-size-fits-all solutions.
Named9 Mar 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Matters Arising
Scrutiny Review into the Effectiveness of Transport Delivery Committee in Overseeing the Delivery of WMCA Transport Policies Further to the request of Councillor Cathy Bayton, the Monitoring Officer advised the committee that the Portfolio Lead for Transport was currently considering a response to the recommendations contained within the scrutiny review, and he understood that a response would be provided before the WMCA Board next meet on 20 March 2020.
Said9 Mar 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Single Assurance Framework Project
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted the need to ensure that appropriate, suitable and transparent approval processes were in place for Investment Programme approvals. The Director of Finance indicated that currently there was a cap on the Investment Programme and discussions were being held with local authority leaders on the future prioritisation of the Investment Programme through the development of a new criteria.
Said9 Mar 2020Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Adult Education Budget - Update on Recommendations
Councillor Cathy Bayton suggested that further work needed to be undertaken on the ‘learning for learning’s sake’ agenda which data showed could help slow the onset of dementia. She also highlighted concerns with the lack of monitoring for those being home schooled.
Named18 Dec 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Review into the Effectiveness of Transport Delivery Committee in Overseeing the Delivery of WMCA Transport Policies
The committee considered a report from Councillor Cathy Bayton on the findings of the recent scrutiny review undertaken to determine the effectiveness of Transport Delivery Committee and to ensure that the transport policies of the West Midlands Combined Authority positively contributed towards the delivery of its wider corporate objectives.
Said18 Dec 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny Review into the Effectiveness of Transport Delivery Committee in Overseeing the Delivery of WMCA Transport Policies
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted that further to discussions with the Transport Portfolio Lead Councillor Ian Ward, an amendment would be made to recommendation 3 whereby membership of the proposed Transport Scrutiny Sub-Committee was suggested to be drawn from any member of a constituent authority transport scrutiny committee. This change in wording was supported by members of the committee.
Said12 Apr 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Health & Wellbeing - Progress Update
Councillor Cathy Bayton suggested that a similar process was mirrored by WMCA that was used in Dudley, where health & wellbeing was embedded into every decision making process. Sarah Windrum requested that work be undertaken with the Federation of Small Businesses and the region’s Chambers of Commerce to ensure the work programme was more business friendly.
Declared12 Apr 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Health & Wellbeing - Progress Update
[NB: Councillor Cathy Bayton declared a personal interest in this item.]
Said12 Apr 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Draft Overview & Scrutiny Committee Annual Report 2018/19
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted that the Annual Report needed to reflect the need for adequate resourcing to allow scrutiny to function effectively, and suggested that local authorities should also take in to account diversity considerations when determining their representative on the committee. Sarah Windrum requested that the role of the LEP representation on committee be clearly defined.
Said16 Jan 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Forward Plans
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council’s concerns regarding the business case and arrangements of the finance for New Stations Outline Business Case – Packages 1 & 2 as outlined on the WMCA Board forward plan, due to be considered on 22 March 2019. The concerns were around the decision making process of the £14million feasibility study undertaken. It was therefore agreed that a targeted time-limited task & finish group would be implemented to review this further and feedback would be provided at a future committee.
Said16 Jan 2019Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Extension Project Update
Councillor Cathy Bayton highlighted the importance of the extension for Dudley (and other neighbouring boroughs) in order to boost local skills and rail economy. Committee members raised concerns over the possibility of future freight train operation on the line and suggested that this should not be brought into costing arrangements. It was agreed that the Budget Working Group would oversee the arrangements of the final business case prior to approval at WMCA Board.
Named20 Nov 2018Overview & Scrutiny Committee
Call In Procedure
This view was echoed by Councillor Stephen Simkins and Councillor Cathy Bayton.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.