Matters Arising
The Chair suggested extending this offer to all committee members, noting that Councillor David Stanley had previously raised concerns regarding the Burntree Island scheme in Dudley.
Every time West Midlands Combined Authority's minutes name Councillor Stanley, as the council published it.
The Chair suggested extending this offer to all committee members, noting that Councillor David Stanley had previously raised concerns regarding the Burntree Island scheme in Dudley.
Councillor David Stanley expressed concern about the continued decline in bus patronage and the impact of rising fuel and electricity costs on operators, noting that these pressures were unlikely to be absorbed alongside falling passenger numbers. He also highlighted the increase in single bus fares as a deterrent to public transport use. The Head of Bus Franchising Transition acknowledged fuel price volatility and confirmed that operating costs were being considered as part of franchising preparations.
Councillor David Stanley raised concerns about the performance of the real ? time information system, describing it as increasingly unreliable. It was agreed that his concerns would be fedback to the author of the forthcoming report to the committee on real ? time information.
Councillor David Stanley referred to the need for strategic co-ordination of roadworks particularly around the Burnt Tree Junction Scheme in Dudley. The Mayor discussed the need to enhance project management processes for major infrastructure projects to ensure better communication of timelines, responsibilities and mitigation of negative impacts on local businesses and communities.
Councillor David Stanley requested project delivery progress and timescales be shared with Dudley councillors. The Chair agreed that councillors should be kept informed and undertook to raise this matter with the Leader of Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council when he saw him at the upcoming WMCA Board meeting.
In response to Councillor David Stanley it was confirmed that the West Bromwich to Brierley Hill Exchange and Adren Cross had received additional funding but would need to go through the business case process, with presentations scheduled for the WMCA Board in July.
Councillor Carol Hyatt, Councillor Ian Ward, Councillor David Stanley, Councillor Timothy Huxtable and Councillor Pervez Akhtar provided updated from their Member Engagement Groups.
Councillor David Stanley expressed concern about the subpar service experienced by customers. The Director of Integrated Transport Services provided assurance that efforts were being made in this area to mitigate issues. The Chair acknowledged the commendable service by other operators under challenging circumstances and highlighted the commitment to addressing challenges and seeking improvements in the bus services, acknowledging the perspectives and concerns raised by committee members.
In response to questions from Councillor David Stanley and Councillor Saddak Miah, the Statutory Scrutiny Officer confirmed that scrutiny training would be provided for members and would be delivered both internally and externally, throughout the year. The Chair asked members to confirm with the Governance Service Officer those areas they were particularly keen to receive training on.
In response to a question from Councillor David Stanley, the Governance Services Manager provided a summary of how decisions of the WMCA Board could be ‘called in’ by this committee, along with the role the committee Chair played in the WMCA’s processes for determining urgent items of business.
Councillor David Stanley noted recent passenger experiences that had been reported to him relating to the fares being charged and the lack of reliability in the timetable. The Director of Integrated Transport Services confirmed that fare capping existed on most, but not all, service routes. He also stated that reliability was now being monitored on a route-by-route basis, to identify where improvements and mitigation could be made.
The Chair welcomed Councillor David Stanley, the new board representative for Dudley as a result of Councillor Simon Phipps standing down from his Cabinet role due to work commitments.
Councillor Stanley reported that he would be interesting in obtaining a breakdown of figures from colleges on where people had found work.
· Safe & Sustainable Travel MEG - 5 December · Finance & Performance MEG - 12 December · Rail & Metro MEG - 12 December · Putting Passengers First MEG - 14 December · Air Quality, Congestion & Environmental Impact MEG - 4 January Councillor David Stanley noted the issue he had raised at the Putting Passengers First MEG in respect of the potential confusion caused to passengers when real-time information displays were showing scheduled travel information. The Head of Bus, Transport for West Midlands indicated that he would provided a more detailed briefing to members on this issue at the next MEG.
In respect of the Dudley Interchange project, Councillor David Stanley requested a site visit be held with the Chair ahead of the meeting of this committee on 9 January 2023. The Chair agreed to undertake this visit and requested Transport for West Midlands to make appropriate arrangements.
Councillor David Stanley noted problems with car parking at Coseley station. The Head of Park & Ride indicated that she had met with officers from Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council to discuss this issue, and had undertaken monitoring to assess the impact of station-related parking on local residents.
Councillor David Stanley asked that his request for an update and future information on the Tettenhall line be followed up as he was yet to receive any information.
Councillor David Stanley highlighted and requested that weekly changes made by National Express would be shared with committee members and sought to ensured this happened. The Head of Bus noted this requested would look to ensure that members of the committee would receive this information going forward, he also noted that the current process is undergoing a review.
Financial Monitoring Report (Minute no.11 refers) In relation to Councillor Stanley’s request for further information on the Parkhead Viaduct for the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Metro Extension at the last meeting which he indicated had not been provided, Wayne Farrington, Lead Accountant Transport, advised that the information had been provided via email and undertook for this to be re-sent to Councillor Stanley.
In relation to an enquiry from Councillor Stanley regarding how Dudley Port Rail Station would connect with the Metro given the different levels and distances between the two, the Director of Development and Delivery, TfWM, reported that TfWM was engaging with Network Rail, Midland Metro Alliance and stakeholders as part of the Masterplan for the location, however, he added that this work was at its early stages and an update could be given to the committee in due course.
Councillor Stanley asked to be kept informed with regards to any updates relating to park and ride for Coseley Rail Station.
In relation to the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Extension where slippage is due to the completion of the survey and site investigation works, Councillor Stanley noted that that the Parkhead Viaduct had caused problems over the years and enquired as to the current status of the viaduct and whether this would require additional work for the scheme.
The Lead Accountant-Transport, undertook to investigate the matter with colleagues and for a response to be sent to Councillor Stanley.
In relation to an enquiry from Councillor Stanley as to when Midland Metro Limited could expect to be in a profit position, the Metro Programme Director advised that he envisaged profits would be realised within 2-3 years but this could be earlier dependent on front end costs. He added that he hoped Metro would be carrying around 30 million people when the network is fully expanded and is up and running.
In relation to the remaining 18 objections to the draft Transport and Works Act Order which are being negotiated with the relevant parties, Councillor Stanley reported that he would be happy to help in this matter so that the objections could be progressed as quickly as possible.
The Metro Programme Director thanked Councillor Stanley for his offer of assistance and undertook to contact him if required.
Councillor Stanley commented that the report did not refer to park and ride for Coseley Station and reported that research has been undertaken locally on possible sites for expanding park and ride in the area and undertook to provide the Head of Park and Ride with further details on the matter.
In relation to comments made by Councillor Stanley regarding Coseley park and ride car park and the need to address capacity issues due to the parking problems experienced by nearby residents, the Chair asked that an update on the matter be included in the Park and Ride Update report that is to be submitted to the next meeting.
In relation to an enquiry from Councillor Stanley regarding the cost of Bilston Road track replacement and when this would be due to be replaced again, the Head of Finance and Business Planning, Linda Horne, reported that the new track was expected to last 25-30 years.
In relation to the National Productivity Investment Fund Projects listed in appendix 1 of the report, Councillor Stanley noted that £660k was allocated to Brierley Hill Strategic Centre and asked to be advised of how the money would be spent.
Councillor Stanley reported that the Passenger Champions, Bus Users UK and other passenger representative groups should be recognised for their efforts in providing feedback on the network.
Councillor Stanley endorsed Councillor Horton’s proposal which was supported by the committee.
In relation to the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Metro report and an enquiry from Councillor Stanley as to whether the line would be able to accommodate heavy rail in the future, Phil Hewitt reported that the line would be able to accommodate heavy rail and any upgrades would be made in accordance with Network Rail standards.
In relation to an enquiry from Councillor Stanley as to whether the draft budget included financial information on TfWM taking Metro operations in-house later this year, Linda Horne advised that the information would be in included in a future report.
Councillor David Stanley suggested that the various local authorities be encouraged to assist with the issue of concessionary passes for those customers without access to computers. Sarah Jones advised that this had been the previous practice but had ceased due to the level of additional equipment required. She offered to re-visit this possibility.
Councillor David Stanley observed that the role of ‘Cycling Champion’ had previously been undertaken by Councillor Peter Lowe and suggested that this role now be taken by Councillor Roger Lawrence, Portfolio Lead for Transport.
Councillor David Stanley commented that improvements and enhancements to the Park and Ride provision were required.
Councillor David Stanley welcomed the progress on the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Extension but asked whether West Midlands Trains was aware of the connectivity issues at Brierley Hill and Stourbridge. He expressed concern regarding maintaining the infrastructure for heavy rail and freight in these locations. Laura Shoaf advised that in the absence of considerable investment, Network Rail had no proposals in this area in the pre- 2040 period.
Councillor David Stanley enquired about the cost of the Metro track replacement works in Wolverhampton, previous works undertaken on the Bilston Road in Wolverhampton and remedial track replacement works in Birmingham City Centre.
The Lead Accountant for Transport agreed to provide a briefing note in relation to the costs associated to these schemes to Councillor David Stanley, Councillor Roger Horton, Councillor Daniel Warren and Councillor Judith Rowley.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Stanley attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Stanley's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Stanley was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 3 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Stanley declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Stanley in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Stanley sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transport Delivery Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member - Voting | Jul 2023 | 13 | |
| Joint Overview & Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member - Voting | Dec 2023 | 3 | |
| Transport Delivery Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2017 | 24 | |
| Economic Growth Board | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.