Petitions
c) Councillor Warters presented a petition which called upon City of York Council to fly the Southampton flag in memory of Henry Novak from the Mansion House in York.
Every time York's minutes name Councillor Warters, as the council published it.
c) Councillor Warters presented a petition which called upon City of York Council to fly the Southampton flag in memory of Henry Novak from the Mansion House in York.
d) Councillor Warters presented a petition in relation to Osbaldwick Lane road closure and loss of bus services.
e) Councillor Warters presented a petition in relation to holding City of York Council accountable for the £34m York Station Gateway increase.
1) Religious slaughter of animals A minor alteration to the motion was submitted by Councillor Warters (as set out in the supplementary agenda pack), which sought the consent of Council under Council Procedure Rule B15(2) to incorporate the alteration into the motion. Upon a vote being taken the alteration was lost.
This original motion was then moved by Councillor Warters who spoke on the motion. There was no seconder and therefore in accordance with Council Procedure Rules B16(1) there was no subsequent discussion or vote on the item.
(Councillor Warters left the meeting at 8.10pm at the conclusion of this motion.) 2) Tackling Fly-Tipping and Improving York’s Public Realm This motion was moved by Councillor Waller and seconded by Councillor Hook.
a) Councillor Warters regarding access for vehicles on Ouse Bridge and Rougier Street.
Supplementary Questions Councillor Warters asked whether alternative sites for waste disposal were being considered, given Hazel Court’s location.
in order to ensure York’s tourism remains sustainable, benefiting residents and visitors alike.” Cllr Warters then moved, and Cllr Rowley seconded, an amendment to the above motion, as follows:
Cllr Warters proposed the officer recommendation to approve, subject to the above amendment to condition 11.
Following a brief debate Cllr Warters moved, and Cllr Webb seconded, that the question be now put.
Following a brief debate, Cllr Warters proposed the officer recommendation to approve the application, and this was seconded by Cllr Vassie. On being put to a vote, Members voted unanimously in favour of the application, and it was therefore:
[Cllr Warters left the meeting at 9:08 pm].
Following a brief debate, Cllr Warters moved the officer recommendation to approve the application, subject to the amendment of condition 3 to the lifetime of the development.
Cllr Warters noted, for transparency reasons, that he had called-in the item on the agenda.
I would be very happy to give you a substantive answer to the important questions you raise but you were heckling me so it was impossible to do so.] Devolution From Cllr Warters: Are you content to leave as your legacy to York the handing over of significant powers to an elected Mayor, who is very likely to be the current Police, Fire & Crime Commissioner your colleagues have been critical of in the Lib Dem motion at this meeting?
Councillor Mark Warters spoke on agenda item 4 - Hull Road Verges Status. He called for a full appraisal of annex A to be delivered alongside a covering letter to all residents on Hull Road before the decision is made to allow them to consider the implications. He concluded by stating the negative impacts of this decision for residents and requesting that the Executive Member defers this decision.
Cllr Warters spoke on the petition regarding Noddle Hill. He stated that the Council had created the lay-by issue by expelling the family from an official site and needed to solve the housing issues of the family to end the encampment.
Cllr Warters reiterated the points raised by Murton Parish Council. He suggested that the proposed building was too tall and out of characters for the area. He expressed concerns regarding car parking on Outgang Lane.
Cllr Warters questioned the focus of the Local Government Association (LGA) report and Council response to the Public Interest Report (PIR) as the PIR related to actions of the Council leader and not wider issues. He questioned the success of any changes whilst the Council Leader remained in post.
[Supplementary from Cllr Warters: Can you clearly outline what levels of adverse reaction to consultation on the devolution proposals would lead to the deal not progressing?] Supplementary Response: The results will come here for Council to consider and decide on in the new year. So far, there have been more positive than negative responses to consultation and the part most critically commented on has been the prospect of the elected Mayor having powers to raise taxes or business ... view the full minutes text for item 36.
Cllr Warters, Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent, had been invited by the Chair to attend the meeting and provide a Ward Councillor viewpoint. He stated that Ward Councillors had not been included in any Travel Plan discussions. He noted it was important to address parking at the Heslington East site at the earliest opportunity.
Local residents were given the opportunity to speak informally with Councillor Warters, Councillor D’Agorne and the Head of Highways and Transport prior to the main meeting.
Councillor Warters confirmed that he had been in contact with the university in the past but, to his frustration, he had been informed that the parking issues were not the university’s problem. Another resident stated that she had also written to the university and had received a similar response.
Councillor Warters considered that the university should apply some common sense and either increase parking capacity or reduce charges. It was agreed that the situation had been entirely avoidable and should have been flagged up and addressed when the Badger Hill parking restrictions had been implemented.
Councillor Warters explained that there were approximately 30 cars causing problems in Osbaldwick and that the university should not be permitted to extend its building programme on campus unless robust parking provision was included (preferably a multi-storey car park). He further remarked that there seemed to be no end to the planned expansion.
Councillor Warters pointed out that increased parking provision was being overlooked, which had negative ramifications for local residents. He also drew attention to the significant annual revenue which was generated by the university as a result of its parking charges (which he believed to be in the region of £100,000).
Councillor Warters pointed out that there did not seem to be as much displaced parking arising from Archbishop Holgate’s School and suggested that the school may have increased its parking provision (and/or fewer students were choosing ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Regarding the condition of road surfaces, Councillor Warters expressed disappointed that there wasn’t a policy that dealt with concrete sectional surfacing. He explained that when the tarmac had been scraped off the road in High Field, the underlying concrete sectional surface appeared to be in very good condition. He considered it absurd that as long as potholes were less than the CYC intervention depth of an inch and a half (40mm) the road would receive no attention despite there being barely an inch (25mm) of tarmac overlay on the road as it stands, meaning there would never technically be breaches of the intervention levels despite the state of the road.
The Head of Highways and Transport noted Councillor Warters ’ comments and acknowledged that there had been some structural issues regarding concrete bases. He confirmed that the Highways Department was looking at using different materials on highways which, he hoped, would remedy the issues raised as soon as possible.
Councillor Warters commented that each new road layout sign had a date on the back and that although funding was provided to erect them, there was no funding available for removing them. He added that even on obsolete signs, staff were still employed to apply weedkiller around pole bases (which he considered to be a waste of public funds).
Finally, Councillor Warters drew the meeting to a close and thanked everyone for their contributions.
Public Speakers Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent, spoke in objection to the application. He raised concerns regarding the footpath which had been agreed as part of the original development, he stated that the new design would be out of keeping with the rest of the development. In response to questions, he suggested that Members compare both sets of plans.
Cllr Warters asked that the Executive Member support the stopping up order in item 10.
Cllr Warters, Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward, objected to the application due to concerns regarding a lack of parking provision. He urged the committee to decide to defer consideration of the application, to allow for Highway Development Control comments to be received. He also raised concerns regarding condition 4 and stated that it was not possible to ensure that the bin and bike storage would be used by the tenants.
Cllr Warters raised his concern that he felt the petition regarding Thirkleby Way/Farndale Avenue Highway Condition was and would be ignored by the Council. He stated that the Council was using policy that identified which streets would receive maintenance to avoid addressing the unsafe road service in this area and asked that the tarmac be removed and the concrete road be renovated. He also questioned the prioritisation of transport budgets by the Council.
Cllr Warters made reference to the 10 December 2021 Full Council meeting where it was unanimously voted to initiate without delay a review of the council’s supplementary document with regard to HMO’s, specifically percentage thresholds. He expressed his concerns regarding the delayed time frame for the report to be presented to Executive and he confirmed he wished to submit a formal complaint against misleading statements that he felt were made by a senior officer.
Local residents were given the opportunity to speak informally with Councillor Warters and Councillor Rowley prior to the main meeting.
The ensuing discussion demonstrated a keen sense of injustice, frustration and anger amongst residents, not only in connection with the proposed traffic management plan (which was considered to be basic, shoddy and incomplete), but also the manner in which the planning application had been seemingly rushed through without having taken into account the many objections raised by residents as well as Councillor Warters and Councillor Rowley.
Councillor Warters added that the development would be constructed on greenbelt land despite the availability of alternative brownfield sites in York and he felt aggrieved that the views of residents and local councillors had not been incorporated into either the planning application or the traffic management plan. There was also some ambiguity as to how residents could formally lodge their views and a query was raised as to how best to communicate with City of York Council in the future.
Councillor Warters added that residents could also contact their parish and ward councillors if they wished to express their views.
Councillor Warters thanked everyone for attending the meeting and informed them that a further meeting would be convened when a revised traffic management plan had been submitted. He also advised that a representative from Barratt Homes would be invited to attend the meeting to hear and address residents’ concerns.
Action: Councillor Warters and Councillor Rowley to convene a further meeting (to include a representative from Barratt Homes)
From Cllr Warters: Are you willing to commit to fulfilling the will of Council (as per the motion approved in December 2021) and alleviating the concerns of residents by amending the policy on HMOs to reduce the accessibility threshold for HMOs in York, given the inspectors’ confirmation at the hearing this afternoon that this will not result in the collapse or delay of the Local Plan?
Question to Cllr Widdowson, Executive Member for Environment & Climate Change From Cllr Warters:
Cllr Warters spoke on Agenda Item 13 (Monitoring Report on Complaints Received), objecting to the Monitoring Officer’s decision to dismiss a complaint he had submitted against an Executive Member.
Cllr Warters supported the restoration instead of replacement of the historical knocked down lamppost. He questioned however, why local companies had not been approached for quotes to complete the restoration work. He recommended a longer stretch of the A1079 be set to a 40 MPH speed limit rather than the proposals in item 9.
[Cllr Warters left the meeting at 5.35pm] Cllr Looker declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 4 [Hackney Carriage Licences] with regard to accessibility and the need to maintain a fleet accessible other than to wheelchair users.
Cllr Warters noted that he did not support the restrictions proposed on Cavendish Grove, Tranby Avenue and Moore Avenue/ Osbaldwick Lane junction. He stated that the Council needed to address the issue of university parking.
Public Speakers The Chair and a Councillor from Osbaldwick Parish Council, Cllr Mark Warters and Cllr Rebecca Russell, spoke on behalf of the applicant in support.
Cllr Warters also spoke on Item 6, stating that the recommendations in the report did not address the requirements of the Council motion and that Members should approve Option 1.
Cllr Warters spoke in favour of the ePetition : CYC solve the University related parking, don’t just MOVE it, noting that the Council was only moving parking problems with its use of residents parking. He stated that the report recommendation would not solve parking problems and that the University of York needed to be made to address its parking.
Cllr Mark Warters , the Ward Councillor, spoke in objection to the application and raised his concerns regarding the mass and scale of the planned extension and its impact on the neighbouring amenity.
Cllr Mark Warters outlined concerns that the introduction of restrictions and residents parking would only relocate parking problems to other parts of the city, and not solve parking issues within Osbaldwick , which were connected to the University.
Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward, raised concerns about the council’s house in multiple occupation (HMO) database. He felt that it was inaccurate and that the Committee were receiving incorrect data and basing decisions on this data.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke on matters relating to the general remit of the decision session. He spoke on the December 2021 Full Council motion on a review of the HMO supplementary planning document, stating that the motion had instructed the Executive to carry the review out immediately with a view to halving the acceptable percentage thresholds for HMOs in York.
Cllr Warters protested that the issue had been scheduled for consideration in April 2022’s meeting of the Executive. He stated that he had written to the Executive Member and the Director of Economy and Place on this issue but had received no response, and asked whether a public consultation would be legally required to implement the review, and if so how long would it take.
Cllr Warters requested a full update on progress made on the review.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke on matters relating to the general remit of the decision session. He spoke on the motion passed by Full Council on 16 December 2021 to review the Houses in Multiple Occupation supplementary planning document, which he stated called for 50% reduction in acceptable percentage thresholds for the proportion of HMO properties in York and for the HMO database to be published publicly.
Cllr Warters stated the he had written the Executive Member two days after the Full Council meeting to ask him to progress those actions, but had not had a response until 24 January 2022. He asked the Executive Member whether a reduction in percentage thresholds for HMOs needed to go to a 12 month public consultation, and he asked when the HMO database would be published on the council website.
Cllr Warters outlined his frustration with decisions to expand the Badger Hill Residents Parking Scheme, which he felt had diverted parking and created problems in Osbaldwick and Murton. He noted that the Council’s current policies were not addressing parking issues and requested that work instead be undertaken to tackle parking around York University.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke on Weed Treatment – Options. He stated that he recognised the need to continue some use of glyphosates, however he urged for its usage to be reduced as much as possible, and for a more controlled method of application than spraying from quad bikes, such as using backpack sprayers. He asked the Executive Member to bring all weed control operations under direct control and to reduce usage of weed-killers to two times each year.
The meeting resumed at 20:06 with the Deputy Lord Mayor, Cllr Looker, in the Chair.] (i) Houses in Multiple Occupation Cllr Warters sought consent to alter his motion to incorporate the amendment submitted by Cllr Pavlovic.
Council having granted consent, the altered motion was moved by Cllr Warters and seconded by Cllr Pavlovic, as follows:
This showed that the Independent Member, Cllr Warters, had a total of 10 points and would qualify for the Lord Mayoralty in 2022-23.
Cllr Warters had indicated that he wished to consider his position over the Christmas break. It was confirmed that there was sufficient time to wait until the New Year before formally announcing the Lord Mayor Elect.
Public Speakers Cllr Warters spoke in objection to the application as the Ward Councillor for Osbaldwick and Derwent. He stated that this was a retrospective application, with the HMO already in use and on the database. He also stated that there were a number of properties acting as HMOs on the same street, some of which were not registered.
The Development Manager clarified that a property referred to by Cllr Warters had reverted from an HMO to a family home and this moved the property from C4 to C3 class. This was within permitted development regulations and the property had therefore been removed from the database. Should the property become an HMO in the future, planning permission to move from C3 to C4 would be required.
Public Speakers Cllr Warters spoke in objection to the application as Ward Councillor. He noted that this was the same property management company as the previous application. He raised concerns regarding the possibility of converting the garage into a bedroom and the management of rubbish and parking at the property.
Cllr Warters raised parking around Osbaldwick , noting that the use of residential parking schemes around the University and Archbishop Holgates School were shifting the problems of parking onto different parts of the city and not addressing the issue. He also noted that on Coppergate a majority of residents voting in the consultation voted for a return to a two way street and therefore it should return to being a two way street.
Cllr Warters stated that the process being used to deal with complaints hearings was flawed, and noted that Members of the current panel had also been critical of the process in the past.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke on matters within the general remit of the committee and on item 9, Model Code of Conduct Update Review of Procedures. He stated the review needed member involvement and that the current procedures system was inadequate and referenced two recent hearings which he felt had been poorly managed and brought the committee into disrepute. He stated that he did not have confidence in the Monitoring Officer and felt she was not acting impartially.
Cllr Warters questioned the partiality of the Monitoring Officer and raised a complaint made against the Monitoring Officer, he asked that the Committee maintain oversight of the complaint. He also raised questions about the partiality of the Council’s administration, he noted a number of standards issues which he questioned the outcome of and how they were run, as well as, procedural issues relating to full council.
Jill Edwards, Chair of Kexby & Scoreby Parish Council, stated that on the basis of her experience of Cllr Warters since he became a ward councillor in 2015, the allegations against him were untrue, and that there was no evidence to support them.
Peter Broadley , Chairman of Holtby Parish Council, said he had known Cllr Warters for over 20 years, that he was honest, hardworking and never disrespectful to residents, and the complaint was trivial and did not warrant investigation.
Wendy Maddocks , as a long-term resident of Osbaldwick and member of Osbaldwick Parish Council, said she had known Cllr Warters for many years; the only aggression she had witnessed had been from the complainant at a parish council meeting, and she was astonished that the complaint was being considered.
The Panel considered a complaint made against Cllr Mark Warters, a City of York Councillor, by [name removed].
The complaint related to the behaviour of Cllr Warters towards the complainant during a telephone call. The matter had been referred to the Hearings Sub-Committee for determination following an investigation.
During the debate that followed Cllr Warters moved, and Cllr Looker seconded, that the application be refused on ... view the full minutes text for item 40a
Cllr Warters also spoke on Item 11. He raised concerns about the systems for dealing with complaints and stated that the committee should demand to be more involved in the process.
Cllr Warters raised concerns about the handling of a series of Code of Conduct complaints, noting that little progress had been made since 2016 in improving the standards process.
Cllr Warters then moved and Cllr Melly seconded approval of option 1. Following a unanimous vote it was
Before consideration of the application, the Chair advised that Cllr Warters that his comments regarding officers may be in breach of the Member Code of Conduct.
Cllr Warters declined an offer from the Chair to apologise for his comments.
Cllr Warters moved approval subject to amendment to condition 13 to be changed to the lifetime of the development.
Cllr Melly then moved and Cllr Warters seconded approval of the renewal (option 1). In accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
· The trees were there to break up the hard landscape · The conditions had been modified to improve energy efficiency · The application was DDA compliant Cllr Warters then moved and Cllr Daubeney seconded approval of the application subject to the conditions outlined in the report, additional information and amendment to Condition 20. Following debate, and in accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
Cllr Warters pointed to the Executive making a commitment to the scheme to which the Senior Solicitor advised that this in itself was not a conflict of interest and it was for members of the Executive themselves to decide whether this was a conflict of interest.
Cllr Warters then moved and Cllr Daubeney seconded approval of the application subject to the conditions outlined in the report and additional information. Following debate, and in accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
From Cllr Warters : Will you be lobbying government and Higher Education organisations for students to remain at home after Christmas and continue their courses remotely, rather than repeating the mistake of welcoming 40,000 students to York?
( Supplementary from Cllr Warters : If it’s considered safe for students to return in January, when will the council ask its staff to come back?) Response: I am not going to demonise or segregate groups. I praise the work carried out by public health, the NHS, universities and schools in difficult circumstances. My commitment is to ensure we are communicating health guidance as quickly as possible and taking a York approach, including test and trace work with universities.
Cllr Warters, Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent, spoke in objection and made the following points:
Cllr Warters then moved option 1 and Cllr Melly seconded this. In accordance with the revised Standing Orders, a named vote was taken with the following result:
· To request that the leaders of all York’s political Groups jointly write to the Secretary of State for Education demanding that York be reimbursed for the cost of providing the above-mentioned voucher scheme and to allocate further funding such that an equivalent scheme can be delivered for the remainder of the school holidays in the 2020/21 academic year.” Cllr Warters then moved, and Cllr Rowley seconded, that Standing Orders be suspended to enable an amendment to be put to the above motion. On being put to the vote, the motion to suspend Standing Orders was declared LOST.
· An additional representation had been received from Councillor Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent, in objection on the grounds that taxis were being parked on roads and verges outside the site. In addition, concerns that the facility had no sewer connection for toilet or washing facilities and should therefore not be in operation.
Officers gave a presentation based upon the slides at pages 67 -72 of the Agenda and reported an additional representation from Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent who considered the proposal to be unregulated B1, B2 and B8 usage, unrelated to Horticulture/Agriculture and inappropriate in the Green Belt. He considered there to be no imperative to support this employment site given the extensive industrial estate opposite.
A number of photographs of the site were circulated, at the request of Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent.
He also noted that there had once been other buildings in the grounds of the property. c) Cllr Warters , who said that the application would create a practical family home with a minimal increase in the volume of the building’s footprint, causing no harm to the green belt. In response to questions from Members, officers confirmed that:
Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent, spoke in objection to the application, which he said would create further parking problems in the area unless all tenants were required to be non-vehicle owners.
Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent, spoke in objection, on the grounds of the impact on residential amenity and road safety, and the percentage of HMOs in the area.
[name removed], the Agent for the applicant and Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent spoke in support of the application. Their comments included the following:
Local Plan · From Cllr Warters - did the Leader share the pride expressed by Cllr Ayre in the Plan, in view of the effect of inward immigration on the green belt and infrastructure of the city?
Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent spoke regarding the City of York’s ( CYC) Street Lighting Policy which had been agreed by the previous Executive Member for Transport in July 2018. He expressed concern that the policy allowed officers to rip out perfectly serviceable lamp posts and dispose of cast iron columns replacing them with modern steel ones which were British standard height 20ft high 6ft columns which he considered to be too high for an area of bungalows. He considered that the city centre and rural areas should work to the same policy.
Cllr Warters , Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on Agenda Item 5, Graffiti Removal Policy. He highlighted some gaps within the policy and felt that it should contain a preventative strategy and an enforcement policy. He addressed the difficulties in the current arrangements for reporting graffiti on street telecoms cabinets and would welcome a service level agreement between the Council and the telecoms companies to enable a more simple and effective reporting system.
Prior to the responses from Opposition Group Leaders, it was moved by Cllr Rowley, and seconded by Cllr Warters , that Standing Order 16.2 be suspended to allow Cllr Rowley to respond to the Leader’s report in the absence of Cllr Doughty. On being put to the vote, this motion was declared LOST.
York Outer Ring Road (ORR) · Question from Cllr Warters on whether dualling the ORR would facilitate over-development in the area.
· Supplementary from Cllr Warters on whether the Leader supported reducing the housing allocation in the Local Plan.
· Question from Cllr Warters , on how dualling the York Outer Ring Road would affect carbon emissions.
Local residents were given the opportunity to speak informally with Councillor Rowley and Councillor Warters prior to the main meeting.
Councillor Warters commented that the traveller vehicles moved on a daily basis so were likely to have been driven illegally (which was a police matter). There followed a further discussion about identifying whether a vehicle was legally roadworthy by checking the DVLS website. Sgt Lowery said she would discuss the matter with her colleagues in the Traffic Enforcement Team as they had all the relevant information.
He thanked Councillor Rowley, Councillor Warters , Cindy Benton and local volunteers for their support with regard to the restoration of Dunnington playing field following an infestation of chafer grubs as well as damage created by crows and rabbits. He showed photographs to residents of the poor state of the playing field prior to the restoration. The representative was, in turn, thanked for his contribution to the community by another resident.
Councillor Warters compared York’s poor recycling target with that of East Riding and Councillor Rowley said he would raise this issue with City of York Council.
He also confirmed that Cherry Tree Court had benefitted from some nice planters and thanked Councillor Warters for being proactive in his quest to obtain several planters throughout the ward.
Consequently, there were two vacant seats next to Councillor Rowley and Councillor Warters (with a copy of the Ombudsman’s report strategically placed on one of them).
Local residents were given the opportunity to speak informally with Councillor Warters and Councillor Rowley prior to the main meeting
The meeting was chaired by Councillor Warters who welcomed everyone and set out the agenda. He introduced Sgt Victoria Lowery and PCSO Andy Smith from the Neighbourhood Team who had been asked to attend following several recent incidents of anti-social behaviour in the area (particularly during the summer months).
Councillor Warters disputed the fact that simply driving a police van in the area constituted a visible police presence. He also asked whether the Neighbourhood Team would consider accepting a sports club key (or having access to a high security key safe), this is to use the club as a rest stop when patrolling, this was previously agreed five years ago.Sgt Lowery said she would look into the possibility of this.
Councillor Warters then asked for a commitment to have regular foot patrols in the area and for senior police staff to attend future ward meetings on a regular basis.
At this stage in the meeting, Councillor Warters commented on the dreadful state that David Wilson Homes(development partner to the Joseph Rowntree Housing Association) had left Fifth Avenue when using it ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Councillor Warters commented on the difficulty of getting things moving but confirmed that there would be increased parking near the shops on Farndale Avenue in an effort to avoid inappropriate parking. He also confirmed that the pot holes on Metcalf Lane had been filled in.
Councillor Warters confirmed that matters tended to get held up during the legal process.
Councillor Warters was unsure but put Councillor Andy D’Agorne’s name forward as someone who would be able to advise him on the matter.
Finally, a resident asked who was responsible for the lamppost near the sports Club, Councillor Warters will confirm.
As no further queries or concerns were raised Councillor Warters thanked everyone for attending the meeting which ended at 21: 00.
Councillor Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent, spoke in support of the recommended option.
Cllr Warters , Ward Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent, spoke in support of concerns that had been raised by Holtby Parish Council regarding traffic flow being directed through Holtby due to signage. He also read out a prepared statement on behalf of local resident [name removed], in relation to Holtby , expressing his disappointment that this work had not been included on the 2019/20 Transport Capital Programme Schemes. Holtby Parish Councillor, Peter Broadley , spoke enquiring when the scheme at Holtby would be undertaken.
Cllr Warters , Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on Agenda Items 8 (Waste Collection Methodology) and 10 (Highway Infrastructure Asset Management Plan). On Item 8, he argued in favour of a mixed recycling collection like that operated by East Riding Council; on Item 10, he asked when ward members would be updated on the highways condition survey.
Cllr Warters then moved, and Cllr D’Agorne later seconded, that the application be refused. The Chair called a 5 minute adjournment at this point in order to take advice.
Cllr Warters , Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on Agenda Item 5 (Highway Weed Control). He raised his concerns regarding the current weed control contract and the poor service performance. He asked for confirmation of any payments made so far to the existing contractor and felt that a fifth option should be considered to bring the weed control function in house.
Foss 2008 Internal Drainage Board To appoint Councillor Fisher and Councillor Warters onto the Board.
Cllr Warters , Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, also spoke on Item 11, objecting to the proposals and urging Executive either to approve Option 2 in the report or defer the decision.
With the consent of the Chair, Cllr Warters then addressed the committee in relation to Agenda Item 4 (Monitoring Report on Complaints Received), identifying himself as the subject member in one of the cases and expressing the view that details of all cases should be in the public domain.
Cllr Warters , member for Osbaldwick & Derwent ward, spoke on matters within the Executive’s remit, expressing concern about the state of roads and footpaths in the city and suggesting that the council set up a mobile service to clear debris and bring the week-killing service in house.
Cllr Warters, Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on Agenda Item 6 (Directorate of Economy & Place Transport Capital Programme - 2019/20 Consolidated Report) in respect of the Holtby danger reduction scheme (p.55 of the agenda). He urged that this scheme be progressed as soon as possible, adding that his communications to officers on this and other issues had been ignored.
· Cllr K Taylor – York Central and the delay in a decision on HIF investment Supplementary Cllr Crawshaw – Network Rail Land Registry Documents and S106 funding/planning approval Cllr Pavlovic – HIF investment and the risk of putting further public money into the York Central development · Cllr Rowley – The Green Group working arrangement with the Liberal Democrat Group in relation to voting · Cllr Warters – Graffiti on fibre York communications cabins Cllr Aspden responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementary questions.
He also agreed to meet with Cllr Warters and Officers in relation to the use of graffiti funding.
To Cllr Ayre , Executive Member for Finance & Performance · From Cllr Waudby – Bootham Park Hospital Update · From Cllr Warters – Community Stadium delays · From Cllr Orrell - £10 parking charge at Community Stadium car park ii.
Cllr Warters, ward Cllr for Osbaldwick , then addressed the committee.
Cllr Warters made the following comments regarding the application.
In response to questions from Members, Cllr Warters noted a recent appeal that had been upheld regarding HMO’s in the Hull Road Ward.
· Cllr Cuthbertson – Strensall Barracks site and housing numbers in the Local Plan · Cllr Williams – York Central and the planning consultation response from York Liberal Democrats Supplementary Cllr Williams – York Liberal Democrats and York Central Cllr Richardson – Jobs created by York Central site Cllr Kramm – York Central air quality and Clean Air Zone · Cllr Warters – housing figures in the Local Plan · Richardson – Money being given Haxby library Cllr Aspden responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementary questions.
Supplementary Cllr Crawshaw – Overspend at Danesgate Cllr D Myers – Overspend on Home to School Transport for SEN pupils (iv) To all Executive Members · From Cllr Warters – Clifford’s Tower The Leader/Deputy Leader/Executive Members responded directly to all the questions put to them, including supplementary questions.
Cllr Warters, Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on matters within the Executive’s remit. He stated that he had raised the issue of the 20MPH Speed Limit signage in Osbaldwick at this administration’s first Executive Meeting in June 2015. However, despite a petition being taken to Transport Decisions Sessions, he felt this was rejected for political reasons.
Cllr Warters, Councillor for Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward spoke on behalf of a taxi driver in his Ward on agenda item 5 Update Report – Private Hire ... view the full minutes text for item 31.
He concluded by urging that the application be approved subject to a condition requiring the installation of a signalised pedestrian crossing Cllr Warters moved and Cllr Gilles seconded approval of the application subject to a condition that there should be a pedestrian crossing.
Cllr Warters, Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent Ward, spoke on Agenda Item 7. He criticised the lack of progress since May 2018 and suggested that the Guildhall be put on the private market for hotel use, with the council retaining use of the Council Chamber in perpetuity.
He acknowledged the comments made by Councillor Warters and his offer of assistance. He noted the political commitment made by the current joint administration in 2015 not to impose any additional street clutter nor to impose any further 20mph speed limits. He advised those present that he could not agree to spending any more public money on this at the current time and made the decision to take no further action at present.
Joint Standards Committee · To appoint Cllr Warters to replace Cllr Hayes on this committee.
Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee · To appoint Cllr Hayes to replace Cllr Warters on this committee.
Cllr Mark Warters also spoke in objection and made the point that as there is no clearly defined curtillage , policy GB3 (points [vi] and [vii]), are not satisfied.
Cllr Warters also drew attention to a high court ruling from 2012 in which the residing judge ruled that ‘the use of a dwelling for commercial use or letting amounts to a material change of use and required planning permission’.
Cllr Warters believed the committee, if minded to approve the application, should ensure that it is clearly designated as a residential dwelling and not as a commercial holiday let, allowing for future enforcement should this not be the case.
Cllr Warters spoke as Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward Councillor and expressed dismay that the council had proceeded with the experimental location for the start of the 30mph limit at Common Lane, Dunnington after opposition from Dunnington Parish Council. He suggested that ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
Cllr Warters, Member for Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward, spoke on matters within the Executive’s remit, referring to a question he had asked at Full Council on provision for standing at football matches and urging that standing space be provided at the new Monks Cross Stadium.
· Cllr Craghill – Waste and recycling vehicles and on going co-mingling of waste with supplementary questions from Cllr Craghill and Cllr D’Agorne · Cllr Warters – Waste collection and co-mingling · Cllr Williams – Westfield Primary School Capital Improvements and what made this a ‘One Planet York’ scheme with supplementary questions from Cllr Williams and Cllr S Barnes Cllr Waller responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries .
(i) Children & Young People’s Emotional Health and Wellbeing (Proposed by Councillor Crawshaw and seconded by Councillor Warters) Council notes that:
Cllr Warters, member for Osbaldwick and Derwent ward, spoke on Agenda Item 6 (Waste Resilience Update). He queried why the report included no option to pay drivers more competitive rates and suggested that the current recycling scheme be replaced by a mixed recyclates scheme as used by East Riding, the authority with the highest recycling rates.
Councillor Mark Warters also spoke in relation to the item on Information Governance and Complaints, and in particular on FOI requests made by Members. He stated that he had put in 7 FOI requests over the previous year, all of which he felt he should have been able to get answers to, as a Member, without having to go through the FOI system. He suggested that the figures in the report being considered by Members did not reflect reality.
The Executive Member acknowledged the comments made by both Cllr Warters and Cllr Brooks in relation to this report and the request that Ward and Parish Councillors are consulted on replacement street lighting. Discussion took place around whether consultation should take place for lighting replacement schemes in conservation areas only or for all lighting replacement schemes and how it could work on a practical basis, noting the cost implications of it. In response to concerns raised about disregarding the Streetscape Strategy and Guidance for the present time, officers confirmed that this document was due to be reviewed but until such time as it was, it should be treated only as guidance only and not policy.
Supplementary Cllr Crawshaw - Consideration of co-location with other services, such as the Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB) · Cllr Kramm – Impact of Brexit on York · Cllr Fenton – The need to communicate York’s concerns over Brexit to Westminster Supplementary Cllr Fenton – The benefits of a joint letter to the Brexit Secretary Cllr Kramm – The support being offered to EU citizens trying to gain British citizenship · Cllr Warters – Transfer of clubs to the Community Stadium and sale of Bootham Crescent Cllr Gillies responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementary questions.
· Cllr Warters – Recycling system and co-mingling · Supplementary Cllr Warters - East Riding Council system for waste collection and containers offered Cllr Kramm – Using profit from recycling to subsidise less profitable recycling schemes · Cllr D Myers – Affordable Housing on York Central and sustainability of the site Supplementary Cllr D Myers – How had the Festival of York Central influenced the York Central Partnership Scheme Cllr Waller responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries .
· Cllr Carr – Office for National Statistics revised forecast figures for household growth and the impact on housing numbers contained in the Draft Local Plan Supplementary Cllr Carr – Accuracy of figures within the Draft Local Plan Cllr Warters – Requesting a suspension of the Local Plan examination process to re draw based on the new ONS figures, in order to protect the Green Belt (ii) To Cllr Douglas, Executive Member for Housing and Safer Neighbourhoods:
Cllr Mark Warters, Member for Osbaldwick & Derwent ward, also spoke on Agenda Item 8, asking why standing areas were now being proposed and expressing the view that YCFC and York City Knights should be equal partners in operating the Stadium.
Cllr Warters spoke in relation to Agenda Item 5 (Monitoring Report on Complaints Received), as a subject member of one of the complaints determined by the Monitoring Officer (MO). He objected to the wording of the MO’s decision notice and asked that it be altered. The Chair confirmed that the committee had no authority to do this and that the decision notice was not a public document.
Cllr Mark Warters, ward member for Osbaldwick and Derwent , spoke on matters within the Executive’s remit. He commented on recent media reports about the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust and urged the Executive to issue a statement distancing the Council, and York, from the Trust. In response, the Chair indicated that he would request a report to Executive to consider the matter.
Supplementary questions · Councillor Cuthbertson – Ministerial input on this decision · Councillor Kramm – Would the 500 metres only apply in the City of York or across North Yorkshire Councillor Warters – Thanks to Councillor Hayes in relation to Clifford’s Tower Councillor Crawshaw – Commitment to a Clean Air Zone in relation to York Central Councillor Waller responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries .
Cllr M Warters also spoke in relation to the Street Lighting Policy Update. He expressed concern that the revised policy would remove Ward Councillors, Parish Councillors and residents ability to have any say in the number, siting, aesthetics and quality of street lighting in their area. He also raised concern that the 2014 street scape guidance would be lost and that the proposed revised policy sought to impost 6m high columns outside city’s historic core with ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Cllr Warters, member for Derwent ward, spoke on Agenda Item 10 (Finance & Performance Outturn 2017/18), referring to paragraphs 16 and 11 of the report. He asked that the design of the new York boundary signs be approved by York Civic Trust and that an update be provided on the trialling of machinery to cut rural road verges and encourage wildflowers.
Councillor Mark Warters spoke to advise the committee that he had been contacted by a resident who was a patient of Unity Health and had been asked to read out a statement on her behalf which provided an account of her experiences with Unity Health in relation to medical treatment received by her late husband. The scrutiny officer clarified that officers had offered him procedural advice that, in line with the council’s procedure rules on public participation, the statement should not be read out at the meeting as it disclosed confidential or exempt information including personal information, and that he and the resident had been offered advice on the best route for getting her complaint dealt with.
Councillor Mark Warters , a Member of the Council, spoke on his concerns at the delay in publishing the report into the conduct of the Audit & Governance Committee on 22 February 2017 and asked for a full public disclosure of the report . He also raised further concerns in relation to historic procurement issues, which in his opinion have not been properly clarified and resolved. .
· Councillor Warters – whether the City of York Streetscape Strategy and Guidance would remain part of the Local Plan and whether the City of York Council would be following the guidelines in that document;
Cllr Warters spoke regarding the positioning of a speed restriction sign in Dunnington. He explained that the current siting of the sign was closer to the centre of the village than had been previously agreed with the Parish Council. He asked that it be relocated to the agreed position and that a public apology be issued.
Cllr Warters, as ward councillor, spoke in support of the petition he had submitted. He reported that it was the wish of the village to remove the 20mph restrictions and that the given reasons for retaining them were not grounded in evidence. He asked that, should the restrictions be retained, the area be expanded with signs placed only at the boundary of the restricted area.
Cllr Warters spoke on Agenda Item 11 (Financial Strategy 2018/19 to 2022/23), objecting to the educational exemption from council tax for students and seeking more financial support for waste management and highways repairs.
Cllr Warters spoke in support of the Committee’s request for an investigation into the LGA report completed in February 2017. He asked that any investigation to establish value for money should include wide-reaching consultation and he expressed disappointment that no working practices had changed as a result of the review.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke as ward member for Osbaldwick and Derwent , suggesting that an environment capacity survey be commissioned to determine the effects of over-development on the city’s character and infrastructure.
Cllr Warters , Ward Councillor for Osbaldwick and Derwenthorpe , addressed the committee in objection to the application. His concerns related to the impact of amenity because of extra noise, disruption, parking problems created through the change of use of the property to a HMO.
Cllr Mark Warters spoke further to Minute 48 of the last meeting, drawing out issues relating to governance and transparency and specifically referring to the resolution regarding ‘an appropriate report’ for Audit & Governance Committee. He queried what that would mean in practice.
Under Standing Order 15, the following petition was presented by Cllr Warters, for reference to the Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee, in accordance with the Council’s arrangements for petitions:
· From Cllr Warters – need to address highways defects caused by work to install 21 st century communications infrastructure in the city.
Labour: -1 Liberal Democrat: 42 Green -11 Conservative 22 Independent (Cllr Warters) 7 Independent (Cllr Hayes) 3 Therefore, unless Members wished to review the points system, the Liberal Democrat group should be invited to make the nomination.
Councillor Mark Warters spoke in support of the application as Ward Member and on behalf of the applicant’s family. He expressed his support for the proposals which would provide the family with additional space needed to accommodate parents within the family home. He advised that the house had nothing to do with the adjacent site of the same name and that the proposed extension was in keeping with the design of the existing building and would not impact on neighbouring properties.
Members were then invited to question Cllr Waller on his report and questions were received from the floor from the following Members in relation to the subjects listed: · Cllr Taylor –York Central consultation – concern over lack of transparency and query about making it a car free development · Cllr Mason – Update on work on Foss Barrier · Cllr Danny Myers – update on discussion with defence infrastructure organisation · Cllr Warters – levels of proposed development in the city Cllr Waller responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries.
Cllr Warters also spoke in relation to the LGA report, indicating that the Executive Leader had stated during the last Full Council meeting on 20 July 2017 that the report was to be disseminated to Members immediately upon release. He stated that, as the report had not been released yet, this questioned the integrity of governance at CYC and asked the Committee to request the full draft LGA report investigating the conduct of the A&G meeting from 22 February 2017 for review, if necessary, at an emergency Committee meeting.
Councillor Warters then spoke as the Ward Member and objector and outlined his reasons for objecting, which were set out in detail in the report. He urged the Executive Member to abandon the Order.
Councillor Warters spoke on planning conditions and the use of informatives , particularly in relation to damage caused by HGV’s.
Councillor Warters, Ward Member, echoed the concerns of both Dunnington parish Council and Councillor Brooks. He also proposed that should Members be minded to approve this application that they consider a Construction Environment Management Plan and condition working hours to lessen the impact on neighbours.
· From Cllr Warters – importance of ensuring residents and local groups are in possession of full facts with regard to local plan so they are in position to comment during consultation process.
Welcome Cllr Warters opened the meeting by inviting Sgt Danny Leach from the York North Neighbourhood Policing Team to update residents on their work within the ward.
· Cllr Warters confirmed that his petition on behalf of residents of Bransdale Crescent, Osbaldwick was no longer required as agreement had now been reached on the spelling of the street name.
· Cllr Warters – supervision of utility works on roads and footpaths · Cllr Levene – importance of devolution discussions for the York area · Cllr Craghill – siting of Clifford’s Tower Visitor Centre · Cllr S Barnes – guarantees regarding retention of former Manor School playing fields · Cllr S Barnes – arrangement of meeting with Leader to discuss above matter · Cllr Kramm – clarification regarding affordable housing as part of the partnership between CYC and the Homes and Communities Agency (HCA) · Cllr Kramm – Number of affordable homes aimed for as part of the partnership with HCA · Cllr Levene – the percentage of market value of properties considered as affordable in the city · Cllr Boyce – Children and Social Work Bill and the abolition of the statutory requirement for the set up local Safeguarding Children’s Boards 1. · Cllr Williams – how the proposals for the Guildhall differed from that of the previous administration · Cllr Williams – delay and costs associated with the Guildhall development Cllr Carr responded directly to all the questions put to him, including supplementaries , but agreed to respond in more detail in writing to Councillor Boyce.
· Cllr Kramm – content of the report was similar to the Leaders · Cllr Kramm –further information on devolution · Cllr Reid – implications of the new business rate reforms in the city · Cllr Cannon – concern regarding implications for the city arising from adult social care financing · Cllr Cannon – use of 3% precept for adult social care · Cllr Warters – clarification on the size of investment in Haxby Library 1.
General Remit of the Committee – Highway Works by Utility Companies Councillor Warters raised concerns as to the co-ordination and inspection of utility works on the highway network. He questioned the recording of defects and asked for an urgent review of operations of the Streetworks inspection team, with a view to aligning with the highways maintenance section.
Councillor Warters also questioned whether additional funds had been requested for remedial works following broadband roll out, given that it was a government initiative and asked if utility companies were required to re-turf grass verges after excavations.
It was reported that comments had been received from Councillor Warters in respect of the proposed diversion. He stated that whilst he was not in objection to the diversion the section of the path under consideration, he would strongly object if there was any attempt to divert, alter or extinguish the other Public Right of Way ( Osbaldwick number 2) that ran the other side of the boundary hedge to the development.
Councillor Warters raised concerns relating to the breaches of financial procedures and a failure to maintain records. He asked for a police investigation.
Councillor Warters , Ward Member who called-in the application, spoke in objection. He stated that previous approval was granted on the existing footprint of the barn and that the parameters were now being extended beyond this .
Cllr Warters spoke in relation to the recommendations of the Protection of Grass Verges Scrutiny Review report which had been agreed at the Executive’s meeting on 24 November 2016. In particular he questioned the quality of the remedial works to verges in the Osbaldwick area, following the laying of cables.
Councillor Warters then moved, and Councillor Galvin seconded, a motion to approve the application with appropriate conditions on the grounds that the applicant had demonstrated very special circumstances which outweighed the harm ... view the full minutes text for item 68a
Councillor Warters spoke about landscaping conditions on the site and how he felt that the reasons given for refusal on the loss of landscape were inconsistent with recent planning decisions. He questioned whether a contribution could be sought for the Parish Council for the loss of the trees.
Councillor Warters spoke in objection. He echoed the concerns of the first speaker, and stated that the extension would be visible from residents from the front and behind. The application he felt amounted to the construction of a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO).
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of agenda item 7 – Mazars Audit Progress Report. He drew Members’ attention to the “valid objection” which had been referred to in the report.
Councillor Warters stated that that the committee needed to receive the procurement reports from Mazars and from the Internal Auditors as soon as possible, and that a special meeting should be convened in January 2017 to consider these matters.
Councillor Warters had registered to speak at the meeting under the Council’s Public Participation Scheme in respect of the Asset of Community Value (ACV) application for Osbaldwick School playing fields (agenda item 5).
Councillor Warters urged the Council, as landowner, to give reassurance to the community by listing the playing fields as an ACV. He drew attention to issues that may arise if the school gained academy status and stated that the application met many of the criteria for ACV listing.
The Executive Member stated that he had noted the issues raised by Councillor Warters. He stated that he had sought legal guidance from officers as to whether the application for ACV listing had been met and it was their view that this was not the case. Officers confirmed that consideration had been given to three appeals which had come before the First Tier Tribunal concerning school playing fields and, where the use of the playing fields was solely educational, the criteria for listing was not met.
Cllr Warters spoke to express caution regarding approval of the preferred spatial plan for 162 properties on this site, particularly as it had previously been stated that development would only take place on the existing buildings footprint. He requested Members to support the 95 home option.
Cllr Warters referred to the possible implications of the forthcoming Judicial Review Claim. He expressed support for the sale of the Community Stadium site and the upgrading of the existing Bootham Crescent ground.
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of agenda item 4 – City of York Council Community Governance Review. He explained the reasons why Osbaldwick Parish Council had requested that the development of Derwenthorpe be removed from the parish area, including the historical background. He also drew attention to the precept implications for Murton Parish Council.
Councillor Warters stated that the Derwenthorpe development had been established as a model village and that parish councils should have no role to play in such estates and their residents should not be paying precepts.
Councillor Warters stated that Osbaldwick Parish Council had no desire to remove Meadlands from the parish area and that the Meadlands Residents Association had not been consulted on such a proposal.
Councillor Warters requested that Members deferred consultation on the options detailed in 3.12 of the report but carried out full consultation on the options detailed in 4.1 and 4.2 of the report. Consultation should also take place with Murton Parish Council.
· Cllr Williams – confirmation that clearer signage was required in the city centre · Cllr Williams – questioned the Deputy Leaders support for improved city signage · Cllr Kramm – effect on York’s economy and students of Council’s licensing policy as referred to by earlier speakers during public participation · Cllr Warters – Leaders reference to ‘economies strong growth’ and Deputy Leaders reference to ‘the national economic picture looking increasingly turbulent’ · Cllr Levene – reductions in Council’s housing stock and mitigating measures (no reference in Leader’s current report) · Cllr Hayes – support for independent shops, cleanliness of the city and ‘A’ Boards · Cllr Looker – work to promote and advertise individual city shops · Cllr Kramm – balance between independent businesses and out of town shopping centres · Cllr Hayes – production of a new independent shopping guide to York which promoted independent shopping in the city Cllr Carr responded directly to all the questions put to him.
· Cllr Warters – growth of the national economy and encouragement of tourism with a lower pound · Cllr Fenton – update on the number of representations received to the Council’s Local Plan consultation and next steps · Cllr Kramm – the reduction in the number of houses in the new draft Local Plan and the shift between the York Outer and York Central wards · Cllr Flinders – publicity in relation to the recent Flood Inquiry · Cllr Flinders – responses to the Flood Inquiry and residents awareness of meetings Councillor Aspden responded directly to all the questions put to him but agreed to respond in more detail in writing to Councillor Kramm’s question.
· Cllr Warters – invitation to Southbank Club question and answer session for city supporters of Rugby League · Cllr Warters – residents concerns in relation to Rugby League in the city (iii) To Cllr Aspden, Deputy Leader, Economic Development and Community Engagement:
Councillor Mark Warters suggested that this property was not authorised to act as a HMO and that the proposed application would damage the street scene and affect the level of daylight reaching neighbouring properties.
Councillor Mark Warters spoke as the Ward Member. He stated that he objected to this application on the grounds that the original consent was for a three bedroom bungalow and that this was now a four bedroom house. He also raised concerns about drainage at the site during construction.
Councillor Warters spoke about access to GP services and felt that it should be considered as a scrutiny review topic. He felt that Members should request that the proposed surgery on the former Burnholme School site stay open for 7 days a week.
Councillor Mark Warters also spoke in objection. He suggested that the committee would lose credibility were they to go back on their original decision. He reminded Members of the importance of protecting the amenity of residents.
Councillor Mark Warters spoke as the Member who called in the item, originally as an enforcement case, due to some of the signs already being displayed without prior permission. He proposed that there was no public benefit from the signs and that they were merely advertising, which was unacceptable on a listed building.
Representations in objection were made by Councillor Mark Warters. He called for a deferral of the application until a consultation had taken place, as this was a major approach road into the city and not a suitable site. He suggested that the boxes would be vandalised and that there was no suitable parking for maintenance vehicles.
Councillor Mark Warters spoke in objection to the proposed applications as he felt the signs were unjustified street clutter.
Matters within the Remit of the Committee Cllr Warters referred to current issues in connection with the Community Stadium project which he had raised with the Chief Executive and questioned alternative plans.
Advertising Boards, ‘A’ Boards and Other Equipment on the Public Highway Cllr Warters spoke in support of the implementation of the ‘A’ Board policy but questioned the exemption of Micklegate .
Councillor Warters spoke as a local member, in objection to the application. He made reference to the large number of Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMO) that were adjacent to the property. He also raised concerns at the visual impact of a terracing effect and safety grounds due to parking.
Councillor Warters spoke as the Member of Council who had called in the application. He referred to previous landscaping conditions which had been attached to nearby sites and asked that the following conditions be added to any planning permission, if Members were minded to support the Officer’s recommendation;
· Cllr Gunnell – the future of York Knights Rugby Club · Cllr Crisp – CYC’s contract with York Knights Rugby Club · Cllr Warters – the position in respect of York Knights Rugby Club match on 24 July 2016 (ii) To Cllr Carr, Executive Leader including Housing and Safer Neighbourhoods:
· Cllr Warters – engagement with residents on the Local Plan (iii) To Cllr Aspden, Deputy Leader, including Economic Development and Community Engagement:
Councillor Mark Warters welcomed everyone to the meeting and apologies were received from Councillor Jenny Brooks.
Cllr Warters commented that Dunnington Parish Council may wish to make similar provision and suggested that Inspector Pointon may wish to explore this initiative in other areas of the city.
Cllr Warters introduced Roy Wallington who gave an overview of the redevelopment proposals for the Burnholme site. These include:
Cllr Warters thanked [name removed] for his presentation.
Cllr Warters thanked the representatives from each group for their interesting and informative presentations.
Cllr Warters thanked residents for their attendance and contributions.
They advised that Councillor Mark Warters , also a councillor for Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward, had submitted a series of photographs taken at different locations of the site and these were circulated to Members for their information.
Councillor Warters spoke as the Ward Member. He felt that the Vale of York Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) and Unity Health did not wish to retain a surgery on the Hull Road site. He asked what role the University had taken in the decision to move the practice.
Councillor Warters raised the following issues:
· Councillor Warters commented on the costs of the Public Information Report and associated legal costs. He also referred to the legal costs arising from the decision to initially edit the webcast of the Council meeting.
· Referring to agenda item 6, Councillor Warters expressed his concerns regarding the scratch card car park permit scheme and the potential for abuse of the system that was in place.
Councillor Warters tabled photographs illustrating the problems in his wards. Members agreed that this was an issue which was widespread in the city and that it would be useful to carry out a scrutiny review on this topic.
Councillor Warters questioned why an application for a House in Multiple Occupation in his ward, which he had called in for consideration had been not been brought to Committee. He spoke about the application and the distance between it and another HMO. He felt that the Council’s database of HMOs was deficient and he had tried to get the Council’s threshold of HMOs reviewed.
Cllr Warters spoke to request a review of the Article 4 Direction by the Council’s Local Plan Working Group to consider lowering the threshold for student housing.
Councillor Warters had registered to speak under public participation in relation to agenda item 5 (Report on two Petitions relating to the Relocation of the Carousel). It was agreed that he would address the committee during discussion of that agenda item.
Councillor Warters had registered to speak under public participation and addressed the committee. He stated that he wanted to ensure fairness and give committee members the opportunity to ask the carousel operators, who were in attendance, any questions which they felt relevant in the same way that they were invited to ask questions of the Director of Make it York. He expressed the view that, after 28 years of the Christmas carousel operating in St Sampson’s Square and over 3000 signatures requesting its retention in that location, the committee should request a full report to consider the reasons behind this change to York’s Christmas offer.
Cllr Warters had registered to speak on Agenda Item 5, Working with Students and Landlords and flytipping . He commended officers for finally allowing wards the opportunity to purchase additional bins. He questioned what had happened to the old bins and if parish councils would be reimbursed.
Councillor Warters spoke on a recent issue which had been raised in the media about an incident that had happened at Glen Lodge Care Home where a resident had been alleged bitten by a rodent. He gave a potted history of the Council’s Pest Control Team and the reduction in their budgets. He questioned why inspections were not conducted at night in the home or proactively.
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of agenda items 5 and 11, with particular reference to the Community Stadium project. He highlighted the section in the Annual Audit Letter relating to this project and expressed concerns regarding changes made since the procurement process and in respect of the third party commercial element of the scheme. He stated that there should be a thorough investigation of the project and stressed the need to ensure that residents received value for money from the Council’s investment.
Councillor Warters spoke in relation to ... view the full minutes text for item 23.
Councillor Warters spoke regarding Agenda Item 6) (Appeals Performance and Decision Summaries) and Agenda Item 7 (Planning Enforcement Cases Update). He made reference to one appeal case which specified that that the Inspector required that a management plan for a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) be submitted establishing the ‘types and numbers of occupants’ and he felt that this needed discussion in relation to one of the applications due to be considered on the agenda.
Representations were received from the Ward Member Councillor Warters . He informed the Committee that during the consultation period, he had been informed of five properties which were rental properties including one which was an HMO and was not on the Council’s database of registered HMOs.
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of agenda item 4 – Applications for Community Right to Bid in relation to the Derwent Arms Public House. He advised that the whole site was of value as a community asset and he believed that the field should also be included in the application.
Councillor Warters declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 5 as he held shares in the North Yorkshire Moors Potash Mine (Sirius Minerals) and having taken advice from the Monitoring Officer, felt he should withdraw from that item.
Councillor Mark Warters then addressed the committee in objection to the application. He raised concerns about the “ studentification ” of some areas of the city.
Cllr Warters was in attendance to offer his support on the recommendations in the report. He felt the actions of the Council, installing arms on benches, was to be praised. The arms were a suitable aid for the elderly and a welcomed addition to bus stop furniture to reduce the attractiveness of the benches to the drunks.
· Cllr Gunnell – assurances regarding the budgetary commitment for the Community Stadium · Cllr Warters –when the changes in the retail/leisure offer at the Community Stadium would be brought back to Members · Cllr Taylor – reputational damage to CYC/York Museums Trust regarding resident access to the Art Gallery · Cllr S Barnes – omission of Yearsley Pool and the Pool’s funding from the Executive Member’s report · Cllr Kramm – Plans to celebrate the Diamond Anniversary of York’s twinning with Münster Cllr Ayre responded directly to all the questions put to him
Cllr Brooks opened the meeting on behalf of Cllr Warters and herself and welcomed residents. It was noted the meeting had been organised in part to provide an update on the new arrangements regarding budgets and to begin to establish ward priorities
Representations in objection were received from the Ward Member, Councillor Warters . He felt that the figures used in the report were incorrect and that there were additional HMO’s on Thirkleby Way. He felt that Members should consider the parking facilities and the residential amenity.
Representations in objection were received from Councillor Warters he made reference to the increase in the percentage of HMO’s if the application was approved, magnified by being in a neighbourhood with a low percentage of HMO’s. He added that as this was a retrospective application this should have been made clearer at the start of the report.
Representations in objection were received from the Ward Member, Councillor Warters. He spoke about the parking situation and the opening hours. He noted that when the Members had arrived on the site visit that the barrier to the car park was down and locked, and suggested that it needed to be conditioned for staff and customer usage only and that cycle racks needed to be put in.
Some Members felt that Councillor Warters raised some good points in relation to cycle parking racks but felt that the opening hours were not unreasonable in an urban area. One Member pointed out that the car park was empty for most of the day as the barrier had been down.
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of the Community Stadium and its procurement. He welcomed oversight of the scheme by the Community Stadium Lead Members Group. He also questioned the possible use of outside consultants to bring the scheme to completion.
General Remit Cllr Warters thanked the Executive for their review of the 20mph rollout and signage. He also requested review of the use of the CCTV car in Murton Lane, Murton , highlighted concern at the costs of the Lendal Bridge/ Coppergate repayment schemes and requested details of the agreement between York City Knights and the Council in relation to the Community Stadium project.
Councillor Warters declared a personal interest in agenda item 4a as he knew the applicant through attendance at Police & Crime Business meetings.
Councillor Warters declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in agenda item 4a as he knows the applicant through his membership on the Foss Internal Drainage Board.
Matters within the remit of the Executive Cllr Warters welcomed the new Executive Members and expressed support for their back to basic proposals outlined in their 12 point policy plan. In particular he highlighted suggestions for improvements to traffic congestion, bin collections and highway signage particularly that connected with the 20mph limits.
In relation to Cllr Warters suggestions in respect of 20mph zone signage, Cllr Aspden confirmed that one of the administration’s priorities across the city was a review of signage. In consultation with local residents he confirmed that a report had been requested setting out costs/legal implications etc of removing signage.
Representations were received from Councillor Warters. He urged Members to not feel compelled to grant permission even if Officers reported that it fell within the Council’s percentage of less than 10% of houses being HMOs within 100 metres of the site under consideration. He felt 10% of houses being shared houses, harmed a community’s make up and Badger Hill should be assessed as a distinct community.
Representations were received from Councillor Warters , he mentioned that if planning permission was granted that there would be a 50% concentration of HMO’s on the terrace, in which the property was located. He stated there was inadequate soundproofing, no provision for off street parking and despite the proposed planning condition evidence showed that that there would be no garden maintenance.
http://www.york.gov.uk/directory/5/primary_schools ” (iii) From Cllr Warters “The Leader refers to a new residential care home in the community hub in Burnholme , I will ask the same question I have asked numerous times at Cabinet without a satisfactory answer. Will the Leader rule out any development on the sports pitches and green field elements of the Burnholme school site and if not why not?” The Leader replied:
“Cllr Warters certainly should win the Lord Mayor’s Special Star Prize for persistence. Whether he would win the prize for effectiveness is rather more debatable.
Councillor Warters spoke in respect of agenda item 8 (Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report) with specific reference to the Internal Audit Memorandum dated 22 January 2015 regarding the allocation of funding for highways maintenance schemes.
Councillor Warters expressed his concerns regarding the way in which funding had been allocated for highways repairs and stated that he had asked the Chief Executive to investigate as he believed that this had been subject to political manipulation.
Councillor Warters stated that the investigation by internal audit had demonstrated that there had been weaknesses in the process and he was concerned that this may also apply to other aspects of Council business.
Cllr Warters requested Cabinet’s assurance that all the green field site and surrounding playing fields on the Burnholme site would be retained.
Cllr Warters expressed support to a reference to Outer Ring Road ‘Changes’ rather than ‘Improvement’ as he felt recent works on the A1237 had not provided an improvement in traffic flow. He asked Members therefore to support Option 2 and suspend the scheme.
Report on Interim Evaluation of the Anti Social Behaviour Hub Cllr Warters expressed concern that this report was being considered by Cabinet, prior to its consideration by the Community Safety Overview & Scrutiny Committee the following day.
Councillor Warters raised the following issues:
· Following a response received to a Freedom of Information request, Councillor Warters raised concerns regarding the relationship between officers and developers.
· Referring to paragraph 7 of the report on Internal Audit Plan Consultation and Counter Fraud Risk Assessment, Councillor Warters requested that the community stadium project be considered by Mazars immediately.
Members considered a full application from Councillor Mark Warters for the use of the car park and forecourt at West Offices as a traveller site with three caravan pitches and associated bin storage area.
Councillor Mark Warters , the applicant, addressed the committee. He stated that this application presented the opportunity for the council which had for a number of years advocated extra gypsy caravan sites at Elvington , Nayburn , Rufforth and the withdrawn site at Dunnington and expanded the site at Osbaldwick . He responded to issues raised in the officer’s report explaining that West Offices would be the both the amenity block and management building for the site.
Members considered a full application from Councillor Mark Warters for the erection of a statue on the traffic island at Station Rise.
Councillor Mark Warters addressed the committee as the applicant. He expressed dismay that the officer’s report contained little information on the proposed statue. He asked Members to consider the implications that refusing this application might have on any future applications for statues in the city.
Councillor Mark Warters , raised concerns with regard to the loss of a family home to the letting market and questioned the accuracy of the HMO database and whether it gave a true picture of the number of HMOs in Osbaldwick taking into account those which had been set up without planning permission.
Councillor Warters made a number of comments in relation to the remit of the Committee and to specific items on the agenda.
In response to comments raised by Councillor Warters under Public Participation, the Cabinet Member, stated that the decision made in regards to the implementation of budget savings on council funded local bus services was to re-examine the criteria for consultation. However a date could not be given for when this criteria would be finalised and the Cabinet Member felt that it would not be included within the budget proposals.
The author of the report confirmed to Members following a question posed earlier during Public Participation by Councillor Warters , that she was the Interim Director of City and Environmental Services. She took the Members through the report and gave reasons for why she felt that a review was needed to look the sources of funding and areas of likely growth, she underlined that this was a management report and had been redacted as there were management and HR implications.
Councillor Warters spoke on the following issues:
Councillor Warters expressed his objection to the use of the word “success” in respect of the 20mph South Bank pilot project and stated that a more neutral word should have been used. He also commented that the term “preferred bidder” in relation to the Community Stadium project, should have made clear that this was the only bidder, although it was acknowledged that “preferred bidder” was a term used in procurement.
Councillor Warters expressed concern at the proposals relating to the Lendal Bridge decision which he felt should be taken at the budget Cabinet meeting. He also questioned why the deadline for repayment was being extended to June 2015, following the election, and for details of the budget to cover repayments.
Councillor Warters asked the Chair to clarify his role following the recent changes to Cabinet. The Chair confirmed that Local Plan issues would now fall under the Leader and that it was his intention to carry on as Chair of the Local Plan Working Group.
Councillor Warters asked that it be recorded that he voted against the motion to approve the application.
Matter within the remit of the Committee Cllr Warters spoke in relation to savings proposals for the Eco Depot, in particular to proposed staffing reductions and the removal of the pest control service which affected staff morale. He requested the Cabinet Member to allow scrutiny of the proposals for the pest control service, prior to a final decision being made.
Councillor Warters raised concerns about waterlogged properties at the Burnholme Club site. An application for development on this site had been previously approved by the Committee.
Councillor Warters queried why the “number of homes built in York, especially affordable homes” had been included as an outcome which the committee may wish to monitor when, at the previous meeting, the Committee had not been able to ask the Cabinet Member questions on the Local Plan as they had been told that this was not in the committee’s remit. Officers stated that issues in respect of planning fell within the remit of the Economic and City Development Overview and Scrutiny Committee but that functions such as the social housing landlord responsibilities now fell within the Community Safety Overview and Scrutiny Committee’s remit.
Minutes of Cabinet Meeting, 1 July 2014 Cllr Warters , spoke in relation to the minutes of the last Cabinet meeting, in particular Minute 14 – The Future of the Burnholme College Site. He disputed reference in the minutes that briefing sessions had been offered to neighbouring Parish Council’s and Residents Associations. He also requested removal of the paragraph in the report which had stated that, as the business case developed, it may be necessary to consider use of some of the remaining green space for housing.
Cllr Warters , also raised concerns at the recommendations in the Lendal Bridge report he asked Cabinet to draw a line under this issue and asking for Cabinet Members resignations.
Councillor Warters also addressed the meeting as a Calling-In member, expressing his support for the earlier speaker’s comments and the need for further scrutiny of this scheme. He reiterated his opposition to the proposals and questioned, if approved, would refurbishment schemes outside the city be undertaken using similar design and cost principles.
2013-14 Finance and Performance Year End Report Councillor Warters referred to the challenges of the current financial climate, expressing concern at the recent senior Council appointments during cuts in services and low staff morale.
The Future of the Burnholme College site Councillor Warters spoke to welcome recognition that the Osbaldwick ward would be affected by the proposals for this site. He went on to express the Parish Council, Meadlands Area Residents Association, and his opposition to any development on the playing fields at the College site.
Showing the latest 300 of 406.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Warters attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Mar 2026 | Council | Motions on Notice (8.51pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2025 | Council | Adoption of the City of York Local Plan (9:21 pm) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Jan 2021 | Planning Main | Whitehall Grange, Wigginton Road, York [20/01479/FUL] | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Dec 2017 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Feb 2017 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Dec 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2015 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Feb 2015 | Council | Civic Announcements and Announcement of Lord Mayor and Sheriff Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Dec 2014 | Council | Honorary Freeman | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Dec 2013 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2012 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 May 2012 | Council | Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Council Structure and Outside Bodies 2012/13 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Dec 2011 | Council | Civic Announcements and Lord Mayor Elect | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Oct 2011 | Council | Freedom of the City | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 May 2011 | Council | Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Executive, Committees and Other Bodies 2011/2012 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Warters was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 7 of 59 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Warters declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Oct 2015 | Local Plan Working Group, item 6 | Councillor Warters declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 5 as he held shares in the North Yorkshire Moors Potash Mine (Sirius Minerals) and having taken advice from the Monitoring Officer, felt he should withdraw from that item. | |
| 23 Jul 2015 | Planning Main, item 19 | Councillor Warters declared a personal interest in agenda item 4a as he knew the applicant through attendance at Police & Crime Business meetings. | |
| 25 Jun 2015 | Planning Main, item 11 | Councillor Warters declared a personal non-prejudicial interest in agenda item 4a as he knows the applicant through his membership on the Foss Internal Drainage Board. |
Where Councillor Warters sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | May 2011 | 65 | |
| Licensing/Gambling Hearing | Committee Member | Jan 2021 | 54 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Licensing and Regulatory Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2016 | 10 | |
| Planning Main | Committee Member | Oct 2013 | 46 | |
| East Area Planning Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 24 | |
| Executive | Attendee | Jun 2011 | 24 | |
| Local Plan Working Group | Committee Member | Oct 2011 | 14 | |
| Area Planning Sub-Committee | Attendee | Jun 2013 | 14 | |
| Osbaldwick and Derwent Ward Committee (Please contact the Communities Team for further information) | Committee Member | Jul 2011 | 13 | |
| Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 12 | |
| Communities and Environment Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2013 | 11 | |
| Economic Development and Transport Policy and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2015 | 10 | |
| Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2012 | 8 | |
| Effective Organisation Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2011 | 7 | |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Attendee | Mar 2013 | 7 | |
| Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee (Calling In) | Committee Member | Jul 2012 | 6 | |
| Planning Committee B | Committee Member | Jan 2024 | 6 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Transport - Expired | Attendee | Jul 2011 | 4 | |
| Decision Session- Executive Member for Finance and Performance | Attendee | Dec 2014 | 2 | |
| Economic Development and Transport Policy and Scrutiny Committee (Pre Decision Calling In) | Committee Member | Nov 2015 | 2 | |
| Decision Session - Executive Member for Environment and Climate Emergency | Committee Member | Nov 2015 | 2 | |
| Grass Verges Scrutiny Review Task Group | Committee Member | May 2016 | 2 | |
| Decision Session - Cabinet Member for Environmental Services, Planning and Sustainability | Attendee | Nov 2011 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny Work Planning Event | Attendee | May 2014 | 1 | |
| Staffing Matters and Urgency Committee | Substitute | Mar 2015 | 1 | |
| Joint Standards Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2019 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.