Decision To recommend to the Council: 1 (a) That they increase the internal audit budget by £80,000 per annum to allow improvements to be made recognising that this will reflect the high cost of using private firms compared with direct provision in the short term. This sum to be financed from loan charges savings generated by the Department of Finance through debt rescheduling. (b) (i) That the internal audit plan be reviewed, reducing the total number of core audit days making provision for a value for money perspective in audit activity and developing performance assessment and best value appraisal work and; (ii) that the Council should identify a key player who will develop the managerial and value for Money/Best Value roles within the service. (c) That the Council negotiate a 3 year partnership agreement with an appropriate external contractor to ensure continuity of provision meantime including managing the function and some training in management/Value for Money/Best Value techniques. (d) That the Council review the matter in 3 years time to assess whether partnership or direct service delivery is the way ahead for the Council thereafter. (e) That the Chief Internal Auditor should continue as at present to report to the Director of Finance to maintain corporate identity but with the right to report directly to the Chief Executive and the Audit Committee if there is any disagreement with the Director of Finance. (Ref: Report by Professor Arthur Midwinter, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
97 AGENDAITEMNO, b Review of Internal Audit Service: Report fur Argyll and Bute Coutzcil
Professor Arthur Midwhter
1. Purpose 1.1 The purpose of this report is to advise the Council regarding its internal audit service. My remit is to review the current structure, resources, tasks and reporting arrangements for the internal audit function, through analysis of existing documentation, consultation with users and staff, benchmarking with comparable authorities and to assess the options for development. The approach meets the principles of the Executive’s Best Value initiative.
1.2This report sets out my findings and recommendations for change. Our initial agreement suggested the final report would take account of Audit Scotland’s national VFM study and local audit guide, but there has been some slippage with that timetable, and it is not yet in the public domain. I have, however, had access to the draft report, which is mainly concerned with matters of professional practice. I propose, therefore, to produce a 0 supplementary report for the Council assessing the implications of the national report when it is available.
1.3I am comfortable working within the context of Best Value principles for the review. Best Value is not a new approach, but one which builds on the corporate planning, VFM and competitive tendering experience of the past, and formalises them into a statutory requirement. It advocates a rational management framework with objectives, options and perfomance 98 c
management, using techniques- and concepts such as clear service specification and performance monitoring, with a new emphasis on continuous improvement. . c
1.4I am less comfortable with some of the assumptions and language of the BV advocates, which often assumes that a perfectly consistent hierarchy of objectives is feasible. Authorities are complex organisations which can be more rational, but not fully rational, and judgement remains necessary as information will remain imperfect. Language such as ‘stakeholders’ or ’ , slick consultancy speak, and I prefer clear, simple language which ‘ ~ C S is sets out the arguments, issues and evidence on which recommendations are made. The four Cs - challenge, compare, consult and complete - simply mean that the review should demonstrate there is a need for the function; compare internal audit arrangements with authorities with similar characteristics; consult with clients of the service; and appraise the alternative means of delivering it. In theory, this approach could be comprehensive and time consuming, in practice I shall concentrate on the realistic options. The remainder of the report is structured around the four analytical elements of a Best Value review;
1.5In completing the fieldwork and, background research, I have been greatly assisted by members of the councils staff, the Accounts Commission and Price Waterhouse Coopers. The judgements and recommendations made, however, are my responsibility. 99
2. The Need for an Internal Audit Functiun 2.1 The first issue to address is the core one - is an internal audit function necessary. Authorities in England have a statutory duty to provide an internal audit function, but in Scotland, the statutory requirement is for every authority: "to make urrangements for the pruper udministration of their financial ufluirs and shall secure that the proper oficer has responsibility for their affuirs ''
2.2Internal audit is widely regarded as an essential element of such 0 proper administration in terrns of professional practice, and CIPFA has issued an internal audit code of practice. The function is indeed a long standing one reflecting the British tradition of promoting probity in the management of the public finances, through ensuring authorities had efficienct systems of accounting, authorisation and fmancial control; and that expenditure is legally incurred on approved services.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Internal audit summary of activitiesDecision The Committee noted the contents of the report. (Reference: Report by Chief Internal Auditor dated 24 March ...
Internal audit annual plan 2017 - 2018Decision The Committee agreed and approved the Internal Audit Annual Plan 2017/18 (Reference: Report by Chief Interna...
External audit plan 2017 - 2018Decision The Committee noted the contents of the report. (Reference: Report by Audit Scotland dated March 2017, submi...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.