CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Executive, Thursday 21 February 2008 at 10.00am

ISLAND COMMISSION TRANSPORT WORKSHOP - SHETLAND 22/23 NOVEMBER 2007

Noted Executive 1 paper

Executive noted this item on Thursday 21 February 2008. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item6

Resolved

Decision To note the contents of the report. (Reference: Report by Director of Development Services dated 28 January 2008, submitted). *
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Summary

1.1The Islands Commission, one of the Geographical Commissions of the Conference of Peripheral Maritime Regions, organised a workshop in November 2007 to discuss member’s experience of Public Service Obligations (PSO) in the Maritime and Air transport sectors. This paper outlines the findings of the workshop which was hosted by Shetland Islands Council, 22 / 23 November 2007.

Recommendation

2.1That the Executive note the contents of the paper.

Background

3.1The workshop was attended by a variety of island authorities each of whom gave their experience of PSO in the Maritime and Air transport sectors. Attendees included:

• The National Rail Authority of Denmark (responsible for the procurement of rail and ferry transport) • Regional Municipality of Bornholm (Danish island in the Baltic Sea) • Hiiumaa County Government (Estonia) • National Public Transport Agency (Sweden) • Gotlands Kommun (Swedish island in the Baltic Sea) • Shetland Islands Council • Orkney Islands Council • Comhairle nan Eilean Siar • Argyll and Bute Council

3.2A general debate followed the presentations from each member regarding the implementation of PSO and whether or not they are the best way to achieve cost-effective services for island communities.

3.3The information gathered at the workshop will be used by the Island Commission to make representations to the European Commission and suggest any changes to legislation.

4. DETAIL

Maritime Transport – key points

4.1The EU has taken a more flexible approach to tendering transport services, e.g.:

Page 1 of 3 • no obligation to tender if the annual average passenger numbers in the preceding two years is less than 300,000. • no obligation to tender when a shipping operator is owned entirely by a public authority and acting under the orders of that authority (ANAV ruling).

4.2In addition, the way that EU law is being implemented has also evolved, e.g.:

• tendering a, “bundle” of routes, rather than requiring them to be separated individually (i.e. CalMac). • “reverse tendering” – i.e. the tendering being on the cost/quality of services provided for a set amount of pubic funding. • other factors may be taken into consideration rather than just the, “lowest bidder”. • possibility of increasing sailing frequencies during a PSO period.

4.3However, it remains that the tendering procedure is still required in most cases by EU law in order to allocate public funds to a shipping operator. The experience from the members attending the workshop was similar to that of Scotland:

• the tendering process was complex, long and expensive. • only one tenderer left at the conclusion of the process, despite their being a number of expressions of interest at the start. • the remaining tenderer is usually the incumbent operator. • the tender value usually always increases.

4.4The question was raised as to why the tendering process was largely ineffective on most island routes and a number of explanations were offered:

• any new operator wishing to compete against a well-established business tends to be at a disadvantage. • the ownership of the vessels and depreciation rules play a role in the effectiveness of competition – i.e. the limited duration of PSO (usually 6 years) does not allow an operator to fully depreciate new vessels. • there is a lack of “standard” pier/harbour infrastructure – thus vessels may require to be “unique” in order to use the landing facilities.

4.5The Islands Commission will ask the European Commission to undertake a detailed and comprehensive study of the experience of the various EU islands in the field of tendering for maritime services. This will establish:

• when tendering has proved beneficial to island communities • when tendering has not proved beneficial – why • the costs associated with tendering (allow a comparison) • any instances of best practice that have led to a valued service in terms of island communities / economies.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
ISLAND COMMISSION TRANSPORT WORKSHOP: SHETLAND 22/23 NOVEMBER 2007Agenda 72 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

18 of 22 attended
CH
Charlotte HanburyMember, absent
MA
Maureen ArthurMember, apologies
PC
Paul CannopPublic, expected
RC
Councillor Robin CurrieMember, present
VD
Councillor Vivien DanceMember, present
FF
Fiona FisherMember, present
GF
Councillor George FreemanMember, present
AH
Councillor Alison HayMember, present
DK
Councillor Donald KellyMember, present
DM
Councillor Donald MacdonaldMember, present
DM
Councillor Duncan MacIntyreMember, present
RM
Councillor Robert MacintyreMember, present

All 22 on the meeting page

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. ISLAND COMMISSION TRANSPORT WORKSHOP - SHETLAND 22/23 NOVEMBER 2007This decision
  2. Cpmr islands commission proposal for an island region co-operation initiative in the field of transportNoted

More from Argyll and Bute Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Apr 2012 Leader's reportDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Leader of the Council dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 EnvironmentDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for Environment dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 European affairsDecision Noted the report. (Reference: Report by Spokesperson for European Issues dated April 2012, submitted) Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Social affairsDecision 1. Noted the report; and 2. Agreed that adoption of the Learning Disability Service Users Conference should ... Noted Open
19 Apr 2012 Education capital programme 2012/13 to 2014/15Decision Approved the proposed projects to invest the additional capital allocation of £2.126m in asset sustainabilit... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies