Decision Having regard to the Stage 2 Townscape Heritage Initiative Submission and FBC, the PMB recommended to the Executive on 16 April that – 1. The £300,000 allocated to the Campbeltown THI via the outline business case developed through CHORD is committed to the Campbeltown THI project over the next 5 years; and 2. In the event that the further £100,000 is not available that the project will be scaled down accordingly; [Note: with reference to decision 2 it was confirmed following the meeting that the further £100, 000 has been committed to this project] (Reference: Report by Director of Development Services and Stage 2 Townscape Heritage Initiative Submission dated 5 March 2009, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
Ref Project Monitor’s Comments– on Final Draft Response
1 General There are fundamental issues with the Stage 2 submission which require to be addressed – not least the proposed increase in the common fund and the resultant funding gap and the significant shifts in approved purposes between the two stages. The technical elements of this Stage 2 submission in terms of the costings, The socio-economic chapter has been amended to include the most up to date condition survey etc are all well presented and extremely detailed, meeting statistics available (from A & B Council) and some further explanation as to HLF’s requirements. why the earlier studies remain relevant and have been adopted by the The submission itself however does not “hang together” particularly well. There Council. are inconsistencies in figures presented in different sections and the narrative is Section 4.01.03 gives some detail of the set of integrated strategies and at times somewhat confusing. In particular, there seems to be a blurring of demonstrates how the THI fits with these. conservation management plan into the more specific THI proposals in terms of A new section had been added as an introduction to section 1.00 to try and management, training, community engagement etc which contradicts or adds to explain the complex relationship between the various initiatives and the work proposals elsewhere in the submission. Someone needs to read the whole to be carried out by the Town Centre manager. submission through again thoroughly to ensure that there is consistency throughout and that the proposals for the running of the THI – from management The Training plan now appears as Section 3.05
to training initiatives to community engagement etc – appear where they make most sense and are not hidden away in an appendix. An example of this is the excellent training plan which is provided in full in Appendix 03_05 the proposals from which are not done justice in any part of the main submission. As a general point, which is discussed in more depth below, the overlap, management and joint benefits of the THI, CARS, CHORD and town centre regeneration schemes are not adequately considered. It is not enough to look that the THI in isolation. Ref Project Monitor’s Comments Response
Additional key issues identified in the Stage 1 award letter
2 In terms of addressing the additional key issues which were identified at Stage 1 by HLF, the submission goes a long way to achieving this. In particular Stage 2 has presented a holistic strategy for the THI rather than a building by building approach. The proposals to actively involve the building owners and business community are also well developed.
3 There are innovative proposals to encourage proactive building management by Log books - added a phrase at 3.04.10 owners although this does not appear to include log books as a condition of grant as was suggested in the offer letter.
4 The proposals for use of the Town Hall were to include the possibility of public There will be no direct competition here. uses that complement Aqualibrium. To an extent the proposals put forward are Text added in Section 4 to expand on this for additional public use of and access to the Town Hall but there is no explicit link to Aqualibrium. As I did not undertake the Stage 1 assessment I am slightly unclear why this was set out but I assume that it was to ensure that the facilities in/uses of the Town Hall were not in direct competition to what is already available at Aqualibrium. It would be useful if the level of any potential competition between the two buildings could be examined and explained.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow CHORD Programme Management Board at Argyll and Bute and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.