Decision The Executive agreed:- 1. To note the contents of the report; 2. In line with CHORD Governance arrangements, to recommend to the Council the reallocation of a proportion of the capital allocation for Campbeltown CHORD (£480,000) towards an All Weather Pitch Facility; and 3. To note that the Marina proposal as envisaged thus far is not financially viable and accept that work will be carried out to establish the viability of an alternative proposal within the resources which remain available to the Campbeltown CHORD Project. (Reference: Extract from Minutes of CHORD Programme Management Board of 10 March 2011, tabled and Report by Executive Director – Development and Infrastructure Services dated 2 March 2011, issued)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
1.1This report details the current position and viability of two proposed capital projects in Campbeltown that have previously been considered at CHORD Boards and outlines how funding can be allocated.
Recommendations
2.1That the CHORD Programme Management Board: • consider the contents of the report; • in line with CHORD governance arrangements, recommend to the Executive the reallocation of a proportion of the capital allocation for Campbeltown CHORD (£480,000) towards an All Weather Pitch Facility; • agree that no further work is undertaken in regard to the marina proposals.
3. DETAIL
3.1Three projects in Campbeltown were brought forward for further development following an outline business case process. Two of these projects, the Townscape Heritage Initiative and Kinloch Road are being implemented following the development of a full business case. The third project, a marina proposal, is considered to be unviable, thus the capital allocation for this project cannot be utilised.
3.2Reports to both the Campbeltown CHORD Project Board and CHORD Programme Management Board in January 2010 considered the development of a business case for the construction of a new All Weather Pitch Facility (AWPF) in Campbeltown. It was proposed that this project could be progressed as the part of the CHORD Programme.
3.3It was agreed, at that juncture, that a business case should be taken forward by the Head of Facility Services, separate to the CHORD Programme.
3.4The business case for the AWPF is now complete and concludes that this is a viable project with a very supportive Sportscotland bid.
3.5Similar to the development of the business case for the AWPF, a technical / feasibility exercise has been undertaken for a marina proposal in Campbeltown. This piece of work was required to determine whether or not the project should progress to full business case.
3.6The technical / feasibility study concluded that whilst a marina is technically feasible within Campbeltown Harbour, the proposal would not be ‘self financing’ by virtue of high capital costs (£2.7million) and insufficient revenue generation over the term of the project.
3.7The financial model for the marina proposal demonstrated that neither the capital costs nor an allowance for depreciation are fundable. The most optimistic scenario predicts a Net Present Value of -£169k when capital costs are excluded and depreciation included. 3.8 The Campbeltown CHORD Project Board considered these findings in December 2010 and instructed the project team to undertake further work in terms of:
• investigating lower capital costs/ alternative technical solutions (although it is anticipated that this would have considerable detrimental impact on achieving the original project objectives); • further exploring funding sources; • undertaking a further risk assessment to identify and reduce project risks; • further engaging with stakeholders in respect of the findings of the technical / feasibility study, and; • assessing potential operating models.
3.9The capital funding allocation from the CHORD Programme for the marina proposal is £1,160,000.
3.10Therefore, given current budgetary pressures, the probable poor value for money that the marina would represent and that CHORD funds must be utilised on viable projects, there is an opportunity to consider part-funding the AWPF from the CHORD Programme as previously proposed.
3.11At present there is no allocation within the Council capital programme for the AWPF. A sum of £480,000 would be proposed to “match” the funding application of £380,000 submitted to Sportscotland. The outcome of the funding bid to Sportscotland will be known in late March.
3.12The additional work instructed by the Campbeltown CHORD Project Board in regard to the marina proposal is awaiting confirmation of match funding from the Sailwest INTERREG programme.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.