DECISIONS That the Democratic Services Manager be requested to review the recommendations of the Forward Plan Scrutiny Working Group, and make any necessary amendments to the Forward Plan, and if necessary, submit a further report to Cabinet Executive in respect of any Constitutional Amendments. Reasons: 1. It is appropriate for Cabinet Executive to consider recommendations made to it by the Scrutiny Commission. 2. Advising Scrutiny Commission of decisions made by Cabinet Executive in respect of Scrutiny recommendations ensures transparency in the decision making process and assists Scrutiny with monitoring Cabinet Executive responses.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting.Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk
SCRUTINY COMMISSION REPORT on REVIEW OF THE FORWARD PLAN OF KEY DECISIONS Advised by the Forward Plan Working Group Led by Cllr Phil Fox, Commissioner
26 January 2009
1 Introduction
As a result of queries at a Commissioners meeting regarding the amount of reports on the Cabinet Executive agenda that were considered key decisions, but not included on any Forward Plan, and therefore taken under General Exception rules, the Commissioners decided to examine the purpose and content of the Forward Plan, and the use of General Exception and Special Urgency rules.
The Scrutiny Commission set up a working group comprising: Councillors: P. Fox, A.Tanner, J. Forey, R. Ward, J. Peachey and J. Bell. The group met to consider the scope of their review and agreed on a short piece of work to:
• Define the purpose and usage of the Forward Plan. • Gauge best practice by comparing other local authority forward plans. • Determine the meaning of Key Decision. • Examine the use of General Exception and Special Urgency rules.
The working group findings focused mainly on the format and content of the Forward Plan. Normally, any need for revision of these would simply be discussed with the Leader of the Council and implemented without need for bringing a report to the Cabinet Executive. However, this review raised issues that might lead to possible policy changes and new instructions for officers. In these circumstances it seems appropriate to raise these recommendations with the Cabinet Executive in the context of the Forward Plan.
2 The Forward Plan
The Forward Plan of Key Decisions is a statutory obligation and is produced by the Leader of the Council for two purposes:
• To enable Scrutiny to examine decisions before they are made, and offer the Cabinet Executive further information and advice to aid decision making. • To inform the public of major issues, and when they will be decided, to enable them to attend Cabinet meetings and / or make representation.
The Forward Plan is a key tool for Scrutiny in its role of bringing improvement and should be the first instrument used for determining their work. Good use of the Forward Plan will enable Scrutiny to provide further comment, information, public views and assessment of possible effects that will enable
1 APPENDIX A
the Cabinet Executive to make better informed decisions. Examining proposed decisions in this way will often eliminate the need for call-in.
3 Blaby’s Forward Plan
The Forward Plan is published on the council’s website and is available in the council offices locked notice-board, for members of the public. It is attached at the end of Cabinet papers and goes out with the Cabinet agenda. It is considered at the Commissioners meeting.
Although the statutory obligation is to publish Key Decisions, in common with many other local authorities, Blaby includes all decisions and aims to identify those that are key by printing them in bold.
The landscape style, tabular format and content headings are similar to other local authority Forward Plans considered best practice.
4 Findings of the Review
4.1The front cover of the Forward Plan should describe its purpose in clear and simple terms. It should explain the meaning of Key Decision and show how these will be identified.
The first paragraph of the Blaby Forward Plan carries unnecessary information, inaccuracies and complex detail. It erroneously states that only Key Decisions can be called-in and provides no explanation of ‘Key Decision’.
As the Forward Plan relates to the Scrutiny role of examining decisions before they are made, it is not appropriate to refer to Call-in on this document.
Determination 1
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.