DECISIONS 1. That the conclusion drawn by LG Futures in their report which analyses the Council’s relative overall performance in delivering value for money be accepted. 2. That further work is done to understand and challenge value for money in those service areas highlighted in the report where the Council’s performance and expenditure data compares unfavourably with the benchmarked authorities. Reasons: To understand the Council’s overall relative position in providing Value for Money and increase awareness of the delivery of Value for Money within individual service areas.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting.Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk
Methodology i. Clearly, it should be recognised that the Audit Commission’s VFM profiles are based upon different indicators to those that were available and that we were requested to analyse for the purposes of this exercise. However, of the available National Indicator data provided to us for comparator authorities, we have chosen those indicators that we deem to reflect most clearly appropriate measures of performance for individual services. The use of alternative or additional choices of indicators would therefore potentially affect the outcome of our exercise.
ii. In order to compare expenditure and performance levels, the analysis ranks Blaby’s relative position for expenditure and performance by quartiles. It also calculates standardised values for expenditure and each of the performance indicators.
iii. Standardised values are based on the position of a number (in this case Blaby’s expenditure or performance) within a group of numbers (the Nearest Neighbour Group). They are based on the mean average for the group and the degree of variation within the group and are expressed as the number of standard deviations that a number is above or below the mean average for the group.
iv. For values below the mean, a negative standardised value for expenditure equates to the authority spending less than the average for the group. Similarly, a negative value for performance would mean the authority is performing below the average for the group. Therefore, when the two figures are compared, i.e. the standardised values for performance and expenditure; if performance is a higher value than expenditure, the council is performing at a higher level than would be expected of it.
v. If Blaby’s standardised values for performance were in line with expenditure, it would demonstrate that, in value for money terms, it is performing at a similar level to the Nearest Neighbour Group, of which 14 out of the 16 authorities have a VFM score of 3 or above. Overall Judgement vi. Blaby has a significant number of areas where it outperforms the average level of performance for the group. An overall measure of Blaby’s relative expenditure and performance has been calculated and Blaby was the 8th highest performing council of the Nearest Neighbour group, with performance levels in line with the mean average, whilst expenditure was the lowest for the group.
vii. In summary, using the relevant National Indicator data available to us, Blaby was therefore able to match performance against councils perceived by the Audit Commission to be delivering better value for money, based on their Use of Resources VFM score, despite utilising a lower level of resources.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.