DECISIONS 1. That the report of the Financial Services Group Manager be noted. 2. That the current contract with HSBC be allowed to continue in the short term (3 months) in order for HSBC to provide a more competitive proposition. 3. That the overdraft facility be reduced to £50,000. Reasons: 1. To enable HSBC to provide a comparable quote to those illustrated in the benchmarking exercise. 2. The cashflow of the Council is closely monitored and there is provision for money to be held to ensure we do not require a higher facility. This enables the avoidance of £11,000 of unnecessary cost.
Word for word from the decision Blaby published for this meeting.Source: democracy.blaby.gov.uk
1.1To provide an update to members of the Cabinet Executive on the progress regarding the renewal of the existing banking services contract with HSBC.
Recommendations
2.1That the report be noted.
2.2That the current contract with HSBC be allowed to continue in the short term (3 months) in order for HSBC to provide a more competitive proposition.
2.3That the overdraft facility be reduced to £50,000.
3. Reasons for Decisions Recommended
3.1To enable HSBC to provide a comparable quote to those illustrated in the benchmarking exercise.
3.2The cashflow of the Council is closely monitored and there is provision for money to be held to ensure we do not require a higher facility. This enables the avoidance of £11,000 of unnecessary cost.
4. Forward Plan
4.1Forward Plan Reference Number: 04/10(108)
5. Key Decision
5.1Yes. 6. Matters for Consideration
6.1The current banking services contract with HSBC expired on 31st March 2010. HSBC has proposed a renewal of that contract for two years, which incorporates rates for the processing of cash banked, cheques presented and data for reconciliation purposes. In addition, HSBC are now looking to charge for the provision of an overdraft facility.
6.2The Council had previously carried out a full tendering exercise in 2005, and had received expressions of interest from three banks. It had engaged with Focus on Banking, an independent banking advisory service, to carry out a benchmarking exercise. This company advises many organisations within both the public and private sectors.
6.3Focus on Banking have again been engaged to review the current rates, benchmarking, against their own database, and report their recommendations. The benchmarking exercise therefore compared the terms proposed by HSBC with those of the Co-op and Natwest, the banks most likeliest to respond should it be decided to go to a full tender process.
6.4Focus on Banking have advised that banks are now bringing in charges for overdraft facilities to the public sector. The Council have previously had an overdraft facility of £1.5m which has rarely been utilised. This has previously been a free facility unless utilised. If this level of overdraft facility if retained a charge of £11,000 would be made to the Council.
6.5Focus on Banking have recommended that the transactional elements of the HSBC proposal be challenged, particularly the provision of data files. If the cost of data files could be reduced the HSBC proposal would be comparable with both Co-op and Natwest.
6.6Given the previous observations, it is recommended that :
• The overdraft facility be reduced to £50,000. The cashflow of the Council is closely monitored and there is provision for money to be held to ensure we do not require a higher facility. This enables the avoidance of £11,000 of unnecessary cost. • That HSBC be given time to demonstrate how the Council may obtain the reconciliation data at a zero cost using the current internet access and therefore avoiding costs of £8,000.
6.7HSBC are comfortable to continue within the terms of the current contract until the data facility issue has been resolved. A letter will be forthcoming in relation to the overdraft limit.
7. Other Relevant Considerations
7.1Human Rights Act 1998
Human rights have been considered but there are no overarching matters for concern in relation to this report. 7.2 Legal Implications
Contractual implications of this have been discussed with HSBC and are detailed in the main body of this report.
7.3Human Resources Implications
There are no human resources implications.
7.4Risk Assessment & Business Continuity
There are no risk, business continuity or resilience issues.
7.5Equalities
No Equalities Impact and Needs Assessment (EINA) is required for this report.
8. Other Options Considered
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.