Cabinet RESOLVED to note the content of the report and approve the following approach regarding the payment of refunds in respect of water charges: (1) Refunds for both current and former tenants being calculated from the contractual start dates i.e. Thames Water Utilities 2003 and Affinity Water from 2005. (2) Refunds for current tenants being issued to their rent accounts with those in credit able to apply for the amount to be debited to their bank accounts, and if in arrears, the refund being used to offset the arrears owed. (3) Refunds for former tenants being: (i) issued to their rent accounts where former tenants have rent arrears to offset any arrears owed to the Council; (ii) paid into leaseholders accounts (who were tenants at the time) if they are currently in occupation; and (iii) to establish a process for former tenants (with no current relationship with Brent Housing Management) to apply for a refund and ensure this was publicised with a cut-off date of two years from the point of launching the application process.
Word for word from the decision Brent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.brent.gov.uk
1.1In the early 2000’s, water companies offered Councils and social housing landlords opportunities to enter into a contractual arrangement to provide billing and collection services in return for a void allowance for empty properties and commission to reflect both the administrative costs attached and the transfer of risk and bad debt associated with these accounts. Brent Housing Partnership (BHP) on behalf of Brent Council entered into two of these arrangements, the first with Thames Water Utilities (TWU) in 2003 and later Affinity Water (AW) in 2005.
1.2In 2016, it was ruled the London Borough of Southwark, were acting as ‘water resellers’ in accordance with the Water Resale Order 2001 and 2006 due to this type of arrangement. This position was later reinforced by a 27 October 2020 Court of Appeal decision (Kingston v Moss).
1.3Following this ruling, the Council has reviewed the arrangements with TWU and AW and through this paper is seeking approval from Cabinet to issue refunds to current and former Brent Council tenants. The proposed approach is outlined in the recommendations below but the overall report recommends that both current and former tenants are refunded to the start date of the contracts.
Recommendations
2.1That Cabinet note the content of the report and approve the following approach regarding the payment of refunds in respect of water charges:
(a) Refunds for both current and former tenants are calculated from the contractual start dates i.e. Thames Water Utilities 2003 and Affinity Water from 2005.
(b) Refunds for current tenants are to be issued to their rent accounts and those in credit can then apply for the amount to be debited to their bank accounts, and if in arrears, the refund will be used to offset the arrears owed
(c) Refunds for former tenants are to be; (i) issued to their rent accounts where former tenants have rent arrears to offset any arrears owed to the Council; (ii) paid into leaseholders accounts (who were tenants at the time) if they are currently in occupation; and (iii) establish a process for former tenants (with no current relationship with Brent Housing Management) to apply for a refund and ensure this is publicised with a cut-off date of two years from the point of launching the application process.
Background
3.1In 2016, the landmark case of Jones v LB Southwark the judge ruled in its contract with TWU, Southwark had been purchasing water from TWU and reselling it to tenants at the full charge when in fact Southwark was receiving a discount and therefore was charging more commission than legally allowed. It should be noted that Southwark was able to charge a small fee for administration; this is a nominal amount of 1.5p per day per property, which equates to £5.47 per year per property. Southwark were ordered to refund the tenant any commission charged over and above £5.47 and backdate this charge to the time they either; entered into the contract or the start of the tenancy.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of the Previous MeetingCabinet RESOLVED that the minutes of the previous meeting held on Monday 12 October 2026 be approved as a correct rec...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.