Resolved (5 votes to 3) to accept the officer recommendation t o advise the Executive Councillor for City Centre and Public Places that the Planning Committee supports the proposal to: i. Reduce by ~30-40% by branch length (which equates to approximately ~70% by volume) trees T17, T21, T22, T23, & T24 , and maintain bi-annually at their reduced volume; and that cyclical pruning work is carried out to trees T18, T19, T20 and T27 to retain these trees at their current dimension; and ii. Instruct Officers’ to consider the adoption of the Joint Mitigation Protocol as policy in the forthcoming Tree Strategy.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
47. For some time now, it has been generally accepted that it is not a defence to a claim in nuisance to show that the claimant acquired, or started to occupy, her property after the nuisance had started – ie that it is no defence that the claimant has come to the nuisance. This proposition was clearly stated in Bliss 4 Bing NC 183, 186 per Tindal CJ. Coming to the nuisance appears to have been assumed not to be a defence in Sturges v Bridgman 11 Ch D 852. And in London, Brighton and South Coast Railway Co v Truman (1885) LR 11 App Cas 45, 52, Lord Halsbury LC described the idea that it was a defence to nuisance as an “old notion … long since exploded” and he also said that “whether the man went to the nuisance or the nuisance came to the man, the rights are the same” in Fleming v Hislop (1886) LR 11 App Cas 686, 697.
48. More recently, in Miller v Jackson [1977] 1 QB 966, 986-987, the majority of the Court of Appeal held that the principle was well-established. However, Lord Denning MR, in the minority, considered that the proper approach was for court to “balance the right of the cricket club to continue playing cricket on their cricket ground”, as they had done for 70 years, “as against the right of the householder”, whom he described as “a newcomer” who had built “a house on the edge of the cricket ground which four years ago was a field where cattle grazed”: see pp 976 and 981. He held that there was no nuisance given that the cricket club had “spent money, labour and love in the making of [the pitch]: and they have the right to play upon it as they have done for 70 years”, and answered with a resounding no his own rhetorical (in both senses of the word) question whether this was “all to be rendered useless to them by the thoughtless and selfish act of an estate developer in building right up to the edge of it?”: see p 978.
49. Geoffrey Lane LJ (with whom Cumming-Bruce LJ agreed) accepted, albeit with some regret, that it was not for the Court of Appeal “to alter a rule which has stood for so long”, namely “that it is no answer to a claim in nuisance for the defendant to show that the plaintiff brought the trouble on his own head by building or coming to live in a house so close to the defendant’s premises that he would inevitably be affected by the defendant’s activities, where no one had been affected previously”: p 987. Accordingly, he concluded that the claim in nuisance was made out.
50. The respondents suggest that there is authority prior to the decision in Bliss 4 Bing 183, which supports the contention that the law was somewhat different in earlier times. Leeds v Shakerley (1599) Cro Eliz 751 was cited as an authority for the proposition that coming to the nuisance was a defence, but it may well be explained on the ground that the wrong complained of was the single act of diverting a watercourse, as opposed to the continuing loss of the watercourse. In his Commentaries on the Laws of England 1st ed, (1765-1769), Vol II Chap 26, p 403, Blackstone, after explaining that a defendant can be liable in nuisance for setting up a tannery near my home, continues “but if he is first in possession of the air and I fix my habitation near him, the nuisance is of my own seeking, and must continue”. And in the criminal, public nuisance, case of R v Cross (1826) 2 Car & P 483, 484, Abbott CJ said that a defendant whose trade was said to be a nuisance to a householder or a user of a road “would be entitled to continue his trade [if] his trade [had been] legal before the erection of the houses in the one case, and the making of the road in the other”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.