CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee, Tuesday 17 November 2015 at 5.30pm

Cambridge Northern Fringe East Area Action Plan – Issues and Options Consultation Feedback

Noted Scrutiny 1 paper

Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee noted this item on Tuesday 17 November 2015. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item15/37/DPSSC

Resolved

Decision of Executive Councillor for Planning Policy and Transport i. To note the summary and conclusions of responses to the AAP Issues and Options consultation (as referred to in Appendices A and B); and To agree revised option 2a for the potential range of development for the purposes of; a) testing the potential environmental and infrastructure impact and the economic viability of the emerging AAP proposals; b) informing the preparation of other ancillary assessments required to ensure the deliverability and soundness of the draft AAP; and c) guiding further conceptual urban design work that will inform the ultimate preferred development approach. Reason for the Decision As set out in the Officer’s report. Any Alternative Options Considered and Rejected Not applicable. Scrutiny Considerations The Committee received a report from the Urban Extensions Project Manager. The report referred to the Cambridge Northern Fringe East (CNFE) area as one of the most significant brownfield regeneration opportunities in Greater Cambridge. The emerging Local Plans for both Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire recognised that regeneration and redevelopment of the area was important, both in the short term, aligned with the opportunity presented by the opening of a new rail station, and in the long term to ensure that maximum regeneration benefits are captured for Greater Cambridge. Comments from the Sub-Committee i. An additional recommendation to the report proposed by Councillor Smart at a meeting of the Joint Strategic Transport and Spatial Planning Group on 16 November 2015 had been accepted (5 votes to 0, with 2 abstentions). The Officer’s recommendation in the report and Councillor Smart’s additional recommendation had also been approved at the South Cambridgeshire District Council’s Planning Portfolio Holder meeting in the afternoon of the 17 November 2015. ii. Option 4a, referenced in the Officer’s report, should be kept as new investigations (with updated technology) may demonstrate it is deliverable to relocate the Water Recycling Centre to another site, when previously it had not been shown to be feasible. iii. Would not want to see development on the 2a option (referenced in the Officer’s report) without option 4a being investigated. Therefore both options recommended by the Officer should be left open. iv. There had been many discussions over a number of years (ten years approximately) regarding the relocation of the Water Recycling Centre. Previously Anglian Water had indicated that relocation of the Water Recycling Centre to Fen Ditton had been the only option but this had been refused. v. Did not want to see ‘history repeating itself’ with no action taken on the site and only open ended discussions for a further ten years. vi. Questioned who would fund the relocation of the Water Recycling Centre. vii. Queried if a new stadium could be proposed by Grosvenor Estates instead of housing if the Water Recycling Centre was relocated. Officers stated the following i. Grosvenor Estate had confirmed they were having positive discussions with Anglian Water on how to go forward. Both parties had agreed a contribution to the cost of a transport study and supported the recommendation that both options (2a and 4a) should be investigated further. ii. The relocation of the Water Recycling Site offers a major sustainable opportunity to develop a brownfield site and accommodate significant levels of development. iii. The Employment Options Study has provided confidence that option 4a could be viable. iv. Previous exploration of the relocation of the Water Recycling Centre had determined that this was not necessarily the best option and there had been some resistance. However the proposed investigation would be looked at differently with the support of Anglian Water. v. If the opportunity was not taken to explore the possibility of relocating the Water Recycling Centre the prospect could be permanently lost. vi. The resources needed to investigate options 2a and 4a were not significantly different. vii. Further detail on option 4a could be brought back to the Committee in approximately eight months’ time. This would include whether a longer term phased approach would be realistic and how this strategy could be taken forward. viii. The development of this site was not being relied upon in the 14,000 properties referenced in the Local Plan. Councillor Smart proposed an additional recommendation (d) of the Officer’s recommendations (additional text underlined ) which was the same as the additional recommendation agreed previously by both the Joint Strategic Transport and Spatial Planning Group and South Cambridgeshire District Council Planning Portfolio Holder. To note the summary and conclusions of responses to the AAP Issues and Options consultation (as referred to in Appendices A and B); and To agree two revised options for the potential range of development for the purposes of; a) testing the potential environmental and infrastructure impact and the economic viability of the emerging AAP proposals; b) informing the preparation of other ancillary assessments required to ensure the deliverability and soundness of the draft AAP; and c) guiding further conceptual urban design work that will inform the ultimate preferred development approach. d) investigate a phased approached from option 2a to option 4a . Resolved (2 votes to 4) to endorse the additional recommendation. The additional recommendation was therefore lost. Councillor Sarris next proposed an amendment to the Officer’s recommendations (deleted text struck through and additional text underlined ). i. To note the summary and conclusions of responses to the AAP Issues and Options consultation (as referred to in Appendices A and B); and To agree revised option s 2a for the potential range of development for the purposes of; a) testing the potential environmental and infrastructure impact and the economic viability of the emerging AAP proposals; b) informing the preparation of other ancillary assessments required to ensure the deliverability and soundness of the draft AAP; and c) guiding further conceptual urban design work that will inform the ultimate preferred development approach. Resolved (4 votes to 2) to endorse the amended recommendations. The Head of Planning of Services requested that it was minuted that the amendment had been against the recommendation of Officers. The Executive Councillor approved the recommendations. The Executive Councillor stated that the approval of the amended recommendation ensured a realistic vision for the City as it was unacceptable to leave this site in an indeterminate state; there was also an issue of financial viability. At the meeting of the Joint Strategic Transport and Spatial Planning Group reservations to option 4A had been raised. Option 4 had also been rejected by the County Council at the Issues and Options stage as they did feel this option was viable within the local plan period and would not be deliverable. The County also believed that there was no feasible site to be found. Conflicts of Interest Declared by the Executive Councillor (and any Dispensations Granted) No conflicts of interest were declared by the Executive Councillor.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee

Executive summary

1.1Cambridge Northern Fringe East (CNFE) area is one of the most significant brownfield regeneration opportunities in Greater Cambridge. The emerging Local Plans for both Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire recognise that regeneration and redevelopment of the area is important, both in the short term, aligned with the opportunity presented by the opening of a new rail station, and in the long term to ensure that maximum regeneration benefits are captured for Greater Cambridge.

1.2The Area Action Plan (AAP) will be a key document for guiding and shaping the development of the CNFE area, and its preparation has been prioritised to be undertaken in parallel with the local plans process. In this context, this report:

 provides an update on progress in preparing the CNFE AAP;  informs Members of the key issues arising from comments received on the Issues and Options Report, which took place between December 2014 and February 2015;  seeks a steer from Members on whether two revised redevelopment options should be taken forward for further investigation, including transport and development viability assessments, ahead of the preparation of the draft Plan; and  sets out the proposed revised timetable for the preparation of the AAP for incorporation into each Councils Local Development Schemes. 2. Recommendations

2.1This report is being submitted to the Development Plan Scrutiny Sub- Committee for prior consideration and comment before decision by the Executive Councillor for Planning Policy and Transport.

2.2The Executive Councillor is recommended:

 To note the summary and conclusions of responses to the AAP Issues and Options consultation (as referred to in Appendices A and B); and  To agree two revised options for the potential range of development for the purposes of; a) testing the potential environmental and infrastructure impact and the economic viability of the emerging AAP proposals; b) informing the preparation of other ancillary assessments required to ensure the deliverability and soundness of the draft AAP; and c) guiding further conceptual urban design work that will inform the ultimate preferred development approach.

Background

3.1The CNFE area has been the subject of comprehensive development policy aspirations for more than two decades, but there has been little in the way of any catalyst to provide the incentive to bring forward a co-ordinated development programme for the area.

3.2Currently, Cambridge City Council and South Cambridgeshire District Council are both producing new local plans for the period to 2031. Policy 14 in the submitted Cambridge Local Plan 2014 and Policy SS/4 in the submitted South Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2014 seek the regeneration of CNFE and say that the precise amount of development, site capacity, viability, time-scales and phasing of development will be established through the preparation of a joint AAP for defined area.

3.3The importance of regenerating the northern fringe area has been recognised by both councils with the commitment to undertake the AAP work in parallel with the local plans process. Work commenced on the joint AAP through the publication and consultation on an Issues and Options Report earlier this year which included the identification of four potential options for the provision of future development in the AAP area. The completion of the analysis of comments received during that consultation now enables additional and more detailed work to proceed with a view to preparing a draft AAP for consultation and, ultimately, examination and adoption.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cambridge Northern Fringe East Area Action Plan: Issues and Options Consultation FeedbackReport 649 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 8 attended
PS
Councillor Peter SarrisChair, present
NG
Councillor Nigel GawthropeVice-Chair, present
KB
Councillor Kevin BlencoweExecutive Councillor, present
MA
Councillor Mark AshtonCommittee Member, present
DB
Councillor Dave BaigentCommittee Member, present
CS
Councillor Catherine Smart Lib Dem Spokesperson for Planning Policy and TransportCommittee Member, present
DT
Councillor Damien TunnacliffeCommittee Member, present
SR
Councillor Sian Reid Lib Dem Spokesperson for CommunitiesReserve

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. Cambridge Northern Fringe East Area Action Plan – Issues and Options Consultation FeedbackThis decision
  2. Cambridge Northern Fringe East - Equality Impact AssessmentAgreed
  3. Cambridge Northern Fringe Issues and Option 2Approved
  4. Cambridge Northern Fringe EastNoted
  5. Cambridge Northern Fringe EastNoted
  6. Cambridge Northern Fringe East Area Action Plan - Issues and OptionsNoted

More from Cambridge Development Plan Scrutiny Sub-Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 Feb 2018 Grafton Area of Major Change – Masterplan and Framework Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) designates the area around Fitzroy Str... Approved Open
13 Feb 2018 Land North of Cherry Hinton Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) allocates Land North of Cherry Hinton ... Approved Open
5 Dec 2017 Annual Monitoring Report 2017Decision The Council is required to produce an Annual Monitoring Report (AMR) on at least a yearly basis. The draft A... Agreed Open
12 Sep 2017 Draft Grafton Area of Major Change – Masterplan and Framework Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) designated the area around Fitzroy Str... Agreed Open
27 Jul 2017 Draft Land North of Cherry Hinton Supplementary Planning DocumentDecision The draft Cambridge Local Plan 2014: Proposed Submission (as amended) allocated Land North of Cherry Hinton ... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies