Resolved (unanimously) to refuse the application contrary to the officer recommendation for the following reasons: Condition 33 should not be removed because this would result in the continued harmful noise levels having an adverse effect on the amenity of the occupants of the existing flats contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2006) policy 4/13.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 16/2012/S73 Agenda Number Item Date Received 16th November 2016 Officer Michael Hammond Target Date 15th February 2017 Ward Petersfield Site Station Area Redevelopment Land Off Tenison Road Blocks C1/C2, D1 And F1 Of The CB1 Station Area Masterplan, Cambridge Proposal Section 73 application to remove condition 33 of permission 13/1041/S73 (noise levels in external leisure/amenity areas). Applicant Hill Partnerships
SUMMARY The development accords with the Development Plan for the following reasons: - The publication of a new British Standard has altered the approach to assessment of external noise impact. - The residents of the flats with affected balconies will have access to public open space on adjacent land which will not experience such high levels of noise.
- Given that the flats are now occupied it would be impractical to incorporate physical mitigation measures into the balcony structures.
RECOMMENDATION APPROVAL
1.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT
1.1The application site relates to Blocks C1, C2, D1 and F1 of the CB1 station redevelopment. These blocks are situated either side of Great Northern Road which connects Tenison Road and the main taxi pickup point at the station. There are public open spaces within close proximity to the site. The surrounding area is made up of a mixture of residential and commercial uses. 1.2 The site falls within the air quality management area, the controlled parking zone and is adjacent to the Central Conservation Area.
2.0THE PROPOSAL
2.1The application seeks to remove condition 33 of permission 13/1041/S73 which relates to noise levels in external leisure/ amenity areas.
2.2Condition 33 of permission 13/1041/S73 is stated as follows:
“Before any residential or other noise sensitive development (as defined by PPG 24) is commenced a noise attenuation scheme and/or phased attenuation measures shall be submitted to and approved by the local planning authority in order to demonstrate that no primary external leisure/amenity area associated with the proposed dwellings (rear gardens, balconies) will be affected by a daytime (0700-2300) outdoor noise level in excess of 50 dB LAeq, 16 hours or a night time (2300-0700) outdoor noise level in excess of 50 dB LAeq, 8 hours Any phased measures that form part of the noise attenuation scheme shall be completed prior to the occupation of any proposed residential or other noise sensitive development that requires protection by the requirements of this condition.
Reason: To protect amenity of the occupants of residential and other noise sensitive development (Cambridge Local Plan 2006 policy 4/13).”
2.3The reason why permission is sought to remove this condition is because the noise levels experienced in the balconies overlooking Great Northern Road, as well as the amenity space between blocks D1 and F1, are too high and the requirements of condition 33 can therefore not be met. The applicant does not consider this condition necessary due to the lack of practical mitigation measures and the provision of alternative outdoor amenity areas for the affected occupants. 2.4 The application is accompanied by the following information:
1. Noise information/ mapping 2. Noise survey 3. Cover letter 4. Map of outdoor spaces around CB1
3.0SITE HISTORY
3.1The site has an extensive planning history but of relevance are:
Reference Description Outcome 13/1041/S73 Minor material amendments to Permitted. outline planning permission reference 08/0266/OUT (the CB1 masterplan outline application) comprising an alteration to conditions 4 and 5 to enable an increase in the height of Block C1/C2, a basement car park under Block D1 and minor adjustments to Blocks C1/C2, D1 and F1. 08/0266/OUT The comprehensive Permitted. redevelopment of the Station Road area
4.0PUBLICITY
4.1Advertisement: Yes Adjoining Owners: Yes Site Notice Displayed: Yes
5.0POLICY
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.