Item20/30/DCF
Resolved
Agreed with the petitioner that there should be some retention to the Flying Pig. xi. Had hoped the developers would recognise the commitment to providing housing was valued and should be an important part of the development. xii. The proposal was for 1700 people to work on the site and questioned where these people would live and they travel to the site; the transport assessment had yet to be completed and no travel plan had been created. xiii. Requested the Planning Officer investigated the need for housing and the need for offices; would like to see the outcome of the research and the travel assessment before consideration by the planning committee. xiv. The Tree Officer’s concern should be considered. xv. The developers had highlighted the importance of sustainability but questioned if this were a net zero site so this needed to be improved; if there was housing on site this would be a requirement. Members’ Questions and Comments: In response to Members questions and comments the Planning Officer said the following: i. The proposal did not include affordable housing; the extant permission had included 156 residential units of which 62 were to be affordable housing units. ii. The scheme was now for office-based development, office campus and retention of the Flying Pig as presented; the proposal would be assessed on this plan. However, the applicant had to justify the lack of provision of residential in the scheme. iii. With regards to the extant planning permission, phase 1 was Botanic House and phase 2 the 156 residential units, including the Flying Pig as part of this phase. The consent was extant and could be implemented at any time. iv. The site was not part of the conservation area when permission was granted; this came after in 2012. v. The proposal retained the front element of the bar and sitting area of the Flying Pig, removed the rear section of the building, extending further back to provide additional services, including accessible toilet and services in the basement. vi. The Conservation Officer was satisfied with the proposal regarding the Flying Pig; not withstanding that there would be some level of harm to the building but would be less than substantial harm measured against the National Planning Policy Framework for Heritage Assets. The Assistant Director said the following: i. As part of the work on the new LP there would be a “lesson learnt review” on the station area development and the surrounding area. ii. Reminded the Forum that the 2018 LP had taken a long time to be adopted; therefore, some of the policies had been carried forward several years without analysis. In response to Members’ questions the agent said the following i. A draft framework travel plan had been submitted as part of the application which would be discharged through conditions once occupiers were known. ii. Had engaged with both the County Council (highways authority) and the City Council to clarify the intent to manage future travel plan(s). iii. A travel plan training budget would be available for future tenants with a central co-ordinator (if there were multiple occupants) to manage the travel plan(s) across the site. iv. The highways authority in principle had agreed with the transport assessment; mitigation included improvements to the cycle network along Hills Road, relocation of bus stops and the creation of a new toucan crossing. Discussions were still taking place regarding wider improvements. v. With regards to the LVIA, had worked closely with the Urban Design and Landscape Officer to agree where the most sensitive views would be in respect of the scheme. Then began the process of surveying and using GPS coordinates to obtain a verified view. vi. Had undertaken extensive engagement with Cambridge University and the Botanic Garden who agreed the conclusions of the LVIA were robust and a much more appropriate scheme was being brought forward. vii. At the point extant permission was granted the applicant did not own the entire site. Further land had since been obtained allowing a master plan to be brought forward for the full site. viii. The Botanic Gardens had stated the impact of a residential scheme would have a greater effect to their site than the scheme proposed. ix. Potential conflict on the residential amenity and that of the Flying Pig (well known for its support of the Cambridge music scene). x. Recognised the impact that COVID-19 had on the workplace with homeworking. It had also shown how important human interaction was with a loss of productivity and creativity. It was important for individuals to return to the workplace when safe to do so. xi. The height of the tallest building was ground plus six-storey and was setback on the tallest element. xii. Could not answer how many individuals who worked at Botanic House cycled to work; would clarify post meeting. xiii. The building in its current form would not suit residential living; designed as a 21 st century office for a multi-let beehive of activity. xiv. The design was high up on the urban greening factor. There was greening of the ground floor with extensive planting with potential of greening of the first-floor canopy. Could review whether a biophilic planters’ edge in the space between buildings A&B was possible as a minor amendment. The greening and planting of the roof top would be a benefit to the insect community. xv. Working to encourage sustainable access, taking advantage of being close to the station, with 1300 cycle spaces within the basement for occupants, significantly reducing the level of car parking each year. xvi. Working to mitigate the impact on the junction of Station Road and Hills Road by improving the access down Hills Road; moving the junction into the site which was currently south of Botanic House. Providing a new Toucan Crossing opposite the southern building away from the junction. Summing up by the Agent i. Noted within the planning statement the primary purpose of the planning system was to contribute to the achievement of sustainable development, which it was hoped had been demonstrated throughout the application. ii. There were many aspects to sustainability and the National Planning Policy Framework directed planners to consider the social, economic, and environmental objectives. The development would be the first in Cambridge to exceed the policy and achieve BREEAM Outstanding. iii. To achieve BREEAM Outstanding the application must score 85% or above against the BRE criteria; the application scored 92% of all possible credits and would be operationally zero carbon. This was a direct response to the city councils’ declaration of climate emergency and put the application in the top 1% of all buildings in the United Kingdom. iv. The current LP outlined the development and vision for 22,100 jobs and 12 hectares of new employment land. v. Since the extant planning permission was granted fourteen years ago and ten years since the delivery of Botanic House, the remaining land had been obtained. This had allowed the application to respond to policy requirement to provide a masterplan for the site which protects and builds upon the existing employment. vi. LP Policy 2 sets out the spatial strategy for the location of the employment development, supporting the economy with a wide range of employment opportunities and the focus on growth within urban areas, areas of major change, opportunity areas and areas in the city centre. vii. The site has been in employment use for the last century and was recognised as one of the most sustainable locations across the city. The site was in an opportunity area and designated within two areas of major change. viii. There was not a better location to contribute to the 22,100 jobs stated in the LP. ix. There was less than 3-month supply of office space within central area of Cambridge. x. Recognised a need for homes for workers to live in. LP Policy 3 o sets out the spatial strategy of the location of new homes, with 14,000 new homes to be delivered over the Plan period. xi. The shared planning service (Cambridge City Council and South Cambridgeshire District Council) published housing trajectory on 1 April 2020 which stated the two planning authorities could demonstrate that they could meet their individual housing requirements between 2011 and 2031. xii. Important to focus on the benefits the application could bring with all the external consultees agreeing this commercial scheme was a better scheme for this site. xiii. After engaging with the local community understood the Flying Pig was an asset which should be preserved and have responded to this. The building and community of the Flying Pig will be maintained which will become accessible and inclusive to all which will remain for the next 100 years. xiv. The application proposed a highly sustainable development which responded to the vision of the council for economic growth and prosperity. A scheme which had been master planned to deliver a workplace site and would safeguard key community assets, improve the public realm on a key route into the city. Summing up by the Petitioner i. There was no masterplan for this site as required by LP Policy 21 with no reference to such a plan in any of the supporting documents to this application. ii. If a masterplan existed much of the topics for discussion raised at the meeting would have been addressed in the master plan process. Such a process would normally be conducted by the relevant planning authority and not the applicant. iii. There should be on the council’s website a record of the consultation responses; usually the council would arrange workshops to discuss several issues. Discussions could have taken place much earlier. iv. Questioned if the extant permission was proceedable and believed that conservation area consent was required for demolishing the Flying Pig. v. LP Policy 76 required justification in terms of development. The proposal would not sustain the Flying Pig economically once the development was complete, the capacity would not be as it was now in terms of accommodating customers. vi. Security to the site had not been considered with a small hedge running along the garden area which would not stop access. vii. Ignored the public concerns of the viability of the Flying Pig. viii. There had been no indication of what would happen while the Flying Pig was shut, if it were to be shut. ix. Stated that the Director of Stone Realestate
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk