CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Development Control Forum, Wednesday 16 June 2021 at 10.00am

Application and Petition Details (21/00264/FUL / Blocks B2 & F2, Devonshire Quarter Devonshire Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire)

Agreed Planning

Development Control Forum agreed this item on Wednesday 16 June 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item21/6/DCF

Resolved

Agreed the community area behind the square needed to clearly distinguish between public space and the cycle route. x. Asked how extensive the grey water storage was in in B2. Case Officer Comments i. Provided a timeline to the application: a) 18/1678/FUL submitted Nov 2028 following extensive pre-app of 12 months. b) 18/1678/FUL Planning Committee refused planning permission (two reasons, B2 – Aparthotel, multi-storey car park and cycling infrastructure). c) Pre-application in November, December, January, including member briefing (10 December 2020) d) Revised application submitted 21 January 2021 e) Amendments submitted on 5 May 2021 to address concerns raised. f) Applicant confirmed they will not appeal the refused application. g) Development Control Forum held on 16 June 2021 with further revisions shown and expect them to be submitted formally. Further consultation will then be required particularly with County Council Highway Officers. ii. Several Consultees responses had been received and was summarised as follows: a) Urban Design: No objections b) Environmental Heath: No objections, proposed a condition and informative to include 25% provision of electric vehicle charging points. c) Access Officer: Originally objected. These objections have been addressed with the revisions. Awaiting response from the officer. d) Drainage: No objection. e) Nature Conservation Officer: No objection. f) Landscaping Officer: No objections but has raised minor details of the landscape design, including external gardens to B2 AND F2 which had been addressed with the revisions. Awaiting response from the officer. g) Sustainability Officer: No objections, noted both building designed to achieve BREEAM excellent and Grey water recycling proposed for the hotel. h) County Local Highways: No objections. i) County Transport: No objections. j) County Local Lead Flood Authority: No objections. k) County Cycling Officer: No objections. l) Cambridgeshire Fire and Rescue: No objections. m) Cambridgeshire Police: No objection. n) Anglia Water: No objection o) Environment Agency: No objection. p) Greater Anglia: No objection q) Network Rail: No objection, had confirmed the taxi ranking on the surface carpark was an informal agreement. iii. Approximately 43 separate objections had been received, many of the themes have been presented at the Development Control Forum; these have been received from the following: a) South Petersfield Residents: b) Cambridge Past, Present and Future: Object to the impact of B2 on the Conservation area and anywhere architecture. Requested to go back to the Design and Conservation Panel. c) CamCycle d) Other third parties representations. Member Questions and Comments i. Under LTN 1/20 cyclist should have priority; it also referred to the disability act and therefore important to ensure that people could enter and go through the buildings with ease and access to all the spaces. ii. Reiterated that the loss of Blue Badge parking spaces needed to be replaced. iii. Suggested that the height and mass of the B2 should be further reduced. iv. The Applicant needed to consider the request to change the gradient on the cycle ramps. v. Vehicles should not be permitted to use ‘rat runs’ to the Station. vi. Station Square required redesigning. vii. Agreed the application was a great improvement. viii. There were problems with the existing cycle park and any new cycle park should learn from these issues. ix. Questioned if the applicant had considered the sustainability of the buildings. x. Noted the landscaping was greatly improved but would urge the applicant to take this further and look not just at ground level but what could be done at other levels. xi. Planting should not be included that would need to be taken up when work to the Chisolm Trail started. xii. Needed to consider the effect of the increase in cyclists using the Chisolm Trail, arriving via the guided bus route or the cycle route to Babraham. xiii. It was important to note there would also be an increase in pedestrians arriving from the east west or South Cambridge Station. xiv. Asked if the application should go to the Design and Conservation Panel. xv. Queried how the Taxi Management Plan would be enforced after construction had been completed. xvi. Asked how many charging points would be in the car park. xvii. Enquired if it was possible to have a traffic survey completed before the application went before the Planning Committee. In response the Applicant / Agenda said the following: i. Had worked on the quality of the glazing and the relationship between the glazing and non-glazing areas. ii. Had up graded the UV rating to meet the BREEAM standard which would ensure no overheating of the building; the fabric of the building had also been upgraded which would result in a comfortable building for everyone that used it. iii. The applicant had recommended the access route be installed straight down Station Road but City Council Officers or the Highway Authority did not want this. iv. An access route had been presented to the Planning Committee from Station Road into Station Square, but the Committee took a decision not to pursue that option. v. Under LTN 1/20 the application highlighted pedestrian and cyclist priorities. There was a short stretch of road with four crossing points. From north to the south through the whole development, the application had provided a high quality cyclist route from Cater Bridge, Chisolm Trail, Devonshire Road, crossing Station Road, Hills Road Bridge to Addenbrookes which linked the Station entrance. vi. The cycle routes on the application had been a collaborative effort between City and County Officers, Cam Cycle, and the Chair of South Petersfield Residents Association. vii. The applicant would add a further £30,000 to the £944,000 already contributed to the Chisolm Trail. viii. B2 was well designed compact building close to a brownfield site close which the application utilised. It was a simple and elegant building against major infrastructure (Carter Bridge) next to the railway and was suitable to its environment. The building was not in a conservation area. ix. There had been so many changes to the application that officers were happy with and believed it was not necessary to go back to the Design and Conservation Panel. x. It was always envisaged that there would be buildings on the surface carpark, as stated in the CB1 Masterplan. The CCTV was introduced as a part of the S106 agreement for Station Square and the hotel. The use of the existing station surface carpark for over ranking had always been an informal arrangement xi. Greater Anglia had written to the Case Officer to advise the use of the existing station surface carpark for the use of over ranking was always an informal arrangement. xii. A traffic survey been undertaken, and a summary would be sent to the Case Officer. xiii. Would provide the litre storage for the grey water to Councillor Robertson outside of the meeting as did not have the figures . The building had been redesigned to meet the BREEAM standard which was why grey water could now be included. xiv. Would ensure that the food vans and those who used the area behind Station Square were aware that a clear passage had to be left for cyclists; would agree for a condition to be placed on this space if necessary. xv. The proposed zebra crossing would be on the highway under private ownership of Greater Anglia and the Train Operator. xvi. The car park would start with 25% passive charging and within five years was likely to be 100%. In response to Member’s comments the Case Officer said the following: i. Supported the applicant’s comments regarding the Design and Conservation Panel. ii. Was not sure how much the Panel could add to or influence the design as application had gone before the Panel three times previously. iii. There was a possibility that a condition could be placed on the Chisholm Trail on the northern side of the access road into the carpark. iv. Unfortunate that the Chisolm Trail plans had not developed sufficiently so that the application could be linked into it. v. Would speak with the applicant outside of the meeting regarding planting across an area where these plants would need to be removed when the construction of Chisolm Trail started. vi. There was not yet a resolution as to who would be responsible to manage those taxis who could not park on the rank. vii. The application was for a multi-storey car park and not for a cycle park. Summing up by the Applicant’s Agent i. Thanked the petitioners. ii. Agreed that LTN 1/20 had changed the application. iii. The application sat on a complex part of the city. iv. The site needed a building of quality. v. Offered a transition management plan to assist with the change of the site. vi. Fully understood the comments regarding the longevity of some of the plants. vii. F2 was not part of the refusal so had not been amended apart but the route through to the north, crossing over the Great Norther Road had been improved. viii. If the Safety audit permitted moving the proposed zebra crossing as proposed by the petitioner (moving the crossing away from the corner of Sainsburys and closer to the desire line) this would be done. ix. The proposed zebra crossing would be designed to be all safety standards and requirements. x. Would speak with the petitioners regarding refuse collection outside of this meeting/ xi. The developer was keen to continue working with residents Summing up by the Petitioners i. Thanked the applicant for their engagement. ii. Had expressed their opinion on B2 but it would be the Planning Committee to determine whether the scale or mass was suitable or not. iii. More detail on the taxi management plan was required, it had to be determined who had long term responsibility. iv. More detail was needed on the design of the car park and clarity of on the future proofing. v. Design of the stairways should be improved to negate anti-social behaviour and ensure user safety. vi. Design of the proposed crossing needed to be improved vii. Need to ensure a clear path for cyclists behind Station Square. Final Comments of the Chair i. Summarised the main issues discussed. ii. Notes of the Development Control Forum would be made available to the relevant parties and published on the City Council website. iii. A copy of the minutes would be attached to the Planning Officer’s report when the application would be considered at a future Planning Committee. iv. The Case Officer would contact the applicant/ agent after the meeting to discuss the outcome of the meeting and follow up any actions, as necessary. v. The applicant would be encouraged to keep in contact with the petitioners and seek their views on any proposed amendments.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting
21/6/DCFApplication and Petition Details (21/00264/FUL / Blocks B2 & F2, Devonshire Quarter Devonshire Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire)This decision

Who was there

5 of 9 attended
DB
Councillor Dave BaigentCommittee Member, present
RD
Councillor Robert DrydenCommittee Member, present
IF
Councillor Ingrid FlaubertCommittee Member, present
JG
Councillor Jenny Gawthrope WoodCommittee Member, present
KP
Councillor Katie PorrerCommittee Member, present
MS
Councillor Martin SmartCommittee Member, expected
KT
Councillor Katie ThornburrowCommittee Member, expected
CM
Councillor Carla McQueenReserve, apologies
JP
Councillor Jennifer Page-CroftReserve, apologies

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. Application and Petition Details (21/00264/FUL / Blocks B2 & F2, Devonshire Quarter Devonshire Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire)This decision
  2. Application and Petition DetailsAgreed
  3. Application and Petition Details (20/04261/FUL / Jewish Synagogue 3 Thompsons Lane Cambridge CB5 8AQ)Agreed
  4. Application and Petition Details (20/03429/FUL / 104 - 112 Hills Rd Cambridge)Agreed

More from Cambridge Development Control Forum

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
11 Sep 2025 Application and Petition DetailsAgreed with the College’s wish to replace its library. There were constraints on how to do this. 32) There were two t... Agreed Open
11 Feb 2021 Application and Petition Details (20/04261/FUL / Jewish Synagogue 3 Thompsons Lane Cambridge CB5 8AQ)Agreed to the development of the basement but should not disrupt neighbouring foundations; would like further discuss... Agreed Open
11 Nov 2020 Application and Petition Details (20/03429/FUL / 104 - 112 Hills Rd Cambridge)Agreed with the petitioner that there should be some retention to the Flying Pig. xi. Had hoped the developers would ... Agreed Open
9 Jul 2014 14/0607/fulAgreed that there could be a condition to the materials and / or colour of the rendering. There is also an opportunit... Agreed Open
3 Jun 2014 14/0492/OUT: The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge, CB2 8RUAgreed that the parking on site is not fully utilised but there are conditions in the Travel Plan to ensure that that... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies