CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Development Control Forum, Thursday 11 September 2025 at 11.00am

Application and Petition Details

Agreed Planning

Development Control Forum agreed this item on Thursday 11 September 2025. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item25/4/DCF

Resolved

Agreed with the College’s wish to replace its library. There were constraints on how to do this. 32) There were two things to be addressed by the development. · Replacing the college library. · Unfinished business in Christ's Lane which was created as a result of the redevelopment of Bradwell's Court i.e. the poor boundary on one side. Christ’s Lane was a busy thoroughfare and needed to be made more attractive on the College side. 33) Shared people’s concern about the canyon effect in Christ’s Lane and asked how this could be mitigated? 34) Requested more than a public bench as a public benefit. 35) It would be helpful if a construction plan were considered at the same time as the planning application due to the impact of the development on Christ’s Lane as a public thoroughfare. 36) Encouraged the College to engage with Objectors to overcome concerns. Members’ Questions and Comments: Councillor Porrer left the meeting before this item started and did not return. 37) Sought clarification about the proposed basement/height/massing/construction. Applicant: i. The basement was integral to the design in 2011 then ruled out due to sustainability concerns. The new design had sustainability at its heart. Applicant’s Architect: ii. Bradwell’s Court would overshadow Christ’s Lane not Christ’s College library. iii. The library would be the same height as Bradwell’s Court. It would not overshadow or block light into Christ’s Lane. iv. The design would make a beautiful wall which suited the character of the city. The city had lots of walls so the design was in-keeping with other areas. Applicant’s Agent: v. Digging a basement could have an impact on archaeology and surrounding buildings. vi. A draft construction management plan was request by Planners at the pre-application stage. A final plan would be submitted when requested through planning conditions. CLAG Planning Consultant: vii. The basement was ruled out due to sustainability concerns, but sustainability was more than avoiding digging holes and pouring concrete. It also covered the built and historic environment which the College had ignored. 38) Made the following observations: i. The Objector’s petition seemed to focus on: a. The balance between heritage harm versus public benefit. b. Active use of Christ’s Lane. ii. Narrow lanes could produce a cool place in hot summers. iii. There was a lot of interest in how open the College was to the public, so how could the public learn about the library? iv. Lessons would be learnt from how the design tried to reduce the environmental impact of the building e.g. degassing. v. The application only affected half to one third of Christ’s Lane so would wait to see how the design affected the whole lane including shops opposite the college as Councillors needed to consider the impact of the design on the city. 39) Queried public access arrangements to the college now and in future? Applicant’s Architect: i. The college was open every day except Christmas and exam days. ii. Part of the scheme was to open up a bricked-up door in the wall to give access to the ‘Buttery’ as a café. 40) Made the following observations: i. Who had free/lease hold of Christ’s Lane? Would this impact the library development? ii. Would the development produce funding to improve Christ’s Lane? iii. Was Christ’s Lane well lit? iv. Was the library deficient of BRE standards as mentioned earlier? v. How would the wall be built on Christ’s Lane to mitigate a bulky design? vi. What happened to students/library users whilst the new building went up as they could not access the old facility? Applicant: vii. The library was already being decanted into a temporary space in the third court. viii. People’s study habits had changed since lockdown. The new design would have three times as much study space as the current library. Applicant’s Architect: ix. The proposed boundary wall would be traditional in style, with headers and stretchers, high lime content in the mortar, recycled bricks if possible integrated into a collage of new and old. x. Sunlight was adequate in Christ’s Lane. Overshadowing came from Bradwell’s Court. The new library would reflect light into Christ’s Lane so it would not cause a dark canyon effect. xi. The design of the wall would create a high quality public realm. Applicant’s Agent: xii. Christ’s College and Jesus College were the freeholders of the whole development including Bradwell's Court and Christ’s Lane. Bradwell’s Court was under a long lease to a lead lease holder who was responsible for lettings of the commercial units. Half of the lane was public highway even though the freeholders were the colleges. xiii. A sunlight daylight assessment had been undertaken. There was no detrimental impact on residential units. BRE standards don't generally apply to commercial units, highways, streets or public spaces. So there were no material planning issues. 41) The sunlight assessment of shadow effect in Christ’s Lane covered the summer solstice; would it cover the whole year, or was further information available? Applicant’s Agent: i. Would check as believed the assessment covered the whole year. ii. Bradwell’s Court was the building on the south. So the building that existed already was the building that cast the shadow over Christ’s Lane. The new building would not change the light materially. Lead Objector: iii. Took issue with the Applicant’s description of the height of the application. Suggested it was 15m not 11.4m. This would create a building that was taller than Bradwell’s Court and bulkier. iv. Did not accept the chimneys had to be so high above ground for ‘sustainability’ reasons. v. A café and shops would be overshadowed by the proposed development which would affect their livelihoods. vi. Suggested details were missing from the sunlight study. vii. The boundary wall design looked pretty but did not reflect active frontage at human scale i.e. interesting to look at from eye level. Objector’s Planning Consultant: viii. The college got benefits from the design. Queried what were the public benefits? Private benefits outweighed public benefits of the scheme. 42) Queried if planting, canopies or pop-up markets could be introduced in Christ’s Lane to make it more attractive and mitigate the tall building? 43) The chimneys appeared quite bulky. Queried if the design could be reviewed? Applicant’s Architect: i. The chimney design could be reviewed in future; the application was not at a detailed design stage yet. The chimneys were functional (not decorative) and 14m in height. ii. The new library was lower than Christ’s Lane at parapet height so was not as tall as suggested by Objectors’ concerns. iii. Was conscious of human scale. The design started with human scale, but there was also a case to be made for grandeur and presence in building design as it was a civic asset. Summing up by the Applicant 44) The canyon effect in Christ’s Lane was only mentioned by Objectors. The College took issue with this description. 45) The height of the new proposal was lower than Bradwell’s Court. There was no canyon effect or negative impact on light. 46) Technical advice cautioned against including a basement in the design so a higher building was proposed instead. This was similar in height to adjacent buildings. 47) The new library would improve heritage not harm it. Summing up by the Petitioners in Objection 48) The scheme benefitted the College but not the city/public realm. 49) The building was too tall and massive. Tall buildings policy (60) had not been applied, despite the proposed building triggering it, since the building broke a key skyline view from St Andrew's Street. 50) The College decided not to include a basement which led to negative comments about the design as discussed today. Summing up by the Petitioners in Support 51) Asked for discussion points from today’s forum to be taken into consideration when the planning application was considered by Planning Committee. 52) The proposal improved Christ’s Lane and the design of the library. Final Comments of the Chair 53) The Chair observed the following: i. Notes of the Development Control Forum would be made available to relevant parties, published on the council’s website and appended to the Planning Officer’s report. ii. The Planning Case Officer should contact the Applicant/Agent after the meeting to discuss the outcome of the meeting and to follow up any further action that was necessary. The Applicant would be encouraged to keep in direct contact with the Petitioners and to seek their views on any proposed amendment/s. iii. The Council would follow its normal neighbour notification procedures on any amendments to the application. iv. Application to be considered at a future Planning Committee. v. Along with other individuals who may have made representations on the application, the Petitioners’ Representatives would be informed of the date of the meeting at which the application is to be considered by Committee and of their public speaking rights. The Committee report would be publicly available five clear days before the Committee meeting.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting
25/4/DCFApplication and Petition DetailsThis decision

Who was there

5 of 7 attended
RD
Councillor Robert DrydenCommittee Member, apologies
IF
Councillor Ingrid FlaubertCommittee Member, present
BI
Councillor Bob IllingworthCommittee Member, present
KP
Councillor Katie PorrerCommittee Member, present
MS
Councillor Martin SmartCommittee Member, present
KT
Councillor Katie ThornburrowCommittee Member, present
MT
Councillor Mike Todd-JonesCommittee Member, apologies

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. Application and Petition DetailsThis decision
  2. Application and Petition Details (21/00264/FUL / Blocks B2 & F2, Devonshire Quarter Devonshire Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire)Agreed
  3. Application and Petition Details (20/04261/FUL / Jewish Synagogue 3 Thompsons Lane Cambridge CB5 8AQ)Agreed
  4. Application and Petition Details (20/03429/FUL / 104 - 112 Hills Rd Cambridge)Agreed

More from Cambridge Development Control Forum

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
16 Jun 2021 Application and Petition Details (21/00264/FUL / Blocks B2 & F2, Devonshire Quarter Devonshire Road Cambridge Cambridgeshire)Agreed the community area behind the square needed to clearly distinguish between public space and the cycle route. x... Agreed Open
11 Feb 2021 Application and Petition Details (20/04261/FUL / Jewish Synagogue 3 Thompsons Lane Cambridge CB5 8AQ)Agreed to the development of the basement but should not disrupt neighbouring foundations; would like further discuss... Agreed Open
11 Nov 2020 Application and Petition Details (20/03429/FUL / 104 - 112 Hills Rd Cambridge)Agreed with the petitioner that there should be some retention to the Flying Pig. xi. Had hoped the developers would ... Agreed Open
9 Jul 2014 14/0607/fulAgreed that there could be a condition to the materials and / or colour of the rendering. There is also an opportunit... Agreed Open
3 Jun 2014 14/0492/OUT: The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge, CB2 8RUAgreed that the parking on site is not fully utilised but there are conditions in the Travel Plan to ensure that that... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies