CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cornwall Council
Cornwall Council, Tuesday 20 January 2026 at 10.30am

Review of Council Procedure Rule 12 - Motions on Notice

Approved Committee 5 papers

AI summaryCornwall Council amended Council Procedure Rule 12 so that motions on notice are debated as advisory items, with new agenda parameters including a 6pm meeting close and up to three hours for motions.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedMotions on notice to be debated as advisory
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextReport back within six monthsReview of changes after twelve months operation
Who it affectsCouncil meeting procedureHow motions are debated and managed

What was decided

Council Procedure Rule 12.4 is amended so that motions on executive functions are advisory and do not bind the Cabinet, and motions on non-executive functions may be approved at Council or referred to the relevant committee. Report P8, P9

Rule 12.5 is amended so that where the Council votes on a motion in an advisory capacity, the Cabinet, individual Cabinet Member or Committee must report back to Council within six months. Report P11

New agenda parameters are adopted: meetings close at 6.00pm; statutory business under Article 4 of the Constitution is taken first; up to three hours are set aside for motions; the Chairman can order the motions in consultation with Group Leaders. Report P15

Why

The current Chairman of the Council wanted more motions to be debated, while keeping the distinction between executive and non-executive responsibilities. Report P21

Officers reported that historically around 50% of motions were debated and 50% were referred; the new approach allows all motions to be debated unless time runs out. Report P23

Members wanted better agenda management, prioritising statutory business and avoiding lengthy meetings that affect those with caring responsibilities or incur costs after County Hall closes at 7.00pm. Report P26, P27

What happens next

The Monitoring Officer, with the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Constitution and Governance Committee, is delegated to draft appropriate constitutional wording for inclusion in the report to Council. Report P40

Where a motion is voted on in an advisory capacity, the Cabinet, Member or Committee must report back to Council within six months, with the Leader reporting executive decisions through Leader's announcements. Report P11

A placeholder is added to the Constitution and Governance Committee work programme to review the changes after twelve months of operation. Report P41

Options considered

  • Chosen: Advisory motion approach modelled on Bath and North East Somerset. Had the support of the Chairman and Group Leaders Report P21
  • Rejected: Cap on the number of motions (around six). Members opposed caps and time limits in favour of flexible parameters Report P26
  • Rejected: Allocate motions by political group. Motions were often cross-party Report P26
  • Rejected: Move meeting start time to 10.00am. Most Members supported retaining 10.30am due to travel and group meetings Report P27
  • Rejected: Pre-deadline confirming intention to submit a motion. Considered unnecessary by Members Report P27

Implications

  • Governance: Council motions on executive matters become advisory and do not bind the Cabinet; on non-executive matters they can be approved at Council or referred to a committee. Report P8
  • Governance: Cabinet, Cabinet Members or committees must report back on advisory motions within six months; the Leader reports executive decisions through Leader's announcements. Report P11
  • Other: All members of the Council may vote on motions regardless of whether they sit on the parent committee or Cabinet, with the existing template and briefing note to be kept. Report P23
  • Risk: Meetings that overrun past 6.00pm risk additional costs because County Hall closes at 7.00pm; a 6.00pm closure supports timely close-down tasks. Report P27
  • Other: Lengthy meetings may affect Members with caring responsibilities, so time discipline and a 6.00pm close are intended to manage this. Report P27

Who and where

  • All 87 Cornwall Council Members Report P27
  • The Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Constitution and Governance Committee Report P40
  • The Monitoring Officer Report P40
  • The Cabinet and individual Cabinet Members Report P11
  • Council committees that may receive referred motions Report P9
  • The Leader of the Council, through Leader's announcements Report P11

Timeline

  • 6 January 2026: Constitution and Governance Committee recommended the changes to Council Report P3, P16
  • 20 January 2026: Cornwall Council approved the amendments to Rule 12 Report P2
  • Within six months of a motion being voted on: Cabinet, Cabinet Member or Committee must report back to Council on advisory motions Report P11
  • After twelve months of operation: Constitution and Governance Committee to review the changes Report P41

Plain English for the jargon

  • Motions on Notice: Formal proposals submitted in advance for debate at a Council meeting, governed by Council Procedure Rule 12.
  • Executive function: Decisions that are the responsibility of the Cabinet or individual Cabinet Members rather than the full Council.
  • Non-executive function: Decisions that are the responsibility of the full Council or its committees rather than the Cabinet.
  • Constitution: Cornwall Council's set of rules and procedures, including Council Procedure Rules and Article 4 covering statutory business.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCC/109

Resolved

RESOLVED that 1. Council Procedure Rule 12.4 be amended as follows to enable more motions to be debated at Council meetings:- Motions for which notice has been duly given (other than motions under Rule 13), shall be debated at the meeting on the basis of the following:- (i) Motions approved at Council relating to an executive function will be advisory and not bind the Cabinet, or individual Cabinet Member, but may inform their future decisions. (ii) Advisory motions relating to non-executive functions may be considered and approved at Council or referred to the relevant Committee for detailed consideration. In the case of the latter, an advisory motion approved at Council will not bind the future deliberations of the Committee which the matter has been referred to but may inform its future recommendations. Should a motion not be dealt with at a Council meeting for any reason (other than withdrawal by the proposer), it shall stand referred by the Chairman to the Cabinet or relevant Committee. 2. As a consequence of (1), Council Procedure Rule 12.5 be amended as follows: Where the Council votes on a motion in an advisory capacity, the Cabinet, individual Cabinet Member or Committee must report back to the Council within six months of the date of the Council voting on the motion. Where the motion relates to an executive function, the Cabinet, or individual Cabinet Member, shall consider and make a decision on the motion, and the Leader will report that decision back to Council through their Leader’s announcements. 3. The following parameters be put in place to support effective agenda management: (i) The meeting be closed at 6.00pm; (ii) That the first business on the agenda should consist of statutory business as set out in Article 4 of the Constitution; (iii) That up to three hours be set aside for motions, and that any motions not discussed be referred to the relevant body; (iv) That the Chairman has discretion to order the motions on the agenda, in consultation with Group Leaders.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cornwall's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cornwall Council, 6 pages

Information Classification: PUBLIC

CORNWALL COUNCIL 20 January 2026

RECOMMENDATION FROM CONSTITUTION AND GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE HELD ON 6 JANUARY 2026

REVIEW OF COUNCIL PROCEDURE RULE 12 – MOTIONS ON NOTICE

RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL THAT:

1. Council Procedure Rule 12.4 be amended as follows to enable more motions to be debated at Council meetings:-

Motions for which notice has been duly given (other than motions under Rule 13), shall be debated at the meeting on the basis of the following: -

(i) Motions approved at Council relating to an executive function will be advisory and not bind the Cabinet, or individual Cabinet Member, but may inform their future decisions. (ii) Advisory motions relating to non-executive functions may be considered and approved at Council or referred to the relevant Committee for detailed consideration. In the case of the latter, an advisory motion approved at Council will not bind the future deliberations of the Committee which the matter has been referred to but may inform its future recommendations.

Should a motion not be dealt with at a Council meeting for any reason (other than withdrawal by the proposer), it shall stand referred by the Chairman to the Cabinet or relevant Committee.

2. As a consequence of (1), Council Procedure Rule 12.5 be amended as follows:

Where the Council votes on a motion in an advisory capacity, the Cabinet, individual Cabinet Member or Committee must report back to the Council within six months of the date of the Council voting on the motion. Where the motion relates to an executive function, the Cabinet, or individual Cabinet Member, shall consider and make a decision on the motion, and the Leader will report that decision back to Council through their Leader’s announcements.

It was further recommended by Cole, seconded by Councillor Rowse and RESOLVED Information Classification: PUBLIC

that it be RECOMMENDED TO COUNCIL, that:-

1. The following parameters be put in place to support effective agenda management:

i. The meeting be closed at 6.00pm; ii. That the first business on the agenda should consist of statutory business as set out in Article 4 of the Constitution; iii. That up to three hours be set aside for motions, and that any motions not discussed be referred to the relevant body; iv. That the Chairman has discretion to order the motions on the agenda, in consultation with Group Leaders.

Minute excerpt of the meeting of the Constitution and Governance Committee held on 6 January 2026

Present:- Councillors: Cole (Chairman) Rowse (Vice-Chairman)

Chopak, Dennis, Garrigan, Towill and Yelland.

Also in Councillors: Creek, Jenkin and La Borde. attendance:- Also in attendance Alvey, Batters, Burnett, Donnithorne, Ewert, Hodgetts, (virtual):- Nolan, Parsonage, J Pascoe, Thomason-Kenyon, M Thomas and Webb Apologies for Councillors: (None). absence:-

The Chairman advised that discussion on this item would be split into two parts: first, the ability to debate advisory motions, and second, the parameters for doing so at Council meetings.

The Democratic Lead and Statutory Scrutiny Officer introduced the first part of the report, explaining that motions normally stood referred to Cabinet or the relevant Committee unless the Chairman of the Council considered it conducive to business to debate them on the day. When elected, the current Chairman expressed a desire to allow more motions to be debated, while recognising the distinction between executive and non-executive decision-making responsibilities. The approach to motions from Bath and North East Somerset, as outlined in the report, appeared to have the support of the Chairman and Group Leaders. Information Classification: PUBLIC

During the debate, the following points were noted:

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Review of Council Procedure Rule 12: Motions on Notice: Appendix 1 /109Appendix 11 pages Download
PDF
Review of Council Procedure Rule 12: Motions on Notice: Appendix 2 /109Appendix 4 pages Download
PDF
Review of Council Procedure Rule 12: Motions on Notice: Appendix 3 /109Appendix 1 pages Download
PDF
Review of Council Procedure Rule 12: Motions on Notice: Appendix 4 /109Appendix 26 pages Download
PDF
Review of Council Procedure Rule 12: Motions on NoticeReport 6 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Cornwall

Search all
  1. Review of Council Procedure Rule 12 - Motions on NoticeThis decision
  2. Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment ProceduresAgreed

More from Cornwall Cornwall Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Jul 2026 Minutes of the Meeting Held on 19 May 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting of Council held on 19 May 2026 were correctly recorded and that they be sign... Decided Open
21 Jul 2026 Allocation of SeatsRESOLVED that the allocation of seats as set out at Appendix 1 be approved. Approved Open
21 Jul 2026 Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025RESOLVED 1. That the amendments set out at Appendix 1 be approved, ... view the full minutes text for item CC/207 Approved Open
21 Jul 2026 Governance and Transparency of Appointments and Exit Payments of £100,000 and OverRESOLVED that: 1. The proposed revisions to the Scheme of Delegation (Appendix A) in relation to the approval of exit... Approved Open
21 Jul 2026 Audit Committee Annual Report 2025/26RESOLVED that the be approved. Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies