Cornwall Council Says it Values Trial By Jury: Proposer: Councillor Towill; Seconder: Councillor Blackman
DecidedCommittee2 papers
AI summaryCornwall Council passes motion opposing government plans to restrict trial by jury and will write to the Home Secretary, Lord Chancellor and Cornwall's MPs.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedCouncil affirms support for trial by jury
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextWrite to ministers and MPsPlus publish a public statement on jury service
Who it affectsJustice system in CornwallParticularly cases carrying 3 years or less
What was decided
The Leader is mandated to write to the Home Secretary condemning plans to massively restrict the right to trial by jury. Report P7
Cornwall Council affirmed its support for trial by jury and its civic value to Cornish communities. Report P8
The Council will write to the Lord Chancellor, the Secretary of State for Justice and Cornwall's MPs, urging that jury trials be safeguarded as a fundamental part of the justice system. Report P9
The Leader and the relevant Cabinet Member will work with Communications to publish a short public statement recognising jurors' contribution and signposting official jury service information. Report P10
Why
The Justice Secretary has announced that jury trials are to be abolished for crimes carrying 3 years or less, which prompted the motion. Report P11
Trial by jury is described as a cornerstone of justice across England and Wales, safeguarding open justice, public confidence and community participation in the rule of law. Report P11
Jurors from across Cornwall serve at personal inconvenience, and public trust in justice is strengthened when ordinary citizens deliver verdicts in serious criminal proceedings. Report P12
What happens next
The Leader writes to the Home Secretary at the earliest convenience. Report P7
Writes are sent to the Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice and to Cornwall's Members of Parliament setting out the Council's position. Report P9
The Leader and the relevant Cabinet Member publish a short public statement on jury service with the Communications team. Report P10
Options considered
Chosen: Pass the motion as recommended. No objections raised by the Cabinet Member or Strategic Director during consultation. Report P15
Rejected: Refer the motion to a committee for further consideration. No financial, legal or further background information needs were identified. Report P14, P16
Implications
Financial: None arising directly from the motion; it is a civic resolution with no financial implications for the Council. Report P14
Legal: No legal or constitutional implications for the Council identified. Report P14
Who and where
People in Cornwall charged with offences carrying three years or less, who would face non-jury trials under the government's plans Report P11
Cornish residents called to serve as jurors Report P12
Cornwall's Members of Parliament, who will receive a copy of the Council's position Report P9
Timeline
20 January 2026: Motion debated and passed by Cornwall Council. Report P2
At the earliest convenience after the decision: Leader to write to the Home Secretary. Report P7
Plain English for the jargon
Trial by jury: A court proceeding in which a group of ordinary citizens determines the verdict in a criminal case.
Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice: The UK government minister who heads the Ministry of Justice and has overall responsibility for the courts system.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCC/112
Resolved
RESOLVED that this Council i) Mandates the Leader to write to the Home Secretary at their earliest convenience, condemning the Government’s plans to massively restrict the ancient right to trial by jury. ii) Affirms Cornwall Council’s support for trial by jury and its civic value to Cornish communities. iii) Writes to the Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice, and to Cornwall’s Members of Parliament, setting out this Council’s position and urging the safeguarding of jury trials as a fundamental component of the justice system. iv) Asks the Leader and the relevant Cabinet Member to work with Communications to publish a short public statement recognising the contribution of jurors and signposting official information about jury service.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
Information Information Classification: Classification: CONTROLLED PUBLIC
MOTIONS TO COUNCIL 20 January 2026
Title of Motion Cornwall Council says it Values Trial by Jury
Proposer Cllr Kevin Towill
Seconder Cllr Louise Blackman
Supporters (a Cllrs Ashton, Channon, Grey, Heslington, Kenny, minimum of three O’Connor, Tarrant and Wilson are required)
Recommendation That this Council for Council to vote on i) Mandates the Leader to write to the Home Secretary at their earliest convenience, condemning the Government’s plans to massively restrict the ancient right to trial by jury.
ii) Affirm Cornwall Council’s support for trial by jury and its civic value to Cornish communities.
iii) Write to the Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice, and to Cornwall’s Members of Parliament, setting out this Council’s position and urging the safeguarding of jury trials as a fundamental component of the justice system.
iv) Ask the Leader and the relevant Cabinet Member to work with Communications to publish a short public statement recognising the contribution of jurors and signposting official information about jury service.
Context for the In light of the Justice Secretary announcement that Jury motion (i.e. why is trials be abolished for crimes that carry 3 years or less the motion being which is why I bring this motion. submitted – what is the proposer aiming Trial by jury is a cornerstone of justice across England to achieve) and Wales, safeguarding open justice, public confidence, and community participation in the rule of law.
The civic duty of jurors from across Cornwall—often at personal inconvenience—helps ensure fairness and legitimacy in serious criminal proceedings. Public trust in justice is strengthened when ordinary citizens are directly involved in determining facts and delivering verdicts. Information Information Classification: Classification: CONTROLLED PUBLIC
Does the motion*:-
(i) have potential None arising directly from this motion. The motion is financial intended as a civic resolution recognising the implications for the importance of jury trials and asking that Cornwall Council – if so Council communicates this to national decision-makers. advise what these might be (ii) have potential None legal/constitutional implications for the Council – if so advise what these might be (iii) require further None background information to enable the Council to make a decision and/or require detailed consideration – if so advised what might be required Consultation requirements (Rule 12.2)
I have consulted the relevant Cabinet Member (Cllr Paynter) and Strategic Director (Alice Gunn) I have received no objection to this motion.
*Should any/all of (i)-(iii) apply it is likely that the constitutional provision of referring the motion to the relevant Committee will apply.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.