Individual Decision - Rationalisation and Release of Menerdue Farm, Carnmenellis, Stithians
DecidedCommittee2 papers
AI summaryCornwall Council declares Menerdue Farm at Carnmenellis, Stithians surplus and approves its open market sale, with an expected value of more than £1,000,000.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedFarmhouse, farm cottage, agricultural buildings, around 3 to 4 acres
MoneyMore than £1,000,000Expected market value of the property
What happens nextMarketing and disposal to followHead of Property to finalise terms
Who it affectsMenerdue Farm, Carnmenellis, StithiansFreehold interest to be sold
What was decided
Menerdue Farm is declared surplus to the Council's requirements and is to be disposed of on the open market. Report P1
Authority is delegated to the Head of Property Services and Assets to confirm the disposal method, sale price and terms, in consultation with the Monitoring Officer. Report P2
Final terms will follow the Code of Practice for Land and Property and Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972. Report P2, P12
Why
The Asset Management Group found no other Council service needs the property, and keeping it would carry ongoing repair, maintenance, compliance and security costs. Report 1.4, 8.1, P30
Selling will generate a capital receipt for the Council and cut revenue holding costs and future capital investment liabilities. Report 3.2, P15
The wider Menerdue holding will continue as an agricultural letting, with marginal land moving into the Forest for Cornwall woodland planting programme. Report 1.3, 2.3
What happens next
The property will be marketed for a sufficient period to ensure good open market penetration, with completion aimed at the best price reasonably obtainable. Report P12
The Head of Property and Assets will finalise the method, price and detailed terms of disposal. Report 7.3
The 2019 Farms Strategy review findings are due to go to Cabinet later in 2026. Report 2.4, P35
The money
more than £1,000,000 expected market value of the property Report P24
Options considered
Chosen: Dispose of the property on the open market in line with the report. Generates capital receipt, reduces running costs, fits the Asset Management Plan and Farms Strategy. Report 10.3, P36
Rejected: Do nothing. Adverse financial implications for the Estate and the Council, with no service need identified. Report P36
Implications
Financial: Expected capital receipt of more than £1,000,000; sale is VAT exempt with minimal impact on the Council's VAT partial exemption position. Report P24
Legal: Disposal relies on Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972 and the General Disposal Consent 2003, with authority delegated under the Leader Scheme. Report 7.2, P26, P27
Climate: Marginal farmland at Menerdue will move into the Forest for Cornwall woodland planting activity. Report 2.3
Risk: Continued retention would carry costs and risks including repair, maintenance, compliance, rates, vandalism, knotweed management and unauthorised use. Report 8.1, P30
Who and where
The applicant council service area: Cornwall Council's Farms Estate and property portfolio Report 2.10, 3.2
Prospective buyers and future users of the farmhouse, cottage and farm buildings at Menerdue, Carnmenellis Report 2.3
The local area of Carnmenellis and Stithians, where the remaining farmland will continue to be let commercially Report 2.3
The divisional ward Member, who has been informed and raised no objections Report 2.12
Timeline
December 2019: Cabinet adopted the Council Farms Estate 20 Year Strategy and 10 Year Business Plan. Report 4.1, P19
January 2025: Neighbourhoods Overview and Scrutiny Committee considered a 5 year review of the Farms Estate. Report 4.2
March 2025: Council obtained vacant possession of two farms at Menerdue, triggering the review. Report 2.4
December 2025: An Asset Management Plan was prepared for Menerdue Farm.
April 2026: One of the Menerdue farms was let, covering approximately 124 acres. Report 2.3
June 2026: Sustainable Growth and Place Overview Scrutiny Committee reported Task and Finish Group findings on the Farms Strategy review. Report P34
2 September 2026: Individual Decision Day: portfolio holder to decide on declaring the property surplus and disposing of it.
Late autumn 2026: Findings and recommendations from the Farms Strategy review due to be considered by Cabinet. Report 2.4, P35
Plain English for the jargon
AMG: Asset Management Group, cross-service group that reviews whether surplus property could meet other Council service needs.
AMP: Asset Management Plan, document setting out the issues, liabilities and opportunities for a property holding.
FEH: Fully Equipped Holdings, the unit count of holdings on the Council Farms Estate.
Section 123: Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972, under which councils must obtain the best price reasonably obtainable when disposing of land.
Forest for Cornwall: Cornwall Council's programme for woodland planting and tree establishment.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemIDD-L78
Resolved
That the asset listed in this report be declared surplus to the requirements of the Council and disposed of on the open market. 2. That authority is delegated to the Head of Property Services & Assets to confirm the disposal method, sale price and the terms and conditions of the disposal in consultation with the Monitoring Officer, or their nominee. Also to finalise the terms and conditions in accordance with the Code of Practice for Land and Property.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
1. That the asset listed in this report be declared surplus to the requirements of the Council and disposed of on the open market.
2. That authority is delegated to the Head of Property Services & Assets to confirm the disposal method, sale price and the terms and conditions of the disposal in consultation with the Monitoring Officer, or their nominee. Also to finalise the terms and conditions in accordance with the Code of Practice for Land and Property.
1 Executive Summary 1.1 This report relates to the rationalisation and release of Menerdue Farm, Carnmenellis to include disposal of a farmhouse, farm cottage, agricultural buildings and associated land (“the Property”). Further details of which are provided at Appendix 1. 1.2 The report seeks approval to declare the Property surplus to the Council’s requirements and to dispose of them on the open market.
1.3The future management of the wider holding of which the Property has formed part has been assessed. This is to continue as an agricultural holding. The Asset Management Plan and Head of Property decision are attached in Appendix 2 Confidential Exempt.
1.4The Property has been reviewed by the Council’s Asset Management Group (“AMG”) and has been identified as not being required to support any other Council service or activity.
1.5This report seeks authority to declare this asset surplus to Cornwall Council’s requirements and to dispose of it in accordance with the Council’s Asset Release process.
2 Purpose of Report and key information 2.1 The purpose of the report is to declare the Property surplus to the requirements of the Council and to obtain authority to dispose of the freehold interest in the Property on the open market. Information Classification: PUBLIC
2.2Relevant location, site plans and photographs of the Property are provided at Appendix 1.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.