It was agreed that the former Cabinet Member discuss the matter with the Head of Corporate Finance. · It was suggested that Cabinet Members be informed when a system under their portfolio had identified a high priority finding following an Internal Audit. The Audit and Risk Manager agreed to consider introducing a procedure to inform the relevant Cabinet Member. The Head of Corporate Finance provided an update on Strategic Risks. The Committee sought and received clarification on several points in relation to the Town Hall Project, including the use of consultants and project costs as well as the risk levels assigned to the detailed design specification and project budget. Following a query from the Committee, the Head of Corporate Finance agreed to discuss the possibility of extending ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Word for word from the decision Crawley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.crawley.gov.uk
2.1The Committee is requested to receive this report and note progress to date, as at 30th June 2019.
Reasons for the recommendations
3.1The Committee has a responsibility to ensure that action has been taken by relevant Managers on risk based issues identified by Internal Audit.
Background
4.1Work Completed
Since the last report, the following review has been completed.
Audit Title Audit Opinion Budgetary Control Substantial Assurance Council Tax Substantial Assurance Financial Management System (FMS) Substantial Assurance DWP CIS Compliance Substantial Assurance Sundry Debtors Substantial Assurance Community Centres Substantial Assurance Corporate Health and Safety Satisfactory Assurance
4.2Work in Progress
The reviews in progress and other work that we have undertaken in the period are shown at Appendix A. 4.3 High priority findings in this period
There were no high priority findings identified in this period.
4.4Follow up Audits
Data Centre Migration Project – Post Implementation Review
Following the work undertaken by Internal Audit on the Data Centre Migration Project, it was agreed by management that an independent post implementation review would be undertaken. This is now complete and the outcome of the work undertaken by Actica Consulting has concluded the following:
Change in Scope
A change in scope, to include the Crawley Town Hall Network and the Communications Room was vital in that the Data Centre project could not be delivered without them. The state of the infrastructure was acting as blocker to future IT initiatives, beyond just that of the Data Centre migration. However, the additional cost and effort was ‘shoe-horned’ into the same project due to the Data Centre’s dependency on them. A further change in scope arose when the switch from Virgin to BT Unicorn was recognised. The switch was caused by a problem with the initial design for the wide area network. It was this issue which caused the greatest delay in delivery and the increase in cost.
This eventual scope delivered would be better viewed as a CBC infrastructure modernisation programme, rather than simply a Data Centre migration project. The infrastructure was at end-of-life and needed replacing. The Data Centre project was the catalyst that brought this to the fore.
Delivery Timescales
Virgin Media consistently misinterpreted the design and misconfigured the installation, which delayed identifying that the design was not fit for purpose.
The design fault in the specification of the communications link led to a false expectation being set for the timescales to deliver the link. The lead times for leased lines, which are required and were requested from BT Unicorn, added a further delay which was considerably longer than the original estimates given for using Internet connections.
BT Unicorn’s installation timescales exacerbated the delay.
When taken individually, the other project initiatives were delivered in a timely manner. The delay with the RDC to Crawley Town Hall link inevitably pushed back the delivery of the project as a whole, due to the critical path dependency on the link. It is very difficult to negotiate with large suppliers of this nature, so there was little to no scope for reducing the lead times.
Project Governance
The initial selection of Virgin Media as the network supplier was made in compliance with the inherent CBC policy of choosing the least cost option, unless there are mitigating circumstances. However, in order to ensure that all ‘mitigating’ circumstances are understood, a greater level of due diligence is needed, so that issues such as the difference between traversing the Internet and direct connections are identified.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.