CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Dorset Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 6 October 2020 at 10.00am

'Planning for the Future' White Paper: consultation response

Approved Executive 2 papers

Cabinet approved this item on Tuesday 6 October 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item30

Resolved

That a response be sent to Government, setting out the following as the views of Dorset Council on the White Paper, as well as the more detailed points made in section 9 of this report: (a) That delays in house building nationally are not all due to the planning system – local planning authorities do not build houses - but to other factors including market absorption, the homogenous nature of large developments, and reliance on the private sector for infrastructure provision, as identified in the Letwin review. In the last decade, 2.5 million homes were granted planning permission but only 1.5 million were delivered; similarly in 2019, 371,000 homes were given permission but only 241,000 were delivered; (b) That binding national housing targets and removal of the opportunity for people to comment at outline planning application stage on sites allocated for growth in plans will reduce the ability of communities to have input into proposals affecting their local areas, and reduce local democracy; (c) That greater detail is required on how the national housing targets would be derived, including how environmental constraints will be taken into account, and that this must include an element of national planning strategy setting out the aims for how places will grow and the infrastructure needed to support them; (d) That the proposed timescale for the adoption of new style plans is very ambitious bearing in mind the need for the introduction of new primary legislation, the proposed ‘front loading’ of community engagement and the greater level of technical work necessary if growth areas will receive automatic outline planning permission; (e) That there is significant risk to the progress of currently emerging local plans due to the uncertainty around, and scale of, these changes; (f) That if national policies are not to be repeated in local plans, they need to carry the same weight in decision making as development plan policies. Some local ‘development management policies’ will still be necessary to set out local mechanisms and approaches to addressing national policy issues – for example local solutions to addressing indirect effects of development on protected habitats; (g) That there is no reference to what if any effect these changes are intended to have on minerals and waste local plans, how policies and site allocations for minerals and waste would be applied under the zoning system and how minerals safeguarding can be achieved; (h) That while the support for good design and the publication of a national design code are welcomed, it is important that these focus not only on what places look like, but how they work for those living and working in them. Masterplanning also needs to consider infrastructure provision and mitigation of impacts on habitats, flood risk, heritage and landscape. (i) That the replacement of the Community Infrastructure Levy and Section 106 planning agreements with a single levy is not likely to generate sufficient funding for the infrastructure and affordable housing that is needed, particularly bearing in mind the exemptions proposed. We would ...
Word for word from the decision Dorset published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.dorsetcouncil.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Dorset's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Consultation Response from Dorset Council: Changes to the Existing Planning System

This is Dorset Council’s response to the national consultation on change to the existing planning system, published on 6 August with a consultation closing date of 1 October. It has been prepared by officers and approved by the portfolio holder for planning.

A response to the White Paper on ‘Planning for the Future’ (also published on 6 August but with a closing date of 29 October) will be considered by Cabinet on 6 October before being submitted.

Revisions to the standard method for calculating housing numbers

We agree that the use of current dwelling stock as a baseline for the standard method is helpful in the short term in order to reduce the extent of fluctuation in the figures. This also has the potential benefits of focusing development on the most sustainable locations, and where the need is most likely to be arising. We agree that maximising the use of existing infrastructure is sensible – provided that it has sufficient capacity. The use of the 0.5% existing stock figure also seems reasonable in terms of the resulting figures.

In the longer term however, in relation to the binding figures proposed to be set by government for all local authority areas, it is important not only that environmental constraints be taken into account in determining figures, but also that some form of strategic level planning takes place, to steer development to the most sustainable locations across local authority boundaries and ensure that choices are being made about the most appropriate distribution of future development. It is difficult to see how innovative proposals such as new towns might otherwise be allowed for (Qs 1-2).

We are concerned that too much weight is given to the ‘affordability’ factor in the proposed revisions to the method. In many areas of high demand, there may be significant environmental constraints which would prevent higher targets being reached. The longer term changes proposed in the White Paper indicate that environmental constraints will be taken into account in determining the future binding housing targets, which is very welcome, but in the meantime it is important not to paralyse emerging local plans by identifying targets which cannot be met. In Dorset for example, the extent of designations including green belt, AONB and internationally protected nature conservation sites means that any targets that take account of constraints are likely to be lower. It would assist progress in planning for this area if a method that took the constraints into account were devised as quickly as possible.

The reliance on the affordability factor also increases growth still further in the south east and reduces targets in many other areas of the country that have been identified as suitable for more growth, or that could benefit from higher levels of growth – for example the figures for Cambridge and for many urban areas in the north of England are significantly reduced. There is a risk of exacerbating regional economic differences as a result.

We also disagree with the fundamental assumption behind the affordability adjustment, that greater provision will improve affordability. In many areas, the build cost of housing exceeds what those on average incomes can afford to borrow. These build costs are not significantly reduced when more homes are built, and without subsidy they cannot be reduced to the level that people can afford. Many people can only afford subsidised rented housing, and increased market housing provision will not bring home ownership within their reach. We do not agree that the planning system is the cause of delivery problems: over the last decade, 2.5 million homes have been granted permission but only 1.5 million were delivered. (Q5)

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
'Planning for the Future' White Paper: consultation responseReport 443 KB Withheld: personal details
PDF
Appendix: Response to Consultation on Changes to Current Planning SystemAppendix 212 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 65 attended
SF
Councillor Spencer FlowerChairman, present
PW
Councillor Peter WharfVice-Chair, present
RB
Councillor Ray BryanCommittee Member, present
GC
Councillor Graham Carr-JonesCommittee Member, present
TF
Councillor Tony FerrariCommittee Member, present
LM
Councillor Laura MillerCommittee Member, present
AP
Councillor Andrew ParryCommittee Member, present
GS
Councillor Gary SuttleCommittee Member, present
JH
Councillor Jill HaynesCommittee Member, present
DW
Councillor David WalshCommittee Member, present
MP
Matt ProsserOfficer, in attendance
AD
Aidan DunnOfficer, in attendance

All 65 on the meeting page

On this subject at Dorset

Search all
  1. 'Planning for the Future' White Paper: consultation responseThis decision
  2. Future Meetings of Eastern Area Planning CommitteeDecided

More from Dorset Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
8 Sep 2026 July 2026 (period 4) financial management report 26/27Decision (a) That the Senior Leadership Team’s forecast as of July 2026 including progress in addressing demand for s... Noted Open
8 Sep 2026 Additional Procurement Pipeline Report - over £500k (2026 - 27) and Modern Slavery Transparency Statement 2025 - 2026Decision (a) Cabinet considered the contents of the report (of 8 September 2026) in respect of proposed additional mo... Approved Open
8 Sep 2026 Exempt BusinessDecision That the press and the public be excluded for the following item(s) in view of the likely disclosure of exem... Decided Open
28 Jul 2026 Dorset Council Annual Report 2025 - 2026That the Dorset Council Annual Report for 2025-2026 be received and noted. Reason for the decision The annual report ... Noted Open
28 Jul 2026 Dorset Local Visitor Economy Partnership Destination Management Plan(a) That the Dorset Local Visitor Economy Partnership Destination Management Plan (DLVEPDM) be adopted and (b) That a... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies