CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Durham County Council
Planning Committee (CleS), Monday 11 February 2008 at 6.00pm

Planning Matters

Deferred Planning

Planning Committee (CleS) deferred this item on Monday 11 February 2008. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item60

Resolved

“That this item be deferred pending investigations and discussions on an alternative route for a footpath link further to the north.” Councillors R Harrison and D L Robson returned to the Meeting . (B) District Matters recommended Approval Prior to consideration of the following item, the Chairman referred to correspondence received from the objectors and the applicant, which had been circulated prior to the Meeting and gave Members time to digest the information. (3) Proposal: Resubmission of 07/00494/FUL for the erection of 1 no dormer bungalow Location: Land West of the Poplars, Arcadia Avenue, Chester-le-Street Applicant: Mr and [name removed] - Reference 08/00003/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager advised that since the report had been produced an additional letter of objection had been received from the occupiers of 21 Arcadia Avenue who had raised the following points: The new application shows even greater disregard to the outline planning permission and conditions that were attached to comply with policy HP9. That the new dwelling is no longer in keeping or proportion with any of the adjacent single storey properties or within the size of the existing building plots along Arcadia Avenue. It has been deliberately been altered from a single storey bungalow into a two storey house. It extends well beyond the North East corner of No. 28 Arcadia Avenue. The new application is almost identical to the previous application except that it has been rotated through 180 degrees. All the dormer windows of this new two-storey house continue to cause an evasion of privacy into adjoining homes. The objector considers that the withdrawal of the oversized garage on the previous application has resulted in a new and additional provision of a secondary boundary wall to the Southern boundary of the site which in the objector’s view is unnecessary and is an attempt to bypass planning regulations in order to establish a building line for the future submission of a double garage. If planning permission is approved it should be a condition of any approval that any single or double garage cannot be granted planning permission included by way of a temporary structure. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that he had also received an additional comment of no objection from the occupiers of 15 Arcadia Avenue. A letter had been received from Kevin Jones MP, who advises that he had met with the applicants who feel that the resubmission in comparison to their early refused application now offers in their view a reasonable compromise, which recognises and responds to the concerns, which lead to Committee refusing the previous application. He also points out that the applicants feel that the design of the development fits well in the context of the surrounding area and also to point out that the detached garage has been removed from this revised application. The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. [name removed], [name removed], [name removed], [name removed] (the objectors) and [name removed] (the applicant) spoke in relation to the application. The Development and Building Control Manager spoke in response to the comments raised by the objectors as to why the last application was refused. He advised that at the last Meeting there was some discussion as to the desirability of getting the footprint put back beyond the corner line, which would admittedly comply with the outline approval. However he advised that the decision to refuse the previous application had not been taken on issues of scale or design or by virtue of the fact that it was forward of the line as such, rather it was due to the harm to the neighbouring occupiers of 28 Arcadia Avenue. He explained that the reason why Officers felt they could recommend approval for this revised scheme was that the amendment shown had overcome the refusal reason of the last application, by removing the proposed part of the dwelling closest to number 28, and to ensure that the separation distances are maintained. In relation to the comments on how the proposal would fit into the street scene and the building lines he advised that the forward most part would sit behind the neighbouring properties to the east, this was a point picked up in the last application in that the street scene impact was considered acceptable. He felt it was a key material planning consideration whether Members feel that this revised scheme has overcome the concerns raised against the last application ie. the impact on number 28 Arcadia Avenue. Members gave their comments in relation to the application and were of the opinion that the applicant had met the criteria and made the necessary amendments to overcome the objections raised by the Planning Committee when it had last been considered. Members therefore supported the Officer’s recommendation to approve the application. Councillor Nathan proposed to move the recommendation of approval, which was seconded by Councillor May. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Officer to approve the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions.” 01A The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). 01C The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice and as amended on 28 th January 2008 unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. 02A Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls and/or roofs of the building(s) have been submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. 20A Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, full details of all means of enclosure of the site (including any internal means of enclosure to sub-divide individual plots) shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual and residential amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. 65 Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 (or any Order revoking and re-enacting that Order with or without modification) any external alterations to the dwelling (except painting and repairs) and any development within the curtilage of the dwelling (ie development permitted under Schedule 2, Part 1 (Class A-H inc.) and Part 2 (Class A) of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 shall require the benefit of planning permission in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in the interests of visual and residential amenity. Extra 1 The hereby approved development shall be carried out in accordance with a scheme of landscaping to be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site, and which scheme may provided for the planting of trees and/ or shrubs (including species, sizes, numbers and densities), the provision of screen fences or walls, the movement of earth, the formation of banks or slopes, the seeding of land with grass, or other works for improving the appearance of the development. The landscaping scheme shall include the retention of the existing conifer trees to the south west corner of the site, as shown on the approved plans and shall all so make provision of additional planting along this boundary, adjacent to the turning head. The works agreed to shall be carried out within the first planting season following completion of development of the site (or of that phase of development in the case of phased development) and thereafter be maintained for 5 years, in the interests of visual amenity, the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. At this point Councillor Humes left the Meeting at 7.35pm. Prior to consideration of the following item, the Chairman Councillor Davidson declared his interest and left the meeting. Councillor R Harrison took the Chair. (1) Proposal: Resubmission of 07/00396/FUL - proposed erection of 1 no dwelling on land to West of property Location: 2 Carrowmore Road, Chester-le-Street Applicant: [name removed] - Reference 08/00004/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager advised that he had received a letter from Kevin Jones MP in respect of this application. The MP advises that he has been contacted by [name removed] the objector in relation to this application and notes that he and other residents are still concerned in relation to the position of the proposed dwelling and the fact that it would be only 4.5metres from the front of [name removed] property. The MP feels that it would affect [name removed] privacy and block light entering into his home. He is also concerned that if a house was to be constructed here that the future resident would be likely to park on Carrowmore Road, which is in very close proximity of the junction at Sheelin Avenue and as a result is there is a concern that this may obstruct the traffic using that junction. The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. [name removed] the objector spoke in relation to the application. Members expressed their concerns in relation to the application as follows: That the open aspect of these areas of land should remain on open plan estates. That this development could set a precedent for other applications of a similar nature. The proposal would be overbearing to 1 Sheelin Avenue and would result in a loss of privacy. The proposal would be harmful to the character of the street scene. The proposal was contrary to Policy HP9 of the Local Plan. Some Members raised concern as to how any additional dwelling could be satisfactorily positioned on the plot, without harming the street scene. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that if Members were minded to refuse the application, and had particular concerns as to how the development may harm the street scene, he could add a second refusal reason that the development would be harmful to the character of the street scene contrary to policy HP 9. Councillor Brown proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of refusal with the extra refusal reason as recommended by the Development and Building Control Manager, which was seconded by Councillor Wilkinson. Members were in agreement with this decision and the proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager to refuse the application be agreed for the following reasons. Extra 1 The proposed dwelling would, by virtue of its proximity to and relationship with No 1 Sheelin Avenue and No 2 Carrowmore Road, represent an unacceptable form of development which would appear unduly overbearing in relation to these properties and would also result in unreasonable overshadowing of these properties, detrimental to residential amenity and thereby contrary to Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 2 The proposed dwelling is, by virtue of its scale and siting, considered to have a detrimental impact upon the form and character of the surrounding streetscene and as such is considered to be contrary to the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Councillor Davidson returned to the Meeting and re-took the Chair, (C) District Matters Recommended Approval Prior to consideration of the following item, Councillors Wilkinson and K Potts declared their interest and left the Meeting. (2) Proposal: Extension/alteration to existing South-East stand Location: Durham County Cricket Club, Riverside, Chester-le-Street Applicant: Durham County Council - Reference 07/00397/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. Councillor Brown advised that although he was not against the proposal, he had concerns on the lack of car parking at the Riverside and the problems encountered by residents of people parking in residential areas near to the Riverside and surrounding areas. He referred to the travel survey, which had been promised to be undertaken by the Highways Authority within 9 months of the proposal being approved and suggested that this be carefully monitored. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that the extra seating capacity that this proposal contained had always been envisaged to be part of the development when the original grant of planning permission for this development was approved. He advised the proposals did not amount to a net addition to seating capacity at the ground. He advised that the extra conditions that Councillor Brown had referred to was an opportunity to get the Cricket Club to encourage alternative use of transport on match events which he hoped would lead to a significant improvement. It was suggested that the Development and Building Control Manager raise the parking problems, which were occurring in residential estates with Durham County Cricket Club, Durham County Council and the police. The Development and Building Control Manager suggested that if Members were minded to approve the application he would put an informative on the certificate to say that Members did express their concern about the present practices and he would make it quite clear that he would ensure compliance with the recommended conditions. Councillor Harrison also raised the problems encountered by the Sea cadets on match days, which the Development and Building Control Manager noted for inclusion in his comments. Councillor Turner proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, which was seconded by Councillor Laverick. This decision was carried. Councillors Wilkinson and K Potts returned to the Meeting. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions.” 01A The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). 01B The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 1 Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls and/or roofs of the building(s) have been submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policies RL8 and NE6 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 2 The retail facilities hereby approved shall only be used on ‘match days’ (that is to say events during which the land edged red on the application is in use), in order to ensure the proposals adequately mitigate against flood risk and to accord with the aims of policy 37 of the RSS. Extra 3 Unless otherwise agreed, a detailed travel survey shall be undertaken within 9 months of the approved seating area being first brought into use. Thereafter the results of this survey shall be provided to the Local Planning Authority and Highway Authority and shall be used to agree appropriate mode share targets, outcomes and corresponding timescales, which shall be agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. To ensure the development meets the aims of sustainable transport and to accord with the aims of policies 2 and 54 of the RSS and policies T6 and T15 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 4 Unless otherwise agreed, a detailed travel survey shall be undertaken every 3 years following the approved seating area being first brought into use. Thereafter the results of this survey shall be provided to the Local Planning Authority and Highway Authority and shall be used to agree appropriate mode share targets, outcomes and corresponding timescales, which shall be agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. To ensure the development meets the aims of sustainable transport and to accord with the aims of policies 2 and 54 of the RSS and policies T6 and T15 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 5 Prior to the bringing into use of the development hereby approved a flood evacuation plan shall be available for implementation at all times the development hereby approved is in use. In order to minimise flood risk and to accord with the aims of policy 37 of the RSS. Extra 6 Prior to the bringing into use of the development hereby approved the developer shall submit a Green Travel Plan (to include the appointment of a named Travel Plan co-ordinator) to demonstrate proposed measures to reduce the reliance on the use of the private motorcar to access the development. Thereafter the development shall be carried out in complete accordance with the measures approved as part of the said plan, unless otherwise first agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. To ensure the development meets the aims of sustainable transport and to accord with the aims of policies 2 and 54 of the RSS and policies T6 and T15 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. (4) Proposal: Demolition of library and erection of 4 no. new dwellings Location: Former Library, Front Street, Grange Villa Applicant: [name removed] - Reference 08/00009/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager advised that the Council’s Environmental Health Team had confirmed that they had no objections to this proposal. He also advised that the County Council as Highways Authority had advised that they were concerned about the level of car parking provision proposed for this development and had pointed out that the majority of terraced properties in the surrounding area have little potential for incurtiledge parking. They also advise that the bus st
Word for word from the decision Durham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.durham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Durham's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting
57Minutes of Meeting held 14 January 2008Decided
60Planning MattersThis decision

On this subject at Durham

Search all
  1. Planning MattersThis decision
  2. Planning MattersApproved
  3. Planning MattersApproved
  4. Planning applications - county mattersApproved
  5. Planning MattersApproved
  6. Planning MattersApproved

More from Durham Planning Committee (CleS)

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Mar 2009 Planning Matters“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application ... Approved Open
9 Mar 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 9 February 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 9 February 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Mar 2009 Planning Matters“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application ... Approved Open
9 Feb 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 19 January 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 19 January 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Feb 2009 Planning Matters“That notwithstanding the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, the application be refused for the follow... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies