CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Durham County Council
Planning Committee (CleS), Monday 9 February 2009 at 6.00pm

Planning Matters

Approved Planning

Planning Committee (CleS) approved this item on Monday 9 February 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item51

Resolved

“That notwithstanding the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, the application be refused for the following reasons: Extra 1. The proposal would provide for a form of development that would be harmful to the amenities of surrounding residential occupiers by virtue of an undue overbearing impact contrary to the aims of Policy HP 9 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 2. The proposal, by way of inappropriate scale and massing, would provide for a form of development that would be incongruous within the street scene and as such would be detrimental to the visual amenity of the wider locality, contrary to the aims of PPS 1 and PPS 3, Policy 8 of the Regional Spatial Strategy, and Policies HP 9 and HP 17 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan.” Councillors Shiell and Smith returned to the Meeting. Councillor Nathan left the Meeting at 6.56pm. (B) District Matter Recommended Refusal (1) Proposal: Erection of 62 bed residential care home with access and landscaping. Location: Former Pelaw Grange Cottage, North Road, Chester-le-Street, Durham, DH3 2AD. Applicant: W. Todd Builders Ltd - Reference: 08/00422/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs and plans in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members’ information. Councillor P May spoke in relation to the proposal and felt the design and scale of the development was not in keeping with the surrounding area. He also raised concerns in relation to the site’s close proximity to the BOC plant, as he considered that from a health and safety point of view, this would be hazardous to the occupants of the residential care home. Councillor Laverick was in agreement with Councillor P May’s comments in relation to the scale and design of the development, and also the site’s close proximity to a neighbouring hazardous site. In addition he felt the proposal would have an overbearing impact on the surrounding residents of the site. Councillor Brown agreed with the comments expressed by Councillors P May and Laverick, and proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of refusal, which was seconded by Councillor P May. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager to refuse the application be agreed for the following reasons: Extra 1. The development hereby proposed is incongruous in appearance by virtue of its poor design, scale and massing harmful to the character of the surrounding area contrary to Policy 8 of the Regional Spatial Strategy, and Policies HP9 and HP17 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 2. The development proposed would result in a level of risk and potential harm to those within the development from the neighbouring hazardous site such that the application should be refused on safety grounds in accordance with Policy 2 of the Regional Spatial Strategy and Planning Policy Statement 23. Extra 3. The access to the A167 (North Road) has an inadequate radii and the manoeuvrability space between parking bays is unsatisfactory and as such the proposal is not safe and accessible contrary to Policy T15 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan.” (C) District Matter Recommended Approval (3) Proposal: Variation of Condition 4 of consent 07/00165/FUL to allow the following construction hours; mon to fri 07:00 to 19:00, sat and sun 08:00 to 16:00, no working on Bank Holidays. Location: 2 Drum Park, Drum Industrial Estate, Chester-le-Street, Durham, DH2 1AE Applicant: [name removed] - Clegg Food Projects Ltd Reference: 08/00459/VAR The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs and plans in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members’ information. He advised that photographs and plans on display would relate to items 3, 4 and 5 of the Planning Matters report, as all of these items applied to the same application site. The Development and Building Control Manager spoke in relation to the application and advised that the purpose of the application was to extend the construction hours of the site. He informed Members that the request had been made by the applicant to allow various internal works to be carried out on the site, as set out in the Extended Work Schedule received by the Planning Authority on the 10 th December 2008. He also felt that Environmental Health team’s decision not raise any objections to the proposal had been influenced by the clarification that the construction work would be internally based. The Development and Building Control Manager referred to the view expressed by the applicant that the extension of construction hours would speed up the programme of works and result in a faster completion of the construction works. Councillor Ebbatson raised concerns in relation to work being carried out on site in all daylight hours and sought clarification from the Development and Building Control Manager as to the reasons why the operating hours of the site had originally been restricted by the Planning Authority. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that the restrictions had been put in place to prevent the developer from carrying out ‘heavy-duty’ works, such as those experienced at the external construction phase, during hours, which were deemed unacceptable by the Environmental Health team. He further advised that the Environmental Health team had examined the schedule of works and were satisfied that the proposed works would be low-level internal works, with the possibility of some minor external works also being carried out. Councillor P May spoke in relation to the proceeding application for additional external works on the same site, which was item 4 on the agenda, and queried whether the applicant would be allowed to carry out these works during the proposed extended construction hours. In addition, he felt that it would be unfair to local residents to allow external alterations to be carried out on Sundays. The Development and Building Control Manager clarified that the proceeding item on the agenda did propose for external alterations to be carried out, however they were not included on the schedule of works for which the extended hours were being applied for. He also commented that the Environmental Health team had requested that extra condition 2 be included in the recommendation of approval, as this required any openings in the building including windows and doors to be kept closed for the duration of the construction period, in an effort to minimise any noise disturbance for local residents. In relation to concerns raised by Councillor Westrip as to how any concerns in relation to the proposal would be monitored, the Development and Building Control Manager stated that any conditions imposed as part of this planning permission would be monitored and enforced by the Planning team. He also confirmed that the Council’s Environmental Health team would investigate any complaints made relating to noise levels from the site, which exceeded the statutory nuisance threshold. Councillor Laverick highlighted the fact that having gone through the full consultation procedure only one letter of concern had been received from the occupier of an adjacent industrial unit. Councillor Holding was in agreement with the comments made by Councillor Laverick, and added that the reference to local residents was misleading as the nearest local residents were in fact separated by the east coast mainline railway and landscaping, which would minimise any noise disturbance. Councillor M May was of the opinion that acceptance of the proposal would create further noise disruption for local residents. Councillor Ebbatson raised concern in relation to work being carried out on Sundays, and questioned whether it would be possible to amend the recommendations to agree the extended hours with the exclusion of Sunday working, in the interests of local residents. The Development and Building Control Manager was in agreement and suggested re-wording extra condition 1 of the recommendations to state that any operation in relation to the construction phase of the development should not be carried out on Sundays. Whilst he reminded Members of the Environmental Health team’s decision not to raise any objections to the proposal, he concluded that final approval of the application was a Member decision. It was therefore proposed by Councillor Ebbatson and seconded by Councillor M May that the proposal be approved subject to extra condition 1 being amended to prohibit any construction works being carried out on Sundays & Bank Holidays. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: Extra 1. Operations in relation to the construction phase of the development approved by planning approval 07/00165/FUL shall not be carried outside the following hours: - Monday to Friday - 0700 to 1900, Saturday - 0800 to 1600 No working on Sundays and Bank Holidays. In the interests of residential amenity and the avoidance of any potential disturbance or disruption to adjoining residents which may have arisen though working outside these hours and to accord with the aims of Policy IN3 of the Local Plan. Extra 2. Notwithstanding the submitted information, any openings in the building including windows and doors shall be kept closed for the duration of the construction period, unless for essential access to the building. In the interests of residential amenity and the avoidance of any potential disturbance or disruption to adjoining residents and to accord with the aims of Policy IN3 of the Local Plan. Extra 3. No works or operations shall be carried out on site within the extended operating times permitted by this permission, other than those set out in the document titled Proposed Extended Work Schedule, received 10th December 2008, unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. In the interests of residential amenity and the avoidance of any potential disturbance or disruption to adjoining residents and to accord with the aims of Policy IN3 of the Local Plan.” (4) Proposal: Revision of application 07/00165/FUL to provide a chassis wash area, on site fuel tank, x2 sprinkler tanks, motorbike shelter and other external minor works. Location: 2 Drum Park, Drum Industrial Estate, Chester-le-Street, Durham, DH2 1AE Applicant: [name removed] - Clegg Food Projects Ltd Reference: 08/00474/FUL The Senior Planning Officer spoke in relation to the application for minor external works to be carried out on the site, with particular emphasis being based on the location of each item. He advised Members that at the request of the County Council’s Highway Authority, an additional motorcycle shelter had been included in the proposal. The Development and Building Control Manager further commented that the majority of the external work would be located to the rear and side of the industrial unit, which would lessen the impact on residential properties, in terms of noise disturbance. Councillor Wilkinson therefore proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation, which was seconded by Councillor Brown. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: Extra 1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2. The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice and as amended on plan 15299//A0/0100 Rev C received 24th December 2008; unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 3. Notwithstanding any details submitted with the application the screen for the chassis wash shall be profiled steel sheeting and be no higher than the eaves height of the adjoining Vehicle Maintenance Unit and exactly match the colour of same unit in order to ensure the design quality and integrity of the scheme in accordance with Policy 8 of the Regional Spatial Strategy and Policy IN3 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan.” (5) Proposal: Revision of application 07/00165/FUL to provide minor changes to the elevation of the previously approved warehouse and vehicle maintenance unit. Location: 2 Drum Park, Drum Industrial Estate, Chester-le-Street, Durham, DH2 1AE Applicant: [name removed] - Clegg Food Projects Ltd Reference: 08/00475/FUL The Senior Planning Officer outlined the case before Members and clarified that the purpose of the application had been to provide ventilation louvers for the various plant and equipment on site. He advised that the application had been discussed with the Council’s Environmental Health team and as a result the applicant’s agent had submitted a revised noise assessment, which confirmed that noise levels created by the proposal would remain the same as previously approved. In relation to a query raised by Councillor Westrip on the nature of the fumes being vented from the unit, the Senior Planning Officer confirmed that essentially the purpose of the louvers would be to ventilate the main development to prevent any overheating of the equipment. Councillor Holding therefore proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation, which was seconded by Councillor Brown. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: 01C The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice and as amended on plan 15299//A0/0100 Rev C received 24th December 2008 unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended).” (6) Proposal: Erection of workshop and offices with ancillary access and parking (partly retrospective). Location: Land West of Stella Gill Industrial Estate, Pelton Fell, Chester-le-Street, Durham Applicant: [name removed] - Ambic Ltd - Reference: 08/00484/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs and plans in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members’ information. Councillor Laverick felt that there was no reason to object as in his opinion the building had been erected on more suitable site. Councillor Robson therefore proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation, which was seconded by Councillor Laverick. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: Extra 1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2. Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls and / or roofs of the building(s) have been submitted to, approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy IN4; of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 3. The hereby approved development shall be carried out in accordance with a scheme of landscaping to be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site, and which scheme may provide for the planting of trees and / or shrubs (including species, sizes, numbers and densities), the provision of screen fences or walls, the movement of earth, the formation of banks or slopes, the seeding of land with grass, or other works for improving the appearance of the development. The works agreed to shall be carried out within the first planting season following completion of development of the site (or of that phase of development in the case of phased development) and shall thereafter be maintained for a period of 5 yrs following planting; in the interests of visual amenity, the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in accordance with the provisions of Policy IN4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4. The development hereby approved shall not be open for business outside of the hours of 07:00 to 23:00 Monday to Saturday, with the exception of operations related to essential plant and equipment maintenance, in order to ensure the development does not adversely affect the amenities of nearby occupiers Extra 5. The door openings in the west facing elevation of the building hereby approved shall remain closed at all times the development is operational, except for instances of emergency, in order to ensure the development does not adversely affect the amenities of nearby occupiers Extra 6. Vehicular deliveries shall not be carried out outside of the hours of 08:00 to 16:30 with a maximum of 2 such visits per hour, in order to ensure the development does not adversely affect the amenities of nearby occupiers Extra 7. Notwithstanding the details contained in the application hereby approved precise details of the construction specification of the proposed building (to include appropriate sound attenuation measures) shall be submitted to and approved in writing prior to the commencement of development on site. Thereafter the development shall be constructed wholly in accordance with the approved details, in order to ensure the development does not adversely affect the amenities of nearby residential occupiers. Extra 8. No more than 1 number loading bay door shall be open at any one time when the development hereby approved is in use in order to ensure the development does not adversely affect the amenities of nearby residential occupiers. Extra 9. Within six months of the occupation of the development hereby approved the developer shall submit a Travel Plan to demonstrate proposed measures to reduce the reliance on the use of the private motor car to access the development to the satisfaction of the Local Planning Authority. Thereafter the development shall be carried out in complete accordance with the agree
Word for word from the decision Durham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.durham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Durham's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Durham

Search all
  1. Planning MattersThis decision
  2. Planning MattersApproved
  3. Planning MattersApproved
  4. Planning applications - county mattersApproved
  5. Planning MattersApproved
  6. Planning MattersApproved

More from Durham Planning Committee (CleS)

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Mar 2009 Planning Matters“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application ... Approved Open
9 Mar 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 9 February 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 9 February 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Mar 2009 Planning Matters“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application ... Approved Open
9 Feb 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 19 January 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 19 January 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Feb 2009 Exclusion of Public and Press. To Resolve:-“That under Section 100(A) of the Local Government Act 1972, the Public and Press be excluded from the meeting for th... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies