CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Durham County Council
Planning Committee (CleS), Monday 9 March 2009 at 6.00pm

Planning Matters

Approved Planning

Planning Committee (CleS) approved this item on Monday 9 March 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item58

Resolved

“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: Extra 1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2. The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 3. That the facing materials to be used for the external walls and roofs of the development hereby approved shall match in colour and texture those materials used on the existing dwelling house to the satisfaction of this Local Planning Authority, and where such matching materials are not available samples of the materials which it is proposed to use on the development shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site. Reason - In order to ensure that the proposal does not have an adverse impact upon the scale, form, character or appearance of the building upon completion, as required by Policy HP11 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4. Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 (or any Order revoking and re-enacting that Order with or without modification) the proposed garages shown on the approved drawings shall be implemented in accordance with the agreed details, and retained thereafter for the purposes of the parking of private vehicles, and shall not be used as or converted into habitable accommodation; in the interests of ensuring the development hereby approved is served by adequate off street car parking provision and to accord with the aims of Policies HP 9 and T 15 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Councillor Thompson entered the Meeting at this point. (B) District Matters Recommended Refusal (1) Proposal: Revision of application 05/00152/FUL to substitute plots 71-79 and 107-123 (26 dwellings) with 40 new dwellings. Location: Land at Holly Crescent, Sacriston, Durham Applicant: [name removed] - Barratt Homes Reference: 08/00482/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs and plans in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members’ information. Councillor Holding spoke in relation to the proposal and felt that the developers ought to be given time to produce an alternative scheme which may remedy any concerns the Planning Officers have in relation to the current application. He raised further concerns in relation to the Councils’ policy for section 106 agreements, which requires a developer to increase their contribution to a provision for public art or open space on the development, if they significantly increase the number of proposed dwellings on the site. He felt that due to the present state of the construction industry, it would be unreasonable of the council to request an additional contribution towards the provision of public art or open space for the development. Councillor Ebbatson was in agreement with the Officers recommendation to refuse the application, as the proposal did not comply with the criteria set by National Planning Policy and Chester-le-Street Local Plan guidelines. Councillors Turner and Wilkinson also felt the application should be refused in line with the Officers recommendation, due to the reduced mix in the type of houses being provided and the inadequate provision of affordable housing. Councillor Ebbatson therefore proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Turner. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager to refuse the application be agreed for the following reasons: Extra 1. The design of the development through incongruous house types and an overly dense layout does not create a sense of place or identity resulting in an intrusive overbearing development harmful to the appearance and visual amenity of the area contrary to Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan and Policy 8 of the Regional Spatial Strategy. Extra 2. The development does not provide adequate facing distances between first floor habitable windows and blank two storey gables harmful to the residential amenity of future occupiers contrary to Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 3. The development does not make adequate provision for affordable housing, contrary to Policy HP13 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4. The development does not make adequate provision for public art contrary to Policy BE2 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 5. The development does not make adequate provision for play and open space contrary to Policy RL5 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. (C) District Matters Recommended Approval (Continued) (2) Reference: 08/00471/FUL Proposal: Demolition of two agricultural barns and domestic extensions within Plawsworth Conservation Area and the erection of 13 residential units consisting of part barn conversion, sub-division of existing dwelling and part new build including access and hard surfacing details. Reference: 2/09/0055/CON Proposal: Conservation Area Consent for demolition of two agricultural and domestic extensions within Plawsworth Conservation Area. Location: Plawsworth Farm, Wheatley Well Lane, Plawsworth, Chester-le-Street, Durham, DH2 3LD Applicant: [name removed] and Building Control Manager referred to photographs and plans in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members’ information. The Development and Building Control Manager provided Members with a brief update and advised that an amended layout had been received, which allows for the retention of the existing trees at the front of the site and includes further replacement landscaping along the western boundary of the site. He further advised that since the report had been produced one additional letter of objection had been received from the residents of Priory Heights; with concerns being raised in relation to the impact a proposed new dwelling would have on their own property. The Development and Building Control Manager clarified that although unit 13 is situated in close proximity to Priory Heights; it would not directly overlook the rear elevation of the objectors’ property and would retain a relatively uninterrupted view from the rest of the property. He also advised that the developer had refrained from including any windows in the side elevation of unit 13, to lessen the overbearing impact of the property on Priory Heights. Councillor Ebbatson spoke in relation to the proposal being situated within a conservation area and queried whether an additional condition could be incorporated in the Officers recommendation which would allow the County Council’s Archaeologist access to the site on a regular basis during the ground excavations to examine any artefacts which may be uncovered as part of the works. The Development and Building Control Manager stated that the County Council’s Archaeological Officers had been consulted in connection with the application and had not forwarded any comments in relation to the development. However he further advised that he was in agreement with the comment made by Councillor Ebbatson, on the basis of the general historic value of the site and suggested that a condition be included which required the applicant to agree a method for the recording and publicising of any material or artefacts, which are found on site as part of the development works. In relation to concerns raised by Councillor Brown on the demolition of an existing building within the development site, the Development and Building Control Manager advised that Officers had accepted the applicant’s proposal to demolish the barn on balance, as the developer had demonstrated that part of the site remained inaccessible because of this building. Therefore the removal of the barn would allow the developer to propose a high quality conversion scheme for the additional buildings, which were to be accessed by these works. In addition he advised Members that the County Council Design Conservation Area Officer had not raised any objections to the proposal and clarified that a decision to refuse the demolition of the barn would result in both applications being rejected, as this would fundamentally affect the layout proposed. The Senior Planning Officer confirmed that there were no significant structural defects detected in the barn, however it had been used as a stable yard for a significant period of time and had not been used for residential use. He further advised that as the barn was not clearly visible to the public from the main road and the design of the scheme positively enhanced the conservation area, then these factors would compensate for the loss of the barn. In relation to a query raised by Councillor Brown on the proposed number of new builds associated with the development, the Development and Building Control Manager confirmed that a terrace of four new build properties had been proposed to the rear of the site, however the completion of these properties would be difficult unless the existing barn in the centre of the site was demolished. He also commented that the separation standards between the gable end of the barn and the front of these properties would be non-existent, if the barn remained. Councillor Gollan raised concerns in relation to the access arrangements and the parking provision for the proposed site. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that the County Council as Highways Authority felt the current road network, which services the application site, could accept the additional traffic created by the development as it adheres to the criteria outlined in National Planning Policies PPS1 and PPS3. He further advised that if the business had continued under its existing agricultural use, then a number of vehicular trips would have continued to be generated from the site, therefore Officers could not verify whether the proposed development would significantly increase this number enough to warrant refusal of the application. Discussion ensued in relation to concerns raised by Councillor Ebbatson on the age of the barn proposed for demolition. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that although the barn had a modern roof, it was of a similar age to other existing properties on the site. The Senior Planning Officer confirmed that the actual Farmhouse was built in the 18 th Century and stated that the barns were approximately built around the same date. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that Officers felt the barn was of lesser value than other buildings on the site as it had been significantly changed internally with a modern roof being added in the past. He also spoke in relation to National Planning Policy Guidance PPG15, which states that a Local Authority should resist the demolition of buildings, which are of high value, within Conservation Area and commented that if the barn had been in a more prominent location on the site, then Officers would have insisted the applicants include the barn in the conversion scheme. Councillor Laverick was of the opinion that Officers had secured a well-designed scheme for the site and felt the application should be approved in line with the Officers recommendations. Councillor Holding proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of approval as he felt the applicant had put forward an attractive development, which made best use of the original buildings. The proposal was seconded by Councillor Laverick, subject to the additional condition to allow the County Council’s Archaeological Officer access to the site during the excavation works, being included in the recommendations. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions: Extra 1. The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2. The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice and in accordance with the amended plan received 12th January 2009; unless otherwise firstly approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 3. Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls, hard standings, access roads, roofs of the development have been submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of the visual and residential amenity, character and appearance of Plawsworth Conservation Area and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 and Policy BE4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4. Notwithstanding any information submitted the window and door frames in the hereby approved development shall be of timber construction unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in the interests of the visual and residential amenity, character and appearance of Plawsworth Conservation Area and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 and Policy BE4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 5. Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, full details of all means of enclosure of the site (including any internal means of enclosure to sub-divide individual plots) shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of the visual and residential amenity, character and appearance of Plawsworth Conservation Area and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 and Policy BE4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 6. The hereby approved development shall be carried out in accordance with a scheme of landscaping to be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site, and which scheme may provide for the planting of trees and / or shrubs (including identifying retained trees and shrubs, new species, sizes, numbers and densities), the provision of screen fences or walls, the movement of earth, the formation of banks or slopes, the seeding of land with grass, or other works for improving the appearance of the development. The works agreed to shall be carried out within the first planting season following completion of development of the site (or of that phase of development in the case of phased development) and shall thereafter be maintained for a period of 5 yrs following planting; in the interests of the visual and residential amenity, character and appearance of Plawsworth Conservation Area and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 and Policy BE4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 7. Notwithstanding the provisions of The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (Amendment) (No. 2) (England) Order 2008 (or any Order revoking and re-enacting that Order with or without modification) any external alterations to the dwelling (except painting and repairs) and any development within the curtilage of the dwelling (ie development permitted under Schedule 2, Part 1 (Class A-H inc.) and also Part 2 (Class A) of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 shall require the benefit of planning permission in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in the interests of the visual and residential amenity, character and appearance of Plawsworth Conservation Area and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 and Policy BE4 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 8. Notwithstanding the information submitted thirteen bat crevice roosts will be created prior to the occupation of the dwellings on south and south east facing walls of the development hereby approved and should be 100mm in width and not narrower than 15mm these should be located as high as possible in the respective walls and not over windows or doorways to ensure the preservation and enhancement of species protected by law in accordance with Policy 33 of the Regional Spatial Strategy and Planning Policy Statement 9. Extra 9. No development shall commence unless in accordance with the mitigation detailed within the protected species report ‘Bat Survey Report, Plawsworth Farm, Mervyn Anthony 21st June 2008, Revision 2’ including but not restricted to adherence to spatial restrictions; adherence to precautionary working methods as stated in the report, to ensure the preservation and enhancement of species protected by law in accordance with Policy 33 of the Regional Spatial Strategy and Planning Policy Statement 9. Extra 10. No development approved by this permission shall be commenced until: a) the application site has been subjected to a detailed site investigation report for the recording and investigation of any possible contamination and has been submitted to and approved by the LPA; b) should contamination be found, detailed proposals for the removal, containment or otherwise rendering harmless such contamination (the ‘contamination proposals’) have been submitted to and approved by the LPA; c) for each part of the development, contamination proposals relevant to that part (or any part that would be affected by the development) shall be carried out either before or during such development; d) if during development works any contamination should be encountered which was not previously identified and is derived from a different source and/or of a different type to those included in the contamination proposals then revised contamination proposals shall be submitted to the LPA; and e) if during development work, site contaminants are found in areas previously expected to be clean, then their remediation shall be carried out in line with the agreed contamination proposals. In accordance with the aims of Planning Policy Statement 23. Extra 11. Notwithstanding the information submitted and prior to works commencing a detailed scheme for the disposal of foul and surface water shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority i
Word for word from the decision Durham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.durham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Durham's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Durham

Search all
  1. Planning MattersThis decision
  2. Planning MattersApproved
  3. Planning applications - county mattersApproved
  4. Planning MattersApproved
  5. Planning MattersApproved
  6. Planning MattersApproved

More from Durham Planning Committee (CleS)

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Mar 2009 Planning Matters“That the recommendations of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application ... Approved Open
9 Mar 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 9 February 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 9 February 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Feb 2009 Minutes of Previous Meeting held 19 January 2009“That the Minutes of the proceedings of the Meeting of the Committee held 19 January 2009, copies of which had previo... Decided Open
9 Feb 2009 Planning Matters“That notwithstanding the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, the application be refused for the follow... Approved Open
9 Feb 2009 Exclusion of Public and Press. To Resolve:-“That under Section 100(A) of the Local Government Act 1972, the Public and Press be excluded from the meeting for th... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies