Item65
Resolved
“That notwithstanding the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, the application be refused for the following reasons. Extra 1 The proposal would provide for a forum of development that would be harmful to the amenities of surrounding residential occupiers by virtue of undue overlooking and overbearing impact contrary to the aims of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 2 The proposal, by way of inappropriate scale, massing and detailed design solution, would provide for a form of development that would be incongruous within the street scene and as such would be detrimental to the visual amenity of the wider locality, contrary to the aims of PPS1 and PPS3, Policy 5b of the Regional Spatial Strategy, and Policies HP9 and HP17 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. At this point Councillor Harland left the Meeting at 7.30pm. (B) District Matters Recommended Refusal (1) Proposal: Erection of single storey extension at side of dwelling and erection of detached garage in garden area at side/front (amended plans received 18 February 2008) Location: 3 Kingsmere, Chester-le-Street Applicant: Mr and [name removed] - Reference 07/00544/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. The Chairman referred to a letter from Fairhurst that had been circulated to Members at the Meeting and allowed Members time to digest the information. [name removed] the applicant’s agent spoke in relation to the proposal. Councillor Holding advised that although he thought the garage could be of better design he had no objections to this proposal and would support the application. Councillor Laverick referred to the leylandi trees and advised that there were no powers to ensure that these would be retained and therefore he supported the Officer’s recommendation of refusal. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that the trees that Councillor Laverick had referred to were not owned by the applicant therefore condition could not be applied in the event of approval to require that those trees did remain in situ. Councillor Brown advised that he felt the main issue was the access to the rear garden which required the proposal to be built forward of the property and that he was minded to go with the Officer’s recommendation of refusal. Councillor Nathan agreed with the comments expressed by Councillor Laverick and Brown and was also minded to support the Officer’s recommendation. Councillor Laverick proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of refusal, which was seconded by Councillor Harrison. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager to refuse the application be agreed for the following reasons. Extra 1 The proposed detached garage by virtue of its position is considered to have a negative impact upon the character and openness of the existing street scene creating a detrimental impact on the visual amenity of the street scene and is considered to be contrary to the provisions of Policy HP11 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. (C ) District Matters Recommended Approval (3) Proposal: Various tree works to Sycamore trees (no’s 1,2,4 and 5 on plan), including removing epicormic growth, remove dead wood, crown clean and reduced sail area by 20%. Also management of one Sycamore and one Willow tree (no’s 3 & 6 on plan) on coppice basis (3 to 7 year cycle) and pruning of overhanging branches onto public highway from trees along Southern and Western boundary of garden. Location: 1 Hermitage Gardens, Chester-le-Street Applicant: Mr and [name removed] - Reference 08/00048/TPO Councillor Holding proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval which was seconded by Councillor Harrison. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions.” Extra 1 The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2 All tree works to be carried out in conjunction with the Bird/Bat Risk Assessment as produced by Barry Anderson Environmental Biologists on 6 th February 2008 in order to safeguard the amenity and long term well being of the trees in accordance with Policy NE11 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 3 All tree works to be carried out in accordance with BS3998 in order to safeguard the amenity and long term well being of the trees in accordance with Policy NE11 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 4 All existing trees to be retained and protected in accordance with BS5837:2005 in order to safeguard the amenity and long term well being of the trees in accordance with Policy NE11 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. (D) Planning General (1) List of Planning Appeals and current Status It was noted that since this list had been produced there was some amendments, which would be updated for the next meeting. “That the list of Planning Appeals and current Status be noted.” (2) Development Control Performance Update to end of Quarter 3 for 2007/08 Consideration was given to a report to provide Members with a detailed update on the Development Control Team’s performance during the first three quarters of 2007/08 for the following indicators: BVPI 109 - Speed of Decision Making BVPI 204 - Percentage of Planning Appeals Allowed PLLP 33% of Pre-application Enquiries Responded to within target PLLP 02% of Householder Planning Applications Determined in 8 weeks The Chairman referred to the problems of staffing levels, which had been a problem for the Planning Services Team over the last 12months and had caused performance to drop. The Development and Building Control Manager gave thanks to the Chairman and Councillor Laverick whose comments at the Overview and Scrutiny Management Board had helped (in his opinion) prompt a quick response for approval to be granted from CMT to fill the vacant post of the Planning Officer. “That the contents of the report be noted.”
Word for word from the decision Durham published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.durham.gov.uk