Item72
Resolved
“That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager to refuse the application be agreed for the following reasons. Extra 1 The application has not fully taken account of the potential for contamination of the site by providing a desk top study of the readily available records assessing the previous uses and their potential for contamination in relation to the proposed development. Therefore the proposed development is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 23: Planning and Pollution Control 2004. Extra 2 The application has not had full regard to wildlife and ecology considerations on site by not taking account of known nearby protected species principally the great crested newt population on Waldridge Fell of full consideration of the possibility of bats roosting in the building through inspection and surveys during the emergency periods. It is therefore considered that the presence or otherwise of protected species, and the extent that they may be affected by the development cannot be fully established contrary to Planning Policy Statement 9: Biodiversity and Geological Conservation 2005 and Policy 35 of the Regional Spatial Strategy. Extra 3 The application has not provided for a pedestrian link to Waldridge Lane that would give access to local recreational areas as well as public transport and amenities. This is contrary to the objectives of sustainable development in promoting walking as an alternative to the motor vehicle and as such the development is contrary to Policy 5A of the emerging Regional Spatial Strategy, Planning Policy Statement’s 1 and 3 and Policies HP9, T15 and T17 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan. Extra 4 The development hereby proposed does not provide the required level of affordable housing, thus fails to comply with policy HP13 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan 2003.” Councillor Turner left the Meeting at 6.50pm. (B) District Matters Recommended Approval (7) Proposal: Erection of two-storey extension to side and rear elevations and enclosure, and change of use of land adjacent to side elevation from open amenity space to domestic garden (revised scheme of 07/00376/COU) Location: 100 Queen Street, Grange Villa, Chester-le-Street Applicant: [name removed] - Reference 08/00096/COU The Development and Building Services Manager advised that since the report had been produced one further letter of objection had been received in relation to the following issues: That the two-storey extension would constitute an invasion of privacy as well as a major and unwelcome restriction of view. The 6 foot 6 inch green industrial fence that had already been erected without planning permission was deemed to be an eyesore and was a second hand fence that had allegedly been taken from a local school. The fence was not in keeping with what the Council is trying to achieve in Grange Villa. The two-storey extension would not only affect privacy but it would also block out sunlight. The objector points out that when they purchased the property eight years ago this was on the grounds that the property did have a high degree of privacy because there was not a house in front of the window. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that since considering this objection he proposed to recommend two additional extra conditions of approval as follows: · To secure a different style of fence to the one that has been erected without planning permission along the northern elevation. · That the fence be set back some 2 metres off the footpath edge to protect the visual amenity of the area. The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. [name removed] the objector spoke in relation to the application. Councillor Holding referred to page 85 of the report in relation to the untidy condition of the garden area and whether this was a material planning issue. He queried whether the decision could be split between the extension and the change of use of the land. The Chairman explained that a split decision would not recommended and had been frowned upon in the past by the Planning Inspectorate at appeal. Councillor Nathan sought clarification on where the objector lived which was indicated on a map and shown to all Members of the Committee. Councillor Nathan after viewing the map felt that every property in that street was overlooked in a similar manner. Councillor Ellis queried whether a condition to impose obscure glazing would resolve the issue of overlooking. The Development and Building Control Manager advised that this would not be recommended and clarified that the separation standards proposed for this application did mirror the rest of the properties within the street. Councillor Nathan proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval to include the two extra conditions that had been suggested. This proposal was seconded by Councillor Humes and carried by Members. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions. Extra 1 The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2 The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 3 That the facing materials to be used for the external walls and roofs of the development hereby approved shall match in colour and texture those materials used on the existing dwelling house to the satisfaction of this Local Planning Authority, and where such matching materials are not available samples of the materials which it is proposed to use on the development shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site. Reason - In order to ensure that the proposal does not have an adverse impact upon the scale, form, character or appearance of the building upon completion, as required by Policy HP11 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4 Notwithstanding the details shown on the submitted plans, a detailed planting scheme along the Western elevation of the enclosure to be submitted and agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority, prior to commencement of the development, in the interests of the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion. Extra 5 A contaminated land survey be carried out and submitted to the Local Planning Authority for approval prior to commencement of any work(s) on site. Thereafter any works recommended by the said survey shall be undertaken in accordance with details to be first agreed in writing with the Council in order to ensure the safe development of the site and to accord with the aims of Planning Policy Statement 23 and Policy 24 of the Regional Spatial Strategy.” Extra 6 Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, full details of a revised fence style to the Northern elevation of the site shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority, within 56 days from the date of approval, in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual and residential amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP16 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 7 Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, the proposed fence line to the Northern elevation of the site is to be set back 2m from the footpath. Full details of which shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority, within 56 days from the date of approval, in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual and residential amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP16 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. At this point Councillor Humes left the Meeting at 7.05pm. (4) Proposal: Resubmission of 08/00003/FUL for the erection of 1 dormer bungalow (Amendment to provide additional dormer window at front of bungalow) Location: Land West of the Populars, Arcadia Avenue, Chester-le-Street Applicant: [name removed] - Reference 08/00065/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the report, which were displayed for Members information. The Development and Building Control Manager explained the difference between the application, which was approved in February, and this application. He advised that the applicant’s architect had made a mistake and on the planned view drawings he had made reference to the dormer window but it had not been shown on the elevational drawings. He advised that the applicant then had a choice to make on whether to amend the application to include this window for consideration or delete it. He advised that if the application had been amended Officers would have then had to go back out for consultation therefore the applicant had chosen to leave the application as it was and secure approval for the bungalow without the dormer window. The Development and Building Control Manager clarified that this application was only to consider the dormer window on the front elevation and the remainder of the development had already been agreed at the Meeting in February. He referred to a two-page letter submitted by the applicant, which had been circulated to Members. [name removed] the objector and [name removed] the applicant spoke in relation to the application. Following a query from Councillor May, a plan was circulated to all Members to show the physical difference between the applications. Both Councillor Laverick and Councillor Nathan were in agreement that the substitution of the dormer window in place of the velux would cause no more problem of overlooking on the adjacent property then what was originally approved. Councillor Brown was of the opinion that the application should remain as originally agreed and he did not support the application before him. Councillor Wilkinson felt that there was no reason why this application should be refused as the application complied with the 45-degree rule and separation distances. Councillor Laverick proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation of conditional approval, which was seconded by Councillor Harrison. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions.” Extra 1 The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 2 The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 3 Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls and / or roofs of the building (s) have been submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 4 Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, full details of all means of enclosure of the site (including any internal means of enclosure to sub-divide individual plots) shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual and residential amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 5 The hereby approved development shall be carried out in accordance with the scheme of landscaping which was submitted to the Local Planning Authority on the 20 February 2008 and approved via letter on the 6 March 2008 in accordance with plan reference LPA1 attached to planning application 08/00003/FUL. The works agreed shall be carried out within the first planting season following completion of development of the site (or of that phase of development in the case of phased development) and thereafter be maintained for 5 years, in the interests of visual amenity, the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 6 Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 (or any Order revoking and re-enacting that Order with or without modification) any external alterations to the dwelling (except painting and repairs) and any development within the curtilage of the dwelling (ie development permitted under Schedule 2, Part 1 (Class A-H inc.) and Part 2 (Class A) of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 shall require the benefit of planning permission in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in the interests of visual and residential amenity. (6) Proposal: Erection of new residential dwelling to side of existing property Location: 2 George Street, Chester-le-Street, Co Durham Applicant: Mr and [name removed] - Reference 08/00078/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the proposal, which were displayed for Members information. [name removed] the objector spoke in relation to the application. The Development and Building Control Manager referred to points raised by the speaker and made reference to the access for wheelie bin storage, which he advised, would be a civil matter and this was not a reason to refuse the application. In relation to the access arrangements he advised that this had been subject of discussions with the County Council as a Highways Authority and explained that the gates were designed to open inwards so that they would not obstruct the Highway. In terms of the extra traffic he advised that there was no significant safety risk that the development would propose. In relation to the construction stage he advised that the developer needed to put scaffolding on the Highway then he would need a licence, which would be administered by Durham County Council Highways Authority who could look at alternative provision for pedestrians. In the Development and Building Control Manager’s opinion these were all issues, which did not constitute refusal for this application. Councillor Brown advised that although he agreed with the application in principal he had concerns in relation to parking problems, the lack of parking spaces and access for this development, therefore he felt he could not go support the Officer’s recommendation. The Development and Building Control Manager clarified the points raised by Councillor Brown which he felt would be difficult to refuse the application on the grounds he had raised. In response to a query from Councillor Nathan the Development and Building Control Manager confirmed that he understood the Highways Authority Officers had visited the site. Councillor Harrison referred to the points raised and advised that in his opinion the problems with parking was a civil matter and he agreed with the Officer’s recommendation. Councillor Wilkinson was in agreement with Councillor Harrison and proposed to move the Officer’s recommendation, which was seconded by Councillor Harrison. This proposal was carried. “That the recommendation of the Development and Building Control Manager for approval in respect of the application be agreed, subject to the following conditions. 01A The development must be begun not later than the expiration of three years from the date of this permission, in order to prevent the accumulation of unused planning permissions as required by Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended). Extra 1 The development hereby approved shall be carried out wholly in accordance with the details contained in the application as submitted to the Council on the date specified in Part 1 of this decision notice unless otherwise firstly approved in writing with the Local Planning Authority; in order to ensure the development is carried out in complete accordance with the approved plans. Extra 2 Notwithstanding any description of the materials in the application, no development shall be commenced until samples or precise details of the materials to be used in the construction of the external walls, roofs and hard standings/access roads of the development have been submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion, in the interests of visual amenity and in accordance with the provisions of Policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street District Local Plan. Extra 3 Notwithstanding the details shown on the hereby approved plans and elevations, full details of all means of enclosure of the site (including any internal means of enclosure to sub-divide individual plots) shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the Local Planning Authority prior to the commencement of any development on site in order to ensure the satisfactory appearance of the development upon completion and in the interests of visual and residential amenity in accordance with policy HP9 of the Chester-le-Street Local Plan 2003.” At this point Councillor Holding left the Meeting at 7.45pm. (2) Proposal: Erection of 10 no apartments and associated parking Location: Former Dog and Gun, Front Street, Great Lumley Applicant: Ashbrooke Developments - Reference 07/00542/FUL The Development and Building Control Manager referred to photographs in relation to the application, which were displayed for Members information. He referred to an error on page 33 paragraph 1 of the report, which should state that the open space was to be served by extra planning condition 9 and not 3. He advised that the since the report had been published the case officer had held further discussions with the architect which had resulted in Block B to the rear of the site being moved further forward so that it complied with the 21 metre separation standards. He suggested that an extra condition be added to state that the developmen
Word for word from the decision Durham published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.durham.gov.uk