Resolved
REFUSED as per officer recommendation.
Development Management Committee refused this item on Tuesday 2 April 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
REFUSED as per officer recommendation.
This application is before Members because the recommendation is contrary to the view of one of the Ward Members.
Planning permission is sought for a dwelling on a haulage yard in the countryside to the north of Ottery St Mary. This is a revised scheme following withdrawal of an application just prior to consideration at the April 2018 Committee.
The site is outside the Built-up Area Boundary and close to Cadhay, a grade I listed manor house and its grade II registered gardens. The proposal also involves the loss of part of the haulage yard. These concerns formed the basis for the recommendation of refusal of the previous application. To address these concerns the dwelling has been reduced from two stories to a bungalow and it has been moved away from the boundary nearest Cadhay. In this way a large enough yard would be retained for the business to function and the impact on the setting of Cadhay had been addressed. The current proposal has therefore overcome two of the earlier concerns.
The remaining concern, however, has not been addressed. In countryside locations dwellings are only permitted in exceptional circumstances and where there is specific Local or Neighbourhood Plan support. In the absence of a relevant Neighbourhood Plan policy, the only policy that may offer support is Policy H4 (Dwellings for Persons Employed in Rural Businesses). In this case however it is questioned whether Policy H4 is relevant as the business, whilst in a rural area, is not a rural business in terms of needing to be located in a rural area. In addition, even if Policy H4 were to apply, there is still insufficient evidence of a functional need to live on site. While the applicant claims a need for an on- site security presence, the Local Plan states: "Concerns relating to security will not, on their own, be sufficient to justify a new dwelling." Moreover, there is
18/1442/FUL already a dwelling on site occupied by the applicant's parents and various measures could be put in place to improve security, such as putting a gate across the entrance.
In the absence of a policy to support the proposal, given the unsustainable location of the site, and lack of demonstrable need to live at the site should Policy H4 be considered to be applicable, there is no justification for the provision of a dwelling and therefore refusal is recommended.
CONSULTATIONS
Local Consultations
Ottery St Mary Rural - Cllr P Carter I would like to support this application with the view of supporting local businesses. Being able to live onsite, this application will allow the enhancement and further the sustainability of a family business. With the reductions in daily car journeys to and from work, increasing security onsite and allowing the different family generations to continue and grow this long standing and successful family business.
Parish/Town Council 21/08/2018 - Ottery St Mary Town Council supports this application as it is a better revised application with a single storey and not in view of Cadhay House which is a listed building.
Further comments 25/09/2018 - As requested, please find below a list of comments in response of the Town Council's support of the above application:
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
18/1442/FUL (Minor)Report | 868 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Development Management Committee at East Devon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2834/OUT & 20/0482/RES (Minor) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEARE(19/2834/OUT) Approved as per Officer recommendation. (20/0482/RES) Approved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2724/FUL (Minor) - BROADCLYSTApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0393/OUT (Minor) - SIDMOUTH SIDFORDApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0550/MOUT (Major) - TALE VALEApproved contrary to Officer recommendation subject to S.106 agreement to secure a financial contribution towards off... | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2832/MFUL (Major) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEAREApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.