Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
Development Management Committee refused this item on Tuesday 11 June 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
The planning application is before Members as the officer recommendation differs from the view of the former Ward Member.
The proposal seeks planning consent for the creation of a dwelling.
Due to its isolated location the proposed dwelling would conflict with the development plan. However, the NPPF identifies circumstances to permit dwellings in such isolated positions subject to certain criteria including where the design is truly exceptional and where the development would significantly enhance its immediate setting. The bar to reach such circumstances is a high one and is one which is ever evolving.
Members will have to decide, taking into account the officer recommendation, whether this design meets the very high bar set by national guidance and whether this proposal represents a truly outstanding design raising the architectural standards generally within the district and significantly enhances its setting.
There are un-common uses of traditional materials most notably the integration of straw bales and cob walls to provide air tightness whilst allowing vapour to escape, and the design is of high quality. Indeed it should be noted that the design has the support of the Design Review Panel that the applicant took the proposal too prior to submission of the application.
Balanced against this is that the sustainability levels reached by the use of traditional materials appears not to be ground breaking and there is doubt regarding the wider application of such construction methods to other types of development. This aspect has to be balanced against the potential learning outcomes from the methodology of the construction.
19/0078/FUL Nevertheless, officers have doubts on how the form of the building originated from and references its context. Further, the development takes place almost 10 years after the development of an exceptional cob dwelling at Dingle Dell, Ottery St Mary and searches on the internet demonstrate that combining cobb and bale in construction is neither truly exceptional nor innovative. Officers struggle therefore to see how the concepts now proposed result in an evolution of cob buildings to meet the ever rising bar of exceptional quality and do not believe that the proposal will significantly enhance its setting and be sensitive to the local area given is location, prominence and relationship to the landform.
Taking the above into account a balanced recommendation of refusal is made.
CONSULTATIONS
Local Consultations
Clerk To All Saints Parish Council Proposed by Chair that Council does NOT support the application (Oppose) on the following grounds:
- That Council notes the outcome of the previous two appeals against planning refusal for this site and believes that nothing has changed since that time.
- That Council believes there to be a covenant on the land relating from the prior construction of the property known as "Poppins" (which prevents further development) and would require further reassurances in this respect.
- That the site does not warrant, nor can support, a building of this proposed scale, design and overall size.
- That the use of Paragraph 79 of the NPPFF is not justified as the proposed dwelling is not innovative nor outstanding as it uses established building methods.
- That, even if the building were to be considered architecturally outstanding, the land on which it will sit is not and the building would be out of keeping with neighbouring buildings.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
19/0078/FUL (Minor)Report | 941 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Development Management Committee at East Devon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2834/OUT & 20/0482/RES (Minor) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEARE(19/2834/OUT) Approved as per Officer recommendation. (20/0482/RES) Approved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2724/FUL (Minor) - BROADCLYSTApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0393/OUT (Minor) - SIDMOUTH SIDFORDApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0550/MOUT (Major) - TALE VALEApproved contrary to Officer recommendation subject to S.106 agreement to secure a financial contribution towards off... | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2832/MFUL (Major) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEAREApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.