Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
Development Management Committee refused this item on Tuesday 3 March 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
This application (together with a very similar proposal relating to an adjacent site subject of application ref. 19/2312/FUL) is brought before Members as the officer recommendation differs to the view of the ward member.
The proposal involves the demolition of a former agricultural building, a steel- framed Dutch barn with an attached steel-framed lean-to, at Upcott Farm, between Broadhembury and Kerswell, and its replacement with a four bedroom dwelling. A change of use of additional land around the existing building to form an enlarged curtilage area for the proposed dwelling also forms part of the development.
Prior approval was granted in April 2019 (ref. 19/0239/PDQ) under the relevant provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order for the change of use, and associated operational development, of the building to create a dwelling. The current scheme is therefore, in effect, a substitute proposal for this.
The replacement of an agricultural building with a new build dwelling in an open countryside location outside of any established settlement would ordinarily, at the very least, be likely to be considered contrary to policies intended to restrict new residential development on grounds relating to the non-sustainable location of the site and would therefore deemed to be unacceptable in principle.
However, the application draws on the case of Mansell v. Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council, heard at the Court of Appeal in September 2017, which upheld a previous judgment of the High Court that the availability of permitted
19/2311/FUL development rights can properly be taken into account as a fallback position where some alternative form of development scheme is then proposed. As such, a fallback development may be a material consideration in relation to such a proposal.
Indeed, the circumstances of the Mansell case were similar to those surrounding this application insofar as they involved a new build residential scheme as a substitute proposal for a barn that could be converted to residential use using permitted development rights, albeit that there was no permission or prior approval in place for such a scheme at the time of the court hearing. In fact, the case in support of the Slade Farm proposal is arguably stronger given that there is an extant prior approval in place for the conversion of the application building that remains capable of being implemented.
In such circumstances therefore, it is not considered that the principle of the development in this case could readily be opposed.
However, it remains the case, as with the majority of proposals, that development should be sympathetic to its context in line with the provisions of Local Plan Policies D1, D8 and Strategy 46, which requires that development be undertaken in a manner that is sympathetic to, and helps conserve and enhance, the quality and distinctiveness of the natural landscape character of the district.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
19/2311/FUL (Minor)Report | 788 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Development Management Committee at East Devon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2834/OUT & 20/0482/RES (Minor) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEARE(19/2834/OUT) Approved as per Officer recommendation. (20/0482/RES) Approved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2724/FUL (Minor) - BROADCLYSTApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0393/OUT (Minor) - SIDMOUTH SIDFORDApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 20/0550/MOUT (Major) - TALE VALEApproved contrary to Officer recommendation subject to S.106 agreement to secure a financial contribution towards off... | Approved | Open |
| 29 Jul 2020 | 19/2832/MFUL (Major) - WEST HILL & AYLESBEAREApproved as per Officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.