Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 17 March 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Refused as per officer recommendation.
This application is brought before Committee as the officer recommendation is contrary to the view of the ward member.
The proposal involves the construction of a two storey three bedroom dwelling within a corner of an open field that forms part of the holding at the Edenvale Turf farm - operated by the applicant's family - at Courtlands, Dulford.
The intended site for the dwelling is around 250-350 metres to the north of the main complex of farm buildings at Courtlands immediately adjacent to the commercial entrance to the farm.
The dwelling is not being expressly proposed as a rural worker's dwelling under the provisions of paragraph 79 of the National Planning Policy Framework or Policy H4 of the adopted Local Plan, although, should Members be minded to view the proposal favourably, the applicant would be willing to accept an agricultural occupancy restriction being placed upon the accommodation by condition.
The development is being justified more strongly on the basis of it amounting to a replacement dwelling (and therefore to be considered having regard to the provisions of Local Plan Policy H6) for one of three approved (but yet to be commenced) residential conversions of farm buildings at Courtlands granted prior approval, under the relevant provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order, in July 2019 (under ref. 19/0267/PDQ). This approval remains extant until July 2022.
As such, and in order to ensure that part of this approval could not be implemented in addition to the construction of the proposed dwelling, were it to be approved, thereby resulting in a net addition of one dwelling in the open countryside, the applicant has offered a draft unilateral undertaking (under
20/1801/FUL section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act) setting out obligations to forego the approved conversion in place of this proposal.
The acceptance of the fundamental principle of substituting the conversion for a new build dwelling has been accepted in case law (Mansell) and the applicant draws upon this in support of the principle of the development.
However, it is considered that the proposal fails to meet the criteria set out in Policy H6 insofar as it would not be located on or adjacent to the footprint of the 'existing' dwelling, or elsewhere within the curtilage of the building where a clear planning or environmental benefit would be achieved and, more critically, would be positioned where it would appear unduly visually prominent in the surrounding landscape and detract from its character and appearance.
Whilst not being actively promoted on the basis of a rural worker's dwelling, the application seeks to justify the proposed siting on the basis of the security that it would provide for the farm at its 'business' entrance and the opportunity that it would facilitate for the provision of a 'succession' dwelling for the applicant to enable her to progress the management of the farm that she has begun during the past year.
It is therefore thought that engaging the Policy H4 criteria is unavoidable. Indeed, the preamble in the Local Plan is clear in stating that succession housing on farms should meet these criteria.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
20/1801/FUL (Minor) TALE VALEReport | 216 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Planning Committee at East Devon and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Sep 2026 | 25/2471/MRES (Major) CRANBROOKApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 1 Sep 2026 | 26/1143/PIP (Other) CLYST VALLEYThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Permission in Principle be approved. | Approved | Open |
| 1 Sep 2026 | 26/0854/FUL (Minor) BROADCLYSTApproved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation. | Approved | Open |
| 1 Sep 2026 | 26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ... | Approved | Open |
| 1 Sep 2026 | 26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.