That council notes the decision to specify sheet piles of in-excess of 50year design life, which enables greater options for future cladding. This decision has changed since the previous cabinet report. 2. That council notes that the works will be phased, with the eastern section work (phase 1) being undertaken this March 2024, and the western section being deferred until all remaining risks can be mitigated, with the earliest start being September 2024. 3. That council notes that the eastern section works (Phase 1) proceed starting in March, with the aim to finish late-May. 4. That council notes that decisions will have to be made regarding the completion of phase 2, without the benefit of knowing the outputs of the larger Exmouth Seafront Placemaking strategy. 5. That council notes that optional weekend working is undertaken to reduce duration on site. 6. That council resolves to increase funding of Phase 1 only to £1.5m (from £1.1m for both Phase 1 and Phase 2 of the wall) 7. That council notes that a further request for funding will be needed to progress phase 2 and cladding. 8. That council notes the need for a further exemption to contract standing orders to allow the direct award contract to Moffat and Nichol (consultant) from due to the increase from £60k to £200k (within existing project budget outlines in recommendation 6) 9. That council notes that expenditure on the contract to Moffat and Nichol has exceeded £ 100k 10. that Council refer this matter to the Scrutiny Committee in order that it can interrogate the reasons relating to the failure of the sea wall and the previous approval that led to business and associated infrastructure being built next to it.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 6th March 2024 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A
Exmouth Emergency Seawall Repairs Update Report summary: The report is to update cabinet on the situation in Exmouth regarding the emergency repairs and to ask for decisions on its repairs and additional funding
Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☐ No ☒ Policy Framework Yes ☒ No ☐ Recommendation: 1. That council notes the decision to specify sheet piles of in-excess of 50year design life, which enables greater options for future cladding. This decision has changed since the previous cabinet report. 2. That council notes that the works will be phased, with the eastern section work (phase 1) being undertaken this March 2024, and the western section being deferred until all remaining risks can be mitigated, with the earliest start being September 2024. 3. That council notes that the eastern section works (Phase 1) proceed starting in March, with the aim to finish late-May. 4. That council notes that decisions will have to be made regarding the completion of phase 2, without the benefit of knowing the outputs of the larger Exmouth Seafront Placemaking strategy. 5. That council notes that optional weekend working is undertaken to reduce duration on site. 6. That council resolves to increase funding of Phase 1 only to £1.5m (from £1.1m for both Phase 1 and Phase 2 of the wall) 7. That council notes that a further request for funding will be needed to progress phase 2 and cladding. 8. That council notes the need for a further exemption to contract standing orders to allow the direct award contract to Moffat and Nichol (consultant) from due to the increase from £60k to £200k (within existing project budget outlines in recommendation 6) 9. That council notes that expenditure on the contract to Moffat and Nichol has exceeded £100k
Reason for recommendation: 1. Although there could be a £75k saving, specifying thicker sheet piles at this point will give greater flexibility in selecting cladding in the future, to give the wall a 100year design life. 2. Although undesirable, from a business, visitor and residents’ perspective, the benefits outweigh the negatives for a March start, with late-May Finish. 3. Due to uncertainties regarding the future of the placemaking of Queens Drive space, and the existing concessions and their leases, we cannot commit to design and construction without delay to the failed eastern section. 4. If weekend working is permitted, it will reduce the overall duration on site, reducing impact. 5. Cross service officer work is required to ensure phase 2 can begin before plans are finalised for any future Exmouth Seafront Placemaking plans, and to do so, phase 2 will need to work on assumptions and may require difficult decisions to be made regarding this section of wall. 6. Unlike most large construction schemes which are years in the making, this scheme has had rapid development, and to keep momentum, and meet deadlines, we may need to make major decisions that cannot wait for cabinet cycles. 7. Project costs have increased largely due to poor ground conditions following surveys so previously agreed expenditure needs to increase. 8. The original £1.1m estimate for the whole wall (without cladding) was based on assumed better ground conditions then found. Therefore Phase 2 and cladding will need to be funded from further budget increase at a later date. 9. As the project has progressed additional research and design has been required.
Officer: Tom Buxton-Smith, Engineer Project Management, [email protected], 01395571630
Portfolio(s) (check which apply): ☒ Climate Action and Emergency Response ☒ Coast, Country and Environment ☐ Council and Corporate Co-ordination ☐ Communications and Democracy ☐ Economy ☒ Finance and Assets ☒ Strategic Planning ☐ Sustainable Homes and Communities ☒ Culture, Leisure, Sport and Tourism
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.