In Perpetuity Funding for Management of Clyst Meadows SANG
ApprovedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryEast Devon Cabinet approves a £1.1m investment fund from CIL to secure in-perpetuity management of Clyst Meadows SANG, overturning an earlier annual funding recommendation.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedSet up £1.1m fund for 80-year SANG management
Money£1.1m from CILInvestment fund plus £100k back-up reserve
What happens nextOfficers to set up fundDelegated authority to four directors and portfolio holders
Who it affectsCIL-funded projects and new authorityFunding decision required before 2028 reorganisation
What was decided
Cabinet approved a £1.1m investment fund from CIL to secure in-perpetuity management of Clyst Meadows SANG. Report P14
Authority was delegated to four senior officers, in consultation with relevant Portfolio Holders, to set up and manage the fund. Report P15
Why
East Devon is a Competent Authority with a legal duty to manage SANG in-perpetuity as part of the SE Devon Internationally Protected Habitats Mitigation Strategy. Report P15, 1.2, P40
Independent financial advice and CCLA Investment Management indicated £1.1m is sufficient to generate returns for 80 years of management and capital replacement. Report P12, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 2.8
Option 3 was considered the lowest financial risk, lowest cost, and avoids leaving the in-perpetuity funding decision to a new authority focused on reorganisation in 2028. Report 3.2, P42
What happens next
Officers will set up the £1.1m investment fund and arrange its management, with an additional £100,000 held in a ring-fenced high-interest account as back-up. Report P15, 2.7
Planning conditions for Clyst Meadows (24/2049/MFUL) are to be amended to require 80 years of management under the SANG Management Plan. Report 1.4
A future report will present a Strategic SANG Delivery Strategy (2025-2040) with estimated costs across the Habitat Regulations Partnership.
The money
£1.1m Investment fund from CIL to fund in-perpetuity SANG management Report P14, 2.8
£100,000 Ring-fenced back-up fund held in high-interest account Report 2.7
£1.63M Total budget for Clyst Meadows site works (excluding land and management) Report P7
£200,000 Capital programme contribution to site works Report P7
£200k UK Shared Prosperity Fund for shared cycle path Report P7
£4.114M Total budget approved by Cabinet on 1 May 2024 Report 1.6, P25
£485,000 Land acquisition for Clyst Meadows Report P25
£1,629,000 Site works including fees, contingency and inflation Report P25
£40k per annum Annual CIL contribution previously recommended by Strategic Planning Committee Report P10, 3.1
Options considered
Rejected: Option 1: Annual £40k from CIL for 3 years, then review in 2028. Creates financial risk and leaves decision to newly formed authority during reorganisation Report 3.1, 3.2, P42
Rejected: Option 2: Annual £40k from CIL with inflation, extended to 5 years until 2030. Still leaves long-term funding unresolved and creates CIL pressure Report 3.1, 3.2
Chosen: Option 3: Create £1.1m investment fund from CIL for in-perpetuity management from 2026. Lowest financial risk, lowest overall cost, and provides certainty for 80-year management Report 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, P42
Implications
Legal: Failure to manage SANG in-perpetuity would breach planning consent and Cranbrook Phase 1 s106, risk Natural England blocking further housing, and expose the Council to legal challenge. Report 1.5, P40, P41
Financial: The £1.1m investment reduces long-term risk of funding shortfalls from CIL but reduces the CIL pot available for other infrastructure projects. Report P12, P18, 1.8
Risk: Investment returns may not always meet needs; the £100,000 back-up reserve mitigates this. If CIL returns are insufficient under the annual draw-down approach, deficits fall on the authority's other budgets. Report 2.7, P18
Climate: Low climate change impact identified; the project supports ecological recovery and links to a strategic cycle path. Report P18, P6
Other: Decision avoids leaving the in-perpetuity funding question to a new authority during Local Government Re-Organisation in 2028. Report P12, P42
Who and where
Cranbrook and wider West End residents (mitigation for housing impact on Exe Estuary and East Devon Pebblebed Heaths SPAs) Report 1.2, P5
Broadclyst and Mosshayne/Tithebarn communities near the SANG site Report P6
Future housing developers in East Devon (mitigation requirement supports continued housing delivery) Report 1.5, P41
Habitat Regulations Partnership (Exeter City Council and Teignbridge District Council also contribute) Report 1.2
CIL-funded infrastructure projects (reduced CIL availability due to £1.1m allocation) Report 1.8, P18
The newly created local authority taking over from 2028 Report P12
Timeline
1st May 2024: Cabinet approved £4.114M budget for Clyst Meadows subject to CIL Member Working Party decision Report P8, 1.6
February 2025: CIL Member Working Party recommended CIL funding for site works but not the £2M endowment Report 1.8
April 2025: Cabinet supported tender and contractor appointment for site works Report 1.9
19th May 2025: Strategic Planning Committee approved CIL for site works and recommended £40k annual CIL for 3 years instead of endowment Report P9, P10, 1.8
3 December 2025: Cabinet decision to create £1.1m CIL investment fund for in-perpetuity management Report P2
Spring 2026: Estimated completion and opening of Clyst Meadows site works Report 1.9
From 2026: Investment fund to secure in-perpetuity funding under Option 3 Report 3.1
Early 2028: Local Government Re-Organisation: new authority to be formed Report P12
Plain English for the jargon
SANG: Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace: open land provided to attract visitors away from internationally protected wildlife sites, reducing recreation pressure on them.
CIL: Community Infrastructure Levy: a charge developers pay to local authorities to fund infrastructure needed because of development.
Competent Authority: A body legally required under the Habitat Regulations to assess and mitigate the impact of plans or projects on protected habitats.
Habitat Regulations Assessment: A process to check whether a plan or project is likely to harm internationally protected wildlife sites, and to set out mitigation if needed.
s106: Section 106 agreement: a legal agreement between a developer and a local planning authority tied to a planning permission.
In perpetuity: Forever; for the report, defined as a minimum of 80 years of management.
BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain: a policy requiring developments to leave biodiversity in a better state than before.
SPAs: Special Protection Areas: sites designated under EU and UK law to protect rare and migratory birds.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item118
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet: 1. Approves the creation of an investment fund of £1.1m, funded from CIL, to secure the in-perpetuity funding for the management of Clyst Meadows. 2. Delegates authority to the Assistant Director Planning Strategy and Development Management, Finance Director, Place Director and Director Governance, in consultation with the relevant Portfolio Holders, to set up and arrange for the management of this fund. REASON: The Council as the competent authority, had a legal responsibility to ensure that SANG was provided and managed in-perpetuity as part of the Mitigation Strategy for the SE Devon Internationally Protected Habitats. The delivery and in-perpetuity management of Clyst Meadows SANG was one of the mitigation measures identified through the Habitat Regulations Assessment process, ensuring the Council met its legislative requirements when permitting housing development through the Local Plan.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 3 December 2025 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release n/a
In Perpetuity Funding for Management of Clyst Meadows SANG
Report summary:
This paper provides Cabinet with an update on the management funding for Clyst Meadows Countryside Park (10Ha Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace (SANG)) at Station Road, Broadclyst which sits within the wider Clyst Valley Regional Park. The paper also provides estimated costs for future SANG delivery to mitigate the impact of residential allocations in the emerging Local Plan.
The delivery of Clyst Meadows will ensure that the planning authority is able to meet our statutory duty to preserve the integrity of nearby internationally designated habitat sites. This project also assists in delivery of Clyst Valley Regional Park objectives. Clyst Meadows is adjacent to Cranbrook, and close to Broadclyst and Mosshayne/Tithebarn, and will facilitate the delivery of the Station Road-Mosshayne strategic cycle link.
The total budget for delivery of the site works at Clyst Meadows is £1.63M (excluding land purchase and management costs). This is funded through CIL contributions, s106 agreements and £200k from the capital programme. A further £200k of UK SPF funding is also allocated for delivery of the shared cycle path.
In order to meet in perpetuity (minimum 80 years) management costs Cabinet approved (1 st May 2024) an estimated further £2M, subject to CIL Member Working Party’s Decision, to fund an Endowment to provide an annual return to fund maintenance and capital replacement costs for 80 years.
Subsequently Strategic Planning Committee (19 th May 2025), following CIL Member Working Party’s advice, approved the funding for site works, but based on the estimated £2M investment requirement on other CIL funded infrastructure projects, supported the following recommendation:
4. That Members advise Cabinet that they do not agree to funding an endowment to cover the maintenance costs of the SANG at Station Road, Broadclyst as per Cabinet’s resolution of the 1st May 2024 and recommend that Cabinet agree that these costs be funded through an annual contribution of £40k from CIL for the first 3 years after which these should be reviewed.
A draft report to Cabinet was prepared early this year, and further work was requested due to concerns about the financial risk to the Council of delaying in -perpetuity funding arrangements until 2028. This approach secures short-term management funding, but in the longer term an annual draw down creates risks for the Council. Should CIL funding be insufficient or on -site capital replacement costs exceed the value of the sinking fund management and site works would need to be funded from the Council’s reven ue and/or capital funds.
Subsequent work has been undertaken to more accurately quantify the value of the investment required to generate sufficient funds to manage Clyst Meadows in perpetuity. Advice from an Independent Financial Advisor and CCLA Investment Management indicate that an appropriate low-risk investment to secure in-perpetuity funding would be £1.1M (to be funded from CIL). In addition to the financial risks outlined above the timeline approved by Strategic Planning Committee will intersect with Local Government Re-Organisation and require the newly created authority to receive a report on the in -perpetuity funding of Clyst Meadows early in 2028 - when the new authority will focuse on reorganisation and a significant number of other priorities. It is therefore considered that either an earlier decision to set up the in -perpetuity investment, or an extended timeline for an interim annual payment, would minimise the risk to the Council.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.