AI summaryEast Devon Cabinet adopts the Exmouth Beach Management Plan Update, supporting three leading options for managing coastal flood and erosion risk over the next 100 years, and pushes for the project to be a priority for the successor authority from 2028/29.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedCabinet supports three leading options under adaptive pathway
Money£140k remaining budgetFor preparatory studies under £100k, not returned to general pot
What happens nextBusiness case from 2028/29Successor authority to take project forward after LGR
Who it affectsExmouth coastal frontageHolders of property, beach, tourism and infrastructure at risk
What was decided
Cabinet adopted the Exmouth BMP Update and supported the three leading options under the adaptive pathway approach for short, medium and long-term management of the Exmouth frontage. Report P3
Cabinet agreed to recommend the project, including preparatory work by South West Flood and Coastal, as a priority for the successor authority following Local Government Reorganisation from 2028/29. Report P3
Cabinet approved using the remaining £140k from the 2 October 2024 approval for preparatory studies under £100k by South West Flood and Coastal, rather than returning the underspend to the general pot. Report P3
Why
The 2015 BMP needed updating due to revised sea level rise guidance, more monitoring data, seawall failures at Exmouth in autumn 2023 and changes to national FDGiA funding rules in 2020/21. Report P3, 1.6
Under a do-nothing scenario over 100 years, around £20m of FDGiA-eligible damages and over £800m of wider local economic damages are at risk along the BMP frontage. Report 1.8, 1.10
The previous 2013 EEFCERMS approach of maintaining the wall and beach has not been successful, so a more significant capital intervention is needed to continue defending the frontage. Report 1.16
What happens next
From 2028/29 to 2032, develop a business case and outline design for the National Economic or Local Aspirational option, alongside a funding strategy and environmental surveys to address Habitat Regulations Assessment gaps. Report P40, P41, P42, P44, 1.27
Between 2033 and 2034, complete detailed design, secure planning permission and marine licences, agree mitigation with Natural England and undertake further early contractor involvement. Report P45, P46, P47
Construction of the chosen option is estimated for about 2035, with movement between options handled through the adaptive pathway approach based on funding triggers. Report 1.16, 1.22, 1.23
The money
£140k Remaining budget from 2 October 2024 Cabinet approval, to fund preparatory studies under £100k Report P3
£20m Present Value of FDGiA-eligible coastal flood and erosion damages over 100 years under do-nothing Report 1.8
£800m Present Value of wider local economic damages over 100 years under do-nothing, not eligible for FDGiA Report 1.10
£800,000 to £900,000 Central Government FDGiA funding eligible for the National Economic or Local Aspirational options under current rules Report 1.16, P26
£18 million Additional funding needed to implement the National Economic Leading Option Report 1.16
£20-23 million Additional funding needed to implement the Local Aspirational Leading Option Report P26
£1.6-£2.1m Minimum additional funding required under the new Defra funding policy from April 2026 Report 1.20
Options considered
Chosen: National Economic Leading Option: seawall encasement with setback floodwall. Most cost-beneficial under current national FCERM appraisal and funding rules; eligible for £800,000 to £900,000 of central Government funding Report 1.16, P23
Chosen: Local Aspirational Leading Option: beach nourishment with groynes and setback floodwall. Retains beach amenity and tourism benefits; closely aligned to 2013 EEFCERMS preferred approach; eligible for £800,000 to £900,000 of FDGiA but costs more than the National option Report P24, P25, P26
Chosen: Back-up Option: do minimum (small-scale repair and maintenance of existing seawall and groynes). Retained as fallback if additional funding cannot be secured; not eligible for central Government funding and unlikely to secure the frontage long-term Report 1.18, P28, P29, P30
Implications
Financial: Adopting the updated BMP does not bind EDDC to additional financial commitments now, but any future scheme funding request will be brought back to Cabinet; £140k of existing budget will be used for preparatory studies under £100k. Report P48
Climate: High impact: sea level rise and climate change will increase coastal flood and erosion risk at Exmouth if the long-term sustainable options are not implemented. Report P6
Risk: High risk: failure to implement the leading options would lead to further seawall failures, loss of beach amenity and infrastructure, and wider negative impacts on the area. Report P6, 1.18
Legal: EDDC has permissive powers to provide coastal defences under the Coast Protection Act 1949 and Land Drainage Act 1991; there is no statutory legal duty to do so.
Equalities: Low impact identified for equalities; no substantive legal issues raised in the report. Report P6, P48
Who and where
Residents and property owners along the Exmouth coastal frontage Report 1.7, 1.8
Visitors and tourism economy of Exmouth, dependent on the beach amenity Report 1.10, 1.13
South West Flood and Coastal, who will carry out preparatory work Report P3
Successor authority taking over from 2028/29 after Local Government Reorganisation Report P3
Natural England and statutory environmental consultees, given the Habitat Regulations Assessment cannot be finalised until scheme stage Report 1.26, P44
Timeline
2011: Shoreline Management Plan policies adopted, including Hold the Line for Exmouth frontage Report P7
2013: Exe Estuary FCERM Strategy published by the Environment Agency Report 1.2
2015: Original Exmouth Beach Management Plan produced Report 1.5
2020/21: National FDGiA rules changed Report 1.6
Autumn 2023: Seawall failures at Exmouth demonstrated the 2013 approach is not working Report 1.16
2 October 2024: Cabinet previously approved £140k budget for BMP development Report P3
November 2024 to 10 February 2025: Public consultation on the BMP update Report P3, 1.14
14 October 2025: Defra published a new FCERM funding policy Report 1.20
3 December 2025: Cabinet adopted the Exmouth BMP Update Report P3
April 2026: New FDGiA funding rules are due to take effect, reducing the funding gap Report 1.20
2028/29: Successor authority begins after Local Government Reorganisation; business case development scheduled to start Report P3, P40
2033 to 2034: Detailed design, consents and further contractor involvement Report P45, P46, P47
About 2035: Estimated construction period for the chosen leading option Report 1.16, P26
Plain English for the jargon
BMP: Beach Management Plan, setting out how Exmouth's coastal defences are monitored and maintained
FCERM: Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management
FDGiA: Flood Defence Grant in Aid, central Government funding for flood and coastal defence schemes
SMP: Shoreline Management Plan, the long-term strategic policy document for the coast
EEFCERMS: Exe Estuary Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management Strategy, published in 2013
Adaptive pathway: An approach allowing movement between management options over time, triggered by factors such as funding availability or asset condition
PV: Present Value, a way of expressing future damages or costs in today's money terms
HRA: Habitat Regulations Assessment, required where a plan or project may affect protected habitats
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item119
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet: 1) adopt the Exmouth BMP Update and support the leading options set-out in the adaptive pathway approach as the basis for managing the Exmouth BMP frontage in the short, medium and long-term. 2) That Cabinet support recommending that progressing this project, including preparatory work by South West Flood & Coastal, is promoted as a priority for the successor authority following Local Government Reorganisation to commence in 2028/29. 3) In the meantime, Cabinet support South West Flood & Coastal in progressing preparatory studies below £100k, utilising the remaining budget previously approved by Cabinet for development of the BMP on 2 October 2024 of £140k rather than returning the underspend to the general pot as proposed in that previous paper. REASON: Adopting the updated BMP and strategic approach it set out would enable preparatory work to commence in the coming years by South West Flood & Coastal. With aim of commencing work to develop a business case for the local or national options from 2028/29 in order to provide long-term sustainable management of coastal flood and erosion risk to Exmouth.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 3 December 2025 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A
Exmouth Beach Management Plan Update Report summary: The existing Exmouth Beach Management Plan (BMP) was produced in 2015 and sets out how the Exmouth coastal defences are to be monitored and maintained in line with the long-term strategic approach as set out in the Shoreline Management Plan (2011) and Exe Estuary Flood and Coastal Risk Management (FCERM) Strategy (2013). Since 2015, there have been a number of developments including updates to sea level rise and climate change guidance, collection of more monitoring data, and seawall failures at Exmouth. As a result, it was timely to review and update the BMP and this report presents a summary of the key outputs of that work. A key focus of the BMP update was to critically review and re-appraise the long-term strategic approach to sustainably managing the present and future risks of coastal flooding and erosion over the next 100 years, to secure the long-term future of Exmouth seafront for future generations to enjoy in the way that many people do so today. This has involved assessment of the technical, environmental and economic viability of a range of options, and involved input from local and statutory stakeholders, including public consultation between November 2024 and February 2025. As a result, three leading options for the future management of coastal flood and erosion risk along the Exmouth BMP have been identified. These are combined to provide an adaptive pathway approach to future decision making that is based on key triggers. The actions specified in these options would not be undertaken immediately. In the interim it is important that the short-term recommendations of the updated BMP – including for ongoing monitoring and maintenance – are implemented over the next 5 to 10 years to ensure the beach and existing defences are kept in a good to fair condition to facilitate future improvements over the long term. Alongside that ongoing monitoring and maintenance activity, the BMP update also sets out the forward programme and actions for EDDC to progress the leading. Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☒ No ☐ Policy Framework Yes ☒ No ☐ Recommendation: 1) That Cabinet adopt the Exmouth BMP Update and support the leading options set-out in the adaptive pathway approach as the basis for managing the Exmouth BMP frontage in the short, medium and long-term. 2) That Cabinet support recommending that progressing this project, including preparatory work by South West Flood & Coastal, is promoted as a priority for the successor authority following Local Government Reorganisation to commence in 2028/29. 3) In the meantime, Cabinet support South West Flood & Coastal in progressing preparatory studies below £100k, utilising the remaining budget previously approved by Cabinet for development of the BMP on 2 October 2024 of £140k rather than returning the underspend to the general pot as proposed in that previous paper. Reason for recommendation: Adopting the updated BMP and strategic approach it sets out will enable preparatory work to commence in the coming years by South West Flood & Coastal with aim of commencing work to develop a business case for the local or national options from 2028/29 in order to provide long- term sustainable management of coastal flood and erosion risk to Exmouth.
Portfolio(s) (check which apply): ☐ Assets and Economy ☐ Communications and Democracy ☐ Council, Corporate and External Engagement ☐ Culture, Leisure, Sport and Tourism ☐ Environment - Nature and Climate ☒ Environment - Operational ☐ Finance ☒ Place, Infrastructure and Strategic Planning ☐ Sustainable Homes and Communities
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.