What was decided
The Shadow Habitat Regulations Assessment was adopted as the council's Appropriate Assessment under the Habitats Regulations. Report 1.1, P14
The outline application for up to 72 dwellings on land south of Harepath Hill, Seaton, by Baker Estates was approved subject to completion of a Section 106 agreement. Report 1.2, P20
An additional phasing condition, an amendment to Condition 2 adding 'for each phase', and a new condition requiring a water conservation strategy with water butts of at least 110 litres per bedroom were imposed.
Why
A Likely Significant Effect on the Beer Quarry and Caves Special Area of Conservation was identified from habitat loss, modification and fragmentation, including construction and operational lighting, for greater horseshoe, lesser horseshoe and Bechstein's bats. Report 3.2, 3.3, P54, P55, P56, P61
No Likely Significant Effect was identified on the River Axe SAC from water quality, as the site lies outside its catchment, or on Beer Quarry and Caves SAC from traffic collision. Report 3.2, 3.3, P49, P57, P62
Avoidance and mitigation including 10 metre dark corridors under 0.5 lux, a dark development with no street lighting, retained and buffered hedgerows, and habitat creation were judged sufficient to avoid an adverse effect on the integrity of the SAC. Report 4.2, P92, P93, P96, P102, P109, P113, P114
What happens next
A Section 106 Agreement must be completed before the permission is issued, and the additional phasing and water conservation conditions must be discharged.
A Construction Ecological Management Plan, Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan, and detailed lighting assessment with lux contour plans must be produced and approved by the council. Report 4.2, P89, P100, P101, P107
Post-construction monitoring of bat activity and lux levels must be carried out in Years 1, 3, 5 and 10, with results submitted to the council. Report 4.2, P105, P106
Options considered
- Chosen: Adopt Shadow HRA as Appropriate Assessment and approve subject to conditions. Avoidance and mitigation measures, including dark corridors and habitat creation, are judged sufficient to avoid an adverse effect on the integrity of Beer Quarry and Caves SAC. Report 4.2, P102, P109
Implications
- Legal: Council must adopt the Shadow HRA as its Appropriate Assessment to comply with the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 before granting permission. Report 1.1, P12, P14
- Other: European designated bat populations within 10km, particularly those linked to Beer Quarry and Caves SAC, must be protected through retained flight lines and strict lux limits. Report 3.2, 4.2, P50, P53, P92, P95
- Risk: If monitoring shows lux levels or bat activity are adversely affected, remedial action must be taken under the monitoring strategy. Report 4.2, P105, P106
- Environment and climate: A water conservation strategy including water butts of at least 110 litres per bedroom is required, addressing local water resource concerns.
Who and where
- Greater horseshoe, lesser horseshoe and Bechstein's bats associated with Beer Quarry and Caves SAC Report 3.2, P50, P53, P61
- Future residents of the proposed up to 72 homes Report 1.2, P20
- Applicants and developers, Baker Estates Report 1.1, P2
Timeline
- May 2019 to April 2025: Ecological and bat activity surveys undertaken across multiple seasons Report 1.4, P31, 4.2, P80
- August 2025: Shadow Habitat Regulations Assessment final report prepared by EAD Ecology Report P3
- 9 February 2026: Planning Committee decision to approve, subject to conditions
- Years 1, 3, 5 and 10 post-completion: Bat activity and lux level monitoring to verify dark corridor performance Report 4.2, P105, P106
Plain English for the jargon
- HRA: Habitats Regulations Assessment, the process to check if a plan or project affects European protected sites.
- SAC: Special Area of Conservation, a European site protected for habitats or species.
- Appropriate Assessment: The detailed Stage 2 HRA test of whether a project will harm a European site's integrity.
- LSE: Likely Significant Effect, the threshold that triggers the need for an Appropriate Assessment.
- S106 Agreement: A legal planning obligation between a developer and the council, often used to secure affordable housing or other contributions.
- Dark corridor: A landscaped strip kept under 0.5 lux so light-sensitive bats can continue to commute and forage.
- Pinch Point: A restricted route, such as between Seaton and Colyton, that bats use to move between roosts and foraging areas.