Resolved
RESOLVED that subject to:- (i) the applicant/owner first entering into a planning obligation under Section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 on terms drafted by the Solicitor to the Council to secure; a) A financial contribution to secure satisfactory mitigation of the ‘in combination’ effects that the increase in residential disturbance on the Solent Coastal Special Protection Areas; b) A financial contribution towards off-site provision of affordable housing in accordance with Core Strategy Policy CS18; (ii) the conditions in the report; and (iii) an additional condition requiring the open space/paddock area to be substantially in accordance with the illustrative layout PLANNING PERMISSION be granted. A further update was provided by the Head of Development Management in respect of minute item number 7 (12), which should read: (12) P/18/0654/FP – LAND TO THE WEST OF SEAFIELD ROAD & MORAUNT DRIVE; SOUTH OF TATTERSHALL CRESCENT The Committee received the deputations referred to in Minute 5 above. Councillor Walker declared a non-pecuniary interest in this item in that he is the chairman of the Parish Hall Trust Board of which 2 church wardens are also members and who are also member trustees of the Churchlands Trust which owns part of the site. At the invitation of the Chairman, Councillor R H Price, JP addressed the Committee on this item. He left the room after making his representation and was not present for the debate or vote on this application. The Committee’s attention was drawn to the Update Report which contained the following information:- Following the updates to the FIVE-YEAR HOUSING LAND SUPPLY POSITION report, the following paragraphs replace those currently published in the report: 1.6 Members will note from the ‘Five Year Housing Land Supply Position’ report elsewhere on this agenda that this Council currently has a housing land supply position of 4.67 years (a shortfall of 167 dwellings within the 5-year period). 1.7 The Housing Delivery Test results which were due to be published by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government in November 2018 have not been published. Officers have carried out their own assessment against the dame criteria the Government will use and are of the opinion that the Housing Delivery Test results will require this Council to apply a 20% buffer to its local housing need increasing its annual requirement to 575 dwellings per annum. This in turn would result in a 5-year housing supply of 4.1 years and a shortfall of 527 dwellings. One third party further representation was received following the 14 November committee meeting, this related to concern over reptiles on the site. With regard to comments since the letter of 29 th November from the agent, there have been fifteen letters of representation, some of which raise concern that has already been discussed within the officer report. With regards to the letter of 29 th November, the following concerns are raised: · The Council should be overseeing the appointment of independent ecologists to oversee the project. · The letter from Bryan Jezeph does not contain specific solutions for management and maintenance arrangements, the ecology of the site is important and should not be brushed aside from the sake of providing housing. · Nothing offered as a solution addresses any of the issues raised by the committee at last month’s refusal. · Cannot be satisfied that extensive ground clearance, however carefully worded or timed is valid or acceptable or would satisfy or rescind the LPA’s grounds for refusal, due in part to the capacity of the southern part of the site for protected species or lizards. · With regard to no works until February 2019, reptile species have been recorded above ground in February by reptile specialists both in south Hampshire and on the Isle of Wight. · Excavating archaeological trenches from the end of March while undertaking a translocation process from April for two months is unworkable. · The Developers Agent proposal fails to address the issues and concerns raised at the previous planning committee to safeguard the southern side of the site. · The ecological ‘mitigation’ or proposed ‘benefits’ will not outweigh the negative impact and net loss that this proposal will bring, the proposal has not been fundamentally changed. · The overriding reasons for refusal still stand. · The ecological issues seem to be clouding the issues and concerns of the residents; traffic issues and impact on services have not been taken into consideration. · Concern over enforcement of planning conditions. · Concern over process and procedure and that the decision notice has not been issued following the meeting of 14 November. · The Public Inquiry us the correct place to resolve the grounds for refusal. The planning agent has submitted a revised affordable housing plan which would result in the provision of 20 affordable homes rather than 19.2 and a financial contribution. As referenced to in paragraph 7.17 of the Committee Report, the Housing Officer advises that the applicant may either provide an additional affordable unit or pay a financial contribution. Officer advice is that the provision of 20 affordable homes is acceptable in accordance with policy and therefore the recommendation in paragraph 9.0 within the report should reflect the ‘provision of 20 affordable housing units’ and delete the reference to ‘contribution’. The list of recommended approved plans in condition 2 should include reference to this revised plan CB_93_074_A2_104 Rev A. A revised layout plan and housing schedule to reflect the additional affordable housing unit has been submitted reference CB_074_A1_100 Rev B., the list of recommended approved pans in condition 2 should include refence to this plan. Officers propose revised wording relating to condition 8, boundary treatment to read: No dwelling hereby approved shall be occupied until the boundary treatment relating to it has been carried out in accordance with the approved details. The brick wall as shown to the rear of number 49 Sissinghurst Road shall be constructed prior to the occupation of plot 31. The boundary treatment shall thereafter be retained at all times unless otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority. REASON: To protect the privacy of the occupiers of the neighbouring property, to prevent overlooking, and to ensure that the development harmonises well with its surroundings. The Committee further requested that: (1) officers secure an amended plan to show: (a) 1 tree rather than 3 adjacent to the boundary of 49 Sissinghurst Road; and (b) the Field Maple trees along the southern boundary of the site being retained; and (2) Condition 20 being amended as follows: No development shall commence on site until a Construction Management Plan (CMP) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority (LPA). The Construction Plan shall address rge following matters: a) how provision is to be made on site for the parking and turning of operatives/contractors’/sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles: b) the measures the developer will implement to ensure that operatives’/contractors./sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles are parked within the planning application site; c) the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of all vehicles leaving the site; d) a scheme for the suppression of any dust arising during construction or clearance works; e) the measures for cleaning Moraunt Drive, Wicor Mill Lane and White Hart Lane to ensure that they are kept clear of any mud or other debris falling from construction vehicles, and f) the areas to be used for the storage of building materials, plant, excavated materials and huts associated with the implementation of the approved development. The development shall be carried out in accordance with the CMP and areas identified in the CMP for specified purposes shall thereafter be kept available for those uses at all times during the construction period, unless otherwise agreed in writing with the LPA. No construction vehicles shall leave the site unless the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of construction vehicles are in place and operational, and the wheels and undersides of vehicles have been cleaned. REASON: In the interests of highway safety and to ensure that the occupiers of nearby residential properties are not subjected to unacceptable noise and disturbance during the construction period. Upon being proposed and seconded the officer recommendation to grant planning permission, subject to:- (i) the applicant/owner first entering into a planning obligation under Section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 on terms drafted by the Solicitor to the Council to secure: · Financial contribution to secure satisfactory mitigation on the ‘in combination’ effects that the increase in residential units on the site would cause through increased recreational disturbance on the Solent Coastal Special Protected Areas; · The provision and management of public open space and ecological enhancement area for the lifetime of the development; · Educational contribution; · The delivery of affordable housing and contribution; · No clearance work to be undertaken on the site before 1 st February 2019; the Council must be advised in advance of any proposals to undertake clearance work at the site; the Council to be given advance notice of any clearance works to be undertaken at the site and the clearance works to be undertaken at the site and the Council’s officers/representatives give unfettered access to view all clearance related works; all clearance work to be overseen by Radian’s appointed ecologists in accordance with a scheme first agreed in advance with the Council; (ii) the receipt of a satisfactory amended plan showing: (a) 1 tree rather than 3 adjacent to the boundary of 49 Sissinghurst Road; and (b) the Field Maple trees along the southern boundary of the site being retained; (iii) Condition 20 being amended as follows: No development shall commence on site until a Construction Management Plan (CMP) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority (LPA). The Construction Management Plan shall address the following matters: a) how provision is to be made on site for the parking and turning of operatives/contractors’/sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles; b) the measures the developer will implement to ensure that operatives’/contractors’/sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles are parked within the planning application site; c) the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of all vehicles leaving the site; d) a scheme for the suppression of any dust arising during construction or clearance works; e) the measures for cleaning Moraunt Drive, Wicor Mill Lane and White Hart Lane to ensure they are kept clear of any mud or other debris falling from construction vehicles; and f) the areas to be used for the storage of building materials, plant, excavated materials and huts associated with the implementation of the approved development. The development shall be carried out in accordance with the CMP and areas identified in the CMP for specified purposes shall thereafter be kept available for those uses at all times during the construction period, unless otherwise agreed in writing by the LPA. No construction vehicles shall leave the site unless the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of construction vehicles are in place and operational, and the wheels and underside of vehicles have been cleaned. REASON: In the interest of highway safety and to ensure that the occupiers of nearby residential properties are not subjected to unacceptable noise and disturbance during the construction period; (iv) that Members confirm that the reasons for the refusal 1(a) and 1(c) in respect of planning application P/17/0920/FP should not be pursued at the forthcoming appeal: and (v) all conditions in the report. Was voted on and CARRIED. (Voting: 6 in favour; 3 against) RESOLVED that, subject to:- (i) the applicant/owner first entering into a planning obligation under Section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 on terms drafted by the Solicitor to the Council to secure: · Financial contribution to secure satisfactory mitigation on the ‘in combination’ effects that the increase in residential units on the site would cause through increased recreational disturbance on the Solent Coastal Special Protected Areas; · The provision and management of public open space and ecological enhancement area for the lifetime of the development; · Educational contribution; · The delivery of affordable housing and contribution; · No clearance work to be undertaken on the site before 1 st February 2019; the Council must be advised in advance of any proposals to undertake clearance work at the site; the Council to be given advance notice of any clearance works to be undertaken at the site and the clearance works to be undertaken at the site and the Council’s officers/representatives give unfettered access to view all clearance related works; all clearance work to be overseen by Radian’s appointed ecologists in accordance with a scheme first agreed in advance with the Council; (ii) the receipt of a satisfactory amended plan showing: (a) 1 tree rather than 3 adjacent to the boundary of 49 Sissinghurst Road; and (b) the Field Maple trees along the southern boundary of the site being retained; (iii) Condition 20 being amended as follows: No development shall commence on site until a Construction Management Plan (CMP) has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority (LPA). The Construction Management Plan shall address the following matters: a) how provision is to be made on site for the parking and turning of operatives/contractors’/sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles; b) the measures the developer will implement to ensure that operatives’/contractors’/sub-contractors’ vehicles and/or construction vehicles are parked within the planning application site; c) the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of all vehicles leaving the site; d) a scheme for the suppression of any dust arising during construction or clearance works; e) the measures for cleaning Moraunt Drive, Wicor Mill Lane and White Hart Lane to ensure they are kept clear of any mud or other debris falling from construction vehicles; and f) the areas to be used for the storage of building materials, plant, excavated materials and huts associated with the implementation of the approved development. The development shall be carried out in accordance with the CMP and areas identified in the CMP for specified purposes shall thereafter be kept available for those uses at all times during the construction period, unless otherwise agreed in writing by the LPA. No construction vehicles shall leave the site unless the measures for cleaning the wheels and underside of construction vehicles are in place and operational, and the wheels and underside of vehicles have been cleaned. REASON: In the interest of highway safety and to ensure that the occupiers of nearby residential properties are not subjected to unacceptable noise and disturbance during the construction period; (iv) that Members confirm that the reasons for the refusal 1(a) and 1(c) in respect of planning application P/17/0920/FP should not be pursued at the forthcoming appeal: and (v) all conditions in the report. PLANNING PERMISSION be granted. At the request of Councillor Price, JP, one further amended to be made to minute item no.1 Apologies of Absence, to read: (2) APOLOGIES OF ABSENCE Apologies of absence were received from Councillors F Birkett, K D Evans and R H Price, JP. The apology from Councillor Price was due to him having a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest and is therefore unable to sit on the Planning Committee. RESOLVED that the minutes of the Planning Committee meeting held on 12 December 2018, subject to the changes in the update report, the update from the Head of Development Management and the change from Councillor Price, be confirmed and signed as a correct record.