Fareham Coastal Study (Fareham Quay and Alton Grove to Cador Drive)
AgreedExecutive2 papers
AI summaryExecutive notes coastal study leading options costing £13M and £13.4M over 50 years for two Fareham frontages, agrees to publish a public position statement, and continues lobbying for funding.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedLeading options noted; delegation to update statement
Money£13M and £13.4MWhole life 50 year cost for two leading options
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsAround 400 properties at tidal flood riskAcross both frontages over the next 100 years
What was decided
The Executive noted the leading options developed by the Fareham Coastal Defence Study for Alton Grove to Cador Drive and Fareham Quay. Report P47
Members agreed to publish a public facing Position Statement at Appendix D, setting out current roles, future scenarios, residual risks and next steps. Report P63
Authority was delegated to the Director of Planning and Regeneration, in consultation with the Executive Member for Planning and Development, to update the Position Statement as appropriate; continued lobbying on coastal landfill funding, routine inspections and patch and repair were supported; and officers were asked to explore Property Flood Resilience at Fareham Quay once new Defra funding rules are introduced. Report P59, P62, P65
Why
Both frontages are legacy coastal landfill sites on which existing defences are at or near the end of their serviceable life, with about 400 properties at risk of an extreme tidal flood over the next 100 years. Report 1.5, 1.6, P34, P35, P39
Under current Government funding rules, none of the options considered are economically viable because benefit cost ratios are below one, even after local benefits are counted. Report P44, P45
New Defra funding rules are expected in April 2026 and are more supportive of Property Flood Resilience approaches, offering a possible alternative to a full capital scheme. Report P45, P58, P59
What happens next
Publish the Position Statement at Appendix D and keep it updated under delegated authority to the Director of Planning and Regeneration. Report P63
Continue routine coastal defence inspections and patch and repair at both frontages within available revenue and capital funds to extend asset life. Report P65
Officers, working with the Environment Agency, will explore whether a Property Flood Resilience project at Fareham Quay is viable once new Defra funding rules and guidance are available in April 2026. Report P58, P59
Continue lobbying, through established Coastal Networks and the LGA Coastal Special Interest Group, for funding and policy reform on legacy coastal landfill. Report P62
Check and update Emergency Plans to reflect the study findings. Report P64
The money
£80k Cost to FBC of repairing a 27m failed section of wall at Fareham Quay in 2022 Report P35
£13M Estimated Whole Life Cash cost over 50 years for the Alton Grove to Cador Drive leading option Report P49
£13.4M Estimated Whole Life Cash cost over 50 years for the Fareham Quay leading option Report P52
£6.6M Whole Life Cash cost (50 year) of the Do Minimum option at Alton Grove to Cador Drive Report P56
£12.5M Whole Life Cash cost (50 year) of the Do Minimum option at Fareham Quay Report P56
Options considered
Chosen: Leading option for Alton Grove to Cador Drive: Phase 1 new erosion protection to legacy landfill, Phase 2 new raised flood defences in about 20 years. Best balance of cost, technical feasibility, environmental impact and carbon footprint against the project objectives Report P48, P49, P47
Chosen: Leading option for Fareham Quay: Phase 1 raised frontline erosion and flood protection plus Property Flood Resilience, Phase 2 replacement of frontline erosion protection in about 20 years. Best balance of cost, technical feasibility, environmental impact and carbon footprint against the project objectives Report P51, P52, P47
Rejected: Do Minimum: sustain current standard of service for 50 years through maintenance only. Did not fully meet the project objectives Report P56
Rejected: Property Flood Resilience as a standalone measure. Does not reduce all risk, including erosion risk to landfill, so was not taken forward to shortlist stage; to be revisited under new Defra rules Report P57, P59
Implications
Financial: Under current Government funding rules, none of the options are economically viable and no specific funding has been identified for reducing erosion risk to coastal landfill. Report P44, P45
Legal: As landowner, Fareham Borough Council is responsible for flood and erosion protection and for managing the coastal landfill sites; any future defence works would be carried out under the Land Drainage Act 1991 or Coast Protection Act 1949. Report 1.9, 1.10
Equalities: Around 400 properties are at risk of an extreme tidal flood event during the next 100 years, rising to higher numbers by 2043 and 2073. Report 1.5, P37, P38
Climate: Sea levels are expected to rise by approximately 1m over the next century, increasing flood and erosion risk and the threat of releasing landfill material into Portsmouth Harbour. Report 1.8, P36, P41
Environment: Both sites are near Portsmouth Harbour SPA, Ramsar and SSSI designations, and erosion of landfill debris and leachate into the harbour is a key environmental concern. Report 1.11, 1.12, P41
Risk: Continued deterioration of defences could expose landfill material and increase flood and erosion risk, with the possibility of further failures such as the 2022 Salterns Wall collapse. Report 1.6, P65
Staffing: Foreshore management at Alton Grove to Cador Drive will continue to be led by the council's Streetscene Service under a Risk Assessment and Management Plan. Report P66
Who and where
Around 400 properties at risk of an extreme tidal flood event during the next 100 years across both frontages Report 1.5
Residents and property owners at Alton Grove to Cador Drive (18 properties at risk today, 95 in 2043, 160 in 2073 without defences) Report P37
Residents and property owners at Fareham Quay (24 properties at risk today, 37 in 2043, 59 in 2073 without defences) Report P38
Key infrastructure, transport links and the legacy coastal landfill and open space areas behind both frontages Report P39
Portsmouth Harbour environment, including SPA, Ramsar and SSI designations for habitats, plants, invertebrates and over-wintering birds Report 1.11, 1.12
Timeline
1932: Earliest identified historical landfill operations at both frontage sites Report 1.2, 1.4
2017: SCOPAC Coastal Landfill Study identified both areas as key sites to protect from flooding and erosion
2021: A 27m section of wall at Fareham Quay failed Report P35
2022: Visual assessment of defence assets carried out as the basis for the Defence Condition Assessment Report P33
2022: Fareham Borough Council repaired the failed 27m section at a cost of £80k Report P35
2023: Defence Condition Assessment prepared as part of the Study Report P33
20 January: Presentation on the study outcomes made to the Environment Advisory Panel, which supported reporting to the Executive and publication of the Position Statement Report P29
03/02/2025: Executive approval for Portchester Foreshore Management (Risk Assessment and Management Plan) Report P66
2026-03-02: Executive meeting considers the Fareham Coastal Study report
Within 10 to 20 years: Existing defences at Alton Grove to Cador Drive expected to fail if no maintenance is undertaken Report P34
Within 10 to 15 years: Existing assets at Fareham Quay expected to fail if no maintenance is undertaken Report P35
2043: Projected number of properties at risk at both sites under an extreme tidal flood event without defences Report P37, P38
2073: Projected number of properties at risk at both sites under an extreme tidal flood event without defences Report P37, P38
About 20 years' time: Phase 2 of both leading options (raised flood defences at Alton Grove, replacement frontline erosion protection at Fareham Quay) Report P48, P51
April 2026: New Defra funding rules expected to be introduced Report P45, P58
Plain English for the jargon
FCERM: Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management
PFR: Property Flood Resilience measures that help individual properties cope with flooding
TAG: Technical Advisory Group of key stakeholders set up for the study
SCOPAC: South East Coastal Group that produced the 2017 Coastal Landfill Study
RHPS: River Hamble to Portchester Strategy
SPA: Special Protection Area, an international nature conservation designation
Ramsar: International designation for wetlands of importance
SSSI: Site of Special Scientific Interest, a national nature conservation designation
AEP: Annual Exceedance Probability, the chance of a flood event happening in any given year
SRFCC: Solent Resilient Flooded Coastline, which funded the 2017 SCOPAC study through a levy
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item12(1)
Resolved
RESOLVED that the Executive: (a) notes the leading options developed by the Fareham Coastal Defence Study; (b) agrees that the Position Statement which summarises the current roles and responsibilities of key partners in relation to ongoing coastal management, potential future scenarios for the management of each site, alongside the residual risks and next steps, as set out at Appendix D to the report, be published; (c) agrees that authority be delegated to the Director of Planning and Regeneration, following consultation with the Executive Member for Planning and Development, to update the Position Statement as appropriate; (d) supports continued lobbying, via established Coastal Networks, on the challenge of securing coastal landfill funding; (e) supports the continuation of routine coastal defence inspections and patch and repair to extend the life of coastal assets within available resources; and (f) requests that Officers explore opportunities for Property Flood Resilience Measures (PFR) at Fareham Quay (as outlined in the Executive Briefing Paper) when the new Defra funding rules are introduced and seek to work with the Environment Agency to determine if such an initiative is viable.
Word for word from the decision Fareham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.fareham.gov.uk
Portfolio: Planning and Development Fareham Coastal Defence Study (Fareham Quay and Alton Subject: Grove to Cador Drive)
Report of: Director of Planning and Regeneration
Corporate Priorities: Respond to climate change and protect the environment.
Purpose: This report updates members on the outcomes of the Fareham Coastal Defence study, delivered by Coastal Partners, Fareham Borough Councils Coastal Team.
Executive summary: Coastal Partners undertake the ongoing monitoring, maintenance and management of Fareham Borough Council’s sea defences.
Significant external funding was secured from the Southern Regional Flood and Coastal Committee (SRFCC) Local Levy (£457.5k) for Coastal Partners to undertake the Fareham Coastal Defence Study (the Study). In addition, Fareham Borough Council (FBC) approved £30k to support the work. Through careful monitoring and management of the project to its conclusion, the FBC contribution will not be required to complete the Study and will therefore remain within the Coastal Protection Reserve.
The Study has now concluded with the identification of leading options to reduce flood and erosion risk at Alton Grove to Cador Drive, and at Fareham Quay. This has achieved the primary objective to “identify a leading option that aligns with the River Hamble to Portchester Strategy, addresses climate change, tidal flood risk and coastal erosion risk to both property and legacy landfill whilst delivering the maximum Standard of Protection possible”.
At Alton Grove to Cador Drive, the (phased) leading option involves new erosion protection to legacy landfill areas in Phase 1, followed by new raised flood defences in around 20 years’ time in Phase 2. £13 Million of funding is estimated as required to construct this option.
At Fareham Quay, the (phased) leading option provides new raised frontline erosion and flood protection to the recreation ground in the north in Phase 1, followed by replacement of the frontline erosion protection at the same height around the recreation ground in the south in around 20 years’ time in Phase 2. Property Flood Resilience measures are proposed to a small number of properties at risk on Fareham Quay itself during Phase 1. £13.4 Million of funding is estimated as required to construct this option.
Although technically feasible leading options have been recommended for each frontage, the economic appraisal has shown that under current Government funding rules, none of the options considered would be economically viable (i.e. benefit cost ratios are less than one). The economic appraisal does also recognise ‘local benefits’ such as recreation, biodiversity and ecology, water quality and protection/remediation of legacy coastal landfill, however these do not form a strong enough business case for securing national sources of funding without a benefit cost ratio above one.
To proceed to the next stage of a capital scheme (detailed design, planning & consenting), it will be necessary to secure further funding which under current national funding rules, is unlikely to come from Defra Grant in Aid. However, having completed the study FBC are now well positioned to take advantage of any future changes in the funding policy space and Coastal Partners continue to lobby for national change in relation to coastal landfill funding via the Local Government Association Coastal Special Interest Group (LGA Coastal SIG).
Due to uncertainty regarding funding availability to implement all options, a position statement and adaptive coastal management pathways have been developed, to help decision makers plan for and prioritise future actions and engagement.
Recommendation: It is recommended that the Executive:
(a) notes the leading options developed by the Fareham Coastal Defence Study;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Corporate Complaints Handling PolicyRESOLVED that the Executive: (a) agrees the updated Council’s Complaint Policy as attached at Appendix A to the repor...
References from Other CommitteesIt was RESOLVED that, in order for Officers to answer Members questions about the contractual arrangements for the cu...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.