AI summaryGateshead Council refused retrospective planning permission for render on the rear of 12 Selborne Avenue, citing harm to the Low Fell Conservation Area.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedRetrospective render application refused at 12 Selborne Avenue
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affects12 Selborne Avenue, Low Fell Conservation Area
What was decided
Gateshead's Planning and Development Committee refused retrospective planning permission for the render and insulation board on the rear walls of 12 Selborne Avenue, against the applicant's resubmitted application. Report P3, 7.0
Officers recommended refusal because the works harm the character and appearance of the Low Fell Conservation Area, with no public benefits shown to outweigh that harm. Report 6.1, 6.2, 5.12
Why
The render is inappropriate on the rear elevation, appears overly dominant, and obscures original windowsills, lintels and brick dentils at the eaves, forming an incongruous addition to the host property. Report P53, 5.6
The proposal causes less than substantial harm to the Low Fell Conservation Area, a designated heritage asset, and no public benefits have been evidenced to outweigh that harm. Report P54, 5.3, 5.8, 5.12
The applicant has not provided evidence of energy savings or thermal enhancement from the insulation and render, and the western gable of the offshoot was left unrendered, weakening the thermal case. Report 5.11, 5.16, 1.7
What happens next
The Service Director of Climate Change, Compliance, Planning and Transport is authorised to add, vary and amend the refusal reasons as necessary. Report 7.0
An earlier identical retrospective application, DC/24/00846/HHA, was refused under delegated powers on 12 December 2024, and the applicant missed the 12 week statutory deadline for a householder appeal. Report 1.11
Options considered
Chosen: Refuse planning permission. Less than substantial harm to the Low Fell Conservation Area with no public benefits to outweigh it, contrary to the NPPF, Core Strategy policy CS15, Local Plan policies MSGP24 and MSGP25, and the Household Alterations and Extensions SPD. Report P53, P54, P55, 6.2, 7.0
Implications
Legal: The refusal engages paragraphs 212 and 215 of the NPPF, which require great weight to be given to conservation of designated heritage assets and weighing of harm against public benefits. Report 5.3, 5.12
Equalities: Six letters of support were received noting improved energy efficiency, reduced heat loss, and reduced damp, but officers found these benefits unevidenced and outweighed by heritage harm. Report 3.2, P20, P23, 5.11
Climate: The proposal is accepted to align with policy CS16 on climate change, but external wall insulation must be balanced against visual impact, and here that harm is not outweighed by unquantified energy savings. Report 5.14, 5.15, 5.16
Risk: A previous identical application was already refused and the applicant missed the statutory appeal window, raising questions about repeated submissions of the same scheme. Report 1.11, 5.22
Who and where
The applicant at 12 Selborne Avenue, Gateshead NE9 6ET Report P2, P3
Owners and occupiers of neighbouring properties on Selborne Avenue, including Nos. 2, 4, 14 and 15 Report 1.3, 5.7
Residents and visitors to the Low Fell Conservation Area, designated in 1999 Report 1.4, P54
Properties on Killowen Street on the opposite side of the back lane Report 5.7
Timeline
2021: Render on insulation board was installed on the rear elevation of 12 Selborne Avenue. Report 1.6
12 December 2024: Earlier identical retrospective application DC/24/00846/HHA was refused under delegated powers; the applicant later missed the 12 week statutory deadline for a householder appeal. Report 1.11
19 January 2026: Current application DC/25/00614/HHA was validated. Report P2
2026-03-25: Gateshead Planning and Development Committee considered and refused the application. Report 7.0
Plain English for the jargon
NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the government's national planning policy.
Conservation Area: An area designated for its special architectural or historic interest, giving it protection from inappropriate development.
MSGP: A Local Plan policy reference used by Gateshead Council.
CS: A Core Strategy policy reference used by Gateshead Council.
SPD: Supplementary Planning Document, providing detailed guidance on plan policies.
Retrospective application: A planning application made after works have already been carried out.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemPD84
Resolved
That permission be REFUSED for the following reason(s) and that the Service Director of Climate Change, Compliance, Planning and Transport be authorised to add, vary and amend the refusal reasons as necessary 1. By virtue of its siting on the rear elevation of the host property, the render is inappropriate, appears overly dominant, obscures original architectural detailing, and forms an incongruous addition to the host property. The proposal results in less than substantial harm to the appearance of the Low Fell Conservation Area, a designated heritage asset, without public benefits to outweigh that harm. It is therefore contrary to the aims and objectives of the National Planning Policy Framework, Policies CS15 of the Core Strategy, MSGP24 and MSGP25 of the Local Plan for Gateshead and Gateshead Council's Household Alterations and Extensions SPD.
Word for word from the decision Gateshead published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gateshead.gov.uk
Application No: DC/25/00614/HHA Case Officer Aimee Gregory Date Application Valid 19 January 2026 Applicant [name removed]: 12 Selborne Avenue Gateshead NE9 6ET
Ward: Low Fell Proposal: (Retrospective) Render on insulation board to the external, first floor, rear walls of existing dwelling house. Recommendation: REFUSE Application Type Householder Application
1.0The Application:
1.1DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE
1.212 Selborne Avenue is a substantial end of terrace nineteenth century dwelling. The front elevation is finished in glazed white brick with stone dressings, and it has a slate roof. The rear elevation features pale red brick and render. The property is two storeys high and includes a ground floor bay window and a front garden. To the rear, there is an original monopitch roof offshoot that rises part way up the main roof slope, together with a walled yard.
1.3The house is at the western end of a short terrace of similar houses which are largely unchanged at the front. To the rear, the adjacent houses have unaltered pale red brick. Numbers 2 and 4 have a thin white render finish which preserves the original windowsills and lintels as recessed features.
1.4The property is within the Low Fell Conservation Area (a designated heritage asset), which was designated in 1999. The area is characterised by a variety in building types, ages, materials, and design. Selborne Avenue is in the section described as ‘West of Durham Road. -The character of this area is strongly influenced by the Victorian terraces...the terraces are constructed of red brick with stone dressings and slate roofs.’
1.5DESCRIPTION OF THE APPLICATION
1.6The application seeks retrospective planning permission for the installation of render on insulation board to the external rear walls of the dwelling. The rear elevation, including the inner and rear walls of the offshoot, has been covered with a substantial cladding treatment approximately 75 mm thick, finished in a pale grey render. The work was undertaken in 2021.
1.7The outer wall of the offshoot, which faces No. 14 Selborne Avenue, has not been clad; it remains as original brickwork at ground and first floor level, with an older cement skim present at second floor level. 1.8 The cladding works have obscured original architectural features, including the windowsills, lintels, and brick dentils at the eaves. New white uPVC windowsills have been installed, and a white uPVC trim has been added to the rear eaves of the offshoot.
1.9Officers note that the submitted existing elevation plans omit key elements of the buildings original architectural detailing, such as the brick headers, stone sills, and brick dentils.
1.10RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY:
1.11DC/24/00846/HHA – Retrospective application for the installation of render on insulation board to the rear elevation. This was refused under delegated powers, on 12 December 2024. The applicant subsequently missed the statutory 12-week deadline for lodging a householder planning appeal. 1.12 The same scheme has now been resubmitted, by the same applicant, under the current application. The plans and supporting information are identical to those assessed as part of the earlier refused application. However, as the current submission has been validly made and the necessary consultation has taken place, the Local Planning Authority has determined that it is appropriate to proceed to determine this application.
2.0Consultation Responses:
None.
3.0Representations:
3.1Neighbour notifications were carried out in accordance with formal procedures introduced in the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) Order 2015, including the display of a site notice and a press notice.
3.2Six letters of support have so been received, and these comments can be summarised as follows:
• The rendering/insulation work significantly improves the property’s energy efficiency, reduces heat loss, and tackles damp.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.